We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>In my rambles around the net, I have seen pictures of pieces that folks have turned in preparation for shows, etc. that show obvious defects even in the photos (tool marks, sanding marks, lumpy/dusty finishes, poor form) which you can pretty well assume would be even worse in real life. Yet these folks sell their wares, apparently with some fair degree of success. I also see pieces that look like you could not find a defect with an electron microscope! My question, for those of you who are successful in selling your work, is where do you draw the line? Do you require a piece to be absolutely perfect in every aspect before you will let it be sold? Is there a line in the sand, so to speak, that you will not cross? If a piece is not perfect in your mind, do you sell it anyway but adjust the price accordingly?
I don't know that I have ever turned a single piece that I could not find something, no matter how small, that I thought could have been done better. I don't know that I ever will, because that just seems to be my nature. If that is the case, I will never sell anything! Is this a stumbling block that all of you had to cross somewhere in your turning career?
Self critique is a healthy thing in moderation, then we have to accept that we are not and will not ever be perfect and adjust our attitude accordingly.
>Excellent question Carole! I too am looking forward to this answer. I have trouble giving things away because I'm always finding faults myself. I can't imagine actually selling! Though my wife's nursing class saw the penlights I made for her and she wants me to do up a little order form so those that are interested can pick their colors and such. Fingers crossed!
>I think you should strive for perfection. And then read Jorge's post again. At some point you have to keep it real. I'm guessing the turner is alot more aware of the flaws in his work than the average person viewing it. And if turners of different skill levels are viewing or critique(ing) a piece opinions probably vary in comparison of the turners skill level compared to yours. If you still have your first bowl or hollow form ctitique it and you will see what I mean.
>Carole, I think we all have a different idea of what's "acceptable" in regards to finished product. I'm sure it all has to do with what we've been exposed to. If all we've seen up close is mediocre work then that's the level we'll shoot for. If you've seen superb work first hand then you have something to compare your work to and go from there. I think it's something that will always be evolving too. At the beginning we don't put as much pressure on ourselves to create the flawless pieces with the finishes we desire so much as we do later on.
I'm a pretty harsh critic of my own work, but will admit that there are pieces that I�ve sold knowing that there was some flaws about them that I didn't like. Mind you I'm not talking tool marks and chunks of tear out missing...but flaws that to me were not up to snuff. Like you said...I think that will always be the case. I�ll probably never be 100% completely satisfied with anything I make. As I progress in my turning those become fewer and farther between though, and that's what makes the journey of learning woodturning, and getting better at it so much fun.
This is an interesting topic. Since most of my work that sells are pens I will comment on my thoughts and process. When I first started to make pens 6 years ago I was so excited that people would actually buy my work. I think I enjoyed knowing the work was wanted more that I thought about the money.
If I look back know I know that my skills have improved and pens I used to sell I would not even consider trying to sell now.
What separates my earlier work from now is that I now make a ranking of my pens (last 2 years) when I am finished turning one. I will not knowingly sell any of my work if I know there is a mark or imperfection in the work that I am responsible for (tools marks, sanding marks, cracks, hardware issues etc.).
I have taken the thought that my work today advertises my work of tomorrow�and that quality is important to me and for my customers. Am I perfect yet, not yet, but persuing that is what keeps me at making more interesting work and improving my processes.
I believe my own credibility rides on each piece of work I make and allow for sale, my customers decide what they want and what they accept, I know I can not accept selling anything less than my best�and in turn they help to create my future�Just like in �Annie�, the Line, Tomorrow , Tomorrow is just a day away�.
>I know I'm nowhere ready to sell anything other than pens and bottlestoppers.
We have a turner with a shop in the Farmer's Market so he sells all the time. I mentioned to him I was having a devil of a time getting ride of the tool and scratch marks from the endgrain on the inside of the bowl. He told me just to tell the customer that that's the way it is with wood. Sometimes you can't get it the way you want it. When I told him the piece was going to another turner, he understood why I couldn't do that!
