We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I sold a lot of turning blanks at our club meeting last night and forgot to give this tip about finding the center point when the blank is already cut in a circle but no center point is discernable. I know a lot of our club members are also WC readers, and figured it could/might be valuable other folks, too. I realize this is not exactly a new revelation, still, it was a brilliant tip for me when I first read about it.
Most of the blanks I cut have a compass center point indentation in them, but sometimes its hard to find.
1. Take the round blank, and draw the most accurate square you can that touches all 4 corners on one of the flat sides.
2. Draw diagonal lines on the square that intersect in the middle.
On the subject of center-finding tips, I use a compass or sharp pointed dividers. I guess at the radius and draw or scratch two arcs from opposite edges (A). If the arcs don't meet close enough, I bump the radius a little until they do (B). Then draw one arc to cross for the center (C).
Note that the radius does not have to be perfect to show the precise center, as shown in the closeup.
I prefer the square method (which is very easy using a square, by the way), because I find most of my bandsawn circles are not the greatest circles. A square works easier, quicker, and more accurately for me than the ruler/straight line method.
>Thank you for posting your method Mike. I appreciate that there is more than one way to skin the cat. I personally prescribe to the compass/intersecting arcs method but for larger blanks, I might try your method.
That being said, I'd like to mention something for everyone to think about. When someone posts a technique, unless it's dangerous or completely inaccurate, think before posting your methodology. Challenging someone's way of doing something by posting a different way and saying your way is easier or better can stifle the flow of this type of information. If I'm going to be challenged or one up'd every time I post a tip, I'll stop posting tips and that isn't good for the community. Not that I have any tips that I haven't thankfully borrowed from someone else anyway.
Posting a, "This is how I do it," seems reasonable. Posting a, "This way is easier," sounds like you're challenging someones skill. Mike's way of doing this produces the desired result. So do the others.
>Glad to help. And thanks for saying what I held back from stating on my response above.
It does suck, and automatically put the poster on the defensive, when responses like the ones you refer to appear after describing a perfectly acceptable method or practice. And it does give one the "fine, if you guys know how to do it better, I'll keep to myself" attitude from there on. I have forum battled thick skin, yet I'm susceptible to the same responses.
I think that we've just seen 3 perfectly good methods for finding a center point - none of which are exactly intuitive at first glance. They should be put together in an article for the turning section!
Other than someone posting a question asking how, there are very few ways to post a tip that don't generate other responses. None of them are intended as challenges, but they are perceived thusly regardless.
In the past I've tried to catch them beforehand by stating something like "yes, this is only one of many methods" but thats all so much work it defeats the quick little "here's a tip I found handy that you may as well" attitude.
>I was only trying to post another way of doing it. I didn't mean to start an argument or hurt anyone's feelings by it; and I damn sure didn't intend to start a war. I appologize to all who got offended.
>Thank you Russ, but no apology required, demanded, or needed. As I said, no challenge or anything else other than helpful intentions were present in any of the responses. The gut response to such a reply is simply an unintended natural consequence of such a conversation. I didn't say anything because I wasn't certain that the feelings were exclusive to me. Raymond confirmed that the phenomenon isn't exclusive to me.
>Is it the center of the blank that is important or is it the best way to show features, grain and figure?
So often we are concerned with "getting the most" out of a hunk of wood when perhaps we should be getting the "best" out of a hunk of wood. Quite often the "best" and the "most" aren't the same.
To that end the clear plastic layout template lets you observe the figure of the blank while you balance that with the resultant size such a center will resolve.
As for a tip on the layout template. If you scrape away parts of the circle lines to yeild a solid line with the next circle being a dashed line and the next circle being a dot line (repeat that patern of solid, dash, dot) then the template is easier to use.
The template can also be used to determine the best places to chainsaw or to bandsaw.
Naturaly the blanks which Mike makes are so execlent that "most" and "best" are the same thing.
>I can see where someone might take alternate methods posted as sharpshooting but try to remember part of sharing and being a help to others is being willing to listen to the message between the lines.
When somebody says"This is easier" what they mean is "This is easier for me".
Many times posting a tip about basics prompts someone else to say to themselves "Hey,there is something different than what I do.Maybe folks would like to see how I do it and THOUGHT everyone else did it".It`s not so much oneupsmanship as it is the first tip switched a lightbulb on and they`re sharing what`s illuminated by that light.
I`ll keep posting tips and reading about how others do things till I can`t type anymore.Hang the words involved,it`s the process that counts.
BTW-I made those circles with a hole in the center that I use to tack to 1/2 logs going to the bandsaw out of clear plastic so I can also put them on flat blanks and find center while evaluating the grain to make best use of the blank.
I`ve also been meaning to post a tip I saw up at Center for Furniture Craftsmanship.Use the white,plastic clad metal closet shelving at the "Borg" to gaurd things like windows and overhead lights.Quick,easy and they cut it for you.It`s saved my shop from being visited by the glass man more than once.
>I don't disagree at all Bob. The key to the response is a, "That works, here's an alternative method that I've found effective," approach instead of a, "That's not the easy way to do it. This is," approach. Everyone here usually does a good job of respecting one another and compiling a list of methods from discussion and no one intentionally causes a rift.
Posting on a message board full of "experts" and "top seated amateurs" is a daunting task sometimes. The thick skin and not reading too much into replies is a must.
