Re: Design questionaire:
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
>Good morning Keith, et al
Excellent discussion. I think that design is critical to good turning technique. At the most basic level, a person can be taught that the tool must be held in a particular fashion to make a particular cut, but immediately following, there needs to be a discussion on where that tool is going and what it is going to do to the wood. I spend hours with students drawing on the pieces they are making, and telling them to "cut here" or "cut between these lines". There is a lot of stop and start with the lathe, where they stand back and look at what one single cut did to change a lumpy form into a fair curve. But this is stuff that gets taught on a personal level, or with a lathe running.
I don't know how many people I could stand to watch when it comes to theory. I thought your demo was excellent, and it is stuff that has to be understood, but how many demos can a person see when it comes to theory? I guess it depends on that person. Theory is the basic stuff, but then a person has to get on a lathe and start practicing it. In a demo, I would like to see a person get on a lathe and start showing what is good, what is bad, and why. Slide shows are okay, but it is sort of like watching someone's vacation. Wait, we did that, didn't we?!? ;-) A real piece of wood spinning has a lot more flexibility to it than a whole list of slides.
I would be more inclined to attend a demo on general design and technique more than something very specific, although that would again depend on what that specific thing was. I learned a great deal watching Stuart Batty use a negative rake scraper. As an aside, I sat there wishing I could have some of those folks who blather about how real turners don't use scrapers sitting next to me!
So, I guess my answer would be, it depends. But then again, I am not planning on going anyway, so the whole thing is academic. Maybe someday.
Bill



