Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Building oil finishes

Posts

Building oil finishes

#1

Building oil finishes

Carole Valentine

>It is not really my preference, but it seems that a lot of people (buyers in this region, at least) like a high gloss finish on decorative pieces, especially dyed ones. I sincerely hate working with lacquer so I have been experimenting to see just how high a gloss I can get with oil (Waterlox). I can get an extremly high gloss - lacquer-like in appearance - by building and wiping, building and wiping and on the final coat, merely smoothing the oil and not wiping it all off. These last few coats, especially the final one, are more *on* the wood than *in* it. Are these *on-the-wood* layers of cured oil subject to degradation over time like many of the film finishes I have seen? Crazing, flaking, etc.? Russ says that oil remains a little more flexible than lacquers and that makes sense, but don't the successive layers of lacquer sort of dissolve into one another? I am not sure if Waterlox or other hardening oils do that when used as a high-build finish. Of course the only way for me to tell anything about the durability is to let the pieces sit around for years and see what happens, so I thought I'd check on the collective experience here.

Re: Building oil finishes

#2

Re: Building oil finishes

John Lucas

>Carol Try True Oil. It is a high build finish that you rub on. I'm doubt that it is an oil, probably an oil varnish mix. It builds quickly and looks great.

Just to give you a comparison. I put 60 coats of boiled linsead oil on an old gunstock to get the kind of sheen and depth I wanted. I steel wool it and then apply a new coat every night. to get the very nearly the same look with True oil it took about 5 or 6 coats (I didn't count) There was a little more depth and color the the linsead oil stock but not enough to make the difference in my opinion.

I bought my last batch at Walmart but I 'm sure there are probably better places to buy it, especially in quantity.

Re: Building oil finishes

#3

Re: Building oil finishes

Carole Valentine

>John,

What about the durability? Will it craze or crack?

Re: Building oil finishes

#4

Re: Building oil finishes

RussFairfield

>Waterlox has long been a preferred finish on furniture because it builds a durable gloss surface film that doesn't turn as yellow or get as brittle with age as some of the other oil and varnish finishes. The gloss and hardness is from the phenolic resins that are added to it, and the colorfastness is from the UV resistance of the cured Tung Oil that binds them together.

Yes, it will yellow and get brittle with age, because ALL finishes yellow and get brittle with age. Some are just worse than others. The Tung Oil is more UV resistant than the Linseed, Fortifies Soybean, and other oils that are used in finishes. And there is nothing you can put on a piece of wood that will get as dark an prange as fast as a Polyurethane.

If hardness and durability were your only criteria for a finish, you would want to use any of the Polyurethane finishes. The reason that Polyurethanes have replaced alkydes on the market is that they are harder and more durable. More important, they are cheaper to produce, and price is the NUMBER ONE reason that most people use for selecting a finish.

We accept the yellowing because the finish is on a dark wood or a light wood such as Maple that itself turns an amber color with age. I think the larger reason is that we have learned to accept the yellowing as a fact of life. When all of our wood is coated with Polyurethanes, nobody knows the difference because it all looks that way.

Nitrocellulose lacquers will turn yellow and become brittle with age. Being such a lacquer, Deft will turn yellow with age, but maybe not as dark or as fast as others, nor as brittle because of the plasticisers that have been added. Coat a piece of bleached white wood with Deft and it will have a definite yellow coloring in less than 3-years of normal indoor exposure. A better lacquer would be a CAB Acrylic lacquer that is clearer to start with and stays that way longer. Most woodturners don't use them because Deft is more convenient and more available. Mark Kauder uses McFadden's Instrument and Joel Hunnicutt uses Sherwin-Williams. Both are a sprayed application of CAB-Acrylic lacquers that have been modified for use on wood.

Re: Building oil finishes

#5

Re: Building oil finishes

John Lucas

>The rifle I did with this the true oil was done about 6 years ago and still looks great except for some abrasions from use. The linsead oil gun was done about 15 years ago and still looks great. Neither of them have any problems with the finish as far as clouding, cracks etc.

Re: Building oil finishes

#6

Thanks, John

Carole Valentine

>

Re: Building oil finishes

#7

Re: Building oil finishes

RussFairfield

>John,

I would expect both finishes to be the same because they are the same. Tru-Oil is a modified Linseed Oil. It builds faster because it has a higher solids content, and it cures faster because it is modified by a process of partial-polymerization. It also costs more than Linseed Oil.