>I agree with Mr. Shaver. When I started out many years ago in photography and compare what I did then with what I do now, there is no comparison. Hopefully, that will happen in my turning. I am in no way ready to sell anything, but I can see an improvement over a year ago. So, If I keep turning for as long has I have been in photograpy, I can't wait to see how good it will be. Probably, never
>Carole, most of my hollow forms are sold while still in process, usually after the outside is nearly done but the inside is still in the raw. Most buyers do not care if the inside is perfect or not so I price it both ways....the inside sanded as well as the outside or the inside just "presentable". It is rare that I have a buyer say they want the inside perfect. Recently I have started offering a choice of finishes. I find that many buyers will pay more for an oil finish but some prefer a cheaper finish such as poly. Some varying degrees of quality are acceptable, I think, if you wish to make a living in this sport. My serial number reflects the nature of the piece; a piece with a poly finish will have a "P" added to the serial number. At festivals and such where I turn to promote our wood-turning club I give away the pieces that I turn and these are initialed with the year only, no serial number, no finish.
When I get a special piece of wood with a lot of character I go all out. I try to do the very best that I can do. I may spend months on the finish, I may strip the finish off and start over half a dozen times. Any visible flaw will be corrected until I am satisfied. Then I put a price on it and it doesn't leave my shop until it brings the price. If I spent that much time on every piece I would sell very few pieces. My advice: save your best efforts for your best wood.
>As others have said here "quality always sells".There is always someone who can do it faster or cheaper but you shouldn`t let that impact what you do.
The idea is not to make a "perfect" peice as wood is not a perfect material.The idea is to stretch your skills and make your things as good as you can make them.Be tough on yourself (which you already are) and don`t let substandard work go out the door,for any price.Bring your work to other turners who`s work you admire and ask them what they think it needs.When they have to look long and hard to find something then you know it`s well beyond what the public expects.
That being said,there is a point where good enough is good enough.I once turned a handle for a clamming rake out of birdseye maple for a friend(as a joke).He got so much flack from the other guys out on the flats he stopped using it altogether and went with another rake with a galvanized pipe handle.I also leave the handholds on every ship`s wheel I turn rough because that`s what`s needed in rough seas.Form (and finish) follows function.
After you think you have everything figured out and have finally arrived because your work`s in a gallery don`t be surprised to see someone walk right past your technicly superior work to buy that bowl with everything done "wrong" or half way.Chances are they know nothing about turning and all they see is a piece of pretty wood.
>Hi Carole, this is a great question! A thorough answer could fill a book! Here's the way I look at it.
Like most other turners, I'm able to find things in my work that can be improved. NOBODY is perfect. I think the trick is to analyze your work, and determine what your weak points are, then set about to improve them. Making the same mistakes over and over and over will not make you a better turner, it simply reinforces bad habits.
Like Mike pointed out last week, I have a "mantra". Instead of producing great quantities of work, focus on only one piece at a time....and make that piece as good as you are capable of. Not perfect, but something you know is the best you can do RIGHT NOW!
By taking that approach, you will notice a steady improvement in your work. You won't have pieces sitting on a shelf that you are not happy with....If you constantly patch things up, re-design most pieces because of catches, and settle for sanding marks, etc, it will be difficult to advance to a higher level. Turn a bad piece? Toss it. Start over. I will admit, it's not the easiest approach, but in the long run, it pays off.
What if I produce a piece I'm not happy with? I either cut it up, or toss it into the wood stove. Does it happen? Yes. Am I a perfectionist...? Maybe, but I won't let a mediocre piece leave my shop. I want each new piece to be my best one yet...I strive to produce a masterpiece each time. I would rather turn one great piece that a thousand lousy ones.....
I cannot stress the importance of practice enough. I still practice my basic cuts each time I turn. I compare this practice to a musician warming up by playing their scales. Good tool control solves many problems all by itself...this only comes from practice.
Unfortunately, some people mistake my attitude towards my work as arrogance, but I don't look at it that way. I want to do the best work I am capable of, and hope I can inspire others to do the same. Ask yourself..." What could I acomplish if I truly did my best?"
Great idea for a thread. I'm looking forward to everyone's responses.
