Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Black Walnut Bowl

Posts

Black Walnut Bowl

#1

Black Walnut Bowl

Spence in Rhode Island

>One for the show. ;) About 5"H and 7"W Walls are about 9/16" throughout. Finished with about 10 coats of walnut oil and waxed. Critiques more than welcome.

Regards

Spence


img

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#2

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

Dave MacLuskie

>Looks wonderful! Very rich. I like the inward sloping rim.

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#3

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

David

>How do you critique THAT? It is just beautiful. I don't know how you'll ever be able to part with it at a show.

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#4

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

RevDoug

>Very nice Spence. I'm loving the shape and the finish. Wood ain't bad either.

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#5

Since you asked...

David

>I take a request for ciritique and comment seriously. It means you want input on what you have posted. My comment is that it seems very well done--fine shape, good finish, and it looks like it may have been manufactured. I feel that a piece made by hand should have the character of something made by hand. I say this from a personal point of view only, of course and is not meant as something derogatory.

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#6

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

James McClure

>Terrific!!!

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#7

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

Carole in VA

>Beautiful work! That is a form that I am particularly partial to. I call them "cuddle bowls" because they are so nice to hold.

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#8

Re: Since you asked...

Carole in VA

>Manufactured? May I ask why? I am asking because I turn a lot of this particular form and they are not easy to get just right.

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#9

Re: Since you asked...

Roger

>I agree,his work is so good it might look manufactured rather than hand made. That tells me he has a great eye and a fine, light touch.A beautiful job all the way around.

Roger

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#10

Steven Antonucci

Best finish I've ever seen on Walnut...I hate you

steve antonucci

>;-)

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#11

Re: Black Walnut Bowl *LINK*

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Spence,

What a great looking bowl. I love these simple forms...in fact when I opened your post I got a good laugh because I just sold a bowl that looks like it came from the same tree : )

Perhaps they are related? Cousins?

Very nice job...I'm going to have to try the walnut oil one of these days. It looks great on yours.

Jennifer : )


The long lost Cousin to your bowl

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#12

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

Barry Turner

>And just how long does it take for 10 coats of walnut oil to dry? It took one coat two weeks to dry on a mahogany bowl I did recently. I haven't had the courage to put on a nother coat...........

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#13

Re: Black Walnut Bowl...Unfortunetly

Spence in Rhode Island

>I've had a small family emergency come up and not able to respond to each of you. :( But all I can say is WOW! I never expected it would be so well recieved. Definetly an ego boost right when I needed it. Will be posting more soon and hope to give you guys the replies that you deserve. Thanks big time!

Spence

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

Keith Tompkins

>Manufactured?! Spence, I would take THAT as a compliment!I believe the goal is to produce something as well as we can....smooth lines, no tearout, clean cuts and good finish. You seem to have achieved that goal. Manufactured....no. Professional.

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#15

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

Spence in Rhode Island

>Thanks Keith. Thats the way I took manufactured to mean. I'm pretty overwhelmed by all the positive comments. Like Carrol said it has to be held for the full impact of the piece. One reason I left the walls on the thick side was to give it a feeling of solidity (?). I really had to force myself to stop and have worried that its too thick but everyone who has held has commented on how great it feels in their hands, so I guess I succeeded in what I was trying to convey with it. LOL Does that make sense?

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#16

Thickness

TDaniel

>Spence, some pieces need to be thicker (heavier) than others. Some people turn everything thin and that is ok; others turn everything thick and that is generally not ok. I agree with you that certain shapes need to be thicker than other shapes. Generally, thicker walls do not work well on heavier woods. Some objects need weight and others do not. An example would be goblets which should be light and thin to work; unless you are doing goblets for a renaissance festival in which case they need to be heavy and thick walled. Another consideration is character which might be turned away if the piece was turned thin; example, a crevice with lots of figure that would become a gaping hole if the vessel were turned thin. The ability to read the wood (not listen to it) is what sets good turners apart from the field. You are doing good....keep at it!

TD

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#17

It says: "Pick me up and hold me."

Jack Savona

>

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#18

Re: Thickness

Spence in Rhode Island

>Thanks TD! For once I listened to that little voice in the back of my head that was telling me to stop right where I was and go to the next step. Once it was parted off and I could hold it in my hands I was pretty sure I'd nailed the feeling(?) I was after. Wish I could pass it around to everyone to see what they'd say. Pic's only go so far.

Re: Black Walnut Bowl

#19

Exactly!!! :)

Spence in Rhode Island

>