Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

OT: Open house at my son's school...

Posts

OT: Open house at my son's school...

#1

Steven Antonucci

OT: Open house at my son's school...

steve antonucci

>I went to my son's open house last night (K through 4th) and I noticed something that I found very disturbing. Not meaning to sound sexist, but the entire teaching staff was female! The only male teacher happened to be brand new, and the son of one of the current teachers, or I'm very sure that he wouldn't have gotten the job. Both of the administrators (Principal and Superintendent) are men, and the music teacher was also a man, but every other member of the staff (office workers, art, gym...) was a female. (except the IT guy...)

I guess I was not aware that teaching was so unpopular among men? My schools were always ~50/50 mix, but I am 39. Has teaching changed that much since I left school?

At the risk of sounding sexist, I wonder if it is because male administrators do not want other men around "challenging" their alpha male status? Or can it be that men just don't want to teach? In a school with probably 35 "regular classroom teachers", there has to be something statistically wrong with one male teacher.

For those of you with younger children, do you see the same disparity?

Steve

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#2

Re: OT: Even more off topic response

David

>Steve -

I'm going to take a dive here and get flamed out. I truthfully do not believe I'm saying anything sexist here, but I'm sure it is controversial. So, without further ado, here is my giant rant.

I can't really say I've noticed anything significant for my kids yet, but I'm worried about my son. I've noticed the growth of a rather overt female-centric view over the past several years on television, organized sports, and various classrooms. Before we decide I'm over the proverbial top, here's what I mean.

- television advertisements have the growing trend to have (for example) a sophisticated-looking woman hawking the cars on their intellectual benefits (mileage, durability, convenience). Guys wear flannel shirts and hawk the power. If a male and female are shown together in the ad (pic whatever product you like), take a look and see who is making observations and who is standing quietly behind her listening to the wisdom. If you see an ad on financial planning, chances are the person extolling the virtues of retirement will be a woman.

- Male characters in sitcoms (for example again) are almost nothing short of morons, compared to their female counterparts.

- It seems to be very possible to find sports teams for kids that are mixed or female only. Very difficult to find a boys' league unless you are talking high school sports.

- There are many educational opportunities that are exclusive to women. Simple example. Take a look at your community's newsletter for the evening classes/sessions available on computer use, financial planning, swimming, reading, exercise - you name it, there will be a "women's only" section, and it will be a big section.

Now, I don't really think I'm saying anything sexist here, I'm sure I will be corrected if I am, but what I'm afraid of is what message are we (societally) going to send to my son? Are we telling him, sorry, special eductaional opportunities are only available to women, you're on your own? Are we telling him that women need to have sports teams that are women only because it helps their development, but boys, you don't need that, you're on your own? Are we telling him that it's ok to be a bonehead husband because his wife will guide him through retirement planning?

I'm not the least bit concerned for my daughter, because it looks like there will be a world of opportunities catered to her. She's smart, she'll be fine. I worry about my son. He's an infant, I'm guessing he'll have decent smarts, but I don't think he'll have the opportunities that his sister will in fifteen years, and I think he'll be given the repeated message that boys are not equally intelligent, capable, or as important as girls. Aka, the pendulum has maybe swung a bit hard in the other direction.

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#3

Steven Antonucci

I purposely avoided some of the things you mention

steve antonucci

>I won't flame you, since I largely agree. I don't mind you adding color to the argument, since you appear to be providing your perception based upon evidence that exists. I do not personally mind some of the stereotypes in the media, since I believe that children's self image is largely governed by home life and real experiences vs. the tube.

Assuming that children are not "athletic", where is the positive male role model in the school systems? Obviously, the majority of the responsibility is bourne by the fathers, but to have no representation in our classrooms seems like a recipe for disaster. If my son decides that team sports are not his thing (my guess), can women teachers provide a male perspective to young adolescents?

Steve

Addy Protocol: Grew up in a single mother(seperated) household from the age of 1, grandfather died at 12.

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#4

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

Eric

>My children's school is much the same as you describe. I think that most of what you both say is quite true and is leading to the emasculation of America. It is not politically correct to be an "old school" man like many of our fathers, which is sad. If you want to study the educational effects of increased female teachers in more depth there was a best selling book out about 1-2 years ago. I have the book at home, but cannot remember the name, it was quite good. I think it was something like "Conspiracy against our boys". Hope this helps!

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#5

sharon in topanga

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

sharon in topanga

>I cannot speak to the ratio of male to female teachers in the schools today, especially the lower grades. My offspring are grown and grandson is too young to attend school yet. However, when my kids were in school, teachers were leaving the profession because they could earn more in the 'real' world. And they happened to be male. I think teaching is now being seen as more of a female occupation, particularly in elementary school. That is unfortunate, because boys growing up need nurturing role models, just as girls do.

One of my daughters is a high school physics teacher, so is providing a different kind of role model for girls. Among her role models when growing up was my sister, the engineer, and me, the computer programmer. When the girls were growing up, I had to fight grandma's influence that girls should not play sports, play certain musical instruments, play with cars, etc. I hope nobody is telling boys (or girls) that junk today!

