Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Design questionaire:

Posts

Design questionaire:

#1

Keith Tompkins

Design questionaire:

Keith Tompkins

>While glancing through the list of demonstrators for the AAW symposium in Louisville, I couldn't help but notice the number of demo's with design as the topic.At least five.

As recently as two or three years ago, the topic was "taboo" at the national level. I was told by aaw brass that there never had been a successful design demo at that level, and attempting one would result in a career-ending failure.

I have a couple of theories concerning the change of attitude, and I would be interested in your feelings... for instance, would you consider attending one?Why, or why not? What would you expect to gain by attending? Why is the topic gaining in acceptance?

What topics could be covered in a design demo that would benefit turners in the audience the most? Do you think design can be taught, or is it something that either you have, or don't have?

Your thoughts?

Re: Design questionaire:

#2

Re: Design questionaire:

RussFairfield

>Why are discussions about design and form now possible?

I think it is because the "old guard" of the AAW is being replaced with a new generation of woodturners. The AAW used to be controlled by folks who were accomplished woodturners before the organization ever existed. As AAW Officers and Directors, they were starting at the top. They are being replaced with people who have grown to maturity in the art and craft of woodturning as members of the local chapters.

Design, form, and finishing have been popular topics for discussions and demonstrations among the local clubs for as long as there have been AAW Chapters. It stands to reason that these new Directors will bring that experience with them.

Can design be taught?

To a point, yes. There are design rules that will get you 40% of the way. You can get another 40% through study and association with good form in other media. But, the last 20% is talent that you either have or don't. You may disagree with the proportions, but rules and education will only take you so far. The rest is what you already have.

Re: Design questionaire:

#3

Re: Design questionaire:

Barry Irby

>Russ has it right. Certainly design can be taught. There is a certain amount of what we do that is mathematical and that part can be taught. We can learn even more by observing and living with great designs from our piers and from other fields. To some extent, even creativity can be taught. I have taught my son what I can about turning and then took him to a class at Arrowmont to work with David Ellsworth. David took me aside and said they hate it when the father and son or husband and wife come together. I was amazed and asked why. David sort of fumbled around and finally said that it was because one of them was better than the other. I was not offended, I was thrilled, he thought my son was better than I am. I told him I taught him what I could and now was bringing him to someone clearly better than I to teach him more, I was just along for the ride. My son is also lucky that he came along in the age of videos and books and classes and clubs. For the first twenty years I tried to turn things I did not know Bob Stockdale or David or any of the others existed. And then there is the last bit that comes from within and it may not be possible to teach it, but it can be nurtured.

And yes, I would attend those classes.

Re: Design questionaire:

#4

Re: Design questionaire:

Ed Kelle

>Yes I sure would go. Heck I got a lot out of your demo in Saratoga and that little 1 hour deal has paid off big time ($$$) for me this year. I can't wait to see what you teach us next month when you come down to the Island.

design can be taught, just like drawing, it is a matter of teaching people to see shapes lines and forms as they are and not as your mind wants to represent them. Of course there is still some instinct involved, but once you get a good understanding behind the principles, it all makes sense and you can learn how to violate them with good results.

Maybe some of those people who didnt want design classes were more concerned with the instant gratification behind teaching techniques. I think too many people get stuck with the improper beilef that they are not artistic and as so, have no desire for any artistic training. If there is the desire to learn, anything can be taught successfully.

Either way there are plenty of us out here who look forward to your seminars.

Re: Design questionaire:

#5

Re: Design questionaire:

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Can and should design be taught? Definitely yes. As Russ says, it works, up to a point. In all of my classes, I teach and stress form and design. Even to beginners. Some people have questioned that, but my answer is "why not". The first bowl that a beginner turns in my class will have good form. I try my best to explain the basic "rules" of good form before we even start turning, and also while the forms are being developed. Some of the students develop an understanding of good design, others don't. I have a rather unique opportunity to watch former students as they develop in their turning. My town, a retirement area, has a large, well equipped community woodshop. We have seven woodfast lathes. Over the years I've taught over 150 students there. Some of them use the shop lathes on a regular basis. Some of them turn very nice, well designed pieces. Others don't, simply because the concept of good design just isn't there for them, even though I continue to encourage then to try.

