Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

skew grind - hollow or flat?

Posts

skew grind - hollow or flat?

#1

skew grind - hollow or flat?

Paul Tacy

>Hi all,

I'm brand new here - my first post. Wondering how many out there follow Ernie Conover's advice about grinding the skew? He is the only one I've heard (read) who insists that skews MUST be ground on the side of the wheel - flat grind.

I've done this, and admit to some improvement, but that may only be because I'm getting a little more proficient, and the hollow grind would work for me as well. Maintaining a sharp tool is pretty laborious with a flat grind, and I'm inclined to go back to the hollow grind. Any thoughts?

Re: skew grind - hollow or flat?

#2

Re: skew grind - hollow or flat?

John Lucas

>I've tried both ways and can't tell the difference. Since I hone the edge of my skew very frequently I prefer the hollow grind because it's quicker to hone the edge. There is simply less metal to remove. If you honed the edge with a machine, flat might be just as easy.

Re: skew grind - hollow or flat?

#3

Brad Vietje

Re: skew grind - hollow or flat?

Brad Vietje

>Paul,

I bet John expected me to jump in here...

I'll agree with John that there is little practical difference in using the tool. If you like to hone a lot, I'd also agree that a slight hollow is easier to hone many times before returning to the grinding wheel, but I like a slight hollow from a 8" or 10" wheel a LOT better than the severe pointy and catch-prone shape that comes from smaller wheels. (There are also many who feel pretty strongly about doing anything with the sides of those spinning wheels, but that's another matter...)

Where I'll differ with the lot is that it's very easy to maintain a flat bevel on a skew -- with an inverted belt sander, or a large disk sander. With a fine grit belt (or disk), there is little need to hone, and the flat grind can be honed pretty well until human error rounds it a bit, at which time you can touch it up on the belt again. I use 150 grit with a very light touch, and only hone for the final cuts to save on sanding later.

If you like to use a curved, or radius skew, a grinder is a poor way to sharpen it in my view. There are all sorts of experts and experienced turners who will take that statement as fightin' words, but trying to wrap a cylinder (the outer surface of the grinding wheel) around a curved surface like a radius skew will, by definition, result in an inconsistent geometry with an odd-shaped bevel. This is where an inverted belt sander, or flat disk sander makes a much better sharpening tool -- as long as the belt runs away from the cutting edge. Contact me directly if you want to discuss how to make something inexpensive to sharpen your skews more easily.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: skew grind - hollow or flat?

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: skew grind - hollow or flat?

Keith Tompkins

>I agree with both Brad and JOhn.....hollow or not, not much difference. However,I will join the arguement between curved and straight grind . Tried both in depth....I don't care for the curved grind..it limits the tool a great deal. The only thing it's really good for with the curved grind is a planing cut. I find I cannot get into the bottom of a bead with either end of the tool before the curved portion hits the turning.(in effect, the long point and the short point have been ground away)

Re: skew grind - hollow or flat?

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: skew grind - hollow or flat?

Brad Vietje

>Hey Keith,

I keep two with a curve after watching Raffan's box-making video, especially his peeling cuts -- I think that's what he calls them -- where he sizes and shapes the sides of a box (or spindle piece) with the tool flat on the rest, with rapid side to side motions. I may not be explaining it very well, but I use it for that sort of thing, and for sizing and shaping most tenons. I have never been able to do this as well with a straight profile skew.

I also prefer a curved skew for cutting across end grain -- especially a slightly conical shape -- much like the spindle gouge cut you showed a few days ago, cutting across end grain at center. When I was learning the skew, I almost never got a carch doing this with the curved tool, as the curve takes the edge away from the wood.

I also agree entirely that the short point (heel ?) of the tool is lost when curved, so traditionally shaped skews are better for making beads that way.

My 3 cents,

Brad

Re: skew grind - hollow or flat?

#6

Re: skew grind - hollow or flat?

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>Alan Lacer has 2 DVD's that deal with the skew. I made a skew with his directions and love it. It is a hollow grind, curved with a small straight spot. The key to using a skew is it must be really sharp. Honing is a must. My 2 cents.

Mike

Re: skew grind - hollow or flat?

#7

Same Here John

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi John,

I do the same, for that reason alone, honing is so much easier.

Take care,

Jim