Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

turned vs. unturned

Posts

turned vs. unturned

#1

Keith Tompkins

turned vs. unturned

Keith Tompkins

>I read with great interest the thread on what constitutes a turning or not. I'll share a few of my thoughts. The field of "wood art" developed as a direct result of people pushing the limits of the lathe, and ultimately their own limits. Wood art is not going away, in fact may be a large driving force behind the tremendous growth in woodturning.

Personally, I have been a turner for years, lots of furniture parts, some art stuff. I was unaware of the AAW and the trends in turning. I happened to see a few books books at Barnes and Noble on contemporary wood turning........BANG!! I showed the books to my wife "Look what these people are turning!" Some pieces bore an eerie resemblance to things I had produced years ago...I wasn't intimidated by the work at all; in fact, I could see myself fitting right in. I joined the AAW instantly. Not just for turning, the artistic element is what excited me. THIS IS WHAT I WANTED TO DO!

I knew how to carve...I knew how to turn...I could apply a good finish. What would happen if i combined all of these things? It seemed that the possibilities were endless. I know I am not the only one who thinks this way..thousands upon thousands of others do also.

The big question is....can both turning and art exist under one roof? I think the AAW is aware of their roots, but on the other hand, is not about to toss out the fastest growing segment in the art field. I think turning should be put into categories:pure turning, embellished turning, and open (wood art) turning. All three categories should receive equal respect and representation. The AAW needs all of us in order to succeed.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#2

Re: turned vs. unturned

RonZ

>The following is my opinion only and only food for thought. There is no intention to influence an opinion nor change anyones views.

I think the original question was; should a fully carved piece be shown on a turning forum. I like Mike's work and don't mind seeing it. It would be a courtesy, such as Mike did, to state in the post that it was fully carved is my only caveat. In general, I think its like a motorcycle showing up to a bike race. They both have two wheels, a seat, handle bars, forks, etc. they're both a means to get from point A to point B yet a bicycle would not like to compete with a motorcycle even if you're Lance Armstrong. While people might only think of a lathe as only a tool as a means to their end product, many turners such as myself look at the lathe as the main vehicle to develop their work and will use it as much as possible. A saw, sander, grinder are all parts of a turning but they are singular tools that is a means to an end. Whereas if one were to make a piece from start to finish on a bandsaw, then he can consider himself a bandsawer [?] which would be a unique title for him/her to be proud of.

There is no question that there is room for many other forms of wood art that would fit under the rubrick of turning although I would like to see them as embellishments instead of a piece that was 5% turned and 95% carved classified as a turning.

It is becoming such that you can't see the forrest for the trees. You are getting a large segment of the new turning populus getting discouraged. They have no idea how they are going to get their simple bowl to be a a vessle with feathers all over it or leaves shaped like a bowl. You also discourage professional turners from displaying their wares, too. A turner who does it as a living usually has no time to turn out such pieces that will make little or no return on their time invested. When I met with Richard Raffan and we were discussing this topic, we came to the conclusion that to the best of our knowledge, almost all turners that produce work that the embellishments are in a higher ratio to the actual parts turned, all have full time jobs to support themselves. For example, Jack Vesserey has a full time job and his wife clocked his first carved piece out at 55 hours. I am also a member of the old school where I feel it is necessary to master basic skills before moving on to the next level or delving into the abstract. Just as famous painters such as Van Gough mastered painting before moving on to his signature works, you can have a novice and a professional present a turned box and they'll look identical. The novice did it over the weekend while the pro did it in an hour. While the novice should be applauded for his work but what happens to the recognition for the professional?

As you stated, I'm happy to embrace all exisiting and new additions to turning but I feel that you need catagories such as turning, embellished turning, and open (wood art) turning. I would think however that just because a turner does carving that it should be presented at a turning show. You won't see for example, Del Stubs carvings at a turning exhibit.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#3

Balance

tdaniel

>I think this entire thread is trying to address a problem that some do not want to accept. We see the AAW mag or we go to a symposium and we see more embellishments than turning skills presented. We have had a few demonstrators at our club who taught how to embellish turnings with various techniques and each time we get a lot of complaints from members who say they aren't ready for that, they are still trying to develope the skills to turn a nice bowl. Maybe we should either separate the various turning forms or see to it that plenty of good turnings with good finishes and few enhancements are also represented. I would have no problem with a table set aside for "non-turned wood art" unless it was called "unturned-turned wood art".

