Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Bowl end grain question

Posts

Bowl end grain question

#1

Bowl end grain question

David

>Not sure if I will ask this correctly or not, but I'll try. I'm having trouble with end grain, but not all of the end grain.

Let's break it grain into three sections as the bowl is spinning toward me. Section 1 - first contact area of end grain on any given revolution, Section 2 - "dead on" the end grain, Section 3 - trailing edge of the end grain. My problem is with section 3.

I've gotten good enough to avoid tearout in section 3 (at least most of the time), but it is never smooth. I haven't been able to get it smooth the point where the figuring blends with the rest of the piece. I end up with a more or less smooth area, but it almost looks like a patch on the wood - you can't detect the figuring in there. On different pieces I've experimented with sanding it to death on the lathe, (starting as low as 60 and working my way up to 600), I've tried different lahte speeds, I've tried sanding it to death off the lathe. I've tried Circular patterns, with grain, against grain, perpendicular to direction of the lathe to avoid scoring, etc. I can make section 3 feel smooth, but have not been able to get it to where the figuring emerges and blends with the rest of the piece.

I'll tell you one thing - I can make the rest of the piece baby-butt smooth.

Here's what I have at my disposal today:

- non-reversable lathe

- lots of sandpaper

- a reasonable amount of patience

Can you offer suggestions (that don't involve huge capital investments)? I don't mind sanding, but I'm spending forever doing it and not getting where I want to be. If I can defeat this problem, I'll finally be able to complete a bowl without a "yeah, but" attached to it.

Thanks for any advice -

David B.

Re: Bowl end grain question

#2

Re: Bowl end grain question *LINK*

Chas

>Sounds like you are still getting some 'pulling' if not actual tearing of the structure.

What wood are we talking about?

Have you tried treating the bowl with cellulose sanding sealer "before" your final cut?

Do you sharpen your gouge immediatly before the last cut?


My Turnings Gallery

Re: Bowl end grain question

#3

Re: Bowl end grain question

David

>Most recently, I've been working with White Birch and Boxwood Elder. I haven't consciously re-sharpened immediatey before the final pass, but that would probably be a good idea. I haven't tried putting anything (sealer or otherwise) on the wood - I'm a bit concerned about sanding that stuff into the air.

Haven't looked at the link you put in yet - thanks for your comments and adding in the link!

David B.

Re: Bowl end grain question

#4

JL

Re: Bowl end grain question

JL

>Shear scraping/cutting? Have you tried that?

Re: Bowl end grain question

#5

Re: Bowl end grain question

David

>Yes - it definitely helped make it smoother. I'm still very much in "just barely learning" to use the skew, so that might be part of it, but even after the skew, I'm still experiencing the "patch" thing I described in the first post.

Re: Bowl end grain question

#6

Re: Bowl end grain question

Rick Allen

>Hi David

You can use any of a number of things to stiffen the edngrain for the last few passes.

Water, oil, wax, WD-40 (not the spray but the liquid), epoxy, sake, apple juice, white grape juice, rubbing alcohol, suntan lotion, K-Y jelly, goats milk, beer, hair spray, sanding sealer, whatever finish you will be using.

The whole idea is to get a clean cut. To do that on section 3 with soft woods like boxelder you need to provide support to the fibers being cut. Anything that will fit between the fibers will give you enough support to resolve a clean cut.

Please note that quite often the tearout or bruising can be 1/4" deep. So the last pass may be to late to eliminate this sort of endgrain problem.

Good Luck

Richard

BTW it's Boxelder

Re: Bowl end grain question

#7

Re: Bowl end grain question

David

>Got it - thanks for the help. So, the idea is during the final stages with the tool (when I'm approaching final pass), put some on the affected area section 3, give it a couple of minutes to get in there, then, with the freshly ultra-sharp skew, finish it off.

David B.

Re: Bowl end grain question

#8

Re: Bowl end grain question

George Van in WI

>David, I would use a bowl gouge or a HSS forged spindle gouge (preferred) rather than a skew. Use the bowl gouge in a shear scraping approach, the forged gouge on edge gives you that angle automatically.

Good Luck, George

Re: Bowl end grain question

#9

Re: Bowl end grain question

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>David, I think that the most important way to solve your problem hasn't been mentioned. In order to avoid heavy end-grain tearout, you must cut with the grain. Think of planing a board in the wrong direction...you'll get torn grain. If you're working on an end-grin piece, with the grain running parallel to the lathe bed, cut from large diameter to small. The reverse is true if the piece is face grain. Cut with a sharp gouge. You'll still get a little tearout. Shear scrape it with the grain, after applying some oil. You should be able to completely remove the damaged area. Now you can eliminate the heavy sandpaper grits.

Wally

Re: Bowl end grain question

#10

Re: Bowl end grain question

David

>Wally -

Not sure I'm understanding you correctly. If I've got a typical bowl blank (grain perpendicular to the lathe), and I'm shaping the outside (before flipping it and hollowing out the middle), are you saying I should work from the (eventually) rounded bottom of the bowl toward the chuck?

Re: Bowl end grain question

#11

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Bowl end grain question

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>David, your question might be answered by referring to my posting: Cellulose Sanding Sealer and End grain tearout. David Nittman uses the same method for his large platters just to counteract tearout within a few millimetres.

Regards Peter.

Re: Bowl end grain question

#12

Re: Bowl end grain question

DWFII

>REcently, I've been working on this same problem myself. I just finished a bowl made from poplar ot willow or something that is relatively soft (it was given to me as maple but I don't think so).

What I did with considerable sucess was apply a 30% solution of pure tung oil and mineral oil. Let it sit for a hour or two and then shear scrape...towards the bottom of the inside, towards the rim on the outside.

Worked real good. Maybe that will help a little.

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: Bowl end grain question

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bowl end grain question

Keith Tompkins

>David, sharpening before the final cut is definitely a good idea, otherwise, you are finishing up with the tool in its dullest state. It will help.

Re: Bowl end grain question

#14

Re: Bowl end grain question

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Yes

Re: Bowl end grain question

#15

Re: Bowl end grain question

JKJ in East TN

>You might do a search here for a lot of discussion (a couple of months ago?) on grain tearout on the sides of bowls. I personally use wax, water, sander sealer, shear cuts, and often, a cabinet scraper (with no tool rest).

JKJ

Re: Bowl end grain question

#16

Re: Bowl end grain question

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>I just tried the cabinet scraper trick this week after seeing it demonstrated during Bruce Hoover's Sanding Techniques session at Totally Turning. It worked great for me - one of the smoothest pre-sanding surfaces I've been able to get so far.

Re: Bowl end grain question

#17

Re: Bowl end grain question

JKJ in East TN

>>cabinet scraper trick... one of the smoothest

>pre-sanding surfaces I've been able to get so far.

I agree. As an experiment I made a goblet from eastern red cedar, notorious for tearing grain, and smoothed entirely with cabinet scrapers and no sandpaper, inside and out, and the surface was excellent. I recently got a new set of small scrapers at Highland Hardware that included small ovals for hard to reach places. I want to grind some special-purpose profiles to try things like reaching inside the lip of a closed form.

JKJ