Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Tool rest height

Posts

Tool rest height

#1

Keith Tompkins

Tool rest height

Keith Tompkins

>A little survey....How many turners here at WC have trouble with tool rest height? Do you turn with it high, or low? WHY? Do you find you are constantly tinkering with the height of the tool rest?

Here's my theory....This applies to all spindle turning, and outside of bowls only. The higher the tool rest, in relation to the centerline of the piece, will result in poorer forms, and more frequent catches. Catches high up on a turning will be more severe than catches on the center-line. Why? The higher the tool contacts the turning, the more mass is under the cutting edge. The cutting edge is also further away from the rest. A catch will pull the tool deeper and deeper into the cut, resulting in a major catch. On the other hand, a catch that occurs right on the centerline has only air beneath, so a catch won't tend to be as severe.( I use gouges with the flute on the side in most cases)

I have been studying people using the skew....most use the tool high up on the turning...when a catch occurs, it's usually a good one...the tool is pulled into the cut by the wood beneath.Can the skew be used right on center? Yes, especially with long point down.

Also using a gouge with a high rest, in order to obtain a smaller diameter on a turning, the tool handle must be raised,and at the same time, the tool must be rolled to prevent an edge from digging in. In this situation, the handle of the tool cannot rest against the body, and support and control is lost. It is difficult to watch the cutting edge and the "horizon" of the turning at the same time, so the form usually suffers. Coves are hard to cut, as the gouge tends to be used flat, with the flute down. With a low rest, It's easy to cut from large diameter to small without raising the tool handle at all. One fluid motion. This topic is a new demo I'm doing, and the basis for a new article...(I hope) Thoughts and opinions welcome.

Re: Tool rest height

#2

Re: Tool rest height

Sean Troy

>I think this topic would be of great benefit to all turners but especially those who have a strong desire to learn correct tool technique. The importance of using a particular tool to it's full advantage brings better and safer cuts.

Re: Tool rest height

#3

I just haven't had the opportunity

Jay in TX

>Keith,

I just haven't had the opportunity to use the toolrest above centerline except maybe the skew on a small diameter (1" or less) piece. Maybe I've been a prodigy in that regard, or maybe its just my Irish luck telling, "Lad, thet uis noot the way to be doin' sucha thing." I'd be interested to hear where good technique would put one in a situation to use the toolrest above centerline, cause it just seems counter-intuitive to me.

Re: Tool rest height

#4

8 causes of catches

tdaniel

>Keith, you have named a couple of the 8 causes of catches. Understanding the physics of the cut will help a lot to eliminating catches. The toolrest height is a critical part of eliminating catches. People who have done a lot of spindles turning tend to hold the gouge handle level....not good. When holding the handle level the cutting edge has no choice but to cut any wood that comes to it because the downward force from the wood coming to the cutting edge is met by an equal and opposite force exerted by the toolrest. If, however, you lower the tool handle so that it is leaning against the toolrest instead of supported by it then the gouge has the opportunity to back out of a cut when it cannot cut the mateerial in one pass. The tough grain that could not be cut will be cut on the next pass. It is just like using a riding lawnmower to mow over a septic tank field line where the grass is heavier and thicker than the rest of the yard...you get to the heavy area you take a more narrow cut or you slow down. Again, the lower handle position allows the tool to back out of the cut just a tiny bit and will complete the cut on the next revelution or two. Another major cause of catches is the dewign of the flute of the gouge. A shallow flute will cause the cutting edge to be too high and if it is above the center of the tool then it will twist into the wood instead of rolling out of it. To see how a tool is cutting just position it on the wood and rotate the lathe by hand and watch the cutting contact point (edge). If the edge would rotate into the wood if it hit tough grain this would be a catch; if it would rotate out of the wood when the tough grain came around then there is no catch.

These are basic tool control techniques that should be taught the first day of any bowl turning class but I have never heard them covered in any class that I have ever attended. Thanks for bringing it back up!

Re: Tool rest height

#5

Re: Tool rest height

Ed Moore

>When Keith said ALL spindle turning a red flag was raised for me. When you are hollowing out a box and wish to avoid catches, you RAISE the tool rest and the handle so that the tool is cutting at the centerline and is sloped downward to that point. I asked Ray Key for help on this at Arrowmont and he told me to raise the rest. I did and he came over and REALLY raised it. I was amazed at the difference in the cut and the lack of a catch. As mentioned, the physics of this approach makes sense when dealing with endgrain and you don't want the tool to dig in deeper.

