Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Tormek

Posts

Tormek

#1

Tormek

Brian McInturff

>OK I'm looking at complimenting my Oneway 1042 with a Tormek. Basically my sharpening skills suck other than for scary sharp method. My question is: Which package do I go with. Do they have an Ultimate package? Seems buying the basic and then to keep adding the jigs later would just be frustrating. You always need what you don't have when you can't get it right away. Also who has the best deal? Will Woodcraft meet other peoples prices? Or is Amazon probably the way to go. I can drive 90 miles to a Woodcraft is the reason I ask. Any and all help is surely appreciated. Brian

Re: Tormek

#2

Don't buy it.

tdaniel

>The Tormek works great for maintaining an edge on one particular tool; however, it is not good for sharpening gouges and scrapers or skews. It will do either quite well but when you go from a gouge to a flat tool you have to dress the stone. Dressing the stone takes way too long and wastes a lot of the stone. The stones are over-priced. I would suggest a good low speed grinder instead. Don't get me wrong, the Tormek will get your tools sharp; I just think there are more faster and more economical ways to do the job.

Re: Tormek

#3

Re: Tormek

RK in Milw

>I have to respectfully disagree with Terry on this one. The wheel does not have to be dressed between tools. The diamond dresser is necessary maybe once or twice a year at most. There is a stone grader that is used after each tool and to change the grit of the wheel from 220 grit to 1000 grit and back. This takes about 15 - 30 seconds.

The Tormek is easy to set up and use. The instruction book is excellent. It does a superb job on gouges, scrapers and skews. You can go all the way to a honed razor sharp edge if you want to. This is especially nice on skews. I made a bit holder to sharpen the bits for the Sorby Hollowing tools. There is even a gizmo for sharpening the round scraper blade that comes with the Sorby Hollowmaster.

Really sharp tools with consistent edge shapes make turning a whole lot easier. Very little metal is removed so your tools don't get short so soon. Scrapers sharpened at 1000 grit are a real joy to use.

Tormek does have a package set for woodturning. Prices don't vary much in my experience and I have always found that the Woodcraft store here in Milwaukee willing to match any published price. Doesn't hurt to ask, but shop around. If you can, get a demo from someone who knows what they are doing with turning tools.

Good luck!

Re: Tormek

#4

Steven Antonucci

Ditto- you can have my Tormek when you pry it from

steve antonucci

>my cold dead hands.

Love it. Just had a new stone ($140, after 3 years). Can't buy a better system for turning tools. No danger of overheating, sharp enough to shave with, so easy that I typically refresh my edges in <1m.

Only machine in my shop that I can't upgrade to a better one.

steve

Re: Tormek

#5

Re: Tormek

John K Jordan

>Brian,

I am one who highly recommends the Tormak. Although expensive, it is the one tool that has contributed the most to my pleasant time on the lathe. If mine broke, I'd buy another one tomorrow. As I mentioned in another message, I recommend getting an extra support bar to save constantly switching it from front to back on the machine.

The Tormak does take a long time to do major reshaping of a heavy tool. However, this is rarely needed and I use a standard slow-speed grinder for this as necessary. Once you get the inital grind, subsequent sharpenings take are extremely quick - just a couple of minutes. I sharpen all my skew chisels, bowl gouges, spindle gouges, and even scrapers with the Tormak. The scrapers, especially the very large and thick scrapers, take longer than the gouges and chisels. I also sharpen knives, plane irons, flatwork chisels, sissors, etc.

I find the wheels last a very long time if used properly. Don't try to do major reshaping of a tool profile, use a blackening marker and set up the jigs properly so the resharpening takes off just a whisper of metal, do not use excessive force, and control the motion so the wheel is abraded evenly. It also helps to read the manual carefullly - for the first year I was sharpening one tool contrary to the instructions. The wheel must still be trued occasionally with the included diamond tool, but I found this was a simple and quick process (unless the stone had been abused).

The Tormak does come with a video but I found it without much value.

The edge you get is fantastic, even for a beginner or a ham-fisted klutz like me. The edge is better than most you see from the factory. Since the edge is close to perfect, it is also easier to hone between sharpenings to keep a razer sharp edge. This makes turning a lot more fun!

Tormak claims that a good edge properly polished will last stay sharp longer than one straight off a standard grinder. I can't vouch for that, but those few times I turned around those with a lot of experience, I seems to sharpen less often. I polish most gouges but not my skew chisels. The polished edge does help make for some exceptionally smooth cuts in hard exotics.

It's interesting that one local person who loudly proclaimed the Tormak a waste of money had some of the worst sharpened tools I've ever seen. I do respect those who can get a perfect edge by hand from a standard grinder, but for the rest of us I think the Tormak is a real asset. If it is too costly, the next best thing would be a gouge jig to use on a standard grinder.