I wrote an article on form and design which was published in the American Woodturner a number of years ago. I revised the article and it was recently published again in Woodturning Design magazine. I use copies of that as a handout in my classes. Some of my students probably toss it, others have told me that it helped them a lot.

Would I attend a demo on design? If I respected the work of the presenter, I certainly would. I have attended demos on design by David Ellsworth. and by Del Stubbs. I learned a lot from both.

Wally

Re: Design questionaire:

#6

Re: Design questionaire:

Ed Moore

>Keith,

I probably need to attend the five sessions on design as much as or more than anyone. But it might be helpful to analyze how I plan to optimize attendance at demos for me so that you understand things from my perspective.

First, I see the demo matrix as capital that I must divvy up and spend carefully, very carefully. I have some good friends who will be doing demos and some new acquaintances from Wood Central who I hope to see, including you. Then, I must consider which "big hats" to see and factor in the access I will have to them outside of this program. I am intrigued by the work of Hans Weissflog and wonder how many times I could/should see him demo. There are certainly design considerations in his work, but a lot of technique may be shown as well.

What are the chances that I will attend five design presentations? Slim to none. What would I hope to get from a design presentation? PRINCIPLES! I need a well-structured presentation that teaches me some guiding principles. Your answers to me when I asked about the ugly box were exactly what I was looking for.

Where are the potholes in a design presentation? There is a risk that a discussion on plagiarism will break out and that a "rant" is all one takes away from it. There is a risk that the presenter has some good ideas but has not thought them completely through -- so that things are left hazy or nebulous. And, no matter how good they are, can the presenter explain themselves clearly?

Finally, I agree with Russ that one either has it or one doesn't when it comes to design, once you get past the basics.

Re: Design questionaire:

#7

What to include

Jack Savona

>Keith, I attended your demo with Steve Sherman at Totally Turning this past fall and learned some new tricks of 'seeing', i.e., holding a chain and seeing its shape, looking at the bowl sideways on the lathe, drawing what I want beforehand...all basic tricks that YOU innately and perhaps unconsciously use, but others, like me, may not.

What helped me TREMENDOUSLY years ago in a Photo Club was recorded critiques by an experienced photographer of various club members' work. "I find this _____ distracting..."; "Centering the subject made this too static..."; etc. After a few weeks of this, I found I could look at others work and MY work and evaluate them all so much better.

So my suggestion would be to have tons of turnings (slides) and talk about what you (or others) like or don't like about each and what you would do to improve them. That would help ME the most. I need to further train my 'design eye'... to take all those experiences and info hidden inside me and bring them into my consciousness. The theory is to look at classic forms and assimilate their shapes; the reality is how to evaluate our own pieces and make them better.

Why design info? If I'm going to spend all the time, expense, and energy into getting and preparing wood and producing a turning, I want it to be the absolute best I can do. And the next one even better!

Re: Design questionaire:

#8

Re: Design questionaire:

Verne

>First off, let me say that I am a retired commercial artist and designer, and have taught as well. IMHO, the basic concepts of design can be taught/learned, however, there is a danger which must be always be acknowledged and that is that these concepts are NOT rules! When one begins to see them as rules, true art and creativity usually goes out the window! In art and for that matter design, there are no hard and fast rules - only guidelines. I can't begin to count the number of times, I have seen design guidelines broken, but the "artist" made it work anyway. Should you take classes? Definitly, but be ready to forget what you learned as soon as you are able.

Re: Design questionaire:

#9

Re: Design questionaire:

Ed Karch

>Yes I plan to attend all the sessions on form and design. Last year I attended my first AAW symposium and then analyzed the sessions I attended. Only three were technical and two of those stressed form and design. The session I thought was best was the panel on form. Can design be taught? I hope so as I have signed up for a design and drawing classes.

Re: Design questionaire:

#10

Re: Design questionaire:

Joe Flemig

>Keith,

What a loaded question. Would I go? Absolutely. Maybe to the exclusion of "how to" demos. Can design be taught? Yes. Can good design be instilled in a 90 minute demo? No. What you can do is equip a person with tools to improve their design skilss and eye.

For example, the last two years in Provo, Kip Christensen handed out 4" x 8" pieces of paper to everyone in attendance. Then, he told people to draw the profile of a vessel. The class would vote on the "best" design and he would turn it. He had a 4" x 8" block of wood to use. Funny thing - most people draw a 4" x 8" upright vessel. In other words, they feel compelled to use the whole piece of wood. A few turned their papers 90 degrees and some made 4" x 4" vessels. These were often the best pieces.

