Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

You variable Speed guys...

Posts

You variable Speed guys...

#1

You variable Speed guys...

DWR

>... can possibly help me. Will the following motor work for a Variable Speed conversion on my lathe? (I know that a similar 1/2hp rated Leeson at CS-USA is nearly $500 w/controller.)

Specs as I know them:

Brand new DC permanent magnet motor.

Rated 1/2 HP,

180 Varm,

2.8 A,

1725 RPM,

TEFC,

Shaft is 5/8" diameter,

Motor frame size is 56C, which allows base or face mount.

If so, what type of controller etc. do I need to look for?

If not, why? (so I can learn a thing or three...)

Thanks!

Dave...

... with too much time on his hands... and no tools in them...

Re: You variable Speed guys...

#2

DC motor

T Daniel

>DW, this motor is available from Grainger and normally comes with a controller. The permanent magnet dc motors are not as good as the 4 wire motors and are especially weak at low rpm. I would not buy the motor by itself but if I got a deal on one with the controller I might give it a try. 56 is the frame size and the "C" indicates face mounting but some of these also have a foot mount.

Re: You variable Speed guys...

#3

Re: You variable Speed guys...

John Lucas

>I agree with Terry but you didn't say what size lathe you were going to put this on. 1/2 horse is to small for anyting but a mini lathe.

Re: You variable Speed guys...

#4

Re: DC motor

DWR

>Terry,

Thanks... I can use all the info I can get.

The motor is currently listing for $85... Magnetek I think, so was thinking it might be worth a look as a separate piece...

Dave

Re: You variable Speed guys...

#5

Re: DC motor

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>I just recently contacted Surplus Center and priced a 1 1/2 DC motor for $89.95, a speed controller for 59.99, and an extra set of aluminum fins to help cool the controller. When I called I asked my question and they connected me with a very knowledgeable tech who says he has helped many turners upgrade lathes. FWIW

Mike

Re: You variable Speed guys...

#6

Re: DC motor

DWR

>Mike,

How long ago was this and do you have the part numbers to the pieces you ordered?

How is your set-up working for you?

Thanks!

Re: You variable Speed guys...

#7

Re: You variable Speed guys... (A little long)

Gary Ratajczak

>I just did a little research myself on DC motors. (Anyone with more info - feel free to correct me on any errors).

The ones I found from Surplus City are typically open frame motors. They are commonly used by the guys with mini metal lathes, and mounted in a box in back of the lathe. The motors commonly used are from a treadmill, and rated at 2 to 2-1/2 hp. They are not a direct correlation. You would end up with somewhere between 1/2 to 1 actual hp in an AC motor. Any motors rated less will not have proper torque at the lower speeds. In order to run continuous, they MUST be fan cooled (again, problems with being open ported).

The motors I was able to find that would have been large enough hp, and totally enclosed, were to big to mount under the mini lathe. Also, keep in mind that you will need to make mounting brackets, and change pulleys.

Most motors are 90VDC. A speed controller with 110 VAC in and variable DC out is what is required. I found them surplus for $49.00 to $250.00, depending on source. One already in a box, with switches, heatsink and proper setup was $150.00.

If you have a Jet mini, they now offer an upgrade kit. It sells for about $150.00, plus shipping. You need to search a little. Direct from Jet is more $$. I have a link at home for one e-shop that has it for the $150 price. Provides motor, controller and all mounting.

So - to sum it up - after you buy a surplus motor, DC speed controller, heatsink, power resistors, control potentiometer, brackets, pulley and time, I think you will be right at the Jet upgrade kit. Hmmmm..... I bet they knew that when it was priced :-).

So - what have I done so far. Nothing but continue to change belts on my Jet Mini. I think I might just offer current unit for sale, and buy a new Jet VS model. Still seems like the easiest option in the long run.

I am going to keep looking for a motor and control. I had a few ideas for using one on a multi wheel grinder setup. I turn a lot of miniatures, and could use a very slow speed setup. DC motor would be a nice unit to have for that type of setup. I need to read up a little more on the torque requirements, and what DC motors are capable of.

Re: You variable Speed guys...

#8

John... *LINK*

DWR

>... sorry, you are correct. I forgot the lathe info.

I currently have an old Wards Powercraft cast iron lathe. I am running a 1hp, 115V, 1725RPM, 56C, TEFC motor with a four-pulley system and a Drum Switch for on/off/reverse.

I can turn up to 14 inches but the speed is just too much at the rim of any bowl over about 8"... Would like to convert to a 1 or 1.5 hp variable speed. Some VS units have a starting RPM of around 400-500, which in my mind negates the whole aspect of a true variable speed... especially for larger bowls and roughing... To me variable speed is 0-max RPM...

I know that Dealers Electric offers a 1hp "kit" for $323 that requires 220v Input for full HP Rating to be achieved. $425 if you want up to 2hp.

Now, I consider this a fair deal, if you have:

A)� an additional 220 circuit and

B)� the $$$.

I also understand that you will need a 3phase motor if you want to run variable speed from your 1phase AC input...

As do many woodworkers, I try to stretch my tool dollars. I was hoping to source a VFD from EBay and a 3phase motor. There seems to be a ton of both there and the 3phase motors are the more easily understood and affordable.

The myriad VFD's are another question. I know that people from an electrical background could easily identify a good deal on an EBay VFD that could be used for a lathe... even if it was yanked from something else... I just get lost in all the "proton" data;) I know that VFD's are HP specific in the sense that you can run up to a certain HP but not beyond, so you have to find a drive that matches the maximum HP output of your motor. But what about all the other electrical mumbo-jumbo... what's critical and what can be ignored? Do you need additional components...?

I have to believe that a patient person could match an EBay 2-3HP, 3-phase motor with a New/used VFD for a lot less than the $425-$500 kit packages... given the proper knowledge of the critical components and specifications to look for...

Then when you start to factor in DC Permanent Magnet or Shunt Wound motors... it becomes a nightmare...

Dave...

... still looking for the right combo...


Dealers Electric