If you are undecided, perhaps you could get a hands-on demo by someone who is experienced on the Tormak.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Tormek

#6

Don Pencil

Re: Tormek

Don Pencil

>I have both the Tormek and the Wolverine. I use them both. I like and use the Tormek more. The Wolverine is faster at completely reshaping a tool, but after you become acustome to the Tormek I think it is better and I can sharpen a gouge faster with it than I can with any other system I have used. Many say that others are faster but I have yet to see any of them do it. Most do not like the Tormek because it can be pricey, but I believe it is worth it. And you can get many, many options with it.

Re: Tormek

#7

Re: Tormek

Tim Grenville-Cleave

>Ruddy brilliant at keeping a tool razor sharp (or sharper).

Ruddy useless (too much stone wear & time consuming) for re-profiling tools. Use a slow speed dry grinder and a jig, (Unless you are a superhero and can grind freehand !! ).

Ruddy expensive, but so are Bentleys and Rollers!.

'Nuff said!!

Regards from this side of the pond.

Tim

Re: Tormek

#8

Re: Tormek

Shopdude

>Who's Ruddy? ;-)

Re: Tormek

#9

Re: Tormek

John Lucas

>I guess I grew up sharpening by hand and even though I sharpen most of my tools with jigs now I use more than one homemade jig because I like different grinds on different tools. I simply can't feel or see what I'm doing on the Tormek. I'm used to feeling the bevel as it gets flat on the wheel and then watching for the sparks to come over the edge. I can't do that on a water wheel.

I find that my one grinder will rough out or reshape an edge quickly. I don't do that a lot because I have 3 gouges ground to different profiles so Idon't have to reshape very often.

As far as edge burning, who cares. OK that sounded nasty and I didn't mean it that way. HSS won't heat up enough on a grinder to damage it. I like to use an 1800 rpm speed because it simply feels safer and cuts metal fast enough for me. When I sharpen carbon steel tools I simply use a light touch and pull the tool back from the wheel 1/16" between passes so the air from the wheel cools the edge.

Don't get me wrong I've tested the Tormek and it is a great tool. I just don't think you need to spend that much money to sharpen lathe tools. If I did more flat work I might be more interested but I've been sharpening my chisels and planes so long by hand it rarely takes very long to re-establish an good edge on one. I've had 2 other water wheel grinders and I guess the best advantage has been sharpening planer blades that have really been damaged. For simple sharpening of planer blades I still think the scary sharp system with a simply homemade jig is just as fast as setting up the Tormek.

Re: Tormek

#10

Me too

CapeMayMike

>I'd be up the creek without a paddle if not for my Tormek. I can rough shape and change profies on my regular bench grinder and then fdinish them on my Tormek. The Tormek is mounted nest to my lathe, less than a minute to sharpen a tool.

Steve is right, it's one tool that you can't upgrade. If you're a turner, get the turner package. My wife bought my Tormek as a gift for me, I bought all of my jigs individually and I'm sure that I paid more than getting them in a package deal. They are specific to each tool and I use them all.

Re: Tormek

#11

Google Sharp Tools USA - Great Company

Clem Wixted

>They even have a few videos on their web site on using the Tormek.

Clem

Re: Tormek

#12

Re: Tormek

Tim Grenville-Cleave

>LOL ... Us Brits and our quaint sayings hehehe, it's better than a B*^`*! expletive (;-)

Tim

Re: Tormek

#13

JL

Re: Tormek

JL

>I have a Tormek, an 8" 2-speed grinder and waterstones. The 8" grinder gets used for profiling gouges (and keeping them sharp) and bowl gouges. The Tormek gets used for scrapers, initial stuff on plane blades, chisels and skews. The waterstones get used for microbevels on the plane blades, chisels and skews. I like the Tormek. Could I live without it? Probably. I might not be as happy, but it would work out.

Re: Tormek

#14

JL, my feelings also

tdaniel

>

Re: Tormek

#15

Re: Tormek

Stuart Johnson

>I like the Tormek for gauges but have never been able to get a decent edge on a skew using it. I have a Woodcraft slow ginder and Wolverine with the skew attachment that works great. Many can hand sharpen with stones or grinders (slow or fast. But I doubt if many of their wives would hand them their best sewing scissors to sharpen.

I don't think a Tormek is a must but it can't be beat for all around sharpening strengths. Take a look at the different packages and decide what you might use. For example it doesn't make much sense to pay for the planer blade jig if you don't have a planer or if yours uses disposable blades.

