We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Many come to our board to find someone near that can help them get started turning. Should we put a list together of recommended instructors in each area of the country? I took classes when I was learning that hurt more than they helped and some of these were from nationally known and respected turners but were just too far over my head at the time. How much should be taught in a one day class? Should our list be state by state or NE, SE, SW, NW, etc?
>I think that it depends on the class and class description. I just bought my first lathe (30+ years of woodworking) in December. I am taking a Turning 101 class at my semi-nearby Woodcraft. The description of the class is for people with no knowledge. They have other turning classes that describe themselves as for 'little', or 'intermediate' skill levels. There is no way that I would even think of taking a class at one of the WW schools at this point. I think that I would rather take a 'beginners' class from an experienced turner as a start. This class is, by the way, limited to five students so there is going to be a lot of one-on-one. Maybe its just me and my age, but I don't know if I would trust an out-of-the-blue name off of a forum (although a well respected name and forum)for my first class in basics.
>My defining moment was when it dawned on me that we had aspiring woodturners whose first exposure of anything to do with wood was their lathe, and the only cutting tools they had ever used were for cutting paper and peeling a potato. That makes instruction more difficult, but not impossible.
>Russ I have at least 2 people in each of my classes who have never seen a lathe and usually have never worked in wood. We have found at the Craft Center that if we list a class as intermediate and advanced that the class won't fill. By leaving it open it does fill but makes my job really intersting because I will have at least one pretty good turner a couple of advanced beginners and a couple of raw newbies.
>Good post Terry. The new turner is really in a dilema when going for instruction. The problem, to me is, how you are initially taught, is the way you will turn. It will be difficult to change once patterns become habits.
There are so many turners who give instruction, that it's hard to tell who the good ones are, and which ones really know how to turn, let alone teach. sometimes I shake my head when I see how some newbies have been taught....terrible sharpening skills (taught by another turner) etc.
Personally, I would rather teach a raw newbie than someone who has been to a few classes. That way, I don't have to start over.
To answer the question, yes, it's an excellent idea. I would qualify that by insisting that the instructor is rated in all categories, just like the turning schools do it. That way, fellow turners could review their stats. A scale of 1-10 may be a good way to evaluate a teacher.
>Terry this is a great post and prompts a very ambitious project. How would you evaluate prospective instructor? We all teach whenever we share an idea or demonstrate a process, but we teach OUR idea and OUR process. Keith would like to start with a clean palette, so would I but I think it wrong to presume that only my way is the right way and that know one else can convey the truth like I can . I have been turning for a long time and have some methods that I have come to like and enjoy passing on to others but they work for me. I have attended classes with some very well known and respected turners and teachers but not all of their methods are right for me. Whether we call it a craft or art it is very subjective. A skew is like a paint brush. They each have a masterpiece locked inside them. Ellsworth and Raffan each have their method and process of coaxing the masterpiece out. I think you would agree they are both good teachers but I for one find difficulty with some of their processes. Sorry for the rant but I teach, and I don�t think I do a bad job of it, but I believe my students should be the judge.
>I agree Bob, we all have ways of doing things that have evolved and they work well for us. Necessity is the mother of all invention and you learn to work with what you have. It took me a long time to convert to the fingernail grind bowl gouge but I finally got it right. I know people that are still teaching new turners to start with a scraper. That works but I prefer to start with a student who has never had a lesson than one who has learned to turn with scrapers. I think that may be what Keith was talking about. So far we have not received any suggestions from those who have recently crossed this bridge. Hopefully we'll get some names and comments.
>HI Bob, thanks for the response...I have similar experiences to yours...often, during my classes, I'm told "But, that's not the way the Raffan video shows how to do it!"
My reply is, after watching the video, and attending years of instructions, you are in my class. You are here because, in spite of (or because of) your endeavors, you still are not happy with your progress as a turner.Therefore, while you are here, give my methods a chance.
Again, similar to you, I will show a student what has worked for me and past students. They are welcome to try it...I don't insist that my methods are gospel; rather, I suggest they take what they like from my class and use it. If my methods don't work for them, that's fine too. All I ask from them is an open mind.
Here's where the problems begin. A student with several years experience cannot sharpen a tool. His previous instructors insist that any turner worth his salt cannot use grinding jigs, they must sharpen freehand. The student in question has ruined most of his tools; and the grinds are so inconsistant that they are unuseable. (Not a hypothetical case...) I show him how to use a grinding jig..better sharpening and instantly better turner. NOW he can progress as a turner.