Christian Burchard and Jacques Vesery show comparative slides of "good" and better" as well as progression in design over time.

Don Derry shows basic design forms in terms of egss, spheres, pears, etc.

Joe Fleming - San Diego

Re: Design questionaire:

#11

Re: Design questionaire:

John Lucas

>Keith I think it is simply a matter of enough turners realizing that techniques only go so far. Once you've reached the point where you have the skills to turn most things then you start looking for the perfect form and if you have never been taught what good form is then you have to go looking. I think we simply have enough good turners out there that they need that extra help. Maybe the critics that some clubs do also help them become aware that there's more to a bowl than just any ole shape.

Re: Design questionaire:

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Design questionaire:

Keith Tompkins

>Barry, You and Russ bring up a good point, and I am a good example. I loved baseball as a kid and studied the game religiously. I knew just about everything about the game. I could study a batter's swing and tell him what corrections he needed to make. I knew what moves the coach should make...hit and run, walk the batter, etc. And, I practiced more than anyone I knew....yet, I wasn't very good at the game...I lacked the physical skills needed to excel. In much the same way, a turner may understand design principles, yet be a poor turner...limited by the his skill level.

I never was major league material, and the poor turner will never cause Mr. Ellsworth to lose any sleep. By understanding the game, I helped our team, and played as well as I could, without making stupid mental errors that would cost the game. And, even the poor turner can produce work that he is proud of...maybe better than he ever thought possible by applying sound design principles.

Re: Design questionaire:

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Design questionaire:

Keith Tompkins

>HI Joe, you hit the nail right on the head...I am limited by time, so I can't possibly cover enough ground. What I can do, is make an impression; create a spark that will make those in the audience think.."holy smokes this works! I really need to study this!"

You KNOW when a design demo worked....people leave the demo, and you can almost see the light bulb glowing above their heads.

Re: Design questionaire:

#14

Re: Design questionaire:

Jim K in Trappe PA

>Keith,

As a new turner (1 year this month), design is one of the things I struggle with the most. I've turned maybe 30 bowls and platters, and a few boxes, so I have the basic technical skills, but I struggle with design - It looks too flat, it looks too round, it's too tall, the proportions aren't right.....

I'm getting better, and what I do now is much better than what I did six months ago, but it is not something that comes completely naturally to me. Can design be taught? Yes, probably to a point. I'll take all of the teaching I can get!

Re: Design questionaire:

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Design questionaire:

Keith Tompkins

>It's important to stay on topic...if you let one or two ranters carry on , the demo is over. I leave a few minutes at the end to answer any questions or defuse a debate.

I try to keep the pace lively enough that most trouble makers don't have time to reload their ammunition.

Trust me on this, I have probably encountered every negative turner possible while dealing with this subject...or so it seems.

Re: Design questionaire:

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: What to include

Keith Tompkins

>you got it! in the same way, I try to make each demo better than the last...I'm glad you attended the demo!

Re: Design questionaire:

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Design questionaire:

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks, ED. I'm looking forward to my visit...As we discussed an hour long demo just isn't enough time to cover the topic....just enough to show that the possiblities exist. AND it just might be the thing to boost a turning career.

Re: Design questionaire:

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Design questionaire:

Keith Tompkins

>Verne, are you a jazz musician? Exactly how they think...practice scales all day, then forget them when you play.

I say study all you can, use what you like, build on what you know. Forget the rest. I tell people , use what you can from my demo...add it to what you already know. If you don't like what I teach, that's ok too.

Re: Design questionaire:

#19

Re: Design questionaire:

Niedling

>I might make it to one design demo at the most. I like to see people that I have never seen before the most. I always get some element of design learnings from most of the demostrators. A design demo for me would be to see an original turning and a second modified turning to show the difference. This visual helps me learn best.

I think it is important to help turners understand the rule of thumbs and basics of good shape, form and balance.

I agree with the others that most of us can learn and take it to some level. From there on it is what talent we were born with.

