Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Absolute beginners classes...survey

Posts

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#26

Mixed bag classes

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>It`s those classes that are a mix of snails and jackrabbits that really keep you on your toes isn`t it?

I try to start all the students with a roughing exercise to get a feel for where everyone REALLY is at.I just cut more blanks than I think I`ll need in case I get some real speedy turners.

For those who don`t know anything at all there`s always the I do,we do,you do approach.I`ve found that talking only conveys about 10%(or less) of what they need to learn.It`s the seeing and doing where the learning and retaining that info takes place.

I also find that my hearing comes into play alot in teaching.After awhile you get where you can hear impending doom even with 6 lathes running.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#27

Re: It won't work, as a matter of ......

JamieDonaldson

>......practical reality. There is not standard test to qualify someone as "Instructor," and the situation becomes more of a cult of personalities rather than an inclusive listing of skills. As an Army trained "Instructor" a first principle was to assume the "Trainee" knew nothing, a tabula rasa and sponge to be molded onto the Army Way or the highway. There is no Big Judge to render accreditation and bless the list in most fields in the real world, and that's certainly also true in turning. And a method that works for one doesn't work for the rest, just ask a school teacher these days! I think that local turning clubs are the first/ best contact to connect beginners with mentors, and places like Arrowmont and J.Campbell Folk School are the intermediate stepping stones to higher education in turning. I have observed this dilemma in other business fields, and there is no teacher certification or diploma that guarantees success.

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#28

Re: Bill, entertainer or teacher?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Terry, I think that there are a few that fall into that category, and I have even had a couple myself, who would rather watch than work. I am with Wally on this one, the more hands on a person can get, the more they are going to learn.

I usually handle my class in one of two ways. If the person has seen my DVD or had previous experience, I get them right on the lathe. If not, I do a very quick roughout of the piece to give them a framework to understand the process I am taking them through. I find that a few minutes beforehand watching adds up to a much more enjoyable experience for the student (and the teacher!) because they know better what is coming next.

Bill

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#29

Re: Who vs. What

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Jim

Very good comment - what is the most important I think. The measure of a teacher is how well they can communicate the information, and ultimately how much students take with them. Not every student will be a fantastic success, but if more are successful than not, I think that is a good measure of the effectiveness of a teacher. Part of that is giving the student reasonable expectations. I have had students come in wanting to do three days worth of work in one, but once we get through the first half day, things start to come clear. Sometimes somone will show up wanting to turn a winged bowl without having ever done a basic one first, so we need to scale things back a bit. In every case (with me at least) people have been very cooperative and easy going. I have to say that I find teaching very enjoyable, and I love seeing where people go and what they do once they leave here.

Bill

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#30

Re: Who vs. What

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>I am currently involved with a turning program at Roundtop Center for the Arts and have been since the beginning.I have either helped to write or have written myself(mostly bowlturning classes)the programs of instruction (what the manager calls a syllabus).Now we all teach from the same programs and the same skills are being taught.If the WHAT is the same then perhaps someone could explain why some instructors have no problem filling classes and others can`t fill.Also why some students will request the next class but only if taught by a certain instructor.If that instructor is not teaching the follow on class next they will wait till they are teaching.

I think the reason comes down to a mix of skill,ability,and personality and not all related to turning either.

I spent more than 15 years as an Army instructor,10 of them with the Drill Sgt program,and another 6 teaching how to be an effective NCO and leader.I can`t count the number of times I have been told by a civilian with no military experience that my experience is NOT applicable in thier program(including Roundtop),but I`d be willing to bet the number is equal to the number of people who have appologised after being proven wrong.

The job of ANY instructor/teacher is to find the switch between the student and the program and flip that switch so learning can begin to flow BOTH WAYS.The student is there to learn what you have to teach and you are there to learn how to be a more effective instructor in the classes to follow.Each class should teach YOU something as well as the students.