I am also putting a bevel like Stuart Batty has popularized on scrapers that I use inside boxes. This increases the effect described above.

The original point about catches and high tool rests may be valid elsewhere, but inside a box it is invalid.

Ed Moore

Re: Tool rest height

#6

consider the lathe height instead

John K Jordan

>>Understanding the physics of the cut will help...

I think it has more to do with the height of the spindle relative to your eyes, arms, and hands rather than simply the height of the toolrest relative to the centerline of the spindle.

In the diagram below, the geometry of the spindle, rest, and tool is identical for each case - I simply rotated the three components as a group then added the vertical shaft. The physics of each is the same except for the tiny component due to gravity and the insignificant flexibiliy of the vertical tool rest support shaft.

While I would be uncomfortable turning in the top or bottom configuration, each would cut the same way. What would be different is my view of the work, and the position of my hands and arms and angle of bend at the elbows. Each configuration would require a different grip and in some positions I would sacrifice control. For example, for the top configuration the lathe would have to be very low to keep my wrists straight and then my elbows would not be bent enough for control unless I leaned over the lathe. Then my back would hurt.

I think the key is to find the lathe height which gives me the most comfort and control and set the tool rest accordingly.

JKJ in East TN


img

Re: Tool rest height

#7

Re: Tool rest height

John Lucas

>Keith

Here's my theory. The wood is round and spinning in an arc. It doesn't matter where the tool rest is as long as the tool is in the same orientation. That's a lousy description. If I welded a bar to the tool rest so it stuck straight up. I could turn with the tool at 12 oclock and the handle sticking up in the air. I would be making the exact same cut that I would if the tool were at 9 oclock and the tool rest is horizontal. I adjust the tool rest lower on a tall lathe and higher on a short lathe when I demo because I like the tool handle to be on my hip for control.

Now the problem comes in when you have a tool rest that only moves up and down but stays horizontal. Too low and you can't rub the bevel, too high and your holding the tooll under your amrpit. I think where you cut on the wood and how the tool is used is as important as tool rest height. I adjust the tool rest up and down frequently because of where I like the tool handle to sit on my body and how that tool cuts.

I have more control over the skew with the tool rest high so the tool is cutting on the top surface. For a spindle gouge I would have the tool rest lower. Bowl gouges vary. If I am doing a pull cut I have the tool rest low so I can get more of a shear cut. With a push cut I like the tool rest on the center line.

When turning beads on the face of my mirrors I have found that raising the tool rest really high, maybe an inch above center, makes it easier to roll the gouge. I can cut a much cleaner bead this way than if I leave the tool rest at the center line. Bear in mind this is cutting on the face, like the top of a platter, not the edge.

I think the problem of tool rest height comes into play more often on spindles because the rest only moves up and down which means it moves further away from the spindle as you go above or below the center line. This leaves more or the tool hanging over the rest and in some cases you can't rub the bevel if the tool rest is wrong for that cut.

I'm not argueing with you or Terry. A catch is still a problem of having an unsupported edge allowing a tool to roll but tool rest height is not all of the problem and for me at least locking the tool rest at one particular height would be useless.

Re: Tool rest height

#8

Re: Tool rest height

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I have listened closely to, and taken to heart, everything that Terry has said over the past few years on this subject. I don't do much spindle turning (if at all), so Terry's methods are directly applicable to the things I like to do. I have to say, I don't have catches, ever really. Inside or outside. I attribute this to paying close attention to why a tool is doing what it is doing and understanding the forces involved. Since learning Terry's handle down, bevel rubbing slicing cut method I have had absolutely zero trouble with catches and my finish cuts and forms have improved.

My general rule of thumb is - Exterior work: for roughing I set the toolrest so that my tool cuts at the spindle axis. For shaping and finishing cuts, the toolrest is set quite low, handle down, tool at 45 degree cutting angle. Interior: most all work is done with toolrest at the level which allows the tool to cut at the centerline of the spindle axis.

Re: Tool rest height

#9

Not so John

tdaniel

>What has changed in the pics you show is the angle over the toolrest; when your tool is 90 degrees to the toolrest the tool becomes trapped and cannot back out of a cut. On the other hand, if the tool is leaned against the toolrest then it can back up as necessary when encountering the tough grain or knots.