TD

Re: turned vs. unturned

#4

Film vs. digital

Jack Savona

>As I read the comments on the shades of turning, I'm reminded of the (r)evolution of digital photography. As a film purist, I hated to see my darkroom magazines include articles on Photoshop and publish digitally embellished photos. If you make a collage of photos, alter colors, create rippled effects, blur details, clone, erase, etc., is it still a photograph?

I don't know if the jury is back on that one either. Have you been to a Photo Gallery lately? Silver gelatin and digital prints are side by side.

As a photographer I hated what this new electronic art was doing to my pure art. Over time I guess I have adapted, purchased a digital SLR, messed around with Photoshop, and even printed one of my slides on watercolor paper. It's still not the same. Yes, I'm using all the skills I did in the past as the basis of each photo, but it's a different art medium.

Perhaps what's different with the digital revolution is that more people use this new medium. With the turning revolution (pun recognized) my guess is that less will do it, although in growing numbers.

I offer no solution, just the observation of a parallel experience.

While I'm still doing bowls and other basic turnings (read 'film'), but I do enjoy seeing what others do beyond me (from wood selection to segmented hollowforms, to carving,....). Who knows? Someday...?

We just need to remember there'll always be 'film' folks like me out there who enjoy the creative darkroom experience. (You know I can't wait to teach photography and darkroom to my grandkids...after they learn woodturning.)

As far as an occasional carving post: If we can occasionally share new chainsaws, pick-ups, and pets with each other and offer warm personal responses to the posts..., why not?

Jack Savona

P.S. I dismantled my darkroom so I could have more woodturning space. It's the addiction!

Re: turned vs. unturned

#5

Re: turned vs. unturned

john Lucas

>Keith

I think very much like you in that I see the wood as a canvas. Some times a good bowl is the best way to show that piece of wood but sometimes what's in my mind has to come out and wood is the medium I choose to work with.

As I look over the symposium photos one thing comes to mind. People seem to like to embellish thier work. In the symposium in Florida there were probably 300,to 500 or more turnings brought in by all sorts of people from professional on down. Most were embellished in some form. I think the reason is people want to show off work that that they are most proud of. If this happens to be a bowl made from great wood that's what they bring but most bring work that has been altered in other ways. That tells me that they enjoy that sort of work themselves. Why else would you make it.

As far as selling work that is more art than utility, that depends on your market. Someone stated that most art turners are creating that work because someone else is supporting them. That is the case for almost all professional woodturners. I don't necessarilly say they need supporting but a second income is necessary and that's just a fact of life. Wood art is starting to actually remove this second income barrier by getting prices for work that will help the artist survive on his/her own income. I will say that not all of us will be able to reach those markets. Do all guitar player end up rock stars? Life goes on and you have to either find your market or make your work fit your market. Personally I'm looking for a wealthy woman to support me (yea right).

Every symposium we get the same question that Terry stated. There are too many embellishment or advanced demos. Well when you have a demo on basic bowl turning the demos don't fill. Imagine a club where all we did was basic bowl and finish demos. It would die. You need the other demos. People want to advance. They don't want to be put down because they only make bowls, but I think everyone wants to make a better bowl. Maybe they don't want to go as far as Gold leaf and feathers or turned hats but I can't believe everyone is happy making the same old bowl all the time. Keith has the right idea in teaching form and design but that only takes beginners so far before they want to experiment and add feet or carve a rim and there you go there off into the world of embelishment. You need that growth.

What I try to stress in my demos is too basics and tool usage as well as advanced techniques. Hopefully this helps the beginners and also gives the advanced turners some ideas to use in their work.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#6

Well Said, Jack!