Re: Tormek

#16

Tormek-think before you buy.T-users dont be mad

Bud

>Ah yes, those with a Tormek can produce a sharp beautiful mirror edge on a gouge,….one that for practical purposes will dull as quickly as when done on a bench grinder, but the Tormek takes some up to 10 times as long (total time) to sharpen.

I don’t want to start a flame war here or don’t want to make anyone feel bad if I open a crack in the “window of reality” to them. Brian, you made a great choice in a lathe but just because it’s high-quality & pricey, don’t think you that you can just “compliment” it by getting an expensive sharpening system and that will solve your sharpening problems. What you need is, sharpening experience, and to get is the right tool for the job, and that is almost universally a bench grinder for turning tools. You should take any opinion with a grain of salt, and make your own choice from the overall knowledge you gather, but take the most weight of knowledge from pros who have the real experience, and that is what I will try to give to you. No, I’m not a pro, but I have attended and video taped numerous 1 and 2 day demonstrations from many of the best turners around the world- guess how many use the Tormek to sharpen their commonly used turning tools……Zero, none that I have encountered (Frank Sudol is the only one that comes to mind, who goes off the beaten path and uses a belt sander). Now here’s the best advice I can give (this again is gathered from observing many of the best first hand) and this is one of the main keys in successful woodturning, and that is You Must Sharpen Often, (in the last Jordan demonstration I attended, he said, “when you realize your tool is cutting wonderful, stop and sharpen again” meaning, that is the way to keep your cuts wonderful, by not letting your tool get dull. Most of the best may have different opinions about wheel sizes, speeds, grits and so on, however, what most of them have in common is, they sharpen often. This is the reason the Tormek is not the most practical choice for turning tools, turning tools loose thier turning edge way too fast, and the Tormak is too much of a lengthy, messy process to sharpen the tool often as they need to be, (I think most end up sharpening less often because of the “hassle” and time). Conclusion; buy a good bench grinder (the slow-speed ones seem to be preferred and are more comfortable for most) put it close to your lathe to make it convenient to sharpen often, often, often. Get a sharpening jig (like the Wolverine) and learn to use it correctly, that’s CORRECTLY. I say this because many get the jig and don’t set it up correctly, that’s why many end up in bench drawers. Late last year, one of the best instructional Bowl dvd’s was released. The dvd was by a proficient turner/instructor who post to WoodCentral often, but even he incorrectly shows the use of a sharpening jig, which is the only criticism I have of this otherwise great instructional video. After the initial “correct” set up, there’s no need to fiddle with adjustments (with the same tool), you just shove your gouge in to the correct length, (which is done by a stopper you set up) and grind a wonderful consistent edge in less than 15 seconds. I have my grinder about 1 ½ steps from my lathe, I’m back to cutting in about 20 seconds, that’s from wood to sharpening, to wood, and I don’t mind sharpening often because everything is set up to be convenient. If you get into carving you may want to look at a Tormek, but John Jordan can show you how to make up a system to sharpen/polish carving tool edges that’s probably better than a Tormek and will work right on your lathe that you can make for a couple of bucks using mdf-works great for him. (Join a local woodturning club if possible and attend demos!) Now if you do a lot of fine spindle work you may want to refine that edge by honing but………that’s another subject…good luck and a great choice in a lathe for small work. apoligies for length

Bud in IL

Re: Tormek

#17

Ditto

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>

Re: Tormek

#18

Re: Tormek

Russ Fairfield

>As a former Tormek owner, I can offer the following reasons for why it never replaced my conventional grinder for sharpening lathe tools, and why it was one of the I sold during a “Shop Clearance” sale before moving.

There is a common misconception that when you have a Tormek, you will never need a conventional grinder. That is WRONG. You will still have need for a conventional grinder, unless you want to spend a lot of time shaping tools. Trying to shape a new tool on the Tormek is akin to trying to sand wood with nothing but 320-grit sandpaper. It can be done, but it takes a lot of time. So, it really came down to a question of why I was using two grinders, when one would do everything that I needed. And, that one wasn’t the Tormek.

I can't give you any scientific data to support any of my opinions. Woodturning is an "art". Sharpening tools is an "art". There is nothing scientific about either. There are no "rules". There are only personal skills and preferences. Nobody is "right" and nobody is "wrong". The arguments "for" and "against" the Tormek will go on forever. For what they're worth, the following are mine.

Skews -- I sharpen them, as I would a plane iron, on a fine India stone followed by a couple licks on a hard leather strop with "Gold" abrasive powder. I like the skews to have a polished razor edge and a flat surface. The Tormek may get a similar edge, but it isn't faster, and it isn't flat.