For me, perfectionism is not a line in the sand, but more of a gray area we all strive to achieve. No matter how perfect the finish on a piece, we might look at it and say, this area could be a little more rounded or the foot could have been a little smaller, etc. I think that perfectionism of the mechanics is possible, but only after many years of practice and patience. I know I am not even close to that! Perfection of form, that's a totally different story to me. I honestly feel like just about anyone can learn the mechanics of turning, how to use a chuck and gouge and turn a bowl that looks good. But to turn a bowl or vessel or pen or stopper or whatever that has really good form, that's skill, that's (dare I say it?) artistry. :)
Insofar as my own turning, I look at it like this. I honestly know that what I make is good. It's not great, but it is good. The bowls feel good and have a nice finish to them. I have no real illusions of being a David Ellsworth or Bin Pho or Sam Maloof or whoever, but I know for certain that I can do better than what I am currently doing and that's what I am striving for. I figure if I continually try to improve the mechanics and the form, then I am making progress. I find that each area progresses in fits and starts and at its own rate!
Personally, I sell very little of what I make. I give a tremendous amount of it away, though. I have done pieces that after they were finished, I won't give them away or sell them because the work really has something wrong with it. A too thin wall, funky shape, or what have you. Fortunately, I have a wood burning fireplace :)
I am currently in the midst of a fairly large builtin cabinet project for a very good friend. When going over one of them and my critiquing some of it, she asked about some small problem I mentioned that she couldn't really see. I explained it like this, and it applies to turning as well. I know for certain I will make mistakes. I try to take my time and work carefully with the goal of minimizing those mistakes. I know they will still creep in and I will miss something, but knowing I will not reach perfection, doesn't stop me from striving to attain it.
From what I seen of your work recently your are definately getting their. And being seperated from any other turners, your question and your fantastic results indicate that you are your own hardest critic.
Long ago, I read/heard Wally wrote/said "Good enough is not good enough". When you are done, you need to have done the best you can do. That does not mean the best that can be done. The best that you can do at your current skill and experience level. Since then, I have tried to do that. And like others posting here, what I did as my best two years ago, embarrasses me now. But if I had not followed the "Good enough is not good enough" creed, my work would not have advanced significantly.
NOW, THAT SAID, If you are selling, your best may have categories. Best that you can do - within the price range of what that piece will sell for, is definately a consideration. This is usually a consideration on a more utilitarian piece.
Since I happen to do mostly art pieces, I think that the only way to go with art pieces is the very best you can do - period. It will pay off in the end. Your work will continually bring more and more ($) as the quality of your work is recognized.
>Carol I strive for perfection but I have to be real. You won't see tearout, sanding marks or poor finishing on any of my work. I value my reputation too much for that. But, I have to consider the final price and cut some corners. Around here I can't sell certain items at very high dollar. A good example are my wine stoppers. A wine stopper with a cork will only sell for around $12 and the gallery takes 40 percent of that. I can't justify sanding to 1200 grit or making really fine details in the turning. I have to make them fast. On my finer wine stoppers with Ruth Niles stoppers I take extra time to finish and turn better. It's very subtle and most people cannot tell the difference but I can.
Bowls don't sell for much around here so I can't justify putting 10 coats of lacquer and hand polishing them to a super high finish. I chose a less complicated finish and I only sand to 400 grit. Even though I'm cutting corners on these items you still won't see tool marks, sanding marks or bad finish. They don't have the Wow factor that my top of the line pieces have but I refuse to make one that doesn't look like I cared about what I am doing.
I know I should make the best possible pieces but I need the money so I make what will sell around here. Someday I may find a place to sell what I really want to produce and then I will make each piece as carefully as I can but for now I think I give the customer a very good piece for the money they spend and I'm still proud of what I do.
>Perfectionism, in my mind, is a lose-lose proposition: You spend too much time on fussy details, so your costs go up and your margins go down; plus, you're never completely satisfied with your work. And, to the extent that you obsess about perfection, you never really break free of those self doubts.
But, there is a difference between the wasteful pursuit of perfection and the free and honest and unfettered approach to our craft. I have been called a perfectionist by people who didn't understand the difference between perfection and high standards. To me, the danger is that in resisting the urge for perfection we will settle for something that is less than we are capable of doing.
A very timely question. I have been turning about 18 months. Last Sunday, I set up the first public display of my work. It is 22 items including platters, bowls, and oil lamps and will run for six weeks in the gallery at my church. I was quite anxious about the show, anxious about what was good enough to display.
The "what is good enough question" caused me to rechuck several finished items to try to correct small blemishes in the finish. Imperfections that likely only I, (or a crititcal turner) would see. Unfortunately, I ended up breaking a 14" platter of ambrosia maple. It had wonderful figure and was to be the showcase of my display. While not "perfect" I considered it a beautiful piece.