Clem Wixted

>

Re: turned vs. unturned

#7

Re: turned vs. unturned

Mike Schwing from Md.

>This sure beats "which gouge is better" - but thats an important topic, too.

Of all of the things in that instant gallery at the KC symposium, these 3 pieces were my absolute favorites. They are 3 bowls by David Lancaster that in my opinion, have no peers. I love and admire all of the fancy carvings, paintings, etc.. and obviously have tried to develop my own style using those same kinds of enhancements, but it is these 3 bowls that I could not pass by without stopping to examine them in detail. I know for a fact that I spent more time admiring them than anything else in that gallery.

I also agree and disagree with RonZ on the idea that the multiple skills involved/required to get noticed discourages turners - it discouraged me for about 30 seconds and then I set about learning, learning, learning. Same thing I did learning to turn a bowl, just lots more to learn. I'm sure it discourages some, but encourages others as a great challenge.

Here's David's 3 beautiful maple burl bowls. If I had a spare $3000 I would have bought them.


My other favorite is this piece by Marylin Campbell. It encompasses all of the style, skill, and ingenuity I hope to one day possess. Two quite different works, but the distance between them is what I consider the world of woodturning. The white part (holly) is fully turned, by the way.


Re: turned vs. unturned

#8

Woodturning vs Wood Art

Stuart Johnson

>In my opinion this shows the difference between woodturning and wood art. One photo shows the quality of the wood and the skill of the turner. The other shows nothing of the wood but does show the artist's skill.

As I stated once before when this came up... dog breeders agree on the rules covering each breed and are then able to judge each dog by those appropriate breed rules. These rules also slowly evolve over time, a new breed might be introduced or size modified but they are agreed upon. As a result of agreed standards they can judge breeds against each other for best of show.

Without such guides how can these items be judged against each other? Personally, I would much rather own one of the Lancaster bowls as opposed to the Marylin Campbell piece. But, that is a personal choice and has nothing to do with the quality of one over the other.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#9

Re: Woodturning vs Wood Art

John Lucas

>Stuart I agree 100 percent when it comes to competition. Apples against apples is the only fair way. However when it comes to defining turning that's a whole different ball game. I still submit that all turning, however much embellished is worth looking at and talking about. You don't have to like it but it does spark some conversation and makes you think about what the turner, or artist if you wish, was thinking.

For example I didn't like Todd Hoyers work at all when I first saw photos of it. Then I saw the work in person and listened to Todd explain why he does it and it all made sense. The work had more of a sense of balance and proportion and you could feel the tension in the work. It was great and I really admire the work now. What If I had never been exposed to that style of work. I would still be living in my little shell. There are works out there that I don't like. I still think being exposed to it is interesting even if I say to myself I don't want to do anything like that. At least I looked and made the choice.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#10

Pigeon Holes

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Keith,

After reading all of what was posted and some of the thoughts of many all I can say is the Beatles song "Let It Be" kept coming to mind.

I am a confessed brown bowl - pen - spindle furniture part guy.

Like Jack said perfectly well, I too am a film guy with a digital tool that I now use too. I manage a company photo contest, I bring in professional judges to view the work. two years ago they asked why our contest was still only film based (over 200 entries). I had my committee rethink the process and last year we let digital in. Some of the members struggled with allowing this, but the results were incrediblein 2004. We all learnt that times change and things happen...and for the better the entry levels not only increased (300+) but the quality of the compositions improved...the judges were blown away too!

I will never loose what makes me happy in my wood or my photography, but I do feel strongly that we need to enjoy watching the work of those who can step out of the moulds and make what we dare to even imagine, who cares what they used to make it, enjoy the result!

So "Let It Be" and who cares about labels, machines-tools used and provenance...enjoy the results and have fun!

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: turned vs. unturned

#11

Re: turned vs. unturned -- Amazing Bowls

Dave Fuqua

>I would have stared at those bowls for a long time had I been there in person. They are amazing. I would be afraid with my current skills and tools to turn wood that looked that good.

