Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Tool rest height

Posts

Re: Tool rest height

#26

Keith Tompkins

Re: look again TD

Keith Tompkins

>John, the difference lies in where the tool handle is in relation to your body....same angles perhaps, but some positions are awkward to turn from.

Re: Tool rest height

#27

Keith Tompkins

Re: all true but...

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Russ, I think the point I'm trying to make is not the height of the rest, but HOW the height of the rest affects the way we turn. I don't set the tool rest then compensate with the tool, I set the rest so the tool cuts right on the centerline. the actual height of the rest is irrelevant. Only where the tool cuts is important.

Re: Tool rest height

#28

Let's go back to the pics

tdaniel

>Pic #1 No force into toolrest...all force goes into the tool and the person holding it.

Pic #2 Some force goes into tool and some into the rest but the tool can now back off as needed when tough grain comes to it. (Better)

Pic #3 Here the tool is free to back out of the cut (Best). Notice the force is not opposed by the toolrest. I won't get into angles of incidence but you should be able to understand it with what is presented.

Now mentally drop the toolrest in Pic 3 until the tool is near the center of the spinning piece. Note that this transmits all force into the toolrest and the tool cannot back out of the cut if some tough grain comes to it. The toolrest height becomes important only because the handle position (angle over toolrest) has changed.

Re: Tool rest height

#29

Re: The angle between the vertical toolrest

John K Jordan

>>The angle between the vertical toolrest is what I am referring

>to. The rest of your statement and drawings are accurate but

>my point is the angle between the toolrest vertical

>support and the tool are very important. The

>difference is where the force is going.

Yikes. I just put a dial indicator on the very end of my 12" stock Jet tool rest. I do not see even 1/1000" deflection when I apply a significant force either in line or perpendicular to the tool rest post. I consider a useful tool rest system to be essentially rigid, regardless of the orientation or how the rest is attached to the lathe or the floor. It should be strong enough to support the tool against reasonable forces applied in any direction.

Forces applied to the horizontal bar are distributed to the post, banjo, and ways (and essentially balanced back through the headstock to the work). As long as the components are sufficiently tough and rigid (and not brittle!), the orientation of the toolrest support makes no difference. Instead of a vertical post held in a banjo on the lathe ways, the support could be at any angle, come out the end of the rest and be fastened to the headstock, or sweep under the lathe and be fastened to the back wall or the ceiling. The cut would not be affected, IF the support is sufficiently rigid.

A weak or flexible tool rest would be a real problem and might well contribute to catches. If your tool rest is not sturdy enough you might check out the aftermarket rests. I bought one from Best Wood Tools with a machined 1" solid steel post and a 3/4" horizontal round bar. It is well made and very sturdy.

I consider very strong forces against the tool and rest something to avoid. With sharp tools good technique and light cuts the forces should be too small to flex the toolrest. I can imagine that trying to take off too much wood on one pass around the circumference could indeed be exciting.

>At the equator of the piece being turned, the wood

>is moving straight down against the cutting edge

>and the toolrest (if the tool is held level). If you

>directly oppose this force by having the cutting edge

>supported from directly below, where is this force

>going to go if you encounter grain that the cutting

>edge is not capable of cutting in a single pass?

I believe the force opposing the shaving being removed by the cutting edge comes primarily and radially from the wood directly below the shaving, supported by the back of the tool edge or bevel. When this force is out of balance one way, the tool will quit cutting. When out of balance the other way, the tool will dig in.

There are some excellent diagrams on page 33 of Darlow's "Fundamentals of Woodturning" that appear to be reasonably correct and illustrate this nicely. I believe the forces are more complex than he describes but the basics look close enough. BTW, he includes some amazing dynamic photos on the following pages of shavings being cut at different clearance angles.

Back to the original topic, I read everything I can get my hands on. I find it significant that very few authors discuss tool rest height as if it were an important parameter.

In fact, Darlow writes in the same book mentioned above: "There is no absolute relationshop between the height of the top of the toolrest and the height of the lathe axis. The top of the toolrest would commonly be positioned about 1/4" below the lathe axis, but its ideal height depends on several factors. If using a lathe that is too low for you, raise the toolrest and vice versa. ... The governing factor is your comfort at the lathe."

This is what I was trying say earlier - I think the most important thing is that I feel comfortable and my head and hands and arms are in good positions to see and feel and control the tool.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Tool rest height

#30

Re: look again TD

John K Jordan

>>John, the difference lies in where the tool handle is

>in relation to your body....same angles perhaps, but

>some positions are awkward to turn from.

Keith,

Hey, that's what I said!

Just for fun, I think I'll try running my lathe in reverse and use the skew upside down UNDER the toolrest, looking at the spindle in a mirror laying flat on the lathe bed. I'll be sure to report my experience.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Tool rest height

#31

Keith Tompkins

Re: consider the lathe height instead

Keith Tompkins

>John, I think your illustration reinforces my initial statement. Look at the top photo...this is the position many turners use. I see it all the time, as I usually have six students a week.

In the top pic, the tool handle is level. To reduce the diameter of the piece being turned, the handle must be raised. At the same time, the tool must be rotated in order to cut, o/w a catch will result. It will be a big catch as the tool will be pulled into the wood. With the handle raised high enough to cut, your body cannot help support the tool, only your arms.

Try this.....put a piece of scrap on the lathe, see what shapes you can produce with the rest this high. Beads, coves, etc. Try to produce a piece with a 21/2" diameter at one point, and 3/4" diameter at another. Difficult to do; this is one reason I think we so many poorly executed finials......you cannot produce pieces with "definition" with the rest so high.

A challenge to all.....post a photo of what you can produce with the toolrest in a high position.......or, in a lower position.

Re: Tool rest height

#32

Re: all true but...

Mac

>Ayuh........

Re: Tool rest height

#33

Re: Tool rest height

Don Henthorn

>I am anything but an expert turner and learned to turn by turning and reading. I remember most instructions would begin by saying something like "raise the tool rest to about 1/16" under the centerline" or "raise the tool rest to about 1/16" above the centerline" or something similar. Somehow it never seemed right or comfortable for me until I finally figured out that I was 5' 7 1/2" tall and the guy writing the instructions was 6' 2". Things got a lot easier after that rvelation.(-:

Re: Tool rest height

#34

Keith Tompkins

Re: I just haven't had the opportunity

Keith Tompkins

>HI Jay, I may have worded my post poorly; what I should have said was "tool cutting height", since that is the real point. I usually cut right on center, the tool rest just supports the tool. I don't ever use a high positioned rest on the outside of any turning. My feeling is, there is no reason to.