Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Rough out % going south in a hurry

Posts

Rough out % going south in a hurry

#1

Rough out % going south in a hurry

Chris K in MD

>I have had great results with my rough out turnings having a loss of less than 10% until very recently, total (25-35 bowls with 2 lost). I have lost nearly 90% of the ones that I have made in the last two months. I think there are only two things different from my previous rough outs.

1) My shop is ~45-50 degrees expect on the weekends when I heat it to 60-65.

2) The time of the year that I roughed them.

Some of the species are the same I have done before, cherry and walnut and newly tried sycamore. I used the same methods of sealing and storing etc, but nearly all are cracking within 2 weeks of coming off the lathe. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

#2

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Chris, what exactly is your method? Even though it has not changed, it would be helpful to know. BTW, our local log dump has seen its last days. They are no longer dumping anything other than oak and hard maple - which sadly we don't get much of.

My roughout success has always been about 90-95% by waxing the entire surface of all of my roughs. I also don't rough things when they're freshly cut and soaking wet, but rather let them sit outside for a few months to dry out some. You've been in my basement/shop - I just wax them, let them dry and toss them on the shelf, and layer them as deep as possible.

It could be your shapes, maybe they've changed? Taller tends to be subject to more stress, as do thicker roughs. If you're making very large pieces, however, you of course need thick. Shorter blanks should be more stable.

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

#3

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

john lucas

>Chris Most of my losses have been due to tenons that are too long and thick or excessive air movement around the pieces. I usually only wax all the endgrain and wax the complete tenon. Actaully I mean achorseal. When I have a wood that I worry about I anchorseal all of the bowl.

I have found that even thought the wood still moves on the bottom you have to remove less to make it true, consequently I leave the tenon and the bottom thinner than the outer lips. I think this has reduced some of the cracking tenons.

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

#4

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

Chris K in MD

>Mike,

My method is close to yours based on your success. I anchorseal only the end grain which for a 10-12 bowl leaves 1-2" unsealed. I then put them on a shelf in my shop. This is the same thing I have always done. In the case of the sycamore, I sealed the entire bowl with anchor seal. The shapes have been very similar to other shapes I have done, but are varied (ex not all taller ones crack both shallow and tall have cracked). The cracks have occured in the unsealed as well as the sealed sections. Maybe I shoudl season my blanks for a while, although other I made last april and may were soaling me when I roughed them.

Sorry to hear about the dump, is there any reason why?

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

#5

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

Chris K in MD

>John,

I do exactly what you say this was from a tip that I picked up watching Bill grumbines video. Like I said previously I had great results with this method.

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

#6

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

JKJ in East TN

>When you heat the winter air the relative humidity drops and wood dries much faster. (I run a humidifier in my piano room all winter to help keep the wood from over-drying.) In addition to sealing the end grain, perhaps the drying could be further slowed by another method such as bagging and/or burying in sawdust. JKJ

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

#7

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry *LINK*

Brad Thompson

>I recently tried Dave Smith's alcohol soaking/drying method on some extremely (tranlate to soaking) wet blanks. Worked like a charm. No cracking and minimal warping. These were 7-8 bowls. Since it was the first time trying this method, I was in a hurry to see how it worked and only let them set/air dry for 7 days.

If you haven't tried Dave's method, the article link below provides a great explanation.


http://www.woodcentral.com/articles/turning/articles_473.shtml

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

#8

Re: Rough out % going south in a hurry

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Chris,

I think John K. has the right answer here. Even though you keep the shop cool during the week, the RH is low because you are heating colder, drier air. During the heating season, it might be a good idea to use paper bags or newspaper or put your sealed blanks in an unheated space.

The principle to keep in mind in drying any kind of wood is Strength vs. Stress. As wood dries stresses are produced at the cellular level. The level of stresses is determined by the drying rate. The drying rate, in turn, is determined by RH, temperature and airflow working in conjunction with each other. If the stresses become greater than the strength of the wood, the wood cracks.

Fortunately, as wood dries it becomes stronger. The trick is to not stress the wood anymore than it can stand at the moment. I suspect the difference in humidity is enough to tip the balance in this case. A few weeks in a paper bag will probably be enough to strengthen the wood sufficiently to withstand the lower humidity.

HTH,

Gary