Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

Posts

Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#1

Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

David

>I showed one of my finished bowls to a lady at work yesterday, probably the sixth bowl I've made ever, and she instantly started hinting around what kind of money would it take to get a set of salad bowls. My first response was that she should find somebody competent to make them for her, then I asked her how many bowls. She says 12. 12. Are you kidding me? Is it harvest time in the fields or something?

Anyway, my questions are not really about the $ end of it. I can figure that out, and I'm sure I'll sell my labor for next to nothing. I've read a bunch of "salad bowl" posts on this site, and a few of the linked articles (the seven "S's"), yet questions remain. I could use some help with:

1) Type of wood - I think for 12 bowls this needs to be a fairly inexpensive wood. Suggestions?

2) Size of the blank - I'm thinking blanks that are 8x8x3 or maybe even 8x8x2 are what I'm after? I'll be working with dry wood, and I'll need to find a good source too I guess.

3) Preferred finishes. I've read enought to think non-glossy oil is the route, but there are about a billion choices. The only used example of a bowl I've seen was gummy and nasty on the inside, and if I can avoid that....

4) Care and feeding - how does my customer take care of the bowls for the long term?

Thanks -

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#2

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

Mike Schwing from Md.

>David, congrats!

I would suggest asking her what size she considers to be a good salad bowl, after all, she's the customer. There are only two people in my home, so the right size for us is different than that for a large family. A 2 person salad in a big bowl looks sadly lacking.

Hopefully you agreed on a price beforehand. Did you tell her how long it takes to make a salad bowl from a green piece of wood? Unless you're segmented turning, quite a while, unless you're an alcohol drying proponent.

Species? I made my first bowls out of poplar. Not many would think the best choice, but Mrs. Schwingding scarfed them up out of the burn pile and insists they're her favorite bowls (but they give me nightmares). Mostly I use whatever species I find locally. I believe that Russ thinks walnut is a poor choice for salad bowls due to the color, but I find it attractive against bright red tomatoes and fresh greens. I make a lot of cherry and maple salad bowls. Use whatever you can get your hands on cheaply, unless you're being paid for very fancy figured bowls or something specific. Cherry and maple are my favorites for this, I think.

Finish? Don't go too nuts, any finish you apply will become dull, damaged, and wear off through use. Watco followed by buffing is a favorite choice around here. I've stopped using that finishing regimen on salad bowls because my customers are too disappointed when the nice bright sheen is destroyed by use. Instead I now use nothing other than wax finishes. They're easy to reapply, look nice, and are harmless, and the appearance change with use isn't so dramatic. They take a lot less time to apply, too.

Good luck!

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#3

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>David, may I suggest that your potential customer be offered a set of salad bowls that are not as large? I was commissioned to make a set of 5 smaller bowls for just that purpose. They were 9 inches diameter x 3 inches deep in Sycamore (Maple your side of the pond) and treated with Sunflower oil at the customers request.

Easily refreshed and an individual delight.

Just a thought.

Regards Peter.


img

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#4

must say I'm surprised

Mike Schwing from Md.

>So far you have 142 views on your post. At least half of them have to be from salad bowl turners. Come on guys - everyone has an opinion on this. Give David some help please, he asked nicely.

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#5

Re: must say I'm surprised

David

>Yeah, but I'll bet half of those 142 are me re-reading my request to admire writing!!

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#6

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

Jorge Castaneda

>David,

the article by Russ Fairfield is the bible to me when it come sto care and feed, dig in the archives.

I have turned and sold many bowls, mostly made out of white birch or red maple, because that is mostly the hardwoods that grows in my land. 6"x3" is a good size for salad bowls, if she is buying 12, you might as well suggest a big 14" x 6" to toss the salad. Personally I prefer our home salad bowls oiled with hazelnut oil or walnut oil.

Jorge

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#7

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

woodspinner/ Bill Hale

>Don't second guess the client.

Ask what size she would like.

Ask if she wants light or dark wood.

Remind her that they are hand crafted and will not be exactly the same size ou shape, close but not exact.

DO NOT SELL TO CHEAP and set a president for future sales.

BE SURE TO AGREE ON A PRICE PRIOR TO MAKING THEM.

And as another said , do an add on sale with a larger main bowl if you can turn it.

Good turning and be safe.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#8

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

George Van in WI

>Hi Dave. I also would ask what your customer expects. Is it a set of individual serving dishes or 12 large bowls? I would also consider the capacity of my lathe when suggesting anything.

I have never bought wood so I cannot suggest sources. I rough turn, Anchorseal, and wait. A year later, I have more dry than I will have time to turn.

The last salad bowl I did was yellow birch. I have used maple and cherry also. I have only finished a few bowls at this time.

I use walnut or mineral oil. I should try the wax that Mike suggests, it may leave the wood brighter, and all finishes need to be refreshed after use and repeated washing. I do not like a gloss finish for the same reason Mike suggests.

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#9

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

David

>Thanks for all the responses - and special thanks to my advocate Mike Schwing for getting things going today!!

