Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Posts

Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#1

Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Barry Irby

>Barbara, I have finally acquired a lifetime supply of walnut (4000 BF) only to discover that I am mildly allergic to it. (I think) When I sand it or turn it on the lathe, I get the sniffles and some blood. Not really a nose bleed, just a little blood. When I let some of stay under my watch for an hour or two, I got an inflammation. Sounds like an allergy, Right? I don't know if it is walnut only or just dust, or maybe I am getting more sensitive as I get older.

Anyway, I noticed your posts on your masks. You said you have a North 7700. Is that All I need to know? Is there a size? Are there different types of filters? Which ones should I get? Where do you get them? How long do the filters last? Hours? Days? Months? Can you clean them? Blow the out? How much do they cost? Do you find them hard to breath through? Seems that would be one advantage to a powered unit.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#2

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

alberto

>with all thesupply of walnut in your hands and the fact that you discoverd that you are allergic to it I would highly recomend you invest in a good mask anyhting other than that would not be enough to protect you from the sanding dust you create wich is the worst because it always finds its way into your lungs remember that they can be as small as .005 microns[if you know what I mean by microns] so you need somehting that will filter that type of dust and for your skin protection long sleeve shirt or the likes if we are to enjoy woodturning we should not cut corners in protecting ourselves and be able to enjoy it for a very long time good turnings

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#3

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Carole in VA

>Barry, there is only one solution...send it all to me! :)

Seriously though, if you are allergic, a respirator may solve the breathing problem, but what about the contact dermatitis? Will that get worse with increased exposure as is the case with many allergies? For your sake I hope not.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#4

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others *LINK*

JKJ in East TN

>Barry,

I'm the same way with walnut and have been since working in an industrial woodshop in the late '60's. I recently found out I have similar problems with eastern red cedar, but having not worked it before that may not be a new development. (It is well documented that sensitivity increases with exposure.)

I use both the powered and unpowered respirators. The standard industrial respirators work extremely well and filter very fine particulates with the correct filter.

The link below is to an earlier thread where I included a photos of respirators very much like those I have. I do not use the full face model while turning but use it with a cartridge filter for spraying or working with chemicals. The standard resipirator (without the full face shield) is very comfortable and can be worn under a standard shop face shield. The particulate filters are very light weight and there is zero resistance when breathing. I like the kind that vent the exhalation through a one-way valve on the front. The filters are fairly inexpensive.

I use the powerered respirator (Trend) when making huge clouds of dust when sanding bowls, especially when it is a little warm in the shop since the moving air has a cooling effect.

If it continues to be a problem, ship the walnut to TN and I'll cut it up into pieces, a little at a time. It would be a sacrifice, but one I'd be willing to make to protect your health.

(And yikes, remove the watch around powered equipment!)

JKJ

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives_turning.pl?read=67457


respirator thread

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#5

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Phil Joines Krum, Texas

>You might also want to consider coveralls. There's an interesting thread on the flat side right now.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#6

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

JKJ in East TN

>Oh, I forgot to mention. The industrial respirators have a much higher rating for removal of fine particulates than do the powered respirators marketed to woodturners. These respirators are fairly inexpensive as well, as are the filters. I bought a dozen filters from a local safety products supplier. The big box stores around here carry them as well but the filters are a little higher.

JKJ

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#7

JL

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

JL

>Respirators aside - lets talk about minimizing dust. The DC system is the first line of "defense". Other options - do you wear a turning smock with "tight" knit sleeves? Coveralls are some protection, but how about a Tyvek suit? They make them with elastic sleeves or you could use duct tape and tape the sleeves. Minimize the exposure and you'll minimize the contact dermatitis.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#8

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Anyway, I noticed your posts on your masks. You said you have a North 7700. Is that All I need to know? Is there a size?

Barry, I use a small however I also get a good seal with a med. I know Granger in Richmond carries the North. This time however I bought them on line at http://www.storesonline.com/site/603595/page/369663

Are there different types of filters? Which ones should I get? Where do you get them?

Yes, there are many types of filters. The ones I am buying for turning are the P100 Pancake Filter bought from the same supplier:

http://www.storesonline.com/site/603595/page/369667 There is also a P100 filter cartridge but it has the same specs as the Pancake Filter.

How long do the filters last? Hours? Days? Months? Can you clean them? Blow the out?

