Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

The hardest cut in wood turning:

Posts

The hardest cut in wood turning:

#1

Keith Tompkins

The hardest cut in wood turning:

Keith Tompkins

>What do you think is the hardest cut in woodturning? The one cut that makes you cringe just thinking about it. The one you hold your breath while making. The one that usually preceeds a huge BANG!...then much cursing...

The last cut on a thin walled bowl? A perfect bead with a skew? End grain hollowing? End grain on a spindle...cleanly? A 1/8" stem on a goblet with a skew? Working inside a square turning?

Nah...something harder....turning a sphere with only a skew...that's it!

What do you think?

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#2

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Molly Winton

>I'll take this challenge. My hardest cuts are the ones down at the very bottom center of a hollow form out to the curve of the vertical wall. It involves getting the nub/nipple out and not leaving a spiral cut line. If I'm going to get a catch, it's here. I don't worry about this in a form that has a small opening, who's going to see, but for the ones that have an opening more than 1.5", but less than 4".....eeerrrrggggg!

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#3

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>That's easy for me Keith,

It's the wall cut on the inside of the bowl, the thinning cuts...I always seem to get a catch with my bowl gouge...and that nib at the bottom...

:-)

take care,

Jim

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#4

Re: Did you make a video

Allen Neighbors

>of that feat? I would like surely love to see it. I'd like to even see a pic of it.

You pros on this forum constantly amaze me, Keith.

I've watched several short video clips on skew techniques, tried it once and thought I'd learned it, but now I can't keep it from catching. I need some hands on instruction. I read a post about novice turners having a "death grip", and tried to "lighten up", and my skew went flying under my worktable, behind me.. :o) I put it away.

By the way, where'd you get the intestinal fortitude required to turn a sphere with a skew?

AL

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#5

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Juergen

>The one that doesn't require sanding below 320 grit

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#6

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Turning a SMALL bead around the bottom edge of a vase or lidded box, for example. When using a skew to turn a bead in a rolling cut, for me the difficulty increases tremendously as the size decreases and the possibility of a catch increases. Turning a 1" or 2" ball shape is easy for me, but when it gets down to 1/4" or less, I'm in trouble.

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#8

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

John Lucas

>I have 2 that get me in trouble. On big trouble the other just annoying. When I'm turning a hollow vessel that looks like 2 shallow bowls stuck toghether. Trying to thin out the area where it looks like they are joined. Your always cutting from lip or bottom toward this joint. If you don't go carefully enough as you approach this corner you can get a project destoying catch.

The other one is the start of a cove on a spindle where the sides are 90 degrees to the side of the spindle. Usually this happens when I'm in a hurry and just don't take the time to start the gouge very slowly to I establish a shoulder. I get a slight slight kick back that requires I enlarge the cove a little.

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#9

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Mike Cunningham

>The upper inside walls on a natural edge bowl. Up on those "winged" high spots near the bark where you cutting air half of the time. I manage them but it's an adventure.

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#10

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Tom In Red Deer

>For me it is the transition bit from wall to bottom of a bowl. Usually the catch will leave a deep groove on the bottom that either destroys the piece or requires more nerve shattering work to remove. It also usually requires a trip to the bathroom.

Tom

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#11

All Of Them ! ! !

Barry Turner

>At my skill level......ALL OF THEM ! ! !

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#12

Richard Allen

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Richard Allen

>Why only a skew?

The hardest cut for me is turning a series of captive rings with an Estwing hand axe. I don't do that offten because the axe doesn't hold an edge for very long (;->)

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#13

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Barry Irby

>Prepping the blank. Putting the chainsaw to the blank is the hardest cut for me. (Until I found out about pulling the rope and getting it to make that loud noise.....NOT Really!) Once you take an interesting piece of wood and cut a blank out of it, you are committed. You have made the right decision or wasted some of the potential.

I like making spheres and do most or all of it with the skew. Am I missing something? Can't do much with coves and beads though.

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#14

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Ron in Drums PA

>Right now it is inside of the top of a hollow form with a very narrow opening. I can never get a smooth cut.

Yesterday I made a couple of new tools and today I'm gonna find out If I got it licked!

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#15

Steven Antonucci

Great Videos on the Skew!

steve antonucci

>Concise, and showing each technique extremely clearly...

Well worth the viewing price... :-)

Steve

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#16

I can help with this one...

T Daniel

>Tom, I'll bet that you have the side angles of your bowl gouge ground too steep. When this angle is too steep you cannot roll the tool as you approach the bottom. Check the "Grinds library" and compare yours to the ones shown. There are some grinds that make a certain cut very well but are not suitable for the side to bottom transition. A rounded end and a convex grind on the wings per the pics will help.

TD

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#17

Ken, Thanks for the good link and good videos.

Clem Wixted

>

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#18

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Jorge Castaneda

>Richard,

That's why I gave up using the hatchet, I use the slick now, give it a try...: )

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#19

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Jorge Castaneda

>Keith,

I've watched Michael Hosaluck make a perfect sphere in one go with a skew, no remounting it, and he said it is just an excersise in paying attention and control, he made it look easy, I found it otherwise.

My most feared cuts are coves in a spindle and the underside of square bowls.

Jorge

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#20

Hey Ken

Ron in Drums PA

>I've tried the rolling cut with a skew many times and I'm ( not so) proud to say I usally (but not always) get perfect spirals running uphill.

I noticed you used a radius edged skew, does that help, or do I still need to work on my technique?

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#21

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning: Like Molly

georgetroy

>I agree with Molly. That deep cut over the tool rest, hung over several inches on a closed form trying to get that pip off. Sometimes I just give up and get my sanding air ball out. GT

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#22

Re: I can help with this one...

John Lucas

>I've also found that many new turners make the transition from wall to floor of the bowl too steep. For ease of turning you should have a nice smooth curve from lip through side to bottom but many times the pieces are designed with a more or less flat bottom leading to a Wall (side). This transition area is quite hard to turn especially going from the rim down. If find that on bowl like this I have to turn the bottom from center out (if it's flat) stopping at the wall tranition point. Then turn from the rim down and try to gently blend these 2 areas.

Terry is right about the grind. If your gouge is ground right you can roll the gouge (usually so the flute is more straight up) and keep the bevel rubbing through this transition area

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#23

John is right

T Daniel

>a smooth transition between sides and bottom makes life much easier.

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#24

Keith Tompkins

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Ken, try this....with the skew cutting right on the centerline, long end down, bevel rubbing, and the skew cutting a bit above the tip. 1. you can see the cut from both directions. 2. no rolling involved..that's the hardest part, having to work the skew on an X-Y-Z axis at the same timewhile the tool interferes with your view. 3. Since you are at the centerline, fewer catches, as the tool isn't drawn into the cut.

I would be interested if you posted the result....

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

#25

Re: The hardest cut in wood turning:

Ed Karch

>Richard

Try a double bit cruiser axe. Gives two edges for the price of one sharpening. Watch out for catches they could be fatal.