Spindle gouges -- I freehand sharpen spindle gouges on an 80-grit wheel without a jig, and that is faster than with the Tormek. The Tormek requires a jig because its slow speed removes so little metal that it is impossible to grind freehand on the wheel. I did not find that the edge from the Tormek to cut better or last longer than that from the “standard” wheel.

Scrapers -- I sharpen scrapers with a quick run with a stone across the top to remove the old burr, followed by one pass across an 80-grit wheel using a flat tool rest. It is impossible to get a better edge faster than that. A really fine micro-burr edge is made with a few strokes of the stone across the top, followed by a couple vertical strokes down across the edge. Again, better and faster can't be done.

Bowl gouges -- I couldn't tell the difference between the grind from an 80-grit wheel and the Tormek, so why have a separate grinder for them when I already have one mounted on the other end of the grinder from the scraper rest. I have a choice of whether or not to use the jig on the grinder, but I usually do because it is easier to duplicate the long side-grind that I use on my bowl gouges. But, on the Tormek, it is impossible to freehand grind. So, if I have to use a jig on both, the grinding time is about the same, and I can't tell any difference in the edge, why bother?

Re: Tormek

#19

Re: Tormek-think before you buy.T-users dont be ma

Stuart Johnson

>It would be a waste of time and energy if we get mad whenever we disagree.

I'm not questioning you about how the pros sharpen or even which way is best. The main thing is having sharp tools not how long it takes you to sharpen them. What I'm having trouble with is your statement about the Wolverine being faster because once it is set up properly for the given tool you only have to stick it in the holder and set it to the proper depth with a jig for a quick sharpening.

I am doing the exact same thing with the Tormek.

Step 1. Set the bar the proper distance to the wheel by using a wooden gage block.

Step 2. Set the tool in the holder at the proper depth using the same wooden block.

Step 3. Sharpen

For repeating just go back to step 2. Now I will grant you don't need to fill a water tray at the beginning of your session or empty it when done.

Re: Tormek

#20

Tormek and Grinder

David Propst

>Bud,

I am not mad at your statement, but I am as a relatively long time Tormek user I find it to be very mis-informed.

First of all, for a new turner I would recommend a Wolverine system with a good grinder, and the Oneway balancing system. The Tormek is a luxury not needed to begin turning, but like most good tools it is a luxury I would not want to be without.

To initially shape a grind I use the Wolverine varigrind, but from then on I use I the the Tormek exclusively to maintain an edge on my gouges. It takes not one second more the use the Tormek than the Varigrind and I get what I percieve to be a much sharper edge, especially with shearing or finishing cuts. From thinking about sharpening to finish may take 5-10 seconds. As for messy, the dust from my bench grinder if far more messy than the Tormek has ever been.

David

Re: Tormek

#21

Re: Tormek

Brian McInturff

>Guys, here is ther url on using the Wolverine jig with the Tormek

http://www.turningwood.com/tormek.htm

Re: Tormek

#22

Ditto

tdaniel

>I haven't sold my tormek yet but it hasn't been used in well over a year. The edge may be sharper from the Tormek but it doesn't have the "bite". On most woods I prefer "bite" over a polished edge but there are exceptions. I think everyone should have a good bench grinder and a jig before buying a tormek. If you wish to add the Tormek later that is fine. The Tormek does have some attachments that make it a good sharpening station for a multitude of tools but I do not think it is the best system for a turner. If you can dedicate it to the gouge it is fine but the gouge quickly wears a groove in the wheel and this groove must be removed to sharpen a flat tool.

TD

Re: Tormek

#23

Re: Ditto

David Propst

>Hey Terry,

One reason you might want to hang onto your Tormek is for demos where sharpening will not be available. I have used mine a couple of times this year "out the field". It is a whole lot less cumbersome than lugging my grinder. I have the Heavy Delta and with the base I bet it weighs close to 100#.

Glad you are home safe. Thanks for all you are doing.

David

Re: Tormek

#24

Re: Tormek-

Darryl Hansen

>Hmm interesting comments. Yes the wheel is pricy. Yes it does wear and yes it does sharpen very well. I only use one or two gouges. The main ones with the "Ellsworth" grind. I can set up the Tormek in about 5 seconds since I mark the jigs and have a stop block glued on the bench top for the length of the tip of the gouge I'm using. I can't sharpen worth a hoot on the slow speed grinder even with a couple of jigs. The Tormek does all the work for me. The down side is the initial and continuing cost. I'd probably buy it again if it ever breaks down.

I am certain the experts have tried the Tormek and formed their opinions based on experience. As a real novice I have tired both ways and do tend to turn to the Tormek given a choice.

Re: Tormek

#25

Re: Ditto

Phil Powell

>Everyone may be interested to know that there is a "Tormek Woodturners System"

listed on Ebay right now. Happy bidding.