Re: Tool rest height

#10

By Jove, he has it...

tdaniel

>That is it Mike, you have it nailed. The tool is thrown out of the wood instead of being sucked into it when the tough grain comes. There are a few other causes too so for those who are interested please send a check for $500 and a stamped self addressed envelope and I will get them to you by priority mail. :)

Re: Tool rest height

#11

look again TD

John K Jordan

>>What has changed in the pics you show

>is the angle over the toolrest...

Look again. It may appear different, but no angles have changed. I used the same diagram for each case with the tool, the rest, and the work. I simply rotated the diagram. Up and down are relative.

The distance from the center of the spindle to the round tool rest is the same for each case. The contact point for the tool is the same for each case. The angle of the tool to the work is the same for each case.

The cut is determined by the angle of the tool against the work. Rotating the tool around the centerline does not change the angle. You could cut upside down if you could somehow position the tool rest and your body properly.

This may be easier to see in the diagram below. The red dots on the arc are at the contact point between the tool and the rest. I removed the vertical posts which may be confusing.

JKJ in East TN


img

Re: Tool rest height

#12

Re: Missing ingredients

Russ Fairfield

>I tried to stay out of this one, but overcame my better judgement. If I appear to be disagreeable, so be it.

I have always thought that there is too much discussion on toolrest height by beginning woodturners. They focus on that because they can, and it is an easier target to blame for their shortcomings than their failure to learn the basics of the tools and how to use them.

My opinion, for what it's worth, is that there are more important things than just the toolrest height.

The two most important ingredients are, as it applies to turning spindles, the bevel angle of the tool and the profile of the tool rest. The bevel will determine how we hold the tool to the surface of the wood, and the toolrest will influence how we move and use the tool.

Assuming that we are rubbing the bevel, as we should be when using the tool, the included tool angle between the bottom of the flute and the bevel of the gouge, or between the bevels of the skew, is important. That angle determines how we hold the tool to the wood, and whether the top surface of the tool is more tangential or more at right angles to the surface of the wood. A tool with a 25-degree angle is held very near to being tangential to the wood surface, while a tool with a greater angle is held at a greater angle to the wood surface. In the extreme (as in a "scraper") we are at a right angle to the wood surface.

That bevel angle determines how the wood is cut and the direction of the forces at the cutting edge of the tool. There are only two ways we can separate a shaving from the wood. We can either shear it off, or we can tear it off. Shearing requires less force than tearing it apart. When we are using a very small tool angle (as in the 25-degree), we are as close to shearing as possible, and the shaving slides across the top surface of the tool with very little force and almost no downward component. When we make the bevel angle larger, the tool is held at a greater angle to the flow of the wood at the surface, the cutting forces are greater, the shaving is forced to break against the top surface of the tool, and there is a larger downward force to contend with.

The lower forces from the shearing cut of the small bevel angle makes the tool more difficult to control because there is less resistance to tool movement. With the lower forces, it is easier to get into trouble with too much movement in the wrong direction, resulting in our getting off the bevel and losing control of the tool. The greater cutting forces of the blunter bevels act as a buffer against our making wrong movements. The larger forces pushing downward on the bevel makes it easier for us to "feel" the bevel and keep the tool where it should be. The downside is a worse surface finish and greater forces into the wood to cause deflection and chatter.

The profile of the tool rest determines how we move the tool as the diameter of the wood decreases. The typical tool rest has a narrow top surface that supports the tool at a fixed distance from the centerline of the lathe. This tool rest forces us to both lift the handle and slide the tool forward as we ride the bevel to the smaller diameter; and the tool overhang becomes larger as the wood gets smaller. A larger tool angle increases this sliding movement.

Contrast this with a tool rest that has a long curved shape so the handle is lifted (only) to keep the bevel riding as the diameter of the wood gets smaller. When using this rest, the contact point of support under the tool is rolled forward and the tool overhang remains the same as the the diameter of the wood gets smaller. This action is improved as the tool angle gets smaller.

The ideal would be this curved rest with a pivot to adjust for varying toolrest heights. The problem is that nobody is making anything close to such a tool rest anymore.

Moving the tool rest up and down makes it easier for us to rub the bevel from a comfortable position. As long as the distance of the support under the tool from the centerline of the lathe remains the same, there is no difference in the cutting forces relative to the wood or the tool as it rotates around the centerline of the spindle.. The only difference is the direction of those forces relative to the ground, and how we might cope with them.

