Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

Posts

Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#1

Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

RussFairfield

>Critiques, and on-line critiques in particular, have always scared most people away. Ellis tried to solve this reluctance to ask for comments by starting a separate forum for posting and receiving critiques that was removed from the public view of the general forums. All anyone had to do was post a photo, ask the question, and tell the general forum that it was there. To my knowledge, not a single person from the Woodturning Forum ever did that. I see that the Critique forum has now disappeared

Terry Daniel is going to discuss the design elements of the bowl on the Chat Room tonight. There have been a lot of photos sent in, and Terry has asked that anyone wanting their work discussed to write their messages and ask their questions in "Blue". The audience will be limited to whoever is in attendance and the proceedings will not be recorded. And, you can hit the "Ignore" button if you don't want to hear what some individual is saying. It can't get any easier than this. I hope there are a lot of "blue messages".

Why does all of this have to happen for just 1-hour a week on a Wednesday night?? The Chat Room is one of WoodCentral's least used features. It is there for anyone to use for a 1-on-1 conversation on any topic at any time other than the 8 hours a week that it is used for the scheduled Chats. Using the Chat Room for private conversation isn't as good as the telephone, but it the next best thing, and it is a lot cheaper than the telephone. And, it is a lot faster than E-mail messages.

The Chat Room presents an opportunity for a private discussion about any topic, or a critique of your work, with anyone you want to schedule a few minutes with. Has anybody used it for that?? I have made the offer 2 times in the past 2 years, and the response was underwhelming - ZERO. At the time, Wally also offered to do the same thing. I doubt that his response has been much more than mine. My conclusion has to be that nobody wants to hear what we have to say, or they don't think us qualified to say it.

There is an abundance of experience and talent among the group. We may not be as "famous" as some of the folks on WOW, but we are a lot more accessable. I am wondering why nobody is taking advantage of it. All it takes is a couple E-mail messages to schedule a chat time, and a photo if you want a critique.

My conclusion is that, while everyone says they want a critique of their work, nobody really wants to hear what anyone has to say. And, that is their loss.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#2

...or it's just a timing thing

e

>with the sun constantly moving, it's hard to keep up ... this is another probable reason for the response.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#3

In support of last paragraph...

Ed Moore

>Russ,

You are dead right when you say that folks don't really want an honest critique. When I was evaluating junior faculty members for possible promotion there were strong feelings that the evaluator should provide useful feedback to the person being observed. Almost every time I offered a good suggestion I was met with an argument and resistance. People did NOT want to know the truth, but wanted reassurance that they were doing a good job.

Ed

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#4

JL

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc

JL

>For legs and such, I don't seek critiques.

For bowls and such, I'm still learning and any critique is appreciated.

I'm with e on this. The sun is moving. Scheduling times is a difficult task.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#5

Actually, what I had in mind was:

TDaniel

>Not really a critique but a discussion on design elements. I asked for bowls to show design elements that we might discuss. I don't plan to give critiques tonight on the overall piece but will focus on an area that we might incorporate in our work. Things like beads, grooves, flairs, shadow lines, lips, ogees, foot or no foot, one third rule, etc. You are all part of this and your comments are every bit as important as mine. I have made a sheet listing each posted turning and the time it was posted so that I can find it quickly and have listed my comments about each piece that has a design element that I think might be of interest to us. There may be comments by anyone on the overall design and execution but the primary purpose is to give us things that take our turnings up a level from plain to "elegant" ( I like that word).

TD

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#6

Re: And, woodturners are no different...

RussFairfield

>A long series of attaboys doesn't make anyone a better woodturner. Getting off in the corner at a club meeting with someone whose opinion and skills are respected does make us better.

I am suggesting that the Chat Room can be the equivalent of that discussion in the corner, and wondering why nobody is using it for that.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#7

Re: In support of last paragraph...

Matt Birchfield (SW Virginia)

>Ed, I agree that most people don't really want a critique...

The problem is that I really do! I can't get anybody to say anything negative about any of my turnings. I've put a couple BAD turnings in the instant gallery at our club meetings without my name on them and heard good compliments that were simply not true.

I know that people don't want to offend, but I want good, honest critiques from other turners. This presents a new problem of its own when put in a "public" forum like a club meeting or even a chat group. Most members at our club meetings won't bring in anything for fear of critique, let alone say something that may be perceived as negative for fear of criticism.

Maybe at our next meeting we can have a "Brutally Honest Critiques Encouraged" table. Think that'll work?

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#8

Re: ...or it's just a timing thing

RussFairfield

>Not having enough time is an excuse, not a reason.

Woodturning is no different than any other skill. If someone wants to become better at woodturning, they will find the time to seek the help and ask the questions.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#9

Re: And, woodturners are no different...

John Lucas

>Russ I see two problems. One is that I for one never new this existed. I'm not computer literate at all and had no idea that we could chat other than Wed. night. I would be willing to do this with someone if we could schedule a time and I could figure out how.

I have also found it difficult to give a really honest critic unless the person asks me personally. The main reason is that there are so many levels of enjoyment to this hobby. Some will be perfectly happy with pieces that have poor form and sanding scratches and that's fine. Others would like to carry thier work to the top level, and then there are all those inbetween. I tend to base my critics on how I would want my work to look and this may be beyond what others want to hear. In my classes I'm usually only make suggestions on improvements because I have so many varied skill levels in each class.

I think private chats on critic is a very good idea. One is that i get to hear your side of the why you did a piece as you did as well as discussing options. This also doesn't scare away the newbie's by making them think that we expect too much from them.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#10

Re: In support of last paragraph...

