Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

Posts

Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#1

Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

Ryan Dicker in Renfrew, Ontario

>Hi.

I'm in a little bit of a jam here with my lathe. Literally.

My faceplate, which has a bowl mounted to it, seems to have become stuck on the threads of the headstock. I've had a hard time to get it off before, but it seems that this time it is just absolutly jammed on. I've tried using a monkey wrench on the faceplate with the knockout bar levered against the bed. That didn't seem to work. At this point I could care less about the relatively clear piece of box elder that is mounted on there, I just want it off.

I have a General Maxi 25-100 with the standard 3" faceplate mounted on. All 4 screw holes are in use.

I am afraid of putting too much torque on the bearings and spindle but it seems that this thing just won't come off.

If you have any suggestions, I would certainly appreciate your input.

Thanks,

Ryan

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#2

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

JohnD

>Lock the spindle and with a wrench on the faceplate tap the wrench with a wooden mallet. Don't bang it just a sharp tap.

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#3

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

JKJ in East TN

>Assuming you got a good grip and force doesn't work, I would try letting penetrating oil or wd40 soak into where the back of the faceplate is cinched up against the seat on the spindle, then try the force again.

It doesn't seem likely, but if the problem is in the threads rather than where the faceplate seats against the spindle, applying heat to the faceplate with a propane torch, or alternately, cold to the spindle might help. Heat is commonly used to break loose stubborn threads. However, if the problem is not between the threads, I don't think heat will help. In this case, cold applied to the outside at the very back of the faceplate near the seat MAY work since it may shrink the metal enough longitudinally to releave the friction at the rear. Success may depend on how tight the clearance is on the threads. Cooling the faceplate would also shrink it radially and it might temporarily tighten it firmly on the threads. However, if my faceplate were really stuck I'd try it anyway. Dry ice, used with caution, is a good way to get something good and cold.

Assuming the problem is in the back where the faceplate seats against the spindle, a fiber or plastic washer can prevent this in the future. I put a big o-ring on mine and my stuck faceplate and chuck problems instantly went away. Some people have cut washers from plastic containers or even cardboard. You can buy pre-made washers from Highland Hardware and others to fit your lathe.

JKJ

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#4

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

Ryan Dicker in Renfrew, Ontario

>Thanks for the responses.

I am currently out of any lubricating oil such a WD-40, but will pick some up tomorrow. The back of the face plate looks to be very tight against the spindle head and is likely where the jam has occurred. When I put the faceplate on, I started it on and then gave it a quick spin to finish threading it the rest of the way, which was followed by a quiet pop. Cooling at the seat of the spindle will likely be the best option. Where would I get something like dry ice to get the job done?

I've tried putting on just about as much force as can manage without really putting some stress on the spindle, but what would the chances of the spindle bending be? Should I be worried about that?

I might call up General and see what they can offer as a suggestion if I can't get this thing budged.

Thanks Again,

Ryan

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#5

Penetrating Oil...

Peter Teubel

>Keep in mind that the penatrating oil needs to PENETRATE to work. After flooding the affected area, gently tap the faceplate near the spindle with a metal hammer. Don't bang it hard enough to cause any damage, just lots of light taps to generate some vibration which will allow more oil to penetrate.

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#6

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

Mike from St. Clair Shores

>If you need to cool it, a CO2 extinguisher can really put things into a deep freeze.

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#7

Yes, and a couple of other things

Garrett in Victoria

>First, I find that steady tapping - not hitting - is often successful.

Second, don't use WD-40. It's not a penentrating oil. It's a water-dispersant (that's where the WD comes from.) Buy a can of penetrating oil tomorrow, and as already suggested, let it soak in for a couple of hours. and,

Third, make a 'washer' out of a piece of 1/4" hardboard or even baltic birch plywood and always place it between faceplate and headstock. Guaranteed to prevent this happening again.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#8

Re: Penetrating Oil...

JimQ

>I used a rubber strap wrench(Sears sells them) around the handwheel on the other side of the headstock the last time I used the faceplate without a plastic washer. This was on a Delta Midi, and I put a lot of pressure on the strap wrench without any damage to the spindle. The plastic washer can be as thin as the side of a plastic dish soap bottle(empty). It just needs to prevent seizure between the spindle face and the faceplate base.

JimQ

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#9

Thinking in two dimensions.

Barry Irby

>John, I would not have tried applying the dry ice to the face plate, thinking that it would shrink in diameter and lock even tighter on the threads. It would not have occurred to me that it might shrink it in the the other direction and break the grip against the shoulder. Interesting. Have you tried this? The threads on my faceplates are pretty loose and shrinking them a thousandths or two in diameter would probably not lock them, but but even a ten thousandths the other way might be enough. Good thought.

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#10

Re: Penetrating Oil...

Barry Irby

>Locally there is a company called either Carbonic or Carbolic Industries that makes Dry Ice. Also try industrial sand blaster type companies. They sometimes use the pellets for blasting things clean. Neat idea, They blast away and have no sand to clean up, it evaporates.