The time they last depends upon how much and under what conditions they are used. Here is the site for North. You can get a lot of information from the site or call them.

http://www.northsafety.com/usa/en/bs_home.html?PAGEID=30525&MenuID=10805

Do you find them hard to breath through? Seems that would be one advantage to a powered unit.

No I don't find them at all hard to breath through. After trying on a power unit I can't imagine actually using it. There is so much bulk compared with the North. I wear the facemask year round. The silicon material does not get stiff in the cold. Of course the mask is hotter than no wearing one in the summer and I am sure not as cool as the power units. But for <$30 for the mask and the comfort of no heavy cumbersome bulk plus 0.3 micron 99.97% effectiveness it can't be beat.

I have been very happy with the company from which I bought my filters (above). I had a question about the P100 Pancake Filter which was answered very well and promptly.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#9

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Barry Irby

>Thanks to all of you. I am going to get a face mask/respirator and give it a try. I have some tyvek coveralls and will use them if necessary, but I am hoping I don't have to. I feel like I am girding for battle. Now that I think about it, I have had a persistent cough for some time and I have been turning a lot or walnut. I used to think it was a cold that lasted all winter, but now I am wondering if that is not a symptom of the dust. I do have a DC and a homemade air cleaner. I'm thinking of installing another air cleaner. The DC pulls air out of the shop and dumps it outside. It has clearly made a difference. Thanks again.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#10

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

David

>Barb -

Does the North fit underneath a face shield well? There was a post earlier in this thread relative to the 3M version where that consideration was mentioned.

Thanks -

David B.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#11

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Fog Tanner

>A nose bleed sound more than mildly allergic. I have allergies to Cedar, Oak, and Elm and don't have blood when I turn them. If I don't use a respirator (currently a PowerVisor) I get severe sinus headaches which last for three days. When I turn Walnut, I get cold like symptoms and sometimes the headaches. But, I am also starting to get the same with pine. One reason I am getting the North respirator for when I use the table saw.

I already have a sensitivty to another nontoxic wood dust, Balsa, from prolonged exposure to sanding dust. I found out from my allergist that you can develop a sensitivty to any wood dust, given enough time and dust. I also have a large cyclone with a dust hood that is right up against my lathe. This catches a large portion of the dust, and the powered respirator the rest. I can turn without the powered respirator up to a point, but not the dust collector. Basiclly when my lathe is running, so is the dust collector. I am in the process of making a pickup for the front of the lathe, much like the one in Raffan's book. I talked with Raffan during a hands on workshop and he said that after the three week tours he makes here teaching, he can't go in his shop for two months due to the dust problems. At home he wears and Airstream.

In you think you are having problems with allergies, you might also think of changing pillows. I read an article recently about the various fungi that grow in foam pillows. I am also allergic to dust mites, and as a result I have a covering for my pillow. But, according to the article that is not enough if you have sinus problems. When you are breathing you are inhaling the fungi and it can take up residence in your sinus system. From the studies, the fungi will grow freely in the typical foam pillows, but not in feather pillows. I have found that the sinus headaches I get are on the same side of my head that is against the pillow, never on the other side. And less if I sleep with my face away from the pillow. My wife is looking for some feather pillows to replace the foam wonders. And if you are allergic to feathers, there are some foam pillows which are resistant to the growth.

After all my bouts with sinus/allergy problems, I believe that the wood dust can sensize your sinus to the point that almost any wood dust can cause problems. And, it will no longer be an option of wearing a respirator or using a dust collector when only turning certain woods - it will just become part of all your woodworking activity. The one colsoling thought about the problems with advancing age, is we have lived long enough to get them...........

Fog

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Keith Tompkins

>Barry, have you noticed headaches...especially the day after turning walnut? So far, my only symptom.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#13

Yes It Does.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#14

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Barry Turner

>What you describe sounds more like skin and respiratory irritation rather than an all-out allergy. With an allergy, your reaction would probably be much worse. With repeated exposures, your reactions may intensify. I have a similar problem with Cocobolo, but I don't believe it's a real allergy.

Nevertheless, take steps to minimize your exposure to the Walnut. A good dust collection system and powered air mask will help. Wear a good turing smock........with long sleeves. The reason you have a reaction under your watch is this. Walnut dust collects under your watch. You also sweat under your watch, which intensifies the reaction. Take the watch off when you turn.......... who cares about the time when you are turning anyway?

