Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Design questionaire:

Posts

Re: Design questionaire:

#26

Re: Design questionaire:

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Good morning Keith, et al

Excellent discussion. I think that design is critical to good turning technique. At the most basic level, a person can be taught that the tool must be held in a particular fashion to make a particular cut, but immediately following, there needs to be a discussion on where that tool is going and what it is going to do to the wood. I spend hours with students drawing on the pieces they are making, and telling them to "cut here" or "cut between these lines". There is a lot of stop and start with the lathe, where they stand back and look at what one single cut did to change a lumpy form into a fair curve. But this is stuff that gets taught on a personal level, or with a lathe running.

I don't know how many people I could stand to watch when it comes to theory. I thought your demo was excellent, and it is stuff that has to be understood, but how many demos can a person see when it comes to theory? I guess it depends on that person. Theory is the basic stuff, but then a person has to get on a lathe and start practicing it. In a demo, I would like to see a person get on a lathe and start showing what is good, what is bad, and why. Slide shows are okay, but it is sort of like watching someone's vacation. Wait, we did that, didn't we?!? ;-) A real piece of wood spinning has a lot more flexibility to it than a whole list of slides.

I would be more inclined to attend a demo on general design and technique more than something very specific, although that would again depend on what that specific thing was. I learned a great deal watching Stuart Batty use a negative rake scraper. As an aside, I sat there wishing I could have some of those folks who blather about how real turners don't use scrapers sitting next to me!

So, I guess my answer would be, it depends. But then again, I am not planning on going anyway, so the whole thing is academic. Maybe someday.

Bill

Re: Design questionaire:

#27

Re: Design presentation-an opposite (long) viewpoi

Bill Neddow

>I agree with John about the state of our "obsession". There are now a lot of good technicians out there, and they are looking beyond new techniques when they go to a symposium -- looking for inspiration and potentially new directions. Discussions on design can give this. Realizing there were five such sessions at the next AAW has made me decide to go this coming year. And I will attend all five design sessions -- as well as some technical sessions by people like Marilyn Campbell, who do not have videos out. Most times I can pick up techniques from videos. (But there are exceptions -- I will go to any Ellsworth presentation because technique, design and inspiration are so tightly interwoven that you always leave walking two feet in the air!)

I have attended both of Keith's presentations on design at Albany. I learned a lot from the first one, two years ago. I learned even more this year. Maybe it was the presentation. Maybe I was just a little more open to suggestion. But he did prove to me that design can be taught. As with any other subject, some of the students will pick up the information quickly and easily. Others will have more difficulty.

I am so happy to see this emphasis developing on design because there has been so little of it in the past. The one shining exception is Richard Raffan's book. It has been my bible for years. Now, I can start supplementing it and getting different views. Exposure to good design is so important. Eventually some of it rubs off on all of us.

Re: Design questionaire:

#28

Re: Design presentation-an opposite (long) viewpoi

Ron in Drums PA

>You bring up allot of good points Dinyar, I always enjoy reading what you write. I would like to talk about one item you mentioned.

"Rules of good design, and how to break them"---that I would go to repeatedly.

If you can teach how to break the "rules" those broken rules have become new rules and are no longer broken.

As an example, minor 7th chords where never used in Bach's time and where considered a dissonant tone. In matter if fact, the Em7 chord was deemed the �Devil�s Chord� by the church in Bach�s time. The rule was simple, minor 7th chords where not to be used. Today, minor 7th chords are a staple in blues music. Somewhere along the line the broken rule has become a standard rule.

Re: Design questionaire:

#29

Re: Design presentation-an opposite (long) viewpoi

RussFairfield

>Ron,

Are you saying that classical piano is played on the white keys, and jazz and blues on the black keys??

I think I should be doing more woodturning on those "black keys".

Re: Design questionaire:

#30

Re: Design presentation-an opposite (long) viewpoi

Ron in Drums PA

>:-) not that simple :-)

The key of G has one sharp (black key) and is used in both classical and jazz.

I taught my 3 year old nephew how to play the piano and compose his own music in one sitting. I told him to only play the black keys and only play 1, 2 or 3 keys at a time. Technique with out form.

Re: Design questionaire:

#31

Re: Design questionaire:

Don Tewell

>Ron,

I agree about the budding artist wanting there first piece to be a classic. Since I have been in photography for over 20 years, I've found that the cheapest learning tool is film. Same way with turning, it's practice, practice, practice. You have to learn to fail, before you can learn to succeed.