Use extreme care handling it, It will freeze to you skin. If I were doing this I would try packing the shaft full through the knock out hole.

Next time use either the plastic washer or don't spin the work on so hard. Firmly, but not hard. The worst case I ever had was letting the lathe spin the work on for the last turn or two. I used the tapping method. A little PB Blast penetrating oil, waited an hour. Locked the shaft, put the wrench on and as much pressure as I dared and then tapped the wrench handle about twice and nearly broke my neck because it popped loose and I had most of my weight on it. Let us know what works for you.

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#11

Re: Thinking in two dimensions.

JKJ in East TN

>>Interesting. Have you tried this?

No, but it's something I would certainly try if my face plate was good-n-stuck! I'd try everything I could think of - heat, cold, tapping (and even WD-40).

I HAVE used dry ice in the past for unsticking non-lathe things. You don't want to put it on anything particularly fragile then apply force (the cold can cause brittleness), but a steel face plate is pretty stout.

BTW, the CO2 fire extinguisher idea is a reasonable one. A home/shop/lab dry ice maker works on the same principle - you connect it to a CO2 bottle and the cooling from the expansion of the gas forms dry ice as needed.

For electronics repair I also use "freeze spray" in an aerosol can for spot cooling - available at any electronic supply house and probably Radio Shack. It's great for pinpointing overheating components and solder joint problems. I've used it on mechanical things as well.

JKJ

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#12

Re: Thinking in two dimensions.

John Lucas

>Reading through this thread I see WD-40 mentioned over and over. As was mentioned early on this stuff is not a penetrant. It's also not a particularly good lubricant because it gets gummy after a while. I used to work with a man who repaired typewriters and he said it was the worst stuff in the world to use on moving parts. My boss used to spray the stuff on our overhead rail bearings. The are so gummy now that I have to constantly spray them with a good penetrating oil to keep them working.

This stuff works good for wiping the lathe be down because it does help keep moisture off the bed. As far Is I'm concerned there are better lubricants for almost any other task than WD-40. Sorry for the Rant but I've seen this stuff missused so many times. You don't know how many cameras came into our store where the customer had problems and sprayed wd-40 in to correct it. This virtually always ruins a camera or lens beyond repair.

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#13

WD-40 mania *LINK*

JKJ in East TN

>>You don't know how many cameras came into our

>store where the customer had problems and

>sprayed wd-40 in to correct it.

This probably comes from the timeless redneck advice in the south as related by Sam Venable and others: "If it sticks and ain't s'posed to, use WD-40. If it ain't stuck ands s'posed to be, use duck [sic] tape."

I don't quite understand what I've seen often repeated over the years that WD-40 is not a lubricant. While as you say it may not be the best lubricant (or penetrating lubricant) available, it certainly does contain a lubricating oil.

From the MSDS (Material Safety Data Sheet) WD-40 is an organic mixture containing 15-25% petroleum base oil. It also contains aliphatic (straight carbon chain, unlike aromatic ringed molecules) petroleum distillates. The MSDS doesn't indicate the exact distillate, but other examples of aliphatic distillates are methane, propane, and kerosene, and various solvants (all quite flammable, BTW).

Classified as a "penetrating lubricant" or not, while I would never spray it into a camera my personal experience shows that it works very well for many tasks around the workshop, house, and farm, both for unsticking things and for light librucation. (I also wouldn't use gear oil or penetrating lubricant or even 3-in-one oil around a camera mechanism either - I have also repaired camera shutters that were lubricated by well-meaning people, the last one on an Olympus SLR that a guy dropped into a creek in the Smokeys!)

Now the WD-40 company certainly wants to sell WD-40 and can hardly be considered unbiased, but their product literature is a good place to start. If some of their claims are flat-out untrue, would not a competitor have challenged them by now? They list five basic product functions:

CLEAN: gets under dirt, grime and grease to clean. It also dissolves adhesives, allowing easy removal of labels, tape, stickers, and excess bonding material.

DISPLACE MOISTURE: quickly dries out electrical systems to eliminate moisture-induced short circuits.

PENETRATE: loosens rust-to-metal bonds and frees stuck, frozen or rusted metal parts.

LUBRICATE: lubricating ingredients are widely dispersed and hold firmly to all moving parts.

PROTECT: protects metal surfaces with corrosion-resistant ingredients to shield against moisture and other corrosive elements.

Note that it may not have the best penetration, be the best lubricant, the best cleaner, or best rust protection avialable, but it sure is convenient and I think it has some value. As Sir Lucas mentions, just don't misuse it. (BTW, I like aerosol cans of white lithium grease for most moderate lubrication tasks such as tracks, gears, worm screws, hinges, linkages, and other things without grease fittings.)

JKJ


WD40 product info

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#14

Re: WD-40 mania

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I was told by a gunsmith friend that a fairly high percentage of autoloading shotguns in for repair are there because of overuse of WD-40. It seems that continued use of WD-40 builds up until the autoloading funtion fails to operate properly. My friend uses a solvent to remove the build-up and the problem is solved. He didn't tell me what he charges for this "repair work".