I also found it interesting that several items that I thought the form was lacking on were very well received and desired for purchase. Beauty is in the eye ... The bottom line for my display is that 19 of the 22 items have commitments for purchase after the show and many folks have requested similar work. Granted this is a friendly audience, but I think people truly liked my work and this was very gratifying to me.
I work with wood becasue it is a natural living thing and I enjoy the anticiaption of exposing the grain and figure of each piece I turn. I do not turn to sell gallery pieces. I turn because the process relaxes me. The work displayed on this forum is a constant reminder that there is lots of room for improvement but the reaction to my show has convinced me that folks are happy to have my current work as well.
What are you trying to achieve in your woodworking? Earning a living? Or having fun building things with the hopes that someone will buy a few items and give you a reason to start something else?
The economy is driving industry to build exactly what the customer needs in order to stay in business. Nothing more. Nothing less. Your product has to appeal to your customer base you decide upon. Are you working the art galleries who's customers have a little more disposable income, or the craft bazzar at church? Extra effort will satisify you on a product, but you won't reap any financial reward out of it. Insufficient effort will not yield adequate sales. If you get a good wow-factor on less than perfect work and can make a decent profit, good for you.
The craftsman will always be able to find fault with his work.
Myself - - I'm starting to land on a quality level of my bowls that has been evolving this past year and will be working on developing a customer base this spring. Have no idea where it will take me, but I'll have to adapt to what base I decide upon.
>Putting things in the perspective of selling your work, the turner who produces salad bowls quickly and efficiently, finishes them, puts a $100 price tag on them, and sells 500 of them grosses $50,000 and has 1000 satisfied customers. (Do single people buy salad bowls)
On the other hand, the turner who obsesses over the smallest detail, sells through a gallery and produces 10 to 20 masterpieces a year still may sell $50,000 worth a year but has a completely different experience.
In my opinion both are craftsmen, one's an artist, both have money in their pocket from the work they achieved, and both have customers that appreciate the value of the work they did.
The question is, why are you doing what you're doing? Is the obsessivness truly for you, is it for the customer, or is it for other turners? If it's for you, is your obsessivness causing any harm? Are you staying up at night thinking about finishes and tool marks? Is it hindering your development? Are you stressed when you're turning? If it's for the customer, have you evaluated them correctly and is the price point right for what you're offering? Are they willing to pay for your perfection? Do you have the right customer? If it's for other turners it's for the wrong reason.
For me it's like golf. If I go out and try to play against the other players I'll be tired by the 9th hole, I'll try to force things to correction, and my score will tank. I'll be miserable by the time I finish 18. If I go out with a relaxed attitude, playing against myself instead of the other players, my score will tank but I've still had a great and relaxing time.
>I am glad that Ellis got to this one before me. I am in the good enough crowd, but before I am banned from the forum for not sanding to one million grit with the grain, I need to qualify my statement a bit.
I do this stuff for a living. As such, I have to justify the amount of time spent per piece. Otherwise, it just isn't going to work. I cannot spend four days on a salad bowl. In the first place, no one would pay me for it, and in the second, it is a waste of time for something that is going to get scratched up in use anyway. An artsy bowl is a different story, as it commands a higher price and is going to see a dusting cloth more than mashed potatoes and sauerkraut.
So when I say good enough, good enough is always the best that I can do for a particular piece, time considerations taken into account as well as intended function, my skill level, etc. It has met the standard it needs to meet to be sold for a particular price. I think it is important to continually strive for good enough to be better, and as I look back over my work, that is the case, at least from my point of view.
Ellis made a comment years ago at one of our guild meetings, about how amateurs could turn out better work than professionals because there were no time or money constraints other than those self imposed. There is a lot of truth in that. I make fewer pieces than a lot of turners I know, so maybe I am subconciously taking Keith's words to heart as well.
You said better what I was trying to convey in one of my paragraphs. And as you point out, that "Good Enough" level raises for any given time alloted as skill increases.
This is true for both the utiliarian bowls and the art bowls. As my skill and experience has increased on my art bowls, it now takes me 1/2 as long to finish one of my lacquered bowls, but by requiring a high quality level for myself, the prices that I can command for a piece has tripled.