Another example...a turner has spent five years turning poor forms...and is frustrated by his lack of progress. His forms look exactly like his previous instructor's. He makes what he has been taught to make, and he cannot seem to break out of the rut he has dug for himself. If he is willing, I can show him design ideas that will greatly improve his pieces.
Other turners I will bluntly explain...You need to start over. Forget what you know, and become a blank sheet of paper. Otherwise, there is nothing I can do. You will be wasting your time as well as mine. It may sound a bit rough, but if I truly want to help this person, there's not much else I can do.
Do I think I am the best instructor in the world? Do I think my way is the only way? Of course not. However, I am dead serious about what I do....and I will do my absolute best to teach those who seek my help...and I will tell it how I see it. Am I so narrow minded that I won't listen to other methods? No. In fact, if you had a technique that worked better than mine, I'd use it in a heartbeat.
>Terry, I think you have come up with a terrific idea. As for qualifications, i guess you pays yer money and you takes your chances. For the newbie, anything can help a person get started. Also newbies can get an idea of an instructors competence by looking at their work.
I have paid for videos put out by some big name turners that were pretty disappointing, but I don't regret trying.
Listing by state and specialty should work fine. I teach hollow turning, skew chisel and finials at the Woodcraft store in Milwaukee. I always show my work.
>I can't believe that anyone would accept money for teaching students to turn bowls using scrapers instead of a gouge. It's like teaching driving using a Model T Ford.
>I was a complete newbie less than 3 years ago and took a class at our local community building. Our instructor NEVER used a gouge and never used a chuck. He used files ground into scrapers and instructed me to go to flea markets and buy files and do the same and thats all I needed. We only made bowls and hollow forms!
A month after the class I joined the AAW and our local club and threw away the files.
>The wrong teacher can do you more harm than good. That is the purpose of this thread. The most difficult students are the ones who have received instruction from someone who perpetuates poor turning methods/practices. A basic turning lesson should be a foundation course that can be built upon. In my opinion we should never try to teach more than 2 tools in a one day beginners class. If a beginner can learn to sharpen and use a bowl gouge and a scraper to clean up a dovetail he can build on that. I agree with Keith about using the sharpening jig but there are some well known turners/teachers that insist that a beginner learn to sharpen without a jig; why? If a student is paying $150 a day for lessons why would he want to spend 3 days learning how to sharpen without a jig when he can learn to sharpen with a jig in 30 minutes? My first class was one where I was taught to sharpen without a jig....it was money down the tube. After 2 days of classes (not hands on) I had learned nothing. For learners: ask the "why" questions. If an instructor cannot give a reason for doing something a certain way then he probably doesn't have one....it is just the way he learned it. You must leave a class knowing why you ride the bevel, why you go right to left instead of left to right, why you sharpen the gouge a certain way, why you keep the cutting edge of the tool at the equator, why you don't make straight sided bowls, etc. These are the basic building blocks that will stay with you no matter who you take the next lesson from.
A scraper is a cutting tool, and a gouge is a cutting tool. One is not better than the other. They are different tools and each can do different things better than the other. Not using a scraper is like trying to turn with one hand tied behind out back.
My definition of "The Compleate Woodturner" would have both scrapers and gouges, the skills to use both, and the knowledge to know the difference.
>Russ, you misundersood me. I use scrapers a lot and I teach the use of scrapers where it's appropriate. I find fault with a teacher that doesn't teach the use of a bowl gouge. The virtual explosion of woodturning popularity came about when the bowl gouge became the tool to use in bowl turning.
>What a great group of responses to this post. And Keith your response to my post was exactly what I hoped for. You said what I wanted to with much greater eloquence. I have some of your same experiences and share your frustrations at having to correct what I perceive are methods taught by some one else. But the student bears some responsibility in this as well. They don�t always duplicate the method as taught. Like you, I always present my ideas as what works for me and welcome the student that can adapt them to their style or comfort level. I cannot then fault him for his adaptation, not if he gets good results. I moderate the �Show and tell� segment of our local club and see every level of talent and am forever amazed at what I learn from the process. When I do a demo or teach a class I always come away having learned something. Maybe I just enjoy wood turning so much that I find something fresh in every experience. I can�t imagine how Terry could carry this off but count me in!!