Another problem in spindle turning is that you can't expect to make a proper cut on something you can't see. There is a universal tendency for the spindle to be too high for spindle turning, and the recommendation of elbow height may be too high for most of us. The higher spindle height puts us in a position of looking "into" the wood and the tool contact area, and having to look at the profile of our work over the top of the piece. A lower spindle height lets us look downward at both the profile we are cutting and the tip of the tool. With the higher spindle, there is a tendency to poke, jab, and twist the tool into the wood. With the lower spindle the tendency is towards smoothly lifting and rolling the cutting edge into the wood.

If we have trouble seeing the wood at the lower height, we might consider getting different glasses.

In the end, we do what gets the job done, works for us, and is most comfortable for us to use.

What toolrest height do I use?? I have no idea because I have never measured it. I put the tool where it cuts the best with the bevel on the wood, the handle where I can control it, and place the rest height to meet the underside of the tool. That height can change with the diamater of the piece of wood, the angle of the bevel, or the height of the spindle.

Re: Tool rest height

#13

Re: Tool rest height

Edward

>Hello Ed

What does Stuart Batty's bevel look like????

Edward

Re: Tool rest height

#14

negative rake scrapers *LINK*

Ed Moore

>There are several names by which this style scraper is known. Sorby has a hardwood scraper that is pictured in the link below. This grind is achieved by putting a flat surface on top and then grinding at a greater angle to compensate. Put a burr on the edge by burnishing the lower bevel upwards. Use it flat or slightly dropped and you will have fewer scraper catches. Some use this only for a finish cut. Frequent sharpening or burnishing is required.


Sorby hardwood scraper

Re: Tool rest height

#15

I looked again....

tdaniel

>but I still see the same thing. The angle between the tool and the wood is the same...no disagreement there; but as the handle goes higher the angle between the toolrest and the tool changes. Whenever the tool approaches 90 degrees to the toolrest you have two directly opposed forces and there can be no "give". In addition, when the handle is 90 degrees to the toolrest, any upward movement of the handle will rotate the cutting edge further into the wood which causes a small catch to "grow". This is the major cause of violent catches.

Re: Tool rest height

#16

all true but...

tdaniel

>Russ, something has been left out for years in this equation: The importance of the angle of the tool to the toolrest. The angle to the toolrest is just as important as the angle of the tool to the wood. There are many advantages to using the lower handle, one being the elimination of catches; but there are other reasons to use it. I would also add another cut that you did not list: the slicing cut. Shearing, like is done when you shave, is not a good turning cut. When the cutting edge is rotated so that it is 45 degrees to the wood it is no longer shearing but slicing, (don't try this with your razor). We should always go for the slicing cut. Another advantage of the low handle position is there is less pressure against the wood that the tool bevel is riding on so there is less burnishing or bruising. Mike, help me out here! Believe me folks, there is a lot more to this cut than many of you realize.

Re: Tool rest height

#17

Re: I looked again....

John Lucas

>Terry John Described in pictured exactly what I am saying. It sounds like you are saying that we have moved the handle in relation to the other two points. In John's drawing the triangle formed by the tool rest wood and handle remain exactly the same. If you move the handle up or down in realtion to the tool rest, without moving the tool rest then you encounter the situation you are describing.

Re: Tool rest height

#18

Re: I looked again....

John K Jordan

>>but as the handle goes higher the angle between the

>toolrest and the tool changes.

We'll just have to agree to disagree then, since the measured angle is in fact the same. Certainly the angle between the tool and the vertical toolrest support changes, but that is unimportant. A triangle drawn between the work centerline, the tool tip and the contact point on the toolrest is identical for each case.

I think you are correct about a horizontal tool being harder to control, but perhaps for a different reason. If the tool handle is horizontal and too high, the wrists must be bent forcing hands and arms held into a position which makes control difficult.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Tool rest height

#19

Re: all true but...

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Well you know I agree with you Terry. Learning to use the tool so that the majority of what I do is slicing completely changed my woodturning. I no longer wound up with 10" bowls that started out as 14" ones, for one thing! Seriously though I cannot talk about it as technically as Russ or others, once I figured out how slice a piece of wood on the lathe I was vaulted up at least a couple of notches in my turning ability.

