Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

turned vs. unturned

Posts

Re: turned vs. unturned

#26

Re: turned vs. unturned

Rick Allen

>Hi Mike

Not hollow. A wavy platter that is cut apart and glued together. She has a tenique for the wavy platter part of the turning which is interesting and presuposed that the platter will be cut along certian lines.

You are going to completly enjoy the workshop. She knows more about West System epoxy that anyone I have ever met. I asked a lot of questions and she not only answered the questions she had background for each of her answers.

If all the AAW focused on was "brown bowls" the membership would be composed of good folks that were just starting out and folks that teach such newbies. Thge rest of us would be left with no support.

The question of competition is easy. The AAW Banquet EOG Auction is a competition where "brown bowls" compeat against mostly carved items.

Good Luck

Richard

Re: turned vs. unturned

#27

Re: one more

John Lucas

>Keith Those are great. I love what you've done.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#28

Re: Pigeon Holes

John Lucas

>Jim I think allowing digital into a photo contest is good. A good photo is still a good photo if the content is there, no matter if it's shot on high speed film, 4x5 grainless film, or played with digitally. I just judged a photo contest with digital entries and only one digital placed because too much emphasis was placed on the technique rather than composition and content.

This is true with woodturning as well. You can manipulate, embellish, and surface decorate all you want but if the piece doesn't work or the form is bad it just won't hold water with the judges. I think the same is true with bowl. No matter how good the wood is if the form is bad the bowl is still bad.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#29

amem!

e

>thanks, jamie! well said.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#30

Exactly My Point John

Jim Shaver, Oakville Ontario

>Hi John,

That was what I was trying to say, you got it!!

:-)

I still love my 4x5 too!

Take care,

Jim

Re: turned vs. unturned

#31

so....what is the final word?

tdaniel

>Have we decided that unturned-turned items are to be included in AAW shows? Is AAW going to become an all inclusive art event embracing all mediums? Will we see pottery on the table along with our turnings? Might as well, there is less difference beetween a pottery wheel and a lathe than there is between a turned item and a carved item. What about the blacksmiths? Some of their tools have wooden handles that are turned or carved. Let's see, then there are the glass blowers...their product is also round and similar to turnings; I mean a good form on a piece of glass could be identical to a good form on a piece of wood. You all get my drift...no limits, no boundaries, no standards? If this is the case I will be the first to not renew my AAW membership.

TD

Re: turned vs. unturned

#32

Re: so....what is the final word?

John Lucas

>TD I think we have to draw a line between and AAW sponsored Show such as the ReTurn to Oz and the instant gallery. The AAW does set standards for the juried show by giving the judges a set of guidlines. I would assume these criteria are selected based on what they think woodturning should be at the moment, and this is probably a moving target based on what they hear from the woodturners and collectors.

The instant gallery on the other hand is purely driven by those who show up and have the will to put a piece in the show be it pure woodturning or Alabaster or metal or epoxy. If it's truely objectionable to the masses I 'm sure the person would hear about it and probably wouldn't bring something like that back. On the other hand if a piece recieves tons of praise such as Marks segmented work then you can almost guarantee you will see that work again.

I met a woman 2 years ago who was actually "turning" glass. She had a special lathe and would heat the glass and shape it as it rotated. I personally found this very interesting and think other wood turners would also. I'm sure only a few would ever consider doing this but man was it interesting and who knows there might someday be a glass turners society. I think we all grow by seeing other techniques whether or not we would try these or not. I have visited several metal spinners and can't wait until I give it a go. I'm sure you will see metal spinning on some of my wood in the future.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#33

Well John....

tdaniel

>We are back to square one. AAW=American Association of Woodturning. As far as I am concerned that can be extended to anything that is turned on a wood lathe, be it metal or glass or alabaster. I just think we have to draw some lines. Objects off metal lathes are excluded. Carved items which only use a stopped lathe as a mandrel should be excluded. For these items we should set up a table separately and call it "Other art forms" and we should definitely not use our pages of the mag to promote these arts at the expense of leaving out essential info for new wood turners. And we should not further confuse the English language with words that have no meaning. Heck, I am still trying to figure out what shear scraping means.:)

Re: turned vs. unturned

#34

Re: turned vs. unturned

Jack Savona

>I recall discussions whether woodturning is a craft or an art. For some it's one; for others the other.

