Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

John Jordan shear scraper

Posts

John Jordan shear scraper

#1

John Jordan shear scraper

John Lucas

>I got to spend some time getting used to the John Jordan Schear scraper. This is something new he's offering. It is a handle and a blade with and edge on both ends. The blade stores in the handle when not in use. You extend it and lock it in place with a knob that screws through the handle.

It feels really solid in your hand. It has a 1/4" thick HSS blade that is ground at about 45 degrees in one direction on one end and 45 degrees in the other direction on the other end. This gives you 2 tools in one for use when shear scraping downhill traveling left or right.

The tool is ground to 45 degrees on the bevel and is sharpened by running a stone or diamond hone flat on the top to remove any old burr. Then running up the bevel to raise a new burr. I used a purple/medium EZ lap diamond hone. I tried the finer hones but they didn't raise as good a burr.

It seems work really well but this bowl was too small to really test it. Box elder is really prone to minor tearout when shear scraping. I did get some minor tearout but still had nice curls coming off of the scraper.

If you had to swap the blade around a lot the little knob would probably start to hurt your finger. I don't think this would be much of a problem if at all. My only other complaint is that it didn't come with blade storing instructions. There is a pin in the handle that keeps the blade from going all the way through and dropping to the floor. If you put the blade in the handle with the burr up it will hit this pin and dull it in this area. If you simply slide the handle in with the blade in the normal use position the bottom of the bevel hits this pin and everything is fine.


img

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

#2

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

John Lucas

>Here are some photos of the scraper in use. Hold it at about 45 degree angle or steeper and cut with the lower half. I pull the scraper with the handle ahead of the scraping edge.

Normally you would cut downhill with the grain but on this small bowl I had to cut uphill for the bottom half. It still cut cleanly and smoothed out any tool marks.

This photo shows the tool in both positions, left and right scraper. Did I mention it's hefty. This is a really solid tool.


img

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

#3

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

Ruth Niles

>John,

I got one of these new super-duper shear scrapers at the Florida show. I really love it because of the sharpness and the feel of the heftiness. It took me a few tries to be comfortable using it because it's intimidating until you see how nicely it shear cuts. I'm always respectful of new tools until I feel comfortable with them so that really wasn't exceptional to John's new scraper.

I think I'm going to be selling these in my booth at shows John Jordan doesn't attend; I'm working on it. : )

Ruth

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

#4

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

GaryG in MD

>John, I'm still trying to grasp all the variations. Do you always use this scraper long point up? ...Gary

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

#5

Re: John Jordan shear scraper *LINK*

John Lucas

>Gary I use it mostly long point up because it's a very comfortable angle. You could use it long point down or flat. I rounded over the top edge of the bowl with the scraper setting flat on the tool rest to see how well it worked. It can be aggressive this way so take very light cuts.

I guess I should mention that John is selling this tool. You can get it from his web site.


http://www.stubbylathe.com/

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

#6

Thanks John

GaryG in MD

>

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

#7

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hmmmm....Vedy intarestink!

Thanks for the test drive report, John.

Jen

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

#8

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

John Lucas

>Jennifer I hope to test drive it some more. I think it will make an excellent flat scraper if you polish the burr off and don't put another one back on. This will probably be great for some things. I know it was designed as a shear scraper but since the sharpening angle is 45 degrees it will probably make a good flat scraper.

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

#9

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>John,

I recently purchased the Ray Key shear scraper. It comes to a point like a diamond parting tool, but the two sides are sharpened like a scraper. Anyway, at a recent Don Derry seminar he pointed out that the burr left on the tool after sharpening was only magnetized particles and doesn't really last. He takes a diamond hone and hones off the burr. He then raises a new burr with a veritas burnisher. This burr is extremely sharp and really last a long time. I think this is just one way to do it but it really works for me.

Mike

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

#10

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

GaryG in MD

>Mike,

I'm very happy to hear this, because I had that exact idea yesterday when I saw that dangerous and useless long point hanging out there. I had already considered buying a diamond parting tool and regrinding it as a shear scraper. Now I know I'm going to do it.

I also use the Veritas Scraper Burnisher and like it a lot.

Thanks for the useful comment.

Gary

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

#11

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

John Lucas

>Gary this is a lot thicker than a diamond point parting tool and will chatter less and consequently cut cleaner. You still have the point of the tool hanging out there. Just stay away from it. It's just like using the skew and staying away from the long point on that.

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

#12

Re: John Jordan shear scraper

GaryG in MD

>John,

Yeah, now that you mention it, I could see that thickness in your photos, but at the time, it didn't penetrate my thick skull. Very good point; I'm sure that adds a lot to the stability and "feel" of the tool. Scratch the parting tool version.

I'm one of those newbies who has been avoiding the skew experience to-date, so that makes using the pointy scraper a little more "interesting". Re the diamond point shape: I figure if I don't have that long point hanging out there, I'll be forced to stay closer to the heel where there's less chance of getting it whammed down on the tool rest if my tool placement and angles are a little off.

I'll have to compare the Ray Key version with the Jordan tool. Are you familiar with the former? How heavy is it in comparison? Are you aware of a source of appropriately sized HSS bar stock?

Thanks for sticking with this oldish thread,

Gary