Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Bad Experience

Posts

Bad Experience

#1

Bad Experience

Sean Troy

>Hey all, I was wondering if anyone else has had a bad art fair experience. I was attending the Sedona Arts Festival last weekend and had a booth for my woodturnings. Everything was going very well on saturday and when I returned Sunday morning to open my booth, everything in the booth was soaked with water. Bowls were filled and finishes were ruined on hollow forms. I notified the directors of the festival right away and was told the lawn sprinkler in my booth came on during the night. Only in my booth did this happen. this festival is held on a football field so you know the amount of water these sprinkler heads can put out. The directors took responsability right away and gave me all the insurance info. The director even went as far as to get me a claim number. I thought that was great help. Monday morning I contacted the insurance company and was promptly told, TUFF, thats your problem. You signed away your rights when you signed up for the Festival. If you don't like it, sue us. In my book, this has been a bad experience. Please, if your going to participate in art fairs, festivals, shows etc... make sure you have your own coverage

Re: Bad Experience

#2

Re: Bad Experience

David

>Sean -

I have never had an experience with that level of loss for something I was trying to sell. I'm very sorry this happened. Hopefully you can save some pieces and recover, but what an awful blow.

Re: Bad Experience

#3

Re: Bad Experience

John Lucas

>Oh man that sucks. I'm not so sure you signed away your rights but like you say you would have to hire a lawyer and sue to be able to win and who can afford that.

What about theft after hours. Most places have guards but I assume your personal coverage would have to cover any losses. The guards are there to hopefully scare everyone honest.

Re: Bad Experience

#4

Dick Hines

Re: Bad Experience

Dick Hines

>Sean, sorry to hear about your trouble. When we do shows that are more than one day we always put our things back in the tubs that we take to the shows. I don't care what the weather man said that morning. If we have not parked to far away from the booth we will take the pieces home and bring them back in the morniong.

Of cource what happened to you was a freak thing. I bet everyone who does shows will check for sprinkler heads from now on, I know I will.

Re: Bad Experience

#5

Not so fast

CapeMayMike

>Sean,

That's really bad news. Based upon my experience in my former life I'd recommend going after them full bore............I bet they settle for an amount that at least approaches your loss. Don't just roll over and offer your throat, that's what they're hoping for and the purpose of their reply to you. Take them up on their offer and file or at least contact an attorney in the area where the claim needs to be filed and threaten them and then see what happens. They're playing their game, play it with them. Also, try and document comments, etc. made by the show people ie: sprinklers, "our fault", "insurance claim number"....so and so forth.

Re: Bad Experience

#6

Re: Not so fast

Sean Troy

>That's my plan. Thanks, Sean

Re: Bad Experience

#7

Re: Not so fast

Molly Winton

>I'm glad to hear you're going to pursue this. What a shame we have to play these games, but sadly that is the state of our insurance/litigation system. Good luck in your efforts, and let us know how it resolves.

Re: Bad Experience

#8

Re: Not so fast

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Sean,

First get a copy of the document you signed in connection with the fair, then see an attorney in your area and ask about "bad faith" claims against insurers. Do not run off half cocked and try to do this yourself; with all due respect, you're just as likely to make a mistake and lose your claim over a "technicality" you know nothing about.

Mark

Re: Bad Experience

#9

Re: Not so fast

JimQ

>Make up a list of every piece that waqs damaged with it's selling price. Take pictures of each piece. Send a set to the Festival with a bill for the full amount for damages due to their neglect. If you have an attorney, or a friend who is one, mark the bottom cc: Name, Esq. Usually they will come back with an offer to settle. Also in the letter put the name of the person you dealt with the second day with a summary of their comments. If they settle for the full amount, offer them the pieces, they will probably refuse, but don't try any repairs until you get a response. If they make a partial settlement, don't offer.

JimQ

Re: Bad Experience

#10

Re: Not so fast

Sean Troy

>Your right, "technicality" is my middle name sometimes.

Re: Bad Experience

#11

Re: Bad Experience

Kevin Turner

>I,ve seen some football fields, They are huge..More than one sprinkler..... Or did you have some competition there? I would expect that they did not turn off "all" the sprinklers,therefore they were neglagiable.( even if you signed, they did not hold up to their end of the deal.) Why should you have to use your own coverage..Your rates will go up. No one likes Bad P.R. concerning thier event...A news article???? Play their game, but then add in all of your expenses you occur along with the "No sale sunday".P.S. were where the security guards.? or the urgant call to notify you that the display was water logged ( shortly after it happened). Sad to hear Sean. good luck in your new hobby....The justice system..NSF (not So Funny)

Re: Bad Experience

#12

Re: Bad Experience

Duane C.Leach

>Sean...Sorry to hear of your loss. It realy hurts in the heart when you loose your work that way.

My bad experence was at a show in Tampa Fla. A storm came up about mid day with wind and rain. It wiped out 6 or 7 booths including mine. The management expected all of us to pick up clean up and go on as if nothing had happened. We picked up packed up and left town. When I got home I made an inventory of all damaged pieces and filed it with my insurance co. The insurance co was going to pay for my loss but they wanted me to ship the damaged pieces to them. When I asked what they were going to do with them, they replyed they would sell them to recoop their loss. My reply. If you want to look at the damaged pieces to see if I am lying or not thats fine. But if you are going to sell them I can't let you do that. My name is on the bottom of each piece. And I don't want damaged art work sold with my name on them. In the end they paid for my loss but I had to distroy all the pieces that were damaged. That was real hard to do.

Insurance! don't leave home without it.

Duane Leach

Re: Bad Experience

#13

Re: Bad Experience

Jill

>"You signed away your rights when you signed up for the Festival. If you don't like it, sue us. In my book, this has been a bad experience. Please, if your going to participate in art fairs, festivals, shows etc... make sure you have your own coverage "

Hi Sean,

If you signed your rights away (I doubt you did) it will clearly state so in the contract (if you signed such). The arguement I would offer is this: If the contract doesn not stay clearly that "the festival" is NOT responsible for loss/damage to art then you have a very clear case to win and can do this on your own without an attorney. The judge will help you out by reading the contract. Another arguement might be that this is not a usual occurance of loss; ex: theft, damage by customer etc... The "festival" should have taken dilagence in making sure that the sprinkler system was OFF; this was NOT your responsibilty. As others suggested also: Write an article in the local newspaper. If all else I believe you can take a lien against the organization (if they own real property).

Good Luck,

Jill

Re: Bad Experience

#14

Re: Bad Experience

Sean Troy

>Thanks for all your help to all. I'll keep you all posted on the outcome. Sean