As a practitioner of win-win-win, I advocate those suggestions above that allow everyone to be as happy as possible thru a logical compromise. When I see most turned pieces, I can say: "That was turned". Some, like Keith's rose, I'll say, "That was turned?!!!" For others I'll say: "That looks like it was JUST carved."

In any event I want to be able to appreciate it for its craftsmanship (PC: craftspersonship) and beauty. A well done piece can elevate and inspire me.

Question: What should be allowed in competition? The older I get, the less competition means to me. But, for those who find it important, I like the suggestions of separate categories, as many as needed for win-win-win. (Lathe only, lathe+, wood only, wood+, non-wood, etc.)

Question: Content of AAW magazine? Why not take a hint from my DARKROOM magazine which became PHOTO TECHNIQUES. Maybe we should look at the AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF TURNERS magazine. For now the bulk of info could be on WOOD, with occasional articles on alabaster, epoxies, metal, glass,etc.. At the Totally Turnining Expo last year, I attended a demo on metal spinning. Not my cup of tea at the moment, but in my arsenal of training info.

If we enjoy the fulfillment of turning, some of us may like to branch out to other media, other ways to enhance our turnings. An some may not. If we make each OK, it's win-win-win and we can benefit from each other's experience with forms, finishes, tools, techniques, etc.. The bowlturner can be appreciated for his/her work (and I still use many of you for my vision), or his/her creative exploration (my incite and excitement).

Whatever this forum and AAW evolve into, I hope it will allow for each of us to be a winner.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#35

Ain't No Jury and The Judge

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>has done gone fishin',Terry.

"We", the posters and lurkers one of the outstanding internet turning fora (WC), are not going to be deciding anything on this board.

The way to do this is, in my view, not by ventilating our opinons in a chat room or internet site (including WC and the AAW forum)and then expecting them to filter through cyberspace to those "running" the AAW. Rather, the way to effect change is to write to the organisation's Board and administrators with specific constructive suggestions. Tell them WHY you don't think wooden slippers fit in a juried show on turning. Tell'em that a carved wooden half-eaten hotdog or 1st baseman's mitt will not be welcomed in next year's "Step Up To The Plate" show. We're not in Kansas anymore!!

To anticipate Jamie's comment, if anyone here really cares about the direction the AAW is going, get involved and make your voice actually heard. Don't sit out on the internet and merely post opinions expecting to accomplish anything, do something about what you don't like, push for what you do. Our beliefs and opinions, so easily expressed/vented on any number of websites, are most likely (but probably wrongly) to be viewed as just so much talk by people who aren't prepared or willing to contribute anything more; "We" will be ignored, our "pearls" never seen. There are more than a few very literate and articulate members on this forum with clear-cut views on issues at the core of the AAW and the craft/artform it promotes. Those views will be put to especially good use in submitting articles to the Journal and reaching the 10,000 plus members. This is not to say everybody has to run for office or the Board to be taken as serious or valid in their concerns. Get some thought-out comments AND SUGGESTIONS in Phil Brennion's box with regard to what you want more or less of in the Journal and at the Symposium. If you get no response, go to the membership; e-mail is free and the Directory is full of addresses.

An important opinion and message that isn't communicated to the full audience is kind of like wetting your pants in a dark suit. It's a nice warm feeling, but nobody except your dry cleaner is going to notice.

M

Re: turned vs. unturned

#36

Re: turned vs. unturned

JamieDonaldson

>Mark and Jack- right on!!!!

Re: turned vs. unturned

#37

Re: Well John....

john Lucas

>Terry What about the ornamental turners who use ivory? See it gets more confusing all the time. An ornamental lathe is a very small step from a metal lathe. Then there's the Super Shop made by Smithy. this is a woodlathe,metal lathe, and table saw combination. You could turn almost anything on that.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#38

Very good Point! .

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>

Re: turned vs. unturned

#39

Re: Ain't No Jury and The Judge (Long)

Tim Grenville-Cleave

>As a Lurker from the other side of the pond, my opinion in this debate counts for less than 2 of your cents or for that matter 2 of our pence (Long live the £).

