Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Teaching Bowl Turning 101

Posts

Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#1

Teaching Bowl Turning 101

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi everybody,

I'm looking for some instruction for teaching bowl turning to beginning students. Is there a book, a video or a webpage with tips, hints, information on this topic? Sometimes when we know how to do something...turning around and teaching it to others isn't as easy as actually doing it.

Last night I taught what was "suppose" to be a Decorative Bowl Turning class. When I agreed to teach the class (at Woodcraft) I told the guy who organizes the classes that I would prefer not teaching a raw beginner class just because I have never taught a bowl turning class. In fact I've only taught one other class and that was a pen class a couple of weeks ago. My intention was to spend the first hour turning a small simple bowl and then talk about "enhancing" the simple bowl with different surface treatment ideas. Burning, texturing, coloring, carving etc. As it turned out all 5 students were new to turning and 2 had never turned before. So the syllabus went out the window right off the bat and we started from scratch. My box with the burner, and Prisma Markers, texturing goodies, and carving chisels never saw the light of day. The class actually went off okay though. All of the students seemed to think it was great. So I guess it went okay? I was thankful of that because I felt a bit unorganized and hadn't really planned things out for starting students from scratch. I owe a huge thanks to Bruce Wiseman for assisting me during the class. He was a huge help in getting all of the students out the door in the three hours with a finished bowl. That was a main goal of mine since the description Woodcraft wrote up of the class read "leave with a finished project!".

I would love to hear from any of you who have taken a class of students who have never turned before and taught them how to turn a bowl. What works best, what to avoid, etc. etc. Obviously safety and intro to the workings of the lathe are a must, but beyond that, what works for you when teaching. I would love it if this might be a topic of discussion some evening on the chat discussion. I really do enjoy teaching, but I would love to feel more confident in my approach to it. Perhaps that will just come with time. I'm sure a lot of it will.

Thanks for any insight you might have!

Jennifer

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#2

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

David Breth

>The first and only class I've had the opportunity to take was a bowl-making class, and it wasn't too long after I started turning. The things I found most helpful were hands on help with sharpening, learning how to ride the bevel, and getting help with my physical position (holding the tool, my body position relative to the lathe, etc.) Don't know if this helps or not, but I hope so!

David B.

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#3

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>David it helps a lot! I should have included asking the experiences of people who have taken a beginning bowl class as well. That's probably a more insightful view point actually.

Thanks so much!

Jen

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#4

Jenn, you got it...

TD

>We needed a topic for tonight so why not do this one? TD

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#5

I'd love that! Is it at 9:00 Eastern?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#6

Classes...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Jenn, I've been teaching turning classes for quite a few years. I've taught well over 300 students. I can give you a few pointers on what I feel is important.

I'm big on form and design and I stress that, even to beginners. Why not...it's just as easy to make a pretty bowl as an ugly one if they have a little guidance. I use a chalkboard and draw pictures. Just a few things, such as the foot being 1/3 the dia. of the piece, etc.

On the chalkboard I draw some suggested bowl forms and hand out paper and pencils. I ask the students to choose one and draw a sketch as a guide.

I explain and demonstrate the various ways of fastening a blank to the lathe. 4-jaw chuck, tape, glue blocks, etc. In most of my classes we use a glue block. I want them to know that they don't need a chuck to turn bowls.

I give a short demo on using the bowl gouge. I explain to beginners that they'll very requently hear me tell them to "ride the bevel"

When a student is having difficulty using a tool, I place my hands on theirs and guide them through a cut or two.

When the appropriate time comes I stop the class for "chalk talks" to explain various things. Using a scraper, shear scraping, various methods of hollowing, etc.

With beginners, I do some of the difficult things, and explain what and how it's done. Shaping a foot, parting off, etc.

I try to show and explain more than one way to do something.

When they are ready to hollow the bowl, I have them rough it out first. Make sure that they know that they should leave leave the wood heavy enough, so that when finishing cuts are made there is good support. Draw pictures showing what can happen if they've cut the walls too thin in the lower portion of the bowl.

I hope that I won't hurt anyones feelings if I tell you that often the most difficult students to teach are doctors and engineers. Doctors won't listen, and engineers always think that there's a "better" way. Often the easiest to teach are women. They come to the class saying that they don't know anything about turning and want to learn.

Explain and demonstrate the basics of sanding.

There is a lot more to teaching but this should help.

The best part of the class for me is when they walk out the door with a pretty bowl and a big smile on their faces.

Wally

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#7

Re: Classes...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Couple more things..

I spend time teaching sharpening. Explain the importance in using sharp tools.

Before turning on the lathe, we discuss safety in turning.

Wally

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#8

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

Jim Shaver, Oakville Ontario

>Hi Jen,

Good for you!

I have taught a few pen turning classes. The basics are probably the foundation to any type of turning you will teach. There is an intimidation factor about several things, but the biggest is getting the lathe running and touching steel to wood.