Three things I can say for sure,1-the switch is different for each student and 2-if the students stay motivated thru most of the day and ask to stay after class ends then chances are you`ve found thier switch and flipped it.The third thing I know for sure is that there is nothing quite as fulfilling as seeing one of your students exceed the limits of his teacher.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#31

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

Don Tewell

>I'd be very interested in getting the opportunity to receive more training/instructions. There is a weekly class locally but because of the day on the week, I can't attend a often as I need/like.

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#32

where are you?

T Daniel

>

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#33

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

David Lykins - Marietta GA - guitardude

>My only reccomendation is that the classes reccomended are HANDS ON and not demo type classes where the student never gets to touch the tools. I'f you're learning how to turn anything from a pen to a segmented bowl, you'll learn it much faster and remember more in my book if you actually get to do the work.

However, I'm assuming that most turning classes taught actually let the student turn a piece of wood on the lathe so they have a good feel of lathe speed, how the different chisles cut...etc. I'm a visual and hands on kind of guy much like most of you here, once I see someone do it I want to get my hands on the tools/machine and try it.

Just MHO as a novice turner.

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#34

Re: where are you?

Don Tewell

>Sorry about that. Central Illinois, 30 miles SE of Springfield and 30 SW of Decatur.

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#35

From a novice's perspective

Roger Smith

>First, Terry, thanks for starting a thought provoking thread.

This is some of what I gathered in reading this thread.

1. Not all great turners make great insturctors.

2. Most all people agree that hands-on training is important.

3. The student needs to be open-minded. The hardest person to teach at the seminary was the student with a Scoffied Bible that already had all of the answers.

5. Equally the teacher should not be so narrow as to say their way is the only way.

5. The need for feedback.

6. The difficulty in objective rating an instructor. Instruction is too much a two-way communication.

What I did not notice (maybe I missed it) but was the need of the student to define goals for the training. I am speaking from someone that has not had a turning lesson, yet. In this case I am speaking as a student and not an instructor. It was and is my first responsibility to define my goals for the training session. The instructor may help define those goals. I think he/she also has the obligation to tell me if the class meets those goals or not. If not then release me from the class and not waste mine, yours or the other students time.

just my observation from the sidelines.

roger

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#36

Re: From a novice's perspective

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Roger, you need to come and see me, and I promise I will leave my Scofield in the house (although my Ryrie has been known to surface from time to time!).

Bill (who was almost Calvinized at a Reformed seminary)

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#37

Jumping Back In *LINK*

George (Oxford, NC)

>I had mentioned earlier that I was taking my first (very beginning) class. With many saying that there should be small classes and lots of hands on, I am looking forward to my class, and all day class with the following description:

http://www.woodcraft.com/stores/store.aspx?id=532&nav=classes

George


Agenda For My First Class

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#38

OOPS, Click on Feb 4 Class

George (Oxford, NC)

>

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#39

Re: Mixed bag classes

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Bob, I know exactly what you mean when you mention hearing. In a class I was teaching a while back, we were using glue blocks and faceplates or screw chucks. I heard a sound that could only mean one thing....the student had cut through the bottom of his bowl and was trying to cut through the faceplate screws.

Wally

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#40

Beginner's class should be:

T Daniel

>independant of what the student expects from it as far as establishing basic technique. Now there could be a beginner's class on spindle turning or a beginner class on faceplate turning but beyond that I would not think a beginners class would be tailored to an individual's needs....that would be more in line with what would be done in an intermediate class. If a student wants to learn how to make pens he should enroll in a beginning penmakers class but he should read the requirements for the class first. Some classes will say something like "basic fundalmentals class required before taking this class". Basic 101 might be more of an introductory class or it might be a basic bowl making class or a basic spindle turning class. You just have to ask what is being covered in the class before enrolling.

TD

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#41

Keith Tompkins

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks Bob, I think TD is on to something.

Re: Absolute beginners classes...survey

#42

Isn`t that why...

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>we went to HSS gouges?;^)

MB