I have a few thoughts on the matter here. First and foremost, how are people going to be evaluated? Really, the best way to be evaluated is feedback from students. We already have that here to a certain extent, whether public or private. I rely on student feedback to the point where if someone contacts me, or even if I contact them (rare, but sometimes happens) I will suggest that they ask around for opinions from previous students. Any other system is going to be subject to, well, subjectivity. Even student feedback is that, but at least it is asking the people who have been there.
I think the body of work that a person produces is also important in establishing their bona fides, but the flip side of this, as you have already pointed out, is that there are a lot of well known and accomplished people who cannot seem to do a good job of communicating their skills - i.e. teach.
Geography might enter into it, although I have found that most of my students are from out of town - way out of town, like across the courtry, and even from other countries - well country, that being Canada. I get a fair number of locals, but location doesn't seem to be that important, other than it be close to major highways and airports.
I know it has to be tough on beginners who are looking for a teacher, as there are more teachers out there than one can shake a custom turned stick at, but I think it pays for people to do some research and ask around, and get feedback from others who have actually been there. There is one very famous person who gets recommendations all the time from folks who have never been to his shop, and while his reputation does precede him, I have to wonder how people who have never done something are qualified to hold forth on its value. Of course, there is a lot of that going around on the internet. ;-)
>Bob, you make a good point here. I will get students - repeats a lot of times - who are cutting wrong, and they will solemnly state that is the way I showed them how to do it, even when it wasn't. What is important to remember is that when we get a person in our shop who has been instructed by anyone, including ourselves, they are showing what they learned as they remember it, and not necessarily how it was presented. I go through this all the time with other students as well who are not turning related (But you said the War of 1812 was fought in 1810!).
There are all sorts of variables in the mix when someone comes to us, and the blank slate almost never exists. I have had a few people who have never held a gouge in their hands, but most have started out to some extent, even if it is nothing more than pushing bench chisels into a spindle to see what would happen! Yeah, I've seen that a couple of times. When someone comes into my shop, we do it my way because that is why they are here. If they have a better way they can do it when they leave. This does not preclude me learning from my own students, and I do that every time someone walks in the door, but my point is, if someone is paying me to teach them, there is some expectation that I am going to have something to teach, and a reason for teaching it. If I don't, I can't see how I would survive as a teacher for very long.
>I think that you have a very good idea here TD, but how are we to determine who the good instructors are? There are lots of good instructors out there, but there are also some not-so-good ones too. I've had many students come to my classes complaining that they took a class with someone and learned little or nothing. Unfortunately, some teachers teach mainly by demonstrating instead of by hands-on. That will work to some extent with some students, and not at all with others. I limit my class size to 5, because I feel that I have to spend time with each student individually. With beginners, a limit of 4 is better. Of course one-on-one is the best.
Being an expert turner does not necessarily make that turner a good teacher.
>I think it is, at least it was for me. I can watch someone all day or all week-end and if I can't get a lathe or tool in my hands quickly I forget part of what I saw and the part I forget prevents me from duplicating what I paid my money to learn. I look forward to our "gathering" in April because it will be a "hands-on" event.
I never take more than 2 students at a time for my beginner's class because it is 90% "hands-on".
Well this is interesting. I guess my comment is that we all came to where we are via many different roads and I do suspect that will change for othersa s they become turners. Many who begin do not know the names of teachers or who is who, some research it, but few really do.
I think like myself, turning came from a community based on the internet. I think that many new turners who look around will also find on line communities as a source for learning.
Stores like Lee Valley offer courses for many skill levels on many topics including turning. They publicize their classes and offer them several tiimes a year, so there is an option. The basics are taught based on the teachers level of turning and insights as well.
I joined a turning club last year, the Golden Horseshoe Wood Turning Guild. They offer a Turning 101 class to any member, I believe it runs 4 meetings long covering many basics , all taught by club members.
I guess what I am saying is this, to me it is not important WHO teaches or WHERE...what is important is WHAT they teach to beginners.
So I'd rather see a list of topics that can be taught to beginners, I think what I saw in Turning 101 at the GHWTG was first class, the topics involved sharpening, spindle turning, bowl turning and hollow turning as I remember.
I think the emphasis should be on WHAT is taught not WHO teaches.