Wally

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#15

Partly 'cause it contains silicone.

RevDoug

>

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#16

I didn't see silicone in the MSDS

JKJ in East TN

>

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#17

Re: WD-40 mania

JamieDonaldson

>And among its wonderous other uses is as a fish attractant when sprayed on lures!

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#18

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

Bruce Wiseman

>Well, I'm a little confused here. John Jordon, while presenting at the Ohio Valley Woodturners Symposium, stated that if you keep you spindle threads clean and lubed those washers are not needed. He stated that in fact they create problems with run out because your chuck or face plate is not seated correctly. I took my "milk jug" washer off my lathe. What's everybody else doing?

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#19

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

Ryan Dicker in Renfrew, Ontario

>Hi Guys,

Thanks again for all the responses. I picked up some Gunk Liquid Wrench Super Penetrant and it helped out quite a bit, though it was still very tight on the spindle. I got it off without having to sacrifice the bowl to my relief.

Is making a washer out of some flat plastic the best way to go? Or would a wood washer be better?

Any comments on what Bruce had to say?

Thanks again,

Ryan

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#20

Re: WD-40 mania

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Works for halibut in Wash. and Oregon.

Wally

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#21

Re: Faceplates don't stick; thread adapter does.

Al Crandall- NE of Indy

>Most of my turnings 16" or smaller are done with an adapter, from Best Wood Tools, which takes the 1 1/4" thread down to 1". For larger turnings I use the full 1 1/4" threads. I have had the adapter stick quite forcefully on the lathe. Newer versions of this adapter have flats for the application of a wrench to release it, but mine has only two holes for the insertion of a tommy bar. I have drilled one of the holes deeper so the bar seats better, but it still is a pain to hold the bar in the hole while I hit it with a mallet. If I hit it too far from the adapter, the bar just bends. If I hit it close to the adapter, I get the benefit of the shock but loose mechanical adavantage. I solved this problem, (I hope), with the purchase of a spanner wrench from Best Wood Tools. The chucks and faceplates never lock onto the spindle as tightly as does this adapter, so I don't use a plastic washer with them.

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#22

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I use a ring cut from a sheet of Mylar (PETE). It's from a sheet of plastic drafting "vellum" that was obsoleted by CAD. It's not as soft as milk jugs (HDPE) so vibrations and/or flexing aren't an issue. But it still keeps the faceplate or chuck from locking up on the spindle.

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#23

Re: WD-40 mania

Ed Karch in No.VA

>Wally do you use it for catching them or frying them?

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#24

LIQUID WRENCH vs WD-40 *LINK*

JKJ in East TN

>>I picked up some Gunk Liquid Wrench

>Super Penetrant and it helped out quite a bit

For anyone interested, I looked up LIQUID WRENCH SUPER PENETRANT and WD-40 for a comparison. They both contain (or have contained) the same ingredients, basically propellant, solvent, and light oil.

It's actually more complicated than simple, since the MSDS databases can use different chemical terminology and it takes some digging to figure out what is what. (and I am certainly no chemist) In addition, I understand the makers occasionally change their forumulations without notice so today's product might be different from yesterday's. For example, some databases indicated WD-40 contained trimethl benzene and/or butoxy ethanol. (I found other interesting things as well, for example Valspar Marine Teak Oil was listed as made of 100% mineral oil.)

Sticking to one products database to simplify things (link below) and crossreferencing with other sources to double check, I found this:

--LIQUID WRENCH SUPER PENETRANT

carbon dioxide 2-3%

aliphatic petroleum distillate 89-90%

extracts, petroleum, middle distillate solvent (mineral oil) 8-9%

--WD-40

carbon dioxide 2-3%

aliphatic petroleum distillate (stoddard solvent) 60-70%

Distillates, petroleum, solvent-dewaxed heavy paraffinic (mineral oil) 15-25%

non-hazardous ingredients <10%

--WD-40 11/01/2003

carbon dioxide 2-3%

aliphatic petroleum distillate (stoddard solvent) 45-50%

distillates, petroleum, hydrotreated light (kerosene/mineral spirits) 12-18%

distillates, petroleum, solvent-dewaxed heavy paraffinic (mineral oil) 15-25%

non-hazardous ingredients <10%

I'm certainly not trying to fuel an argument here but as is my nature, in search of the facts. The data above might explain why some people have had success using WD-40 as a penetrating lubricant. The mineral oil content might explain reports of gumminess on drying. (Oil a bowl and don't wipe it off and it will get gummy too.)

I'm first in line to learn something new, so if someone has additional data it would be interesting.

JKJ


Household products database

Re: Faceplate Stuck on the Headstock

#25

Re: WD-40 mania

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>If you're an auto mech or a biker who likes the smell of leather and burnt oil, it would be for frying....

Wally