Re: Design questionaire:

#20

Design presentation-an opposite (long) viewpoint:

Dinyar Chavda

>Keith:

I'm going to take a position contrary to the general sentiment expressed here. When I go to a conference, I want to maximize the value of what I am going to get out of it (I have been known to make spreadsheets to ensure that I can see the key people I want to!). So, to me, the question is not whether I can learn something about design from a design presentation, but will I learn more by going to that presentation versus some other, particularly, if I think that I can learn about design by reading books.

My impression is that most design presentations impart knowledge that can, in fact, be gleaned from books---read Raffan, or any of the myriad books on the golden mean or a fair curve, or the turning book on forms and shapes. However, unless they have videos on the subject, I cannot determine what, for example, Hans Weissflog or Marilyn Campbell do, except by going to their demos (where I actually learn a lot about design).

There are exceptions to the last statement re design presentations being repetitions of what one can find in books--I'd go see any presentation by Vessery or by Ellsworth or the late Phil Wall (there are probably others whom I haven't seen). To have a great presentation, you need to understand design both technically and emotionally, be able to explain why alternatives are inferior, and be able to communicate all this information verbally----a rare combination of talents.

So, I'd flip the question, and ask what the conditions would be under which I would go to a design presentation, when it competes with a technique presentation:

1. The presenter spends an absolute minimum amount of time on "theory"; as I said earlier, I can get that from books.

2. The presenter actually turns a piece, and stops and shows the decisions that he/she makes at each stage---how big do I make the shoulder? Where do I place the shoulder? What effect will that have on decisions down the road? etc.

3. The presenter shows the result of these decisions made along the way (a la Vessery) by showing pictures or actual examples of such decisions.

Now for some more way-out ideas:

4. The presenter is from a field other than turning. Our conferences tend to be fairly insular, and there is a whole other slew of crafts that we can learn from. Obvious ones are pottery and basket-weaving. Perhaps not as apparent are photography and painting, particularly large scale photography of nature, as well as compositions of still life and people scenes. I vaguely remember John Jordan doing something like this at an AAW.

5. The presenter (not, necessarily, a turner) is from a country other than the US, or, better still, other than the West. Some of the greatest explosions in art have occurred when the artists of one country have been exposed to the work of other countries, and have seen the "rules" that they are confined by, being broken. For example, the tremendous influence of Japonica, specifically woodblocks, on French Impressionism (also influence by the new art/craft of photography) changed Western painting by breaking fundamental rules of "good painting".

6. The presentation is billed as "Rules of good design, and how to break them"---that I would go to repeatedly. Learning rules is important, but once you have done that, as Verne says, above, "be ready to forget what you learned as soon as you are able". The problem is that once you learn the rules, your eye and your hand will resist any attempt you make to break them. (Listen to "Flowers are Red" by Harry Chapin, for a heartbreaking example of this). I would love to see work where the creator has deliberately, and successfully, broken the rules, and try to understand why it works. By the way, this can also be from any field, not just turning.

A long answer to your question, for which I apologize.

Re: Design questionaire:

#21

Great discussion!

Chris K in MD

>Kieth,

I am really enjoying this discussion. I have not seen any remark about personal appeal and taste. Its interesting to me how shapes appeal to some and not others. For instance I absolutly adore Cindy Drozda's boxes with finials. My dad attended a talk at his club by an accomplished turner that discussed form and its appeal. The guy presented many photos of turnings and clay pots etc. One was a before mentioned box, he tore it apart, said it wasnt balanced. My dad started feeling the same way. I couldn't disagree with them more. It was strange to see the influence on my dad as well. Before he thought they were nice but still wasnt as in love with them as I am.

would I attend for sure, what am I looking for? I am hoping to train my eye. I recently took a private lesson with Eli Avisera and he talked about the subject of form. A few very simple tips helped me with hollow form "form". turn the item upside down, if its still appealing to the eye then you have hit the mark. It holds true the majority of the time. This has allowed me to train my eye a bit better and strive for better designs and push my limits.

I have seen artists that have a strong sense of form be able to bring it to turning. When they pick out the finer points of a design on a piece it jumps out at me and "registers" your proverbial lightbulb comment.

I think if you take some of the feedback from this thread and incorporate it you will have a very succesful demo. I am looking forward to it!