On the other hand, if you had a spare $3,000 would you really get the bowls or some tool(s) that have been calling you;)?

Dave

Re: turned vs. unturned

#12

Re: Film vs. digital

Gerry in Maryland

>Jack,

My fingernails aren’t black from “Pyro” developer now. I miss my darkroom too.

My digital camera has a Leica lens. But my Leica still takes better “Photogragphs”.

Gerry

Re: turned vs. unturned

#13

Re: turned vs. unturned -- Amazing Bowls

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Honestly, I would have bought the bowls over a tool! I have really been enjoying seeing my collection of other turners' work grow. Every few months I have a new piece from someone I know and admire, and whether it be in the form of a trade or a purchase, its always a good deal. David's bowls would be a proud addition to my "friends" gallery.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#14

Re: turned vs. unturned

Keith Newton

>< Personally I'm looking for a wealthy woman to support me (yea right). >

John, If you find her, see if she has a sister.

All of this is good, and insightful. I would just like to remind everyone that this is not a competitive sport. There are no winners or losers. Everyone should strive to do what makes themselves feel the best that they can about their own work.

For some, it may be turning out simple bowls as fast as they can to give away. For others there may be a steady flow of creative ideas screaming to be liberated from the confines of their head-bones.

Each of us should do whichever makes us most happy, or keeps us from going crazy. Ha ha Ha ha. I guess you know which side I fall into by now.

I have never been to any shows, so as a way to introduce myself, I will post a shot or two. Oh by the way, this is my job, and I don't have a wife or family money. Life would have been much easier if I had chosen to drive a truck.


img

Re: turned vs. unturned

#15

Re: one more

Keith Newton

>Is ther a way to post more than one shot at a time here?


img

Re: turned vs. unturned

#16

Re: turned vs. unturned

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I have some questions on form and technique on the Marylin Campbell form. I can only see it in two dimensions, since I was not there, but it is fascinating.

When viewed from the top, is it round or football shaped? In other words, did she cut the holly bowl up into two or four pieces or is it entire? Is the black part ebony or some composite? (It seems I saw somewhere that it is epoxy, but my memory plays tricks on me sometimes, and It could as easily be ebony.) I can see that the piercings in the black stop before going all the way through the holly on the four quadrants, but they appear to go all the way through on the front and back band. Do they also go all the way through on the two side bands? Any idea how this piece might have been made?

This piece of turned art certainly works for me, as do some other technically complicated pieces, whether the wood and whatever has been added to it was cut up and glued back together before or after it was turned. It still retains the purity of the holly's form and color, even when captured and held by the black forms.

OTOH, I like the burl bowls, too. I assume all three must have been cored from the same burl. In that case, the most important concept to me is to let the figure of wood show. Three bowls together emphasize that the figure extended all the way through the original block of wood. Here the artist shows us as much of the original burl as he possibly can, including an idea of its original mass, and without leaving most of it on the floor of his studio or confusing us with too much superfluous embellishment.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#17

Thinking Outside of the Round, Betty Scarpino *LINK*

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Thanks to Jennifer Shirley I have learned about and admired the work of Betty Scarpino. Betty is considered one of the more talented turners in America. I like her work because she thinks outside of the round. Carving her turnings is a major aspect of her work now.

Does somebody want to challenge her work as "not turning"? I sure wouldn't!

Here is a link...

Tommy


http://www.bettyscarpino.com/

Re: turned vs. unturned

#18

Ditto On That Tommy

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Tommy,

I have to agree with you (some one take a picture). A number of years ago I was a memeber of the Rochester Woodworking Society. Betty came down to the RWS to give a short seminar on just what she does. After sitting through her talk I held a few of her works in my hands, they were incredible!

Since then I know I have looked at carved work from a different prospective, the process yields a result, but the emotion a piece gives is what lasts in your thoughts.

