Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

I must be nuts!

Posts

I must be nuts!

#1

I must be nuts!

Carole in VA

>The article in Woodturning Design on making a winged vessel just kept nagging at me, so today I decided to try it. This is without a doubt the scariest thing I have attempted yet during my 9 months on the lathe! I have been nibbling away at it and finally have the bottom round and the chuck tenon in place. Now comes the really scary part...working up towards the wing and it's underside then reversing and trying to do the upper surface. This may take me a week to do at the rate I am going! I am scared to crank the lathe over 500 rpms, which doesn't make for a very smooth cut or very fast progress! I think Ed Karch was right when he said I would try anything...maybe I need to quit while I am ahead!

Re: I must be nuts!

#2

When in doubt, don't!

Clem Wixted

>

Re: I must be nuts!

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: I must be nuts!

Keith Tompkins

>HI Carole, the winged vessels are intimidating, but not too hard to make. Just don't poke a finger where it doesn't belong! Raising the speed up helps, and bringing the wings to final thickness must be done in stages, as they will become very flexibe. Don't try to go back and touch up a wingtip.....I had been making these for several years before I even knew there was such a thing as the AAW.

Re: I must be nuts!

#4

Re: I must be nuts!

David

>I'm gonna be nuts soon. That project (in the magazine) looked waaay to fun to pass on. the winged vase is in the on deck circle, but hasn't picked up a bat yet.

Re: I must be nuts!

#5

Re: I must be nuts!

kevinT in T Bay

>Carol. just try turning it at a faster rate. I found the slower I turned the more difficult it was. As long as you watch the ghost, you'll be fine. KevinT


img

Re: I must be nuts!

#6

Re: When in doubt, don't!

Carole in VA

>If I don't push my horizons a little, I'll just be stuck doing the same old thing and I don't want that.It is safety front right now: AirShield is in place, I'm trying not to stand in the line of fire (which is hard sometimes), I'm periodically checking the tailstock pressure, I'm trying to constantly be aware of where all my digits are, and speed is being increased ever so slowly as the thing comes into shape. Now I have uncovered a big hidden knot that that has required some re-design at best and at worst, might require the thing to be tossed. The Airshield is giving me a headache, so I will let it rest a bit.

Re: I must be nuts!

#7

I must be nuts!

Ed Moore

>Carole, can we get back to you on that?

Watching Jimmy Clewes turn his (winged) Chinese box at 3000 - 3300 RPM at the OVWG Symposium was a little surreal. He was using a Powermatic 3520B and I knew it wasn't really going to take off, but the sound was not reassuring that it wouldn't. I think he took it down to 1/8 - 5/32".

Ed

Burnt Chimney, VA

Re: I must be nuts!

#8

Doubt and Respect are different.

Clem Wixted

>Hi Carole,

If you are fearful of doing something, the safe thing to do is DON'T do it.

If you are doing it for the first time, and know how it is to be done and know that you will be able to do it better with experience, then proceed - with caution. You have said that you know WHAT to do and are exercising caution and respecting safety concerns, then you have concern and not doubt. A healthy respect for safety issues is smart.

Safety first is always the best way.

I have not done some things because of safety concerns and I have always been justified in that decision. When my safety concern has been covered, I can then proceed.

You have your head on straight.

Clem

Re: I must be nuts!

#9

Re: I must be nuts!

Lan Brady

>Carole,

WE need to always be slightly afraid of the lathe monster! Maybe start with a smaller twig or limb and build the confidence in the sound of a fast running lathe.

My lathe has never been run over 1500 rpms on spindles. I am working my way up the step ladder.

good luck, Lan

Re: I must be nuts!

#10

Progress

Carole in VA

>Ed,

This is how far I have gotten. I screwed up the shape a little when I found that I couldn't get in under the wing with as high a shoulder as I originally started with. I am also having prolems getting a smooth cut on the inside half of top surface of the wing. I think it is flexing. Have not begun the hollowing yet. Even if this turns out to be firewood, it has been a great learning experience so far. Everyone should give it a shot!


img

Re: I must be nuts!

#11

Progress 2 

Carole in VA

>


img

Re: I must be nuts!

#12

Re: Progress 2

John Lucas

>Caarol Your doing good. Keith was right, turn the rpm's up and be really light on the bevel. I like to call it gliding the bevel. If you push the bevel of the tool into the wood you do 2 things. You flex the wood which makes it hard to turn thin. You also make the tool want to drop into the air gap. Higher rpm reduces the time the tool has to drop into that gap and this also lets you relax your hold on the tool so you can be lighter on the bevel. Listen to it. The rapping noise will be loud if you push hard. the lighter you get the less noise it makes.

I test this by pulling the tool. I put the bevel on the wood without the tip cutting and pull the tool out toward the tool rest. This lets me get a feel for where the wood it(on some vessels it completely dissapears) and also how light to push the tool into the wood.