When I was growing up, there were no sports leagues for girls, and they were not allowed to play in the boys' leagues. So I could not play Little League even though I could outplay the boys (pre-teen years). My daughters played soccer on girls' teams and mixed teams. There were boys' teams also. This seems like a fair opportunity for everyone.

I do hope the pendulum has not swung too far the other way, but it did need to swing!

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#6

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

David

>The pendulum absolutely needed to swing the other way - hope I didn't come across as suggesting anything else. I wouldn't want to deny any youngster an opportunity to play an instrument, sport, or especially to learn.

Most importantly to turn wood on a lathe!!!

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#7

It's "traditional"

John K Jordan

>>Or can it be that men just don't want to teach?

It's always been that way that I can remember. Recent NEA statistics: 24.9 percent of the nation's teachers are men and the ratio has been steadily declining over the last several decades.

I think the problem is compound. One, not as many males want to go into teaching, especially teaching the younger grades. Teaching is in no way considered a "macho" choice of career and has carried the stigma of being "women's work", something vaguely related to babysitting. Those enrolled in the elementary education program when I was in school were mostly female.

Two, women are socially those more likely to choose to care for and nurture young children. There are far more men teaching in the jr.high/high school and college levels where the subject matter is more focused. And developmental issues like first-day terror and potty accidents and screaming temper tantrums are fewer. :)

Three, teaching saleries are low. This is horrible but a fact. This creates a problem for men choosing a career with the long term goal of caring for families. Many elementary teachers are married women who are not the primary family breadwinner. It would be difficult to support a family on an elementary teacher's salary. And low saleries are low prestige and lower your "bragging" rights. ("Hi, I'm a jet fighter test pilot". "Nice to meet you, I teach reading to 1st graders.")

Another interesting observation: I've been teaching kindergarten sunday school classes for about 15 years now. I guess I'm strange, but I love working with young children. When I started, I don't remember ANY other males teaching preschool/early elementary, and this is a relatively large church - I guess most men were looking for "important" jobs like usher or deacon or treasurer or adult class teacher. Or perhaps the men didn't have the patience or just didn't know HOW to handle a room full of young kids! (I apprenticed for an entire year to learn the trade and there sure was a lot to learn.) Fifteen years later, I see a big change within the same church. There are now many men teaching the younger children, many of them husband and wife teams. Perhaps the stigma of being a kindergarten teacher is softening. I know the pay is still the same. :)

BTW, being a male teacher has been very rewarding. The director often assigned to me children from families with single mothers just to give the kids a bit of a male influence.

JKJ in East TN

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#8

Re: OT: boys vs girls PENDULUM SWING

Ruth Niles

>Did you ever see a pendulum swing 1/2 way? It's either way over here or way over there.

I'm just wondering if possibly the male teachers were/are more affected by parents accusing them of being to tough on an unruly child, being too friendly to their daughter, being too friendly with their son, etc. I have two male friends who are retired teachers and they've said how glad they are not to teaching today for these reasons. Please don't misunderstand, they would never touch a child in anger or any other way, they said the parents have made teaching more of a challenge than a rewarding experience.

Now, PLEASE, I'm not talking about ALL men, ALL parents, ALL children, or ALL schools. It's just a big part of the force that's pushing the pendulum to the other side.

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#9

sharon in topanga

Re: OT: boys vs girls PENDULUM SWING

sharon in topanga

>I had not thought about it, but when my eldest (now 39) was in second grade, her assigned teacher was male. No problem for me, but the mother of one of her classmates got her changed to a class with a female teacher. Poor kid was from a single parent (mother) home and did not have any positive male role model. We all need them, whether we be male or female.

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#10

Dana's Experience

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi,

Well my daughter is now in grade 4. I don't know if it's a fluke but she's had a male teacher for half of grade 2, all of grade 3 and now grade 4.

Take care,

Jim

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#11

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

John Lucas

>Steve I think it's purely a matter of more men feeling comfortable teaching the higher grades. In High school it seems to be more equal but when I go to elementary schools there are almost always more women teachers. Here at Tennessee Tech I see slightly more female teachers graduate than male but that's only in the education college. That doesn't count the ones who graduate from Agriculture, Fine Arts, Engineering or Business who might end up teaching.

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#12

Re: OT: boys vs girls PENDULUM SWING

Bill Crommett

>In looking back to my days in Teachers Colllege, there was a definite division in the composition of elementary faculty, but most of it was because of pay scale. The males went on to be Lawyers, Dentists, Physicians, engineers because there was no money in teaching. Now the sexist part, (and remember this was many moons ago)The girls seemed to like teaching positions because it gave them a greater exposure to prospective husbands. Now before you fellows have a community "hot flash" re-read my opening phrase. The sad part of our society is that good changes come much slower than bad ones --- note the degredation of the quality of television programming. On a positive note, can any of you relate to the program called "Call Me Mister" that is encouraging Afro men to go into elementary teaching " (that last sentence should dilute your super-masculine vitriol a bit). Before anyone complains about the state of the educational establishment, remember that the most important influence on a students' success in school is the involvement of the parents. In case any of you are wondering where this guy is coming from -- I grduated from Teachers College in 1949, and was lucky enough NOT to get a teaching job that year.