I found that a simple agenda with a basic first part on the explaination of how tools cut with the lathe off can be very informative. The simple act of holding the tool to the wood and slwly turning the wood by hand will show the student what the tool edge will do. Turning on the lathe then doing it is a bit of walking on thin ice at first, but they will understand after a few catches that as you know, riding the bevel is the most important fisrt learning, then sharpening.

Pen making is basic, it's spindle work...turning a bowl is more involved so I rest that the details should be taken step by step, stopping to go over the basics as the studenst approach those elemenst that require different turning requiremenst, the inside to out side balance and then finally after they have walked that mile...actually understanding what a form is...but on a first turning, for me...it's about the introduction of all aspects of the lathe, tools, sharpening, some basic techniques and having some fun...form and finish will come later once the ice get's thicker.

Focus on the basics, the rest will follow..

Take care,

Jim

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#9

My experience with BT 101

Carole in VA

>Hi Jen,

The only class I have ever taken was the beginning bowl turning class at Woodcraft. The class was about 8 folks and a mixture of ones who had never even been near a lathe to those like myself who had already done some bowls. A fair amount of time was spent on sharpening which I think this is extremely important since many would-be turners are "turned off" to turning because their tools are not sharpened correctly and they end up fighting the lathe, the tool and the wood. A lot of time was also spent on tool presentation, movement and the different cuts. All of the blanks used were already set up with glue blocks and rounded out so that saved some time. The bowls were also completed and parted off straight from the glue block...no reverse chucking. Three hours is not much time for a class of mixed experience...I don't see how you can demonstrate, answer questions, give adequate attention to those less experienced and still send everyone home with a completed project! Our class went from 9:00AM to 4:30PM.

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

Keith Tompkins

>HI Jennifer....Teaching is the BEST way to improve your own turning! I think it makes one analyze the way they do things, and find the best way to explain techniques.

I agree with Wally here 100 percent! Form and technique together, right from the beginning. Why waste years turning bad forms? In the photo, the student had never turned before....and this was a basic segmenting course. It's extremely difficult to teach a class of six when several haven't turned before. they will require more time than the rest; which isn't fair to the rest of the group.

Notice that the student had made a basic drawing of the piece in advance, and was required to make the form as drawn.(As closely as possible, no design changes allowed). Like Wally's students, the student has to draw first, to help visualize the form they want to produce. This concept, if followed, will help a student advance rapidly from novice to a skilled turner.

You will find most students, even those with some experience, cannot sharpen their tools properly. I spend a lot of time in that area.

Many students arrive to my classes with pre-conceived ideas; that makes teaching them new techniques or ideas difficult. I cannot tell you how many times I have heard "Thats not how Richard Raffan teaches this!" or some similar statement. "I just let the wood talk to me" is a student favorite saying after I ask how they arrived at their forms. I wonder how Wally combats that attitude....Unfortunately, I cannot say to the students "Dude, your forms totally SUCK! You need to LISTEN!" Unfortunately, the students with the worst sense of form are the ones who will not listen.

I think the hardest thing to accept as a teacher is that some students will be natural turners, and some will not be able to turn...period. I agonize over the students that do poorly, thinking somehow I could have done a better job . According to those I know who teach other crafts, this is commonplace and must be put into perspective. Sadly, Not everyone who takes your course will become a successful turner.

It is very rewarding to teach however, and personally I feel I'm giving something back. It's great to get a letter or email thanking you for a good job!


img

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#11

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101 starts with spindles

RussFairfield

>I am one of those from the "olde school" that still believes that the route to turning bowls is through learning how to use a spindle gouge. Spindle turning teaches them how wood is cut and how to use and sharpen the tool. For me, the task of teaching the beginning beginner is easier with a broad (safe) spindle gouge and a piece of green tree limb so they can make some shavings. After they become comfortable doing that, the move into turning a bowl is an easy one.

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#12

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>Jennifer,

If you are looking for some great beginner info, two videos come to mind. One is from Taunton Press and it is by Del Stubbs and the second is the DVD bt Bill Grumbine. You should get more that enough great info from these two sources.

Mike

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101 starts with spindles

Keith Tompkins

>Me Too, Russ. Everything that a spindle turner does can be applied to bowl turning. In fact, it's easy for a spindle turner to adapt to making bowls. It's NOT so easy for a bowl turner to produce an attractive spindle, especially in multiples.

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#14

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101 starts with spindles

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Keith,

That is interesting, I started as a spindle turner, bowls are not really my deal, but I do make them when the mood hits me, I will find myself with a spindle gouge often when turning the out side form on a bowl, but going to a 3/8 bowl gouge for the inside.

Maybe it was a good thing to start long and lean than round and ....never mind..

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#15

Re: Well said, Wally!