As simple as I can put it, by holding a normal swept back flute gouge, a superflute Ellsworth in my case, held so that you rub the bevel and cut at a 45 degree angle at the same time, is like a skew for a bowl. Body movement is critical with this cut as the tool only works like a skew in a small range of motion. When I teach this cut I lower the toolrest maybe 1" below centerline. With the lathe off I show how I hold the tool first in a pull cut from the right. Tip of gouge pointing up towards ceiling. Left hand top, right hand bottom, tool handle butted up against my thigh. Put tool on rest, using front (or bottom) of hand as guide against rest, then touch the BEVEL to the work. At this point the tool should be at about a 45-50 degree angle to perpendicular from the floor. Feel the bevel ride against the surface, then rotate the flutes toward the work until the cutting edge starts to make contact. At this point I move the blank by hand to show how nice of a slice it makes, and if your gouge is properly ground, only a tiny single contact point of cutting edge is doing the work. Wings too straight and you have a scraping cut. No good.

You have to be very fluid in your body movements with this cut, which is why I like to lock the butt of the tool against my thigh. I move my body instead of moving the tool only. This gives me much more control but is difficult for a lot of people who are not used to holding the tool against their body - nearly every cut I make is with the tool tucked in under my shoulder (interior) or anchored at my thigh.

Most of my work in this manner is done with a pull cut, and since I'm pretty much ambidextrous, I can switch hands. Push cuts I don't find as effective with this method, but since I can switch hands it doesn't matter a bit.

I have not found a more productive, enjoyable tool approach than this one for an exterior of a bowl or hollow form.

Incidentally, but importantly, tool sharpness has a lot of effect on this. Sometimes a finely honed surface cuts perfectly, sometimes I need to regrind with a heavier grit stone and leave it unfinished (not honed). Depends on wood species. I find if it isn't cutting, I just change the sharpening method - sometimes sharper is not better. (never thought I'd say that)

How'd I do Terry? How is this different than your approach?

Re: Tool rest height

#20

Re: all true but...

Russ Fairfield

>Terry,

I am using "shearing" and you are using "slicing", but, we are talking about the same thing.

John and John,

What you say is true. There is no change in the angle or distance relative to the centerline of the lathe as we rotate the tool around that centerline. What does change is the orientation relative to the ground that we are standing on, and that has a direct effect on how we cope with the tool and its cutting forces.

I think we all agree that there is Helluva lot more to this than just the toolrest height. The toolrest is not the first consideration. Once all of the other factors are satisfied, the height of the tool rest takes care of itself. Even Terry's low-handle-ride-the-bevel approach to the bowl gouge works this way. He has first ground the tool profile, then determined its presentation to the wood for the best cutting action and control, and where on the wood he wanted to make that presentation. Only then is the toolrest set to support the tool.

Keith,

You can start with setting the toolrest first, and then making everything else accomodate that rest location, but I think that is a bassackwards approach to using a turning tool, and one that ignores a lot of factors that are more important than the height of the toolrest.

My nickles worth, and that ain't worth as much as it used to be.

Re: Tool rest height

#21

Re: I looked again....

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>You're absolutly right JKJ, we can see what you mean and understand it. Some concepts are difficult for some people to grasp.

Re: Tool rest height

#22

The angle between the vertical toolrest

tdaniel

>is what I am referring to. The rest of your statement and drawings are accurate but my point is the angle between the toolrest vertical support and the tool are very important. The difference is where the force is going. At the equator of the piece being turned, the wood is moving straight down against the cutting edge and the toolrest (if the tool is held level). If you directly oppose this force by having the cutting edge supported from directly below, where is this force going to go if you encounter grain that the cutting edge is not capable of cutting in a single pass?

Re: Tool rest height

#23

Re: all true but...

tdaniel

>You got it right all the way Mike. I don't tuck the tool though but that doesn't matter. For me curves just flow when I can swing the handle forward and back and up and down. The slicing cut and giving the tool the ability to back off when tough grain comes is the important part. As far as the serrated edge, lol, I had to eat those super sharp words myself a while back, er, right Mac?

Re: Tool rest height

#24

Brad Vietje

True 'nuff, but...

Brad Vietje

>True 'nuff, Ed, but the outside of a lidded box is spindle turning, while hollowing the box is really end-grain bowl (faceplate) turning. And you are right on the money -- using a scraper with a high tool rest and a downward rake on endgrain hollowing is a great way to remove the wood.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Tool rest height

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tool rest height

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ed,you are correct. The inside, such as you describe, doesn't apply. I mentioned it wasn't good on the inside of a bowl, should have said inside of a box as well. There, a high rest has the same effect as a low rest on the outside....