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#13

Re: It's "traditional"

Bill Crommett

>John: And you turn bowls, too ??. I seldom hear from anyone like you that really has it all togather Good on you !

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#14

Re: It's "traditional"

vicmarc.fan

>One more reason to admire you.

Ron

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#15

SHEESH Ruth, are 'Aggressive Turners' next??!!??

Molly Winton

>Next thing you know you'll be ranting about male aggressive turners! (THIS IS TOTALLY AN INSIDE JOKE!)

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#16

Been there

Jack Savona

>I started teaching high school here in Maine in 1965. At that time, most all k-6 teachers were women; Jr High mixed; and most H.S. teachers were men. Stereotypes definitely prevailed, so did economics. Men, as the breadwinners, needed the extra $$ that coaching and other extra-curricula activities provided. High school was where those openings were. BTY teaching certificates were for K-12. Now I think they're K-8, 9-12.

Having decided that high school was too late to make a difference, I headed "downward" and taught second and fifth grade. One year I was given most all of the single-parent boys and told "They need a male role-model". 23 boys and 5 girls that year.

Out of 14 teachers K-6, at any one time no more than 3 of us were men.

My son had only two males K-6; my daughter one.

I can remember years ago in high school we men looked on elementary teaching as 'baby-sitting' style work. It was as though you didn't need to know as much academically as the specialists in HS. Since then I have learned that elementary is where the action is, where it all happens, where we need our most "education-oriented" people. Perhaps women, in their maternal role, lean toward the nurturing years and men toward the 'discipline'.

I think a lot of it is still sexually stereotyped. Ever hear the jokes about male nurses, male flight-attendants, male secretaries. I think it IS getting easier for men to choose this area. THEIR peers probably accept it more now than those of the past. However, till the rewards (financial, professional, personal) and the recognition follow, it'll be awhile.

Yes, we definitely need more (good) men at the elementary level!!!

BTW what percentage of turners are women?

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#17

Re: Been there

David

>The comments people have made relative to their own experience growing up are of interest to me - many seem to be about my age (40), and I don't really remember any predominance of one sex over the other or teachers. I Guess that's rare. The kindergarten teachers were all female, first grade I think were female, and after that it was a pretty good mix. Gym - both, history/social studies - both, math - both, science -both, english - both, but mostly female, music/arts - both.

Relative to the how many female turners question of the previous post - when I first started getting involved with this, I was surprised to see how many there are. Several on this site, but also several in my turning club. My little girl is 3 (tomorrow), and I'm really hoping one day to get her and her brother in the shop with me. (My dad's version of getting me in his shop was "hold this tool", so I've had to teach myself EVERYTHING. I love dad dearly, but it will be different for my kids.)

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#18

The lessons we learn from our parents...

Bob Hackett

>only become clear after we`re old enough to wish we had paid more attention.I wonder why that is.

I also find it funny that as we age we become more critical of our parent`s and grandparent`s techniques and realize that many times they best served as a bad example.

Mainely,Bob

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#19

Re: It's "traditional"

Joe Herrmann

>I've been teaching now for almost 35 years and John has pretty much hit it right on the head.

Joe

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#20

Re: It's "traditional"

John K Jordan

>>John: And you turn bowls, too ??.

Aw, shucks, thanks but I'm spread as thin and as scattered as the next guy! I turn an occasional bowl but for now I'm having more fun spindle turning - the tops, magic wands, etc. (These are pretty quick and great when the play time is limited!) My real passion in life is for the kids (so many kids have such a hard life - you would not believe some of the stories) so I especially enjoy making things that kids like. The tops are great for developing coordination and motor skills as well - it's a real challenge for a 4-5-6 year-old to spin a finger top and a huge ego boost when they are successful. We use them with special needs kids to help them focus as well.

I've been making gavels and other things too. I'll try to post some photos of gavels soon in case anyone wants to see - they are a blast and I find some people seem even more interested in the gavels than in the bowls!

Here's to retirement next year (if all goes well), then maybe I'll finally have enough time to play. (I'm collecting wood and tools before I'm too poor!)

JKJ in East TN

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#21

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

Jerry Nicholson

>I was in the sixth grade before I found out that there were male teachers - and the one I had then was the principal and taught half days. Of course that was about 1947. Up to that point, the two grade schools I had attended had only female teachers.

Jerry

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#22

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

Bill Crommett

>Regfarding pay scale: It has been said by some great authority whose name I forgot, that the pay scale for teachers is completely inverse. The best pay should go to the GOOD K-2 teachers so that they could instil a love for learning into kids before the "subject" teachers had a chance to turn them off, ego problems or what-ever.

Another thing: Why is an administrator or principal worth more than a teacher who could have a profound impact on a kids life ??

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#23

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

Russ Fairfield

>I don't know, my grade school principal had a profound impact on my life, every time I had to go to his office, which was often. I got to know his paddle well.

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

#24

Re: OT: Open house at my son's school...

Bill Crommett

>Sounds reasonable !