Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Pentacryl / PEG

Posts

Pentacryl / PEG

#1

Pentacryl / PEG

Jeff

>I have a green piece of wood that I want to turn. I don't have the patience to wait for it to dry. Should I use Pentacryl or PEG to stabilize it? What about a finish? I have heard that if you use the wrong one the stabilizer can leach out over time.

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

#3

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

John Lucas

>You didn't say what you want to turn. Some things simply can't be turned from green wood without serious problems. Let us know and we'll try to help.

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

#4

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

Rick Allen

>Neither of those products will reduce the length of time it takes for the wood to dry.

The quickest and most efective way to dry a turning is to use the time proven methods that woodturners have used for decades.

The only way I am aware of that can render green wood dry quickly is the use of a microwave. Of course different timbers react differently.

There is an interesting article in the Fall 2005 issue of American Woodturner starting on page 46. The article discribes one mans effort at making a dry and stable bowl from green wood in 24.

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

#5

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

John Lucas

>Rick I read the article. I thought that it was a lot of work considering that a thin bowl will dry by itself in about 48 hours.

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

#6

Steven Antonucci

my two cents on pentacryl

steve antonucci

>I have used Pentacryl in the past, and I stopped because:

1.) It stinks like mad...

2.) It's slimy and never dries...

3.) and since it never dries, it stinks like mad...

I recently "returned" some of my older work that wasn't up to my current standards. I had one piece that the second I cut into it, the smell hit me. It had been on the shelf for 5+ years. If you want to make bowls that smell bad, pentacryl will do that.

Steve

P.S. I am sold on Dave Smith's alcohol regimen.

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

#7

Ditto on pentacryl stink!

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

#8

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>Jeff, my experience with PEG is that of total frustration. Not only does the tub/barrel/storage thing take up valuable room for a long period the finish is terrible. All the items I ever turned after the PEG dunking resulted in a very matt finish. They always retained a feeling of tackiness as if they had never dried out.

The thin turning and natural drying is by far the best method in my experience.

Regards Peter.

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

#9

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

Jeff

>I'm turning Madrone Lace burl

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

#10

Re: Alcohol

Jeff

>I think I'm going to try the alcohol method. It seems by far the best I've ever heard. And only having to wait a week, I just hope I can wait that long!!!

Re: Pentacryl / PEG

#11

Madrone Lace burl. Yikes!

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Madrona is the only wood that has caused me problems using the alcohol method. It appears that you need to soak the roughed out bowl more than a day. Also, make sure the alcohol concentration is high. I don't have enough data to determine an absolute minimum soaking time. Also don't leave the walls too thick.

I do know that an 8" madrona bowl with 1" walls soaked 24 hours in about 30% alcohol solution was not a good idea. The bowl split across the bottom in 5 or more places in the first 8 hours of drying. Subsequent bowls with 3/4" walls soaked 2 days in about 80% alcohol solution dried with little distortion or cracking.

Dave Smith

Alcohol is better than char boiled in Longview, WA.