Best regards,

Chris

Re: Design questionaire:

#22

Re: Design presentation-an opposite (long) viewpoi

John Lucas

>Boy I think Dinyar nailed the discussion of what we go see at a symposium. I have the same problem. It's expensive to go to one of these things so you decide to go see someone you will "pay the bill" or at least you learn enough to convince yourself that it was worth spending this money. Of course seeing friends, the instant gallery and trade show are also good reasons but when it comes to what demonstrator to go see I think techniques usually sell better than design. I do see that changing and that has to do with the quality and thinking of the attendees.

When you go to a Furniture Society conference the have a heavy emphasis on design and history. I think that is because the FS attracts many of the top craftsmen and since they already know most of the techniques they are looking for inspiration in the form of discussions on design.

We do need to have advanced discussions on design, direction, and inspiration for those advanced turners who's skill is already there but need to take thier work in another direction.

Re: Design questionaire:

#23

Separation of form and technique.

RussFairfield

>I am wondering why we are always separating shape (design) from technique. It seems to me that they cannot be separated.

When we teach someone how to use a bowl gouge, we should also be showing them what to go with it, and the "what" is the form and shape of the bowl. The good demonstrator will do this. Those that don't are missing one Helluvan opportunity.

I do classes and demonstrations on segmented bowls. We always have to draw a picture of the bowl we want to make before we can start cutting wood. That means the 1st thing we do is have a discussion of a few design principles and how I might use them for the form and function of a good bowl. I don't know how to draw the outline of a bowl unless I have some idea what it should look like.

Re: Design questionaire:

#24

Re: Design questionaire:

Gary Ratajczak

>First off, it has been very interesting reading everyones comments - a great discussion! I have dabbled in turning for years, and have concentrated mainly in miniatures on my Jet Mini. After just purchasing a new scroll chuck, and digging out some maple and walnut I have been saving for years, I'm ready to move up to some new projects. So... from the perspective of a new turner, which I believe is a fair amount of the attendees at a conference, a design seminar should be required in my opinion.

I have, in the past, attended a few "similar" sessions. As a number of posts pointed out, way to much theory. The tone that I feel reading the posts is that the "accomplished" turners are not apt to attend a design seminar during a symposium. Most have migrated to a certain style piece, and would rather attend a seminar that might show a new "technique."

So... for the remainder of us turners who can use some good design tips, I agree with an earlier poster about taking the techniqe approach here also. Attending a symposium and only "listening" will not provide the average attendee with much that actually travels back home with them (my opinion). As a new turner, I need to see it. Again, as mentioned by an earlier poster, start with some wood and show me. Along with that, point out the "general rules" used to get started when you first chuck up a piece of wood - probable the hardest point to get started for any new turner. That's where I would show some guidelines on proportion, suggest that a piece be sketched prior to actually turning, etc., etc.. Maybe even provide a take home paper showing some guidelines. Proportions for a box, proportion for a bowl, how big to make the foot, etc..

To sum it up, I feel there is a good opportunity to provide some value to the new turners with this type of presentation. The principals are important, but convey them by example. That's what sticks. (Again, all my opinion)

Keith - hope to see another presentation in the Albany/Saratoga area! Always enjoy seeing your work!

Re: Design questionaire:

#25

Re: Design questionaire:

Ron in Drums PA

>BB King was once asked if he can read music, He answered, "Not enough to hurt my playing"

For accomplished musicians, the right shape and form of their music comes naturally because of years of practice. Intuitively, they know the rules and can feel what the right sound should be. Importantly, they have an understanding when the rules can be broken. An accomplished guitarist doesn�t break the rules just because they can, they break the rules because it feels rights in the music they are playing.

Russ Fairfield answered the question, �Can design be taught?",

"To a point, yes. There are design rules that will get you 40% of the way. You can get another 40% through study and association with good form in other media. But, the last 20% is talent that you either have or don't. You may disagree with the proportions, but rules and education will only take you so far. The rest is what you already have.�

He is absolutely right, but for those who don�t have that last 20% worth of talent, they will produce better work if they study and understand the first 80% of the basics. Who says everyone needs to be the best to have a greater enjoyment of their hobby.

I feel most budding artists (turners) are afraid to make mistakes and expect every finished piece to be a work of art. The most accomplished turners, the ones who are on top in their field, have already made every mistake in the book and have invented new mistakes along the way.

Picasso once said, �I am always doing that which I can not do, in order that I may learn how to do it.