Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

Posts

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#26

Wally

Ken DeMarco

>Wally,

and any others following, I am going to post this and one other piece I am working on in a new thread with some details, I would really like to hear what you have to say. If you think moving to chat would be benificial we could do that also

Thanks

Ken DeMarco

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#27

Re: Brutally honest???

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I agree.

Wally

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#28

Re: ...or it's just a timing thing

Carole Valentine

>My worry is infringing on the time of the person I am requesting the critique from. If you or Wally or any of the other turners were willing to critique my work, I would be delighted. I have a thick skin and I want to learn everything I can, but I would never "ask" you to take the time out of your shedule for an individual critique. That's almost something I feel I should pay for...unless it was at the peer review level. If I were lucky enough to actually take some private instruction I wouldn't mind asking the instructor for a critique or two afterwards, but I sure wouldn't want to be a pest. So far I have not been able to do the instruction thing. I guess that's why I like a critique board, similar to WoW's. If some of the better turners wanted to take the time to offer their comments they can, otherwise they can ignore it.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#29

Critique from a small Photo...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>There's a lot that you can't see in a small photo. I've been on juries along with some very knowledgable, tough judges. The first thing that they look at is the finish. A poor finish, sanding marks, etc. and some very nice work will get tossed. Being able to handle a piece means a lot. It needs to feel right. So sometimes a critique here might not do a piece justice, or it might pass a not so good piece. I guess that all one can do is try.

Wally

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#30

Re: Critique from a small Photo...

TDaniel

>Those are my thoughts too Wally. We can give pointers about a detail but we cannot judge the whole piece. How the piece feels is very important. We cannot tell if the walls are uniform thickness, if there are sanding scratches, if the finish is "in the wood" or built up on the surface, etc. We can tell if the piece is too plain, too gaudy, out of proportion, etc. As long as everyone recognizes the limitations we'll be ok.

TD

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#31

Re: ...or it's just a timing thing

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Pay for?...C'mon Carole, we're all friends here. If you want an opinion from just ask here or e-mail me.

Wally

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#32

Good point Wally and TD

Ed Kelle

>I will have to leave it up to myself to be super critical of my sanding and finishing skills. they are already improving thanks to Russ and his video!

Even thickness and smoothly flowing non lumpy inside is important and I try to be critical of that. I guess wall thickness itself if more of a subjective point within reason. Like 3/8 vs 1/4. Though 3/4 vs 1/4 is a different story.

Critiques based on pure form itself are the best things to judge from photos. This is all going to be very helpful! Thanks

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#33

Excellent thread!

Chris K in MD

>People are different, ambitions, goals etc are all different. I thrive on progress in all that I do if I am not doing ____ better then its not worth continuing to do. Some are born with the desire to excel. To excel you need to work on weakness'. You cant work on weakness' without identifiing them, it can be very difficult to see them. Some points I would like to make after reading this lengthy but excellent thread.

1) There is a place and time to be brutally honest, to be safe I think one should ask for it. These are the people that can handle it and are looking to push for the higher levels of art/workanship etc. THese people know that they need it to push to the next level they are searching for.

2) For others a good thing to do is to nudge for improvement. The term compliment sandwich is one that I have heard many times and fits. Offer three comments in this order . A fairly positive remark, then a remark of somthing they need to improve, then the strongest thing you can find that is positive to end with.

3) I dont know what to do if someone is really struggling and you cant find one element to say is pleasing/works/appeals etc besides I like your effort.

5) Attaboys you can get from others that dont turn. IMO

6)I have found that people that work for me want honest feedback during performance reviews. As long as you provide examples of things that they do well, they then look to the things that they can improve on to grow. Examples are critical to make things clear. In all cases they felt that they have grown more in a couple years with the feedback I have given vs periods 3 times as long with other managers. I see that a critic is easier then a review the expample is there in front of you both. I only wish you had a chalkboard feature like the NFL games on TV have, it would be very valuable tool.

7) Something that turned me off previouslyt here was what I call the "photo snobs" Some people cant get past that not everyone can take great pictures (fpr a variety of reasons). A friend put it very well they said, when photographers critic a photo they dont say "that is the ugliest looking ____(object in the photo)". But here some dont get past the picture to the woodturning (the point of posting the picture). Now this in itself was constructive for me as it pushed me to learn more about photo's etc so that I could take some that might be respected enough to get a real critic. I also see that one must have a decent photo to have the information to give feeback.

8) I would love to watch other critics, it would help me get better quicker. I could see things that others do and hopefully emulate them if they work or be cognizant of ones that have been highlight that dont. Usually when pointed out I can see it (its really helped train my eye). Otherwise I only learn at the rate I can turn and get brutally honest feedback.

Ill plan on emailing some of you for some brutally honest critics, thank you for your offers. Each day I love this place more and more.

Regards,

Chris

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#34

Re: ...or it's just a timing thing

Carole Valentine

>Ok, Wally! Just remember you said that! LOL

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#35

Re: ...or it's just a timing thing

RussFairfield

>Carole, there was a separate Critique Board here on WoodCentral. Nobody used it, Now it is gone.

As for paying for a critique. You will have to pay Ellsworth. The rest of us work for free. I have been told that you get what you pay for.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#36

Re: ...or it's just a timing thing

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>or pay Lyle Jamieson.

IF your really feel the need to pay someone, Mark Kauder 2013 carriage dr.........Check or money order

;)

Mark