Re: Building oil finishes

#8

Re: Building oil finishes

Carole Valentine

>Russ, maybe I didn't make part of my question very clear...let me try again. What I am wondering is, do successive coats of something like Waterlox actually become *part* of one another, like shellac does? Does the new coat pentrate into the previous coats or does it just sit on top of the last coat? For example, on something covered with many layers of paint, you can chip each layer off separating it from the preceeding layer. Do oil/varnishes act this way if allowed to cure between coats or is there a chemical bond when a new coat is applied?

Re: Building oil finishes

#9

Re: Building oil finishes

RussFairfield

>No. yes, and maybe, are the answers to your questions. Shellac and lacquer are solvent finishes that dry by evaporation, and oils are a polymerization process where the smaller liquid molecules link with each other to form a larger solid molecule.

The solvent finishes bond to themselves by melting the existing finish.

We consider the oils and varnishes as being a mechanical bond and that is why we recommend buffing back the surface gloss before putting on the next coat. However, the reality is that there is some of the same mechanism that makes glue stick; and whether this is a molecular bonding or some other reaction is still open to debate. Some finishes stick to themselves without buffing quite readily. Others don't.

Re: Building oil finishes

#10

Re: Building oil finishes

John Lucas

>Thanks Russ. I haven't used it in years and actually just bought some the other day to try on some turnings just to see the differences between it and some other finishes I'm going to pick up.

Re: Building oil finishes

#11

Thanks! Never an easy answer, huh?

Carole Valentine

>

Re: Building oil finishes

#12

Re: Thanks! Never an easy answer, huh?

David Breth

>Ain't that the truth - but anytime Russ gets involved, the responses are so complete, and so helpful. Anytime I see his name under a post about finishing, I read it all.

And by the way, I recently saw a tru oil gun stock that somebody did years ago, he uses the gun, and it has held up extremely well. Gorgeous.

David B.

Re: Building oil finishes

#13

Re: Thanks! Never an easy answer, huh?

Marvin ewing

>All the woodcraft stores sell tru-oil gun stock finish

Re: Building oil finishes

#14

Ditto for me on Russ...

David

>

Re: Building oil finishes

#15

Building oil finishes

ob obrien In Pensacola

>Carol; Here's something for you to consider. Iv'e been using a water based lacquer. It's sprayed on, drys quickly and builds a thick gloss finish. Three coats are about equal to many coats of lacquer. It's water clear, has a high UV inhibitor content and is food safe. On light colored woods I wipe on some tung oil, then the next day start spraying the WB lacquer. After about 20 to 30 minutes I sort of sand it with the grey or white non woven pads and put the second and third coats on. Then its buffed. Dosen't look like it's been plasticized either. It's not harmful, non explosive and is cleaned up with water. If you get a run, then just wipe it off and spray again. It will burn in to the previous layer. The stuff I use is made by Target Coatings. As you can tell I'm sold on it.

Re: Building oil finishes

#16

Deft is a brand, not a product. *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>I can only assume you mean Deft lacquer. Is that the brush on or the spray?

Deft has a whole line of finishing products, one of which is a brush on lacquer another is a Danish Oil finish. They also have a line of polys.

I think Deft is the only finish brand that I have ever heard treated in this way and frequently 2 different conversations will be talking about 2 different products. I know 2 artists in Illinois that swear by Deft for a finish on a piece, but they are both talking about different products and cannot be persuaded there are any other products in the line. (Not saying that is the case for you, just something I think is interesting related to Deft.)

Carole,

Have you tried Hope's Pure Tung Oil? Based on what Russ has stated, it sounds like Tung Oil (or at least a strong Tung Oil content) is a good way to go. I was surprised how reasonable Hope's is based on other places I had priced Tung Oil. A quart was $12 or $13 and a gallon about $35. I picked up a quart recently, but haven't applied it as yet. One of our group's turners buys it in large quantities at substantial savings. I think he buys direct. Maybe 5 gallons at a time.

-Craig

-Craig


Deft Finishes Home Page

Re: Building oil finishes

#17

Re: Deft is a brand, not a product.

RussFairfield

>We can argue definitions and brand names all day, but the name "Deft" has been synonymous with "brushing" lacquer for at least 30 years that I know of. It has onlt been in recent years that Deft has started using the word "lacquer" (once) on their can of "Wood Finish".

DeftOil and other finishes are relative newcomers to woodworkers. I know they have been around a lot longer, but it has only been within the last couple years that I have seen these other Deft products in general circulation.

Just as there are still people who refer to all refrigerators as a "Frigidair" and all vacuum cleaners as a "Hoover", there are still a lot of woodworkers and turners who refer to all Danish Oils as "Watco". However, there are now lacquers and polyurethane finishes now being marketed with the Warco label, but Watco will always be synonymous with "danish oil" finishes.