Take care,

Jim

Re: turned vs. unturned

#19

Re: Pigeon Holes

JamieDonaldson

>I am pleased this thread continues without using it as a forum for AAW bashing. Defining catagories, definitions,etc. is a process that delineates boundries, and ask yourself as an artist " do I want to be confined to this box?" I personally think that an object called a turning should have been worked on a lathe at some stage of creation, but where do we define the limits- 1%, 10%, 100%? There will always be factions within any large group that champion their own area of interest, and the success of an organization is dependant upon blending those various factions into a homogenous group that can work for the greater good of all those involved. Changing such an organization is better achieved by working constructively from within, not standing outside casting stones.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#20

Re: turned vs. unturned

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I can't speak definitively for Marylin's piece (I'll see if I can get her to respond here) but I believe the holly piece is turned and hollowed then cut apart. When viewed from top, the fully turned piece must have resembled a torque converter from an automotive transmission, for lack of a better comparison. Or perhaps a donut!

The black material is epoxy. I am taking a workshop with her in October where she says I'll learn the technique. I CAN'T WAIT for that as it will give me some new tools to make things that are stuck in my imagination now with no way to get them into 3 dimensional creations.

Her work is truly exquisite. The caliber of defintion and detail she is capable of is rarely seen in woodworking. I would put it more in line with fine jewelry work. If I had to choose one person who's mastery of technical detail I would like to achieve, it would be her.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#21

Posting multiple pictures & links *PICS* *LINK*

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Keith,

You asked, Is there a way to post more than one shot at a time here?

Yes, there is, but it takes a couple of other skills and resources. When you upload the photo using the automatic tool on the Post Response page, it is stored on WC's website, on Ellis's server. To display pictures right in the text of your message, first, you have to upload the pictures somewhere onto a website, so you can access them with a URL. Usually, you would use FTP (File Transfer Protocol) to do this. Then you have to write the HTML statements that display the picture into the message you post. For example, the last pic that you uploaded could be displayed in another message, like this one, by putting the following code in the message text box in the Post Response window:

<img src="http://www.woodcentral.com/content/vpix_tu/pic79447.jpg">

This statement results in the display of this picture:


Two more useful HTML examples: The webmaster who built your Tree Tales Studio website uploaded many photos to your server. You could display any of them in a WC message by writing the appropriate HTML statement. For example, to display your tupelo burl hollow form, you would write the following statement:

<img src="http://www.treetales.com/gallery/Current%20Works/current/images/100-0031_IMG.jpg">

It results in the display of this picture:


If you wanted to include a link to your website that would automatically open in another window, as I did above, you would write the following HTML statement:

<a href="http://www.treetales.com/"target="_BLANK">Tree Tales Studio</a>

To open the link in the same window, just omit the target="_BLANK" part of the statement.

Hope this helps, even though you probably got more new questions than answers.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#22

Re: turned vs. unturned

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Thanks. Please let us know what you learn.

I like epoxy. Not as much as I like wood, but you sure can do some incredible things with wood and epoxy that wood just won't do all by itself.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#23

Mike, both of these are great examples of "turned"

tdaniel

>and should be included in a woodturning gallery.

Re: turned vs. unturned

#24

Re: Woodturning vs Wood Art

Ed in No.VA

>Sturat Johnson brought up the topic of Agreed Standards. This is exactly what is done at fairs. I entered the Virginia State Fair last year for the experience and found that turnings were catagorized.

There were bowls, hollowforms, platters, boxes and containers,vases, turnings with surface treatment or decoration and turning other. There were first places in each category with several seconds and thirds. each first in a category were then judged against each other for best of show. The winner was a very nice turning of a hat from the turning other category.

This style of judging is quite common especially where apples and oranges compete for the same prize.In turning we have several standards that are use in critique. Form,line,finish etc.that are used to judge our selves. this could be the basis for determining standards to work to if we so desired.

Not my idea just an observation.

Ed

Re: turned vs. unturned

#25

Re: Film vs. digital

JamieDonaldson

>Jack- after 40 yrs. in a darkroom, this Epson black box will never be the same as a real darkroom to me either, especially since I am not geek enough to really be able to troubleshoot the problems. But I also remember the similar situation when color printing came along in the late 60's and began to take over market share from good ol' silver gelatin monochromes!