However here it is anyway!!!

Mark's post makes the most sense of all to me, (no offence intended to anyone) I speak as someone whose Countries Sovereignty and National identity could well disapear soon. If you want to change /stop change the only way is to get out and do something about it not sit on the proverbial Butt and sound off. That said, there is nothing wrong with a good old democratic (as in Democracy not Political Party) discussion / arguement.

So, can someone throw a double six, make a decision and get back to chatting about tips, tools, methods, results, gloats, chainsaws, bandsaws, oh and not forgetting lathes, gouges, hollowing tools, power sanding, finishing, grinds (Ignore the last one, far to open to heated discussion!!!) not forgetting anything I have forgotten to mention!!!!!

OK OK I shall shut up now and crawl back into my little shell scrape from whence I came.

Regards to all

Tim

aka The WobblyBootneck

p.s. Mike S. the platter arrived it's Brill!! Customs held it for 5 months. They could'nt work out why I would want a piece of wood.!!

Hi Bill G. the DVD is way beyond amazing! now I am even more determined to meet you!!

Re: turned vs. unturned

#40

Re: Ain't No Jury and The Judge (Long)

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Oh my gosh! 5 months! I wondered why I hadn't heard from you in a while. I hope you are pleased. If not, I offer a full money back garuntee!

Tim got this one....one of my first few turnings actually. I tried to talk him out of it as I could see sanding scratches I wouldn't tolerate these days.


Re: turned vs. unturned

#41

Re: Ain't No Jury and The Judge

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Mark, very well put! I'm curious about the nature of the letter you would send, or do you consider yourself satisfied with the way things are going?

Me, honestly, I wouldn't change much. The current status suits my personal goals just fine, but I do not believe it suits the majority of the AAW membership.

I would like to see two special exhibits next year for Louisville - both juried, one where non traditional methods would be prevalent, and one where beautifully crafted bowls and other vessels could be displayed with equal prominence. I would hold the "invited artists" up to the same standards as the juried artists, not simply accept whatever they happen to submit.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#42

Mark is correct

tdaniel

>Good thinking Mark. We have aired our feelings, now it is time to put it in writing and send it to the AAW. Now let's move on to other topics as has been suggested.

Thanks to Mike for starting this debate and making us express our feelings in words. This argument has been going on for several years that I know of and seems to be getting more intense each year, alienating a lot of turners, so perhaps the AAW will deal with it before the next symp. Let's get the pens out (wooden, lathe turned pens that is) folks and put some thoughts in the mail as Mark has suggested.

TD

Re: turned vs. unturned

#43

Keith Tompkins

Re: turned vs. unturned

Keith Tompkins

>Mike,you bring up some valid points...a turned bowl is a thing of beauty in its own right. A well turned bowl should be a part of the critique process, yet they are usually ignored.

There is a downside to all the carving and embellishing that's going on.....in their rush to produce "art" many turners haven't taken the time to hone their turning skills. The result is still evident....poor form, torn grain, etc. An understanding of form and good turning skills are the foundation of everything else.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#44

full agreement on this

tdaniel

>Keith, I too think this is what so many of us have been saying in this thread. There is an unbalance being perpetuated that is causing people to jump toward embellishments before mastering basic form and tool skills. I just had a regular customer/collector in my shop this morning and we looked at some photos of some of the carved and pierced work in the mags. She saw some that she liked but some she immediately saw as being of poor form. Her comment was that some of the pieces shown might as well have been made from plastic because there was no wood character showing...no grain, no natural wood colors, nada. By the way, she purchased the Russ inspired hollow form that I just posted photos of the other day. It had some flutes cut in the neck opening and some dye to bring out the grain but there was plenty of mother nature left in it. There will be meat in the beans this month!

TD

Re: turned vs. unturned

#45

Re: My Letter

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Mike,

Since I saw very little work at the Symposium not attributable to the lathe as a central influence, I'm not in what I would term "letter-writing mode" because I don't view the carvers (and resin workers, etc.) as more than rather minor branchs off the main stream. Non-ruby slippers (or pumps) aside, even some very heavily carved pieces, Dave Bowers' Tornado and ribbon-forms come to mind along with Andi Wolfe's leaves, were clearly derived from and dependent upon the initial lathe work for their basic form. I think a serious move to exclude or limit those who seek to push the bounderies of turning beyond bowls, vases, and jars will ultimately doom the organization to a death-by-apathy.