As always, my friend, we can depend on you to state things clearly.
�Woodturning is the art of finding beauty and/or function in all types of wood. The joy of discovery, the sensuous feel of shape and contour, the never ending variety of grain, color and texture are what keeps me up late into the night, playing in my shop.�
I stand in awe of Mother Nature.
The better I get at all phases of woodturning the more often I will unleash the full potential of each piece of wood.
If people actually buy one of my pieces, that�s just icing on the cake.
I suggest we either use the imperfect pieces around our shop or home as storage containers, finishing bowls, etc..., or put them to work for us by cutting them in half, or using them as examples of what we don't like about them. I have a few early bowls I use for sanding sealer application, wet sanding with oil, Watco, or other gunky stuff, and clunky boxes that are great for holding little shop gizmos, spare chuck screws, etc... This is where a box with that patented high-tech "Twist Lock" lid mechanism really comes in handy !
Our imperfections are great teaching tools if we work with beginners, or demonstrate at club meetings or symposia.
I think its also good to keep a few as snapshots of our progress and development as turners.
>Some people like to put jigsaw puzzles together. They will buy a 1500 piece puzzle and spend many hours putting it together. They do this for fun. When you are doing things for fun it doesn't matter how long it takes. Now suppose you are making your living putting puzzles together. Now suppose you get paid the same thing for a 100 piece puzzle as you would for a 1500 piece puzzle. Which one do you want to put together? The bottom line is "time is money" when you are making a living at something. Back to the puzzle....if you are getting paid to put the puzzle together do you think your employer would accept pieces not in the proper place? No, he would expect a certain level of quality. Would he pay more if you carefully dusted each piece before putting it in? No, he has agreed to pay a certain amount for each puzzle. So the answer is: if you are doing this just for fun you will go one way; if you are doing it for an income you will go another, but a certain level of quality will be expected either way. Set your sights realistically. Spend enough time to do it acceptably. Occasionally , when you have a jewel of a piece of wood put your best effort into it and then hold on to it until someone is willing to pay the price of your labor. If it never sells you know you put too much time into it unless it was done just for you.
>Still young in my turnings, but I think I can chime in effectively. For me, I'll eliminate tool marks, sanding marks, tear out and the like, such that when I've finished a piece, it feels good in the hand and looks good to the eye. I'm not overly concerned about form, and not sure I have the artistic leanings to actually have that weigh heavily on me - but I know ugly, and it if is ugly, I keep turning until it isn't. That is good enough for me.
BUT - each piece that comes off the lathe, I can still see tool marks or sanding marks that weren't visible before, or something else that makes me think "I should put that back on the lathe". But another part of me - the part that frequently wins - says "no my friend, you said you were done, you're done. Better luck next time." If it weren't for this little voice, I don't think I could enjoy doing this. I would drive myself out of my mind over the tiniest of details. I end up with a triumphant "Good Enough!".......but next time.....! That should not be interpretted as "anything goes", however, as that is far from the case!
Plus, there are two back-of-my-mind elements. First is, I want the piece ready for finish when it comes off the lathe, and I want to discipline myself to resolve issues before I ever remove a piece from the lathe. Maybe that's naive, but I need a point where I can say "I'm done with the tools". It is rare for me to remount. Second, I want to leave some room to improve. If I made "the perfect bowl" even once, I'm not sure I would want to turn another. Even a mighty fine example from me will yield a few lessons on what I would like to improve on next time around. Here we go in pursuit of subjective perfection.
I turn for myself. Lots of items are given away, and I won't give away less than my best effort. If other people are going to examine, purchase, own and enjoy my work, I want it to be mighty fine because the quality of the work is a reflection on how much I care about the recipient and their enjoyment of the item. Truth to tell, most friends who receive something will think it is cool beans unless it is total junk, because they have an appreciation at some level that significant time went into the piece and feel quite special that you did this specifically for them. There's a magical "howdja do that" quality to a bowl. An "I could never do that" mystique. We're jaded and burdened by our knowledge of what could have been done better, but our recipients (frequently) are not. They are burdened only with a self-imposed obligation not to damage the piece because they prize it so.
Anyway, my two cents but you've got change coming. Sorry to write the encyclopedia. Its Friday and I really would rather write like this than work.....