Re: Design questionaire:

#32

Chiropractor needed?

T Daniel

>Keith, most of the time when someone attempts to give a lesson on advanced design it ends up being an exercise in ego. Basic design is easily done. Good curves, proper proportions, balanced grain, etc. can be covered well without one patting himself on the back too much; however, when you try to stretch the limits it sometimes seems like you are pretending to know something that no one else knows. I have heard a lot of critism of nationally known turners who let too much ego creep into their discussion of form and inspiration. If you carefully plan your demo you may be able to pull it off but beware, the ice is thin!

TD

Re: Design questionaire:

#33

Re: Design presentation-an opposite (long) viewpoi

Dinyar Chavda

>Very true, Ron, about broken rules becoming new rules. What I want to do is to learn how to break existing rules. What you wrote, though, leads one to what seems to be a contradictory statement, i.e., in order to be a rule breaker, one must be a rule maker.

Re: Design questionaire:

#34

Re: Design questionaire:

Bill Crommett

>When I look at some of my work of five years ago that is still sitting on a shelf somewhere, I think that some of those pieces would make better firewood than take up space. But then I keep them to recap what I have done wrong and wonder what I should have done to reclaim a sense of proportion. Talk about learning from ones mistakes ! !

Re: Design questionaire:

#35

Re: Design presentation-an opposite (long) viewpoi

Ron in Drums PA

>Dinyar Wrote: "What you wrote, though, leads one to what seems to be a contradictory statement, i.e., in order to be a rule breaker, one must be a rule maker."

Not contradictory at all Dinyar, it's more like those who have broken the rules are now making the new rules.

Re: Design questionaire:

#36

Re: Which is better??

RussFairfield

>Which is better, to know the rules and knowing that you are breaking them, or breaking them with no knowledge of them??

Re: Design questionaire:

#37

Re: Which is better??

John Lucas

>I think You'll find that those who successfully break the rules, know the rules very well.

Re: Design questionaire:

#38

Re: Design questionaire:

John Lucas

>That's exactly why we need a Clay person to do a demo on forms. They can throw a vessel, show whats wrong and change the shape right there, immediately. We can only take away more wood in our demo's. They can squash the whole thing and start over if necessary, to demonstate a point or a shape. In an hour and a half a good potter could throw 5 to 10 shapes, assuming they don't have to be perfect wall thickness, only the outside needs to be right.

Re: Design questionaire:

#39

Re: Which is better??

Ron in Drums PA

>I agree with you John.

Re: Design questionaire:

#40

THE RULES!! ;^D

Ed Moore

>C'mon, Guys! We all know that women make the rules and that men are not allowed to know what the rules are!

Ed

Re: Design questionaire:

#41

Re: THE RULES!! ;^D

John Lucas

>Ed Reminds me of the saying: If a tree falls in the woods and no one is around, is the man still wrong?

Re: Design questionaire:

#42

Re: THE RULES!! ;^D

Ron in Drums PA

>That should be:

If a man is alone in the woods and no one is around to here him, is he still wrong?

Re: Design questionaire:

#43

The Emperor's Clothes -- Woodturner's version

Ed Moore

>TD,

I'm inclined to agree with you. On several occasions I have felt that the expressed opinion of a "big hat" on design was really just an effort to say "something" and that it had nothing behind it.

On the other hand, I think that Keith has something to say of value on this subject and I am looking forward to hearing it.

Ed

Re: Design questionaire:

#44

Keith Tompkins

Re: Design questionaire:

Keith Tompkins

>Wow, quite a response! I'll try to remember the points I want to make....first as several have commented, many big hat turners give an ego inflating slide show and call it a design demo. This is the type of demo I referred to as " won't work". As Bill G. stated "my summer vacation". Yes, that happened!

I come from a furniture design background, and spent several years in the craft field. So to me, design elements were something that was accepted without question. When I entered the turning scene seriously, I could not believe the lack of design knowledge...even the best turners, who produced great forms had difficulty in explaining the thought process behind their work.

I started thinking about a design demo after observing turners with several years of experience turn one poor form after another. I started to form a hypothesis.." Turning bad forms for years does not lead to creating good forms, it merely reinforces bad habbits."It takes a balanced approach right from the beginning, form and technique. The more I thought about it, the more I liked the idea.