I spent a bunch of time in the KC Instant Gallery; far more than I would have if it had been 5 long tables' worth of bowls and hollowforms. Regardless of how well they were done, seeing the same kind of thing over and over would have become rather boring to me in rather short order.

Every one of the seminars that I looked in on (other than the discussion sessions) had a lathe spinning and chips flying so I see no danger of "turning" getting lost in the shuffle of high speed drills, reciprocating carvers, and burning sets.

If, however, I were to see the gallery change and the demoes shift from actual turning to a significant content of other forms of wood-art, I'd probably reasses whether the AAW was the place for my $40. If I felt possessive enough about the organisation and its original goals, I'd be making some noises in protest. Not picketing the Symposium in a sandwich board, mind you, but letting my opinion be heard by the boat's captain and crew nontheless.

Now, which chuck should I buy?

|;-}}

Re: turned vs. unturned

#46

Re: PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Mike,

As for your suggestion on "invited" artists, I view the AAW's being an inclusive group as one of its core purposes. It's well and good to have a juried theme show with presubmissions to "get in," but I'd be very opposed to anything further that begins to sound like filtering or exclusionary policy. The great tradition of the IG is its being open to all who attend the Symposium. That feature of the annual gathering is, in my view, key in setting the tone for the whole organisation; change it and the thing can just as well be another mutual admiration society for a bunch of elitist snobs in serous need of a good proctologist. I took my stuff just to see how I was doing in comparison with the "real turners." I was truly shocked when my piece actually got picked for part of the Critique, but just having that opportunity by being able to put my work out on a table with others was a serious part of the allure of the Symposium.

Mark

Re: turned vs. unturned

#47

Keith Tompkins

Re: full agreement on this

Keith Tompkins

>Hi TD, The article I just finished deals directly with that problem...thanks for the input.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#48

Re: PS

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Oh no I wouldn't ever consider suggesting that. I was trying to say that the invited turners in the themed/juried exhibit (Oz) were less inclined to turn anything to do with OZ (granted my piece was a stretch, too), but it appeared that some of them, regardless of how wonderful their work was, simply picked a piece off the shelf and said to themselves "what kind of story can I come up with to make this fit in with the Wizard of Oz?", and it is accepted without question. I guess you don't invite someone to be juried though! If I, an unknown turner, or you perhaps, or anyone not known by name in elite turning/collecting circles submitted something that had absolutely zero connection with Oz it would have been turned away, regardless of its technical or artistic merit. I suppose that is one benefit of having achieved fame - one's name is a crowd draw as well as one's work. I don't begrudge them that at all, and in fact seek it, but I heard a lot of people in that Oz gallery saying "what does this have to do with Oz?" I say that realizing I'm kind of doing a pot/kettle/black but my work really was created with Oz in mind.

BTW, I thought the "ruby slipper" and the turned wizard's baloon were the two best pieces in that exhibit, even though the slipper had never been near a lathe.

I would not want to suggest changing the instant gallery in any way, shape or form.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#49

Re: Oz

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Gotcha. Misunderstood the juried/invitational context.

Also thought there was a bit of stretching on the subject matter. Movie's images were a tough act to follow. Still haven't decided if those petals were carved or applied.

M

Re: turned vs. unturned

#50

Keith Tompkins

Re: PS

Keith Tompkins

>Mike, you bring up another good point....I don't believe there should be ANY invited turners in such an exbibit as "OZ". In fact, the slides should be viewed anonomyously; sorted into two groups (yes or no), and the names revealed only at that time. That way, ALL turners submitting pieces have the same chance, and the "known" turners cannot depend on previous work to get them into exhibitions. They will have to use their imagination and come up with new material if they wish to participate. By including known turners who submit pieces that don't relate to the theme, many pieces that deserve to be included are not. Fair is fair.

I suppose there is a certain "draw" when known turners are represented in an exhibit, but there are plenty of other shows that are "invitation only". Most turners have no chance of being selected, or even have knowledge of these shows until the event is in progress.