Sorry to get off the topic of finding a center point. Hopefully we can all come to a middle of the road answer to the problem. Maybe we can meet half way? The intersection of minds? A common point instead of being on the circumference of the issue? :-)
>Yikes, I hope my response didn't offend anyone. I thought this forum was more about sharing ideas than one-upmanship.
I love tip threads, and I love to see discussion and various options all in one place. I learn more that way. I can't remember ever being offended myself (here or elsewhere) even when someone came back with an obviously better method, even if they SAID it was better and told why. It actually feels good to know that some discussion was generated, part of the sharing-of-information that makes this forum so valuable! (BTW, I still want to know how best to draw the inscribed square on the leading message - I tried this after you posted and what I used felt pretty clumbsy - I couldn't figure out how to keep the corners square.)
BTW, my bandsaw-cut circles are so sloppy that the traditional centerfinder method is nearly useless for me! The method of measuring 1/2 of the way with the tape works OK (as long as the blank is approximately round), but this either makes me think too hard or makes me hunt for my center rule. There is another good way that finds the center of gravity instead of the dimensional center, if anyone is interested, but it's more envolved and the trial-and-error method is pretty quick.
To continue with sharing information, here's another centering method I use a lot for turning squares, but it's not much good for circles. (I wish I had a picture.)
I hold a pencil firmly between thumb and forefinger and using my forefinger as a sliding guide (marking guage), I draw a line on the end parallel to one edge. Holding my hand stiff to "keep the calibration", I rotate the stock and quickly draw three more lines parallel to the other edges. Even if the lines don't exactly meet in the center, it is very easy to see where the center is. Like the traditional crossed "x" method, this works just as well if the stock is rectangular instead of square.
For me, this is quicker than using one of the center-finders and quicker than drawing an "x" from corner to corner with a straight edge (I have to find and pick up only the pencil instead of the pencil and something else!) I think it's actually more accurate than a center finder for the cases where the sides are not perpendicular. I use this method for most stock up to about 2 or 3" across, but it would be useless on bowl-sized turning blanks unless you have huge hands!
>When I draw my circle with my compass, I drive the point down into the wood enough so that the point can be seen...ream it out a little, so to speak. Then I'll sometimes take a pencil or black marker to highlight that point, if that would make it more visible. Then when I pick up the blank later to mount to the lathe, it's immediately visible where the center is. My indentation is so shallow, it gets turned away.
Of course, I have those times when I'm prepping a lot of blanks and forget to ream out the point :(
>That's pretty much my method too, only instead of using my finger I use another pencil or a stick or whatever's laying on the bench at the time. Works for me.
>I often use one of those clear plastic gadgets that CS sells. A hole in the center for a sharp, thin punch, and circles every half inch. Just center the plastic gadget on th blank and hit the punch.
>That is exactly what I do as well Sue, NOWADAYS. However, sometimes that indentation gets lost among burl eyes, dust, anchorseal, or other dents from banging around on a shelf. Drawing the (mostly) square works well.
Some of the blanks I sold last night were 3 or more years old and I had not learned that particular trick just yet.
Robert - I know you were funning, but I do cut my blanks, before anchorsealing, for what I believe the best grain orientation will be, not just to maximize the blank size.
Nobody's feelings were hurt here, yet we all have insinctive reactions just the same.
>I have heavy cardboard circles that range from 4" to over 20" in diameter which I use on the bark side of the log to get my roughly round shape on the bandsaw. After cutting, I flip the blank over and position the circle I used on the flat side of the blank and mark the approximate center with an awl. Not precise at all, but it gets me pretty close and, afterall, it's just woodturning.
Thanks to Bart from Buna for a DUH! moment in the Georgia mountains for this tip.
I have used, and like, the square method on blanks that I receive already in the round. I have a square close to my bandsaw and never seem to find a pair of dividers when I need them, so it might just be habit.
>Mike, I like your method. If I were organized, how would it work to have a series of squares that were say four inches on the inside and six inches on the outside and graduated so that there was a "set" of them. Then you could lay one on the end or put it "around" the end and then mark the diagonals? Seems like about a half a dozen would cover a lot of sizes.
On JKJ's method. If you used a compass and guessed at the radius or even if you used Russ's idea of a ruler, Let's say you had a rough bowl blank between nine and ten inches in diameter. 9" the short way and 10" the long way. You set your compass at 4 1/2" or hold you rule at 4 1/2". The biggest bowl you can possibly get is nine inches. If you scribe all the way around the outside with either the compass or the rule, any point inside that rough oval could be the center of the bowl. If you get outside that space, the bowl will be smaller than nine inches. It seems that once you have the "inner circle" or oval, you are picking the best center for the blank. Either to balance it so it will run as true as possible or to maximize the appearance of the blank. Have I got this figured out?
This is the politest, most civilized site I have ever been associated with. I hope we can maintain that. I also hope we can still feel free to post tips and better ideas without hurting anyone's feelings. Sometimes we may go a little too far in that direction. I may test the waters by posting a picture of the world's ugliest bowl and asking for a critique. You guys are so polite I wonder if I would get much help?
>... method that involves no tools other than a punch and an eyeball--- I guesstimate the center of the turning stock and whack it with the punch!! After years of calibrations and practice it works well enough, and I know that I'm probably going to re-orient between centers anyway before I'm done! No big deal, and no collection of pencils, forms, rulers, squares,etc. which we can't find when we need to use them!