Design presentation-an opposite (long) viewpoint:
Dinyar Chavda
>Keith:
I'm going to take a position contrary to the general sentiment expressed here. When I go to a conference, I want to maximize the value of what I am going to get out of it (I have been known to make spreadsheets to ensure that I can see the key people I want to!). So, to me, the question is not whether I can learn something about design from a design presentation, but will I learn more by going to that presentation versus some other, particularly, if I think that I can learn about design by reading books.
My impression is that most design presentations impart knowledge that can, in fact, be gleaned from books---read Raffan, or any of the myriad books on the golden mean or a fair curve, or the turning book on forms and shapes. However, unless they have videos on the subject, I cannot determine what, for example, Hans Weissflog or Marilyn Campbell do, except by going to their demos (where I actually learn a lot about design).
There are exceptions to the last statement re design presentations being repetitions of what one can find in books--I'd go see any presentation by Vessery or by Ellsworth or the late Phil Wall (there are probably others whom I haven't seen). To have a great presentation, you need to understand design both technically and emotionally, be able to explain why alternatives are inferior, and be able to communicate all this information verbally----a rare combination of talents.
So, I'd flip the question, and ask what the conditions would be under which I would go to a design presentation, when it competes with a technique presentation:
1. The presenter spends an absolute minimum amount of time on "theory"; as I said earlier, I can get that from books.
2. The presenter actually turns a piece, and stops and shows the decisions that he/she makes at each stage---how big do I make the shoulder? Where do I place the shoulder? What effect will that have on decisions down the road? etc.
3. The presenter shows the result of these decisions made along the way (a la Vessery) by showing pictures or actual examples of such decisions.
Now for some more way-out ideas:
4. The presenter is from a field other than turning. Our conferences tend to be fairly insular, and there is a whole other slew of crafts that we can learn from. Obvious ones are pottery and basket-weaving. Perhaps not as apparent are photography and painting, particularly large scale photography of nature, as well as compositions of still life and people scenes. I vaguely remember John Jordan doing something like this at an AAW.
5. The presenter (not, necessarily, a turner) is from a country other than the US, or, better still, other than the West. Some of the greatest explosions in art have occurred when the artists of one country have been exposed to the work of other countries, and have seen the "rules" that they are confined by, being broken. For example, the tremendous influence of Japonica, specifically woodblocks, on French Impressionism (also influence by the new art/craft of photography) changed Western painting by breaking fundamental rules of "good painting".
6. The presentation is billed as "Rules of good design, and how to break them"---that I would go to repeatedly. Learning rules is important, but once you have done that, as Verne says, above, "be ready to forget what you learned as soon as you are able". The problem is that once you learn the rules, your eye and your hand will resist any attempt you make to break them. (Listen to "Flowers are Red" by Harry Chapin, for a heartbreaking example of this). I would love to see work where the creator has deliberately, and successfully, broken the rules, and try to understand why it works. By the way, this can also be from any field, not just turning.
A long answer to your question, for which I apologize.