Doug Trembath

>I took an Intermediate Turning class at CSUSA quite a few years ago, with Mike Mahoney. I didn't think I qualified as an intermediate turner yet, but took it anyway. Turned out I was the most experienced student there! Mike had ten students, and ran his legs off trying to keep up with them. We had one older gentleman in the booth adjacent to mine who simply could not assimilate the instruction. Mike demo'ed the roughout cut for a bowl, and we went to it. In no time at all, I would hear THUMP,THUMP,THUMP,THUMP, and Mike would show up, cut out the bounce, explain again how to cut, and the guy would begin cutting smoothly. Before Mike got to the next student, it would start again with the THUMP,THUMP,THUMP,THUMP. Finally I left my booth and helped him. I stand behind the student, put my hands over theirs, and show them how to adjust the tool to achieve the desired cut. I pretty much took over for Mike so he could give the other students the attention they deserved. I think that's one of the reasons Mike and I established such a good rapport. Sadly, the guy never did achieve a smooth cut. I don't know if it was that he couldn't see, or was just limited in understanding. Whatever, Mike came up to me later and thanked me for taking the initiative and helping out.

I also agree with your GENERAL statement about Doctors and Engineers. I have had a number of both, and I couldn't have explained their tendencies any better. I was giggling as I read it. The ladies don't have a male ego, and that allows them to learn more quickly, as they don't have that in the front of their minds. I open my sessions with the statement "Gentlemen, check your coats and your egos at the door, please!" Then I explain why. Seems to work for me.

Thanks again for the great post, Wally!

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#16

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

Doug Trembath

>Jen, one of the most effective ways to evaluate what a student knows is to have them turn a mallet as the first task. Spindle turning, as others have already pointed out, should be fairly well understood before side grain turning, IMHO. I think Woodcraft and other venues do the turning community a disservice allowing people into a bowl turning class without requiring a basic woodturning class first. It puts the onus on the instructor to take the students too far too fast, and can easily result in potential disaster. Just my opinion.

The one bowl turning class I took at a Woodcraft long ago was more of a demonstration, and only those who were very confident actually touched the tool.

I admire your approach, in soliciting suggestions like this, and am sure it's going to improve a lot of folks' thoughts about teaching methods. Good subject!

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#17

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Jennifer

I get a number of people who have never laid a hand on the lathe before, as well as quite a few very raw beginners. What is even worse are the ones who have developed bad habits that are already ingrained. I follow the procedure below:

Sharp tools with the proper geometry. This is almost a prerequisite class, especially if you are going to be teaching a lot of people. Proper geometry does not necessarily mean MY grind, but A grind that can cut wood without generating more catches than shavings. I almost always start students with a grind less aggressive than the one I use.

Proper body stance. Many people approach the lathe as if they are jousting with it. I tell them that if a fat guy like me can get that close, so can they. Just about anyone who has been here will tell you that I harp on body movement more than just about anything else (you might even remember that from your own visit!).

Cutting wood and truing the surface. This is a tremendous confidence builder, and necessary to everything that follows. Form will come eventually, but they will never get to good form if they cannot make the tool cut wood. I cannot tell you how many 12" bowl blanks have turned into 6" bowls just going through this step, but learning the cuts is more important than getting that first bowl off the lathe.

Form. Form is very important, as has been mentioned by others, but one thing that is often NOT mentioned is that a good form actually helps with the way the tool cuts. Straight sides and flat bottoms are a real hinderance to smooth surfaces, not just because a person is new with the tools, but also because the wood does not like to be cut that way.

It has been my experience that by the time you cover the above mentioned segments it is time for lunch. ;-) In other words, expect this much to take about three to four hours, depending on the skill and experience of your students, as well as the class size. If you have more than three students, you are really going to be hopping, unless they are all fairly gifted in the listening and learning dept.

Good luck with it, and I hope this helps you out (along with that back channel stuff).

Bill

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#18

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

JamieDonaldson

>I've noticed over the years that the first bowl blank always morphs into a mug? The beginner has so much fun cutting the wood away on the outside that there's not enough left for a bowl, so waste away some practice wood before going for a defined shape project. Relax and have fun with practice- remind them that wood does grow on trees! Rude always said the place to learn turning is standing at the lathe!

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#19

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>Hi Jennifer,

I took the Woodcraft beginning bowl class about 3years ago. None of the 6 people taking the class had any woodturning experience, so the instructor had his hands full trying to keep an eye on 6 wannabe woodturners with sharp gouges and spinning wood.

While the course was a bowl class and we all managed to carve out some crude looking bowls, some of which could fly if you know what I mean, the overall theme of the class was "this is what woodturning is like and you have to decide if it is something you want to do".

It worked for me!

Rick

Re: Teaching Bowl Turning 101

#20

Thanks to All!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>What a great bunch of information from all of you. I really do appreciate it. It is apparent to me that I should have posted this prior to the class! Had a I known what I was walking into I may have. I've really learned a lot from this thread and the chat last night.

Man, I love WoodCentral!

Jen :)