As I started taking on students, I soon realized that my theory indeed worked. Most students I have taught had good techniques, but almost no appreciation for form; they couldn't understand why they were stuck in a rut with their turning. In fact, many experienced turners were so entrenched in their thinking patterns, that it has been extremely difficult to get them to change their attitude. After all, they have been told for years "become one with the wood, it will speak to you". That ONE saying has caused me unmeasurable frustration in my teaching career...and has stunted the growth of many turners.

I will sometimes turn a bad piece into a good piece during a demo, but the problem is,it's boring, and takes away from the message of the presentation. In a short demo format, every second counts, turning is sometimes a distraction.(invariably, that's when the talkers in the crowd start up)

I try to stick to basic form and design principles....NOT what appeals to me. Most turners need basic guidelines to judge their work against as a means of improving. Proportion, balance, emphasis, line, etc.....these are the building blocks of our craft! We learn by establishing a good foundation, and then building upon it.

For an example, if I critique a piece, and say the balance is off, the turner who produced the piece may say "that's you opinion, I think it's fine". But, if I take the time to show how balance affects a piece, and explain the principle behind it, he can use that information on his future work, and see the difference for himself.

Think of any invention...say aircraft. The Wright brothers proved we could fly. from there, it took less that a hundred years to land on the moon. WE built on what we learned..things we alreay knew. Would it make any sense to go back and start over by building the Wright flyer time after time?

That is the theme of my demo...learn to apply sound design principles, and build on what you know. Develop a sound foundation, then strive to improve.

Re: Design questionaire:

#45

Re: Design questionaire:

Ed Karch

>Remembering last years panel presentation on form (Finding the right form) The part that really stuck with me was. J.Paul Fennell who had turned five forms, painted them white to kill any wood influence then discussed each form and why one was better than the others and how they could be improved. Cindy Drozda had prepared three black painted finials about two feet tall and discussed each section of each finial and how then right form in the finial gives lift to the whole piece. David Nittmann prepared silhouettes of ogee curves and discussed which one worked and where they would work and why. These were all visual non theoretical and no wood or clay were used as live sacrifices. Worked big time foe me. I weep for your loss if you missed it.

Re: Design questionaire:

#46

That will work!

T Daniel

>The old KISS rule applies. If the basic forms are taught a person can turn wonderful work with just that. Eventually they may want to experiment with a piece occasionally and sooner or later they will hit on a design of their own that has mass appeal. Some will drift further from the basics than others but all will have respect for those basic fundamentals and will build on them. Teaching accepted form should be no problem but get too far out and I think you'll lose the audience. I took a class on "creativity" from a nationally known turner and I enjoyed every minute of the class but it has not changed my way of turning at all. The class was entertaining and I would recommend it but in actuallity it has not helped me at all. If you don't take the audience too far off course you will do fine. If the wood starts talking I'm outathere.

TD

Re: Design questionaire:

#47

Re: Design questionaire:

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Keith, I like your approach on teaching form and design. I've had the same experience that you've had. I know many experienced turners who've never turned a really well designed and balanced piece, and sadly possibly never will. Allowing the beautiful grain in a piece of wood to "speak to you" and dictate form rarely works.

Del Stubbs, a "big hat" in the 80's, was a wonderful teacher of form and design. His methods were much like yours. I learned a lot from Del. Sadly for the turning world, Del abandond turning and went on to something else.

I hope that someday I'll have the opportunity to see one of your demos on design.

Wally

Re: Design questionaire:

#48

Re: Design presentation-an opposite (long) viewpoi

Dinyar Chavda

>Ron, I said "what seems to be". I agree with you that it isn't. In fact, it is highly likely that the rebels of today will turn into the guardians of the faith of tomorrow.

P.S. (Completely OT) Did you say that you taught your 3 year old nephew to play the piano in 1 sitting? How long would it take to teach a middle-aged man with clutzsy fingers?

Re: Design questionaire:

#49

Only if he doesn't harvest the tree!!!!!

Molly Winton

>

Re: Design questionaire:

#50

Some of the worst turnings I`ve seen...

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>Have been by people who have degrees in art.I don`t know if this proves or disproves if design can be taught.

I know that my older brother has attended turning workshops for decades and everytime he goes to one my work improves at least alittle because he shares what he learned with me.My father once told me I had the potential to be a better turner because I was "Going it on my own" and didn`t have my mind cluttered up with all the "rules" he had been filled with (FWIW-Dad couldn`t have been more wrong.I still aspire to one day be as good as Bill).

Mainely,Bob