The bowls are individual serving bowls. I would love to add on a larger serving bowl, but it would have to be like an ugly serving vase since I've just got a mini lathe.

I'll discuss finish technique with the might-be-customer (among other things such as size). I think my own preference would be to follow the Mike Schwing method of adding wax - maybe beeswax. That gets you off the lathe quickly with a finished item, gives nice appearance, and gives the customer a pretty simple thing to restore from time to time.

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#10

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

Jack Savona

>David, I've probably made 80 to 100 bowls so far, not counting the many partial bowls. Never tried two exactly the same. I did try a pair of Rude Osolnik style olivewood candlestick holders for a friend's 40th anniversary. At that point I decided never to make duplicates, let alone 12!!! Realize that you may spend more time than it would take to individually do 12 separate bowls.

First you need all the same wood and grain pattern. Next you'll probably want the same thickness (hope no catches occur on the final cut or two). But since it seems you have the drive and confidence to undertake a serious challange, may I suggest the option of a non-matched set that truly gives everyone at the table his/her own unique salad bowl. That could offer your friend a most unique "set", ease some potential problems for you, and provide a win-win transaction.

An option???

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#11

Steven Antonucci

My experience from my first one of these

steve antonucci

>I recently had the same experience as you, and I offer the following advice:

1.) People will eat salad out of it. If doesn't need to be sanded to 6000 grit and buffed. I use a liberal application of mineral oil and beeswax, sanded to 220-320 grit.

2.) Agree with others that you need to acquire wood locally for nada, or price yourself out of the transaction. My buyer like a larger bowl and wanted 4 smaller to "match". I went into the woods and cut some more of the spalted maple, and turned 4 6" bowls. She insisted on the spalted maple, even after I tried to talk her down.

1 tank of gas in the chainsaw.

3.) If you are in a hurry, I'm an alcohol guy. Only way I made my customers timeline.

4.) Show her different designs. Not everybody has the same taste, and some people have none, but they do have money. Let her approve of a single bowl before making the other 11.

My customer loved my bowls. She is waiting for the thank you card from her friend to see what she thought of them. Word gets around, so price your work so that you are comfortable with the money you receive for your work. If you really figured out the cost, you know you've lost money or worked for minimum wage, but for me I'd turn even if I never sold a single bowl, so it's a way to buy new tools and such.

Steve

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#12

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

David

>I actually discussed this particular issue with her. She understands that one bowl will differ from another, but would hope that it wouldn't be real noticeable around the table - that people wouldn't be going "hey, that bowl is a different size/shape, whatever from what I have". I think I can come within reason on that. My idea was to make a cardboard template for the exterior and interior of the bowl, that I could use to check shape/size.

And by the way, I do appreciate all the voices of experience here, especially the cautionary notes - bad experience shared is a great benefit of this website. I haven't committed to anything with her, other than to bone up a bit on the subject, and give a $ range of what I think it would run. Personally, I think she will bail out when it isn't $20. I've got a feel for what my time would be/what I would want to get out of the deal, but I need to figure out my source of wood before I can discuss numbers with her.

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#13

Re: My experience from my first one of these

David

>I wouldn't know what in the world to do with DNA. I think I would have to seek wood that was already dry, which all but guarantees an expensive bowl.

Thanks for the finishing suggestion - definitely no need to get to crazy with a finish that will immediately be subjected to the tongs of a fork.

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#14

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

Barry Irby

>I turned a set of 8 and a big bowl out of Bradford Pear. They wee cutting up a storm damaged tree in the median strip and I slammed on brakes and asked for the logs. They looked at me as if I were crazy, but loaded the wood into the car, probably fearing I was an ax murderer or something.

I turned a set of matching bowls from six different types of wood. They liked the sort of "color coding" it gave them.

Any fairly fine grained hardwood will be fine. I have turned many bowls green to finish. I like the warping. Seems to give them character to me. I also find that if you rough them ans wait a few weeks, you can cancel out a lot of the warping.

As you develop your "eye" you will find it both easier and harder to make them match. You will get better and they will match better, but your eye will be more sensitive and YOU will see defects you or your customer may not have noticed before. I make a cardboard or plywood "c" that sets the diameter. I make it deep enough that I can put it over the bowl either way to check the diameter. You are right about the pattern. Some of mine look like a quarter of a circle that I just touch to the outside of the bowl. Some look like a J so that the inside of the long leg of the j touches the top of the bowl and the curl wraps around the outside. This keeps the pattern part inside the curl oriented exactly the same way, if you follow me.

If you get them all the same diameter and height, no one eating salad will be able to tell the difference, especially if she is serving wine. Long neck beer drinkers won't notice either, because long necks make especially poor goggles. I don't know, but I don't think beer drinkers eat a lot of salad or care what they eat it out of anyway.

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

#15

Re: Can't have too many salad bowl posts.

David

>Barry -

Thanks for the response. It is very interesting that you've used green wood and utlized the warp for this. I just happened across some birch (my next door neighbor), and I've been toying with the idea of roughing out a bunch of baloney slice bowls while the wood is green, and take my chances with checking.