Re: Sorry Mike, I cut and pasted & still messed it
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
>Jamie, I think you need to go back and do some reading again on this thread, and maybe on some others. First of all, if you want to disagree with the posts made by some, that is fine, but to say that they are of marginal value is just another way of saying that your perspective is the only one. Say you disagree or say that you think we are misinformed, but the way you put it is quite adversarial and denigrates those with whom you disagree.
No one is trashing the AAW here in this thread. Some of us are arguing for truth in advertising and nothing more. Regardless of what you think about the AAW and how you react to these threads, you have to accept that this is a perception that is gaining ground, and if there are a number of people who feel and think the same way, it needs to be examined. At the very least you need to ask why so many people are starting to think this way rather than just say that their opinions are of marginal value.
Lets review for a moment. Mike posted a very provocative note, and he got a reaction. There are those of us who think that things should be labeled more clearly. No one has said that people shouldn't be allowed to create the art they wish to create, or that artists of a certain ilk should not be allowed in the AAW. There have been a number of thoughtful posts on both sides of the issue. But look at some of the reactions to the posts critical of the things Mike has noted.
Fred, whoever he is, has labeled people as whiners and dragged out an old platitude of questionable value, with absolutely no constructive comments at all. Where is the value in this contribution? I don't see it, regardless of whose "side" he is on. He has a right to whatever opinion he wants to hold, but calling names on the playground? What good does it do beyond provoking people instead of thought?
Nelson has assured us that "Intelligance will previll." (sic) I don't even want to touch this one, but it has been hard, let me tell you.
Now you come in to tell us that our opinions are of marginal value because we have never been to a symposium. So what? I read the journal, and I read the forums. Quite frankly I do not have the time or the money to travel to a national symposium. It is going to be a stretch for me to go to Albany this year, but I am going mainly to see what it is all about. When I look at the offerings I can attend rotations labeled for beginners or go to see someone who I really do not care to see because of artistic and political sensibilities. But why does any of this prevent me from airing my opinion? Why should I be required to attend a symposium to air my opinon of my experiences? I have seen what I have seen, and why do I need to spend time and money if I am not convinced that more of the same is going to be worth my while?
But this thread is not even about this stuff, it is just about asking people to be truthful about who and what they are. I wrote it once in this thread already, but it bears repeating: to take an object that has spent a small fraction of its time on the lathe and call it turned is the same as calling a turned bowl "chainsawed" since it spent some time being sawn into a rough blank. It simply is not accurate. It would be like taking a cabinet and calling it "planed". Sure planing took place, but it was not the majority of the work.
We can argue this until the last tree is cut down and not see eye to eye, but it is discouraging to see people marginalized because one disagrees with their opinion. Attack an idea or a statement to your heart's content, but please leave the person out of it.
Bill