If you want to practice. Take a 3" by 8" piece of 3/4" lumber and put it between centers on the lathe so the wide side is facing the headstock. Crank up the RPM and see if you can turn it. Try to see how thin you can go. Like keith said thin out just the first inch and then try to go another inch. This will teach you to turn winged vessels and if it blows up it probably won't hurt you.

Re: I must be nuts!

#13

Re: Progress 2

Carole in VA

>John, when I went back to it, I had figured I needed to turn the speed up some more. Went to 1500 and I think that did the trick. I was chicken to go any higher. If it's not just right there won't be anything I can do about it because I have to go out tonight and won't get back to it until tomorrow afternoon. The wing will have moved too much by then (despite being bagged with chips) to touch it. It will be hollowing and sanding from here on out. :)

Re: I must be nuts!

#14

Re: I must be nuts!

Ed Karch in No.VA

>Yea Carol. As soon as you do 100 you will be the expert for this form.

Re: I must be nuts!

#15

Re: Progress 2

Ed Moore

>Carole,

I'm glad that you posted the picture. I had not realized that you are turning an end-grain vessel. I would be very careful and I would not use excessive speed. Nor would I try for extremely thin. Are you using a spindle gouge to shape the wing?

John's remark about "gliding the bevel" is an excellent way to describe the process. And on a natural-edged bowl I would use the push-pull cut with a bowl gouge. But the orientation is different on your piece, so I would try for a clean cut with a spindle gouge rolled over so that the bottom of the tool is against the surface and the handle is dropped some. Pressure against the surface while cutting could break off a piece since it is end-grain. So, as John said, "glide the bevel" through the cut. If you roll the tool over and expose too much of the edge you will get a nasty catch. Use just the tip of the spindle gouge.

Ed

Re: I must be nuts!

#16

Re: I must be nuts!

The Wood Spinner / Bill Hale

>Carol

Turn up the speed and make fine cuts. Light touch and easy grip. Don't flex the wood with pressure. RELAX and enjoy the rush.

It is only by pushing ones self that we learn and excell.

When you turn a large piece that sounds like an airplane propeller, now that is a rush big time.

Just be easy with the tool and don't pust.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: I must be nuts!

#17

Dick Hines

Re: I must be nuts!

Dick Hines

>Life is no fun if you don't play with a little fire once in a while.Guess that is why I bought the bike.

Re: I must be nuts!

#18

Brad Vietje

Re: Progress 2

Brad Vietje

>Great progress so far, Carole.

But, you're not out of the woods yet ! I have found that the sanding is more dangerous than the turning, at least so far as wacking my fingers goes. I use cloth backed Klingspore abrasives, and bend them over to form a small "loop", and carefully apply this to the spinning wings with very light pressure, and constant movement. I have also had good success by rolling up a 4" wide piece of abrasive to form a 3/4" to 1" diameter tube, sort of like those fancy pirouette cookies. You'll want to keep the exposed end of the sheet facing away from the direction of spin so it won't catch on any irregularities (that is, facing down, if that's the direction the wood is going). It is very easy to round over the leading edge of the "wings" as they flash by, and you'll have to experiment to see what works for you.

The attached photo is my first crazy winged bowl in Cherry burl -- about 2" on one side, and about 5" on the other. You can see I didn't get a very even thickness !

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT


img

Re: I must be nuts!

#19

Re: I must be nuts!

Dan in the NW

>I've watched Martin Pidgen turned a winged bowl on two occassions. In Provo he was having problems with his glasses but wanted the demo to go on. There were a few moments during the demo that I had to will my butt cheeks to relax.

Here are a couple of pictures of Martin and his winged bowl. He stressed that he ALWAYS wears a glove with a wide cuff when turning a winged bowl. He saws the cuff is a good warning device that tells you when to move the other direction. :)


img

Re: I must be nuts!

#20

Re: I must be nuts!

jeff jilg

>That's interesting that he is more interested in protecting his hand than his face. Maybe a faceshield might be a good investment for him.

Re: I must be nuts!

#21

Re: I must be nuts!

Carole in VA

>Each to his or her own I suppose. Wearing gloves, especially wide cuffed ones on the lathe would really make me nervous. Too easy for it, and my hand, to get snatched into the spin. I would rather get a slash or a knuckle buster than have my whole hand grabbed and pulled in by a glove. I also wear a face shield!

Re: I must be nuts!

#22

Re: I must be nuts!

Dan in the NW

>I don't want to start a big debate over safety devices. I understand your point, however, I'm not sure I have enough experience to tell Martin how to turn or what safety devices to use. It would take me a few life times to equal his experience. I have never seen him make light of safety, in fact just the opposite, he stresses safety. His demonstrations are well worth your time.

Dan

Re: I must be nuts!

#23

Re: I must be nuts!

Carole in VA

>Wouldn't dream of telling him how to do his job and would love to have the opportunity to see him demo (or any other pro turner for that matter) but the bulky-cuffed glove thing violates MY sense of safety. Maybe if I had a lot more experience under my belt, I wouldn't feel that way. As I said, each to his or her own.