Molly Winton

>Matt, using the chat room sounds like exactly what you're looking for. Email someone you want to have critique your work and arrange it just as Russ recommends. I'm like you, I want the brutally honest critique. I think that's how my forms and general technique improved as fast as it did. I aggressively pursued getting the critiques. Rather than trying for the shotgun method of putting it out on a show and tell table, pull someone aside (here on WC too) and pointedly ask them for the style of critique you're looking for. My biggest recommendation is to find someone who's work you respect and admire.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#11

yes...but (don't you just love those words)

e

>thank you russ for the reminder ... but in defense of us on different schedules, some people are asleep when we're ready for answers!

:>)

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#12

Re: Using the Chat Room during the "Off hours"

RussFairfield

>It is no different from logging into the Chat Room on a Wednesday night. All you need is for 2 people to log into the Chat Room at the same time and you have a conversation.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#13

Re: yes...but (don't you just love those words)

Ed Karch

>When first starting out I turned a box of stuff and went to the club enhancement session not to turn but to grab two guys who's turnings I really liked and made them critique the stuff. That made such a huge difference in my output quality that I am a critique junky. I have learned enough that folks are now asking me for critiques. I am definitely going to post and request chat critiques.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#14

Re: Actually, what I had in mind was:

David Breth

>That chatroom is really cool - I just went there to see if it was easy to open up, use, etc. I'm glad you vented a bit, Russ! I knew the chatroom was used for the weekly, but I never knew it could be used this way.

There have been a lot of recent discussions about the importance of understanding form for new turners - making sure it is part of the syllabus of a beginners course, for example. I've turned 22 bowls so far, and the closest I've gotten to a "form" class is looking at a lot of on-line examples, and trying to understand in my own mind what I think works/doesn't work well, and what I think I can do given my current skill set and somewhat limited arsenal of tools.

I still want to experiment/play around/get more comfortable with what I'm doing before I look for a serious critique, but when I'm ready, now I know of an avenue.

A lot of the value in the critique is in selecting the work you want to have critiqued. I'm having a hard time expressing this...I've got a bowl form in mind (in fact, a few), still working it out, that I will probably try to execute within a week or so. If it turns out like I see it in my head, it will represent a change in what I'm trying to do with the lathe, a form I'm not accustomed to, a form I could use some help with to push that method further. I think that eventually made sense.

David B.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#15

Wanna Talk?...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>It shouldn't be too difficult to get a two or three person chat set up. I'm willing to try.

Wally

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#16

Re: yes...but (don't you just love those words)

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I disagree with your logic Russ. I have posted pictures here and asked for critiques and all I got was nice comments. I want to know what's wrong with it and how to improve it. So I haven't posted any photos in quite some time.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#17

Re: In support of last paragraph...

Ron in Drums PA

>Matt I agree

The bottom line is this most people can not handle a brutal and honest critique. All they want to hear is a attaboy. There is a place for attaboys!!

I would rather hear a brutal but honest critique from a turner whose work that I respect. The few rare brutal and honest critiques that I have recieved has helped me leaps and bounds in my turning.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#18

Re: Wanna Talk?...

Ken DeMarco

>Wally,

I would love to take you up on that, I have some hollow forms that I would really like honest crituges on. I think one question would be should the photos be posted here, or emailed. you could name a time and I could probably be avaialable, I would not mind if anyone else (like Russ, or Molly, or anyone) joined in.

Ken DeMarco

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#19

Re: Wanna Talk?...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Okay...I think that they should be posted here. Should others be invited to listen in on the chats if they wish, or should it be kept private?....Comments?

Wally

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#20

Re: Wanna Talk?...

Ken DeMarco

>Maybe that should be up to the person requesting the critique. I have learned just an amazing amount here from some people who have gently nudged me in the right direction with easy critiques when I have asked, but always look foward to taking my work to a higher level. I have a fairly thick skin especially when I ask for a critique, but I also understand the point of scaring off newbies with hard critiqes on the board. I also know that if all I wnat is an "atta boy" there are other forums that I could go to where that is all they do, another reason I like this forum best.

Ken DeMarco


img

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#21

Re: Wanna Talk?...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Very nice piece. I'm not sure how well suited the chat line is for a critique, because we can't see the photo while we're discussing it.

It's probably better suited for discussing techniques, finishing, tools, or just general questions and answers on turning. However, there are a few things that we could discuss about your piece. Here, an e-mail, or on the chat line.

Wally

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#22

Re: Wanna Talk?...

Ed Karch

>If the invitation is open I would love to be a fly on the wall. I know what my thoughts on this form would be and would love to hear what Wally has to say.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#23

Re: Wanna Talk?...

David Breth

>Chat line could work very well for this - just save the picture to your desktop or hard drive, and you can refer to it while in the chat by "toggling" back and forth.

David B.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#24

Me too

Ed Kelle

>I agree. I would also like to use the chat for getting critiques and help. I'm doing this to get to the pro level and want all the critiques/advice I can get. I know the flaws in my pieces so I can take a hit and learn from them if someone is willing to point them out and give the reasoning behind it. Much more beneficial to me if someone is willing to drill these into my head. I've got fine art/graphic design background and I have very thick skin so no need to hold back.

If all our guru's here are willing to help us, I sure will do my part to make good use of this.

Maybe when we post something include the word CRITIQUE in the title if that is what you want.

Re: Some comments on the Chat Room, Critiques, etc.

#25

Re: Brutally honest???

RussFairfield

>This term, "brutally honest", means different things to different people. I have yet to meet the person who is willing to accept such an evaluation on an open forum from a total stranger with the entire world in audience.

I won't give such an opinion here, but others have; and the result was too often an exchange of bad words, your Moderator getting nasty private e-mails, and Ellis got complaints.

If you want "brutally honest", then either meet someone privately in person, send them an e-mail, or meet them in the Chat Room.