Be on the look out for more severe symptoms, hives, shortness of breath, etc. If this happens get out of the shop and get to the doctor or ER pronto.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#15

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Barry Irby

>No, No headaches. I get headaches so seldom I have aspirin that are out of date. My kids take Tylenol like candy, but I almost never get one. My Dad would have said you have to have something in there for it to hurt. My hypochondria is acting up and I may be getting a headache now.

I do get a sort of nonproductive persistent cough. My hands ache and the joints in my fingers are slightly swollen. I can't curl my fingers around and touch my "pads". This tends to come and go, but I have thought it was just working with my hands, not necessarily the type of wood. Maybe I should take a break from the walnut for a week or two and see if situation improves when I work with other wood. There is some family history of arthritis.

I have been wondering about the half face mask. It would not keep dust out of you eyes. Also, would dust getting under the rubber be a source of contact dermatitis?

I have really been sort of Bah! Hum Bug! about the dangers of wood dust. I think I will be improving the air cleaners and DC in my shop.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#16

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Barry Irby

>Thanks for your comments. Could you clear up a couple of things? Does Raffin mean that he is so exposed to dust will touring that he is ill for two months and can't go in the shop? Or is that he gets away and gets better and hates to go into the shop and make himself sick again?

Could you explain your dust hood setup on the lathe? I have done nothing with my lathe. My other tools have DC, but not the lathe. I have a six inch port blanked off, waiting for inspiration. Thinking of splitting it into two fours and putting one behind the lathe and one on the floor to the left of where I stand. I have drawers under the lathe and if they were not there I think I would use some sort of long horizontal slot between me and the lathe. The problem is that spray of chips goes everywhere. OTOH, it's not the chip that are killing me, its is the stuff I can't see. I don't have a cyclone, but have a 1300 cfm(?) Delta unit.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#17

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>If the dust gets under the mask, you don't have a good fit.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#18

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

Barry Irby

>Thanks, I think you are right. I know you are about the watch. I let walnut sit under there on a hot day way too long. Not only did I not know what time it was, I was not even aware I had a wad of crap under my watch. A good indication I was intense on my turning.

It took a surprisingly long time for the redness to clear up.

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#19

Walnut Dust

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>It is not unusual for me to have one or more small cuts on my hands. I have found over the years of sawing walnut that any wound that gets walnut dust in it will take twice as long to heal. Usually a red knot forms before healing. Walnut is just naturally irritating.

Imagine how it treats your lungs. :-(

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others

#20

Re: Questions for Barbara Gill & others *LINK*

Fog Tanner

>Over the years the dust has taken a toll on Raffan's body, to the point that the dust he encounters in his teaching and demos leave him unable to get around any in his shop. He has a dust collector and uses an Airstream, but they don't appear to help.

The idea for dust collector hood I have for my lathe was taken from a slide show that Raffan had during a demo here. His is basicly a box with the right end removable. It had a couple of pieces of PVC for pickups going to his Delta system. He also had a wye with a picup on the front side of the lathe for sanding.

At a woodworking show I picked up a rectangular funnel that was marketed as a dust pickup for radial arm saw. When I saw it, I thought I could build a box around it for my lathe. The first go around was cardboard and duct tape to check the size and get the angles right. My dust collection ducting dictated that the funnel be on the left side and at an angle, so I had to find that angle. Once I had a working cardboard model, I made one out of 3/4" and 1/2" plywood. The top doubles as a shelf for setting my chuck key, rulers, pencils, and sandpaper. It is sturdy enough to fasten my Moffet light to, which worked great. This assembly sets on a table behind my lathe, which is also where I keep my tools. I have several spots that have blind nuts under the table so I can bolt the hood down for doing bowls or boxes, but I have found that it doesn't need to be bolted to the table, so I just move it where I need it and it stays put. The one change I am going to make, is cut and hinge part of the right side. When I swing a bowl gouge around on some bowls, it hits the side. That was the reason that Raffan made his right side removable.

The cyclone provides enough airflow that I can see the stream of dust comming off the tool and going straight back into the funnel (which is black plastic). If you don't want to go to the trouble to build a plywood box, you can always use Russ's method, a cardboard box. Just find a box that suits what you are doing and hook you hose up to it. Of course you need some sort of stand for it to sit on, but it works. I tried that before my current dust hood.

Another place of interest is the link below. Lots of good information.


http://billpentz.com//woodworking/cyclone/index.cfm