Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

choice between two lathes

Posts

choice between two lathes

#1

choice between two lathes

Arw01

>with a $50 rebate, a price drop, free shipping, I'm going to take a look at the Delta La200 and the Penn State TCLPRO lathes as my first lathes. Main interest now is pens, chisel handles, and other small items. Doubt will get much into turning large spindels, and I have a Sears Router Crafter for those anyways.

photos of each:




Re: choice between two lathes

#2

Re: choice between two lathes

Rick Allen

>Without a doubt get the Jet Mini.

Re: choice between two lathes

#3

Re: choice between two lathes

Basil Biberdorf

>I second that. I'm just a beginner, but the Jet mini simply a nice little lathe. It'll also still have some value if you decide you don't like turning or want to upgrade. I've got the basic step-pulley only version (not the VS one), and it's smooth and quiet. How much money are you talking about saving? $50?

Re: choice between two lathes

#4

Re: choice between two lathes

Walt Drummond, Middlesex, NJ

>As a Delta LA200 owner/user who has also worked on the Penn State lathe, there is no question. The Delta is by far the better of the two.

Fit and finish are much better, and much smoother in operation. I'm very satisfied with mine. I've turned bowls up to 9" on it.

Walt


img

Re: choice between two lathes

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: choice between two lathes

Keith Tompkins

>I would go for the Jet. However, I would consider the new rikon 12" mini for the money.

Re: choice between two lathes

#6

Re: choice between two lathes

Larry Plagens

>I asked a similar question on December 4 about the Rikon. Look up the responses to that question about the Rikon. As far as the other two lathes go, read the article about testing 6 lathes in the current edition of Workbench magazine. The Jet mini came in first, followed by Penn State Turncrafter Pro, Delta LA200, Fisch TC90-100, General International, and a miserable last was Grizzly. The Rikon was not tested. Hope this helps.

Re: choice between two lathes

#7

Re: choice between two lathes

Arw01

>I beleive the Fisch tested and the Rikon are the same machine. They look identical and obviously is made for Rikon by Fisch.

Alan

Re: choice between two lathes

#8

Again, without a doubt

Doug Trembath

>The Jet. No lathe I have used has come dlose to the Jet, variable speed or not. They've done a great job on that model, and really haven't been approached [m quality or features by other manufacturers, IMHO, (of course). Using my Jet is very much like using my Vicmark, it's only a question of scale.

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: choice between two lathes

#9

Forgot to mention...

Doug Trembath

>the fact that as soon as you begin to turn, you will progress at lightning speed down a very expensive, all consuming, and slippery slope, and what you think will satisfy you now will very quickly become substandard. The drive will escalate into the search for the ultimate lathe, that will turn eight foot bowls, and thirty foot spindles. OK, maybe I stretched it for some folks, but that's the way I was when I finally got a chance to use a lathe regularly. Hope, for your sake, that you don't like it and sell all of the tools and accessories you have bought for a premium price, and have no more to do with it.

Fat chance.

You're already there, believe me. Try out some different lathes if you have the opportunity. Definitely research the AAW, and find the closest local turner's club. At your initial meeting, introduce yourself and say "I'd like the opportunity to turn on a few different lathes". You will be overwhelmed with the support and enthusiasm this obsession carries with it, a support group, if you will. In this manner, young neophyte, you will spend a LOT less money than by doing it by yourself. I have a tool holder that holds eighty tools, and I'm hard pressed at times to find an empty spot.

If you don't do these things immediately, you will quickly find yourself duplicating the path of almost everyone who regularly frequents this forum, and spend WAY too much money to learn.

Trust me, and if I may, I'll speak for the rest of us unfortunate souls, it'll happen...

Ever hear of heroin? Piece of cake next to this...

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: choice between two lathes

#10

Re: choice between two lathes

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>I would get the Delta. That's what I have and I think it's much better than the Jet. I worked at the Woodworking show last week-end for our club's booth, and was using the clubs Jet. I went to tighten the banjo and it broke off in my hand. The Delta is a much heavier and stronger lathe. I've had it for 2 years and no problems. Although it has not seen to much use in the last couple months since the new Powermatic 3520 has taken over it's place in the shop.

Mike

Re: choice between two lathes

#11

VL100 or used 1018

Ed Moore

>I would get a Vicmarc VL100 or a used Oneway 1018 if my interest was in pens or small items, as you described. They both have better bearings than any other lathes described in this category/thread.

IMHO each of the lathes mentioned in the posts that precede this one have a record of producing some good lathes and some bad lathes. It is my impression that the Jet Mini has the best record or percentage of good lathes. I sold a Delta and bought a slightly used Jet and much prefer the Jet while it is running. But plastic handles on motor/belt mounts are an insult to one's intelligence.

If today I had no lathe and a limited budget, but was caught in the proverbial vortex and was only going to buy one lathe, it would be the Oneway 1224. If that was beyond my means and I could only handle a mini lathe, then it would be a Vicmarc VL100. And if I could not handle that, it would be the Jet Mini. I would not purchase any of the other lathes, no matter how good the offer happened to be.

Ed's opinion, no more, no less.

Ed

Re: choice between two lathes

#12

Warning...

Peter Teubel

>If you decide on the Delta, I would suggest you check it out physically FIRST. Delta's QC on their mini lathe (can't comment on the rest of their tools) has gone WAY downhill in the past couple years. We've had many returns for manufacturing defects (spindle runout, off-center taper bore, noisy bearings, etc). If its good out of the box, its a great lathe, but if you can't inspect it first, I would pass on it.

Re: choice between two lathes

#13

Re: VL100 or used 1018

Fog Tanner

>Ed,

You are right on, the Jet is nothing more than a Chinese copy of a Vic 100. You used to be able to swap parts from one to the other. But, Vic has changed from ball bearings on the spindle to tapered roller bearings like their larger lathes. Which again makes it the most over engineered mini lathe. And when you consider what they can turn, they are stronger for their than some of the larger lathes being marketed. Were I to buy a new mini, like yourself I would buy the Vic 100.

Fog

Fog

Re: choice between two lathes

#14

Re: choice between two lathes

Barry Turner

>Amen. And Amen. Get the Jet Mini. Don't bother with the VS model. The standard model is quite sufficient. Second choice. Oneway 1224.

Re: choice between two lathes

#15

Re: Warning...

Barry Turner

>Always good advice. I had concerns about what would happen to the Jet Mini's quality when manufacture was moved from Taiwan to China, but apparently the QC has held steady. I got one of the older Taiwanese models and consider myself lucky.