Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

a response from the carving forum

Posts

Re: a response from the carving forum

#26

Re: No confusion at all

Dinyar Chavda

>Mike:

You said: It appears that the AAW has decided the opposite to what you are describing. They seem to be saying "as long as the ARTIST is a woodturner, anything goes".

If that is what "they" have decided, then that is truly one of the most self-delusional definitions I've encountered in a while. It implies that a person can call anything he/she creates a turning, so long as he/she calls himself/herself a turner (this gender-correct stuff is for the birds!) So the public is supposed to look at something, and first find out what the creator calls himself, before deciding what it is. And I thought I was confused when I saw my first Andy Warhol!

Note, again, that I am not questioning freedom of artistic creation. I am just asking for some rationality in the definition and use of a term.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#27

Re: a response from the carving forum

Don Henthorn

>I will freely admit that I am an old stick-in-the mud and proud of it. Looking back in history every great civilization has crumbled, usually from within. The crumbling always is caused by people who are convinced that they are smarter than anyone who preceded them and they can vastly improve upon the standard ways things are being done. The untried methods they introduce are emotionally promising but realistically founded on no proven experience. The uncertainty caused by the unproven directions destroy people's confidence in their leaders and themselves and things just fall apart.

This is my first year with the AAW and it will be my last. When the name of the organization is no longer associated with the activitives it sponsors, it has lost it's focus. It should change its name to the American Association of Wood Artists and be honest about who it is.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#28

Re: a response from the carving forum

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Don, less than 2 years ago I would have said the exact same thing! Exactly. Those could have easily been my own words. But then something happened - I ventured out of my own little safety net (not saying this about anyone other than me!) of what I knew - bowls, platters, hollow forms, and I haven't found my way back in. Not really trying though, to be honest.

I have none of the answers about this situation, and agree that it is a very contentious issue the AAW needs to come to terms with, but I do love the discussion.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#29

Re: a response from the carving forum

Mac

>Is this a hoot or what!!......Makes for a good weekend......

Re: a response from the carving forum

#30

Re: a response from the carving forum

Mac

>Even got Terry out of the recliner.......

Re: a response from the carving forum

#31

why does AAW have to ...

Fred

>"...come to terms with it" ... ??? I don't understand why all this emotional whining?

Seems there are those folks who enjoy the technical aspect of turning (what lathe, what new tools are out there, who wants to play with me, how can i make this a better tool, etc.)

However, they don't seem to post pictures much of their work, and yet seem to do most of the belly-aching about those who do display their work.

Seems as if the ole' saying of 'those who CAN do; those who CAN'T teach' is being professed here.

If you don't want to be a part of the 'artsy' AAW group (whatever name they call themselves), why not create your own group for all the folks who just like to play with the tools?

And then you can leave all those artsy folks alone to create some of their beautiful stuff.

And then the whining would stop ... but I doubt it.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#32

Chat room discussion?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Russ, I've not been a member of AAW long enough to understand where they came from, but I would agree with you and the others that it should not lose sight of its roots and where it came from. I feel like they should keep those so called "brown bowls" which I stated that I dearly love, just as important as the wild and creative displays of turning that we see today. I'm not sure how to accomplish that, but it seems that there's a lot of talented and passionate people in this organization to help keep it accessible to all styles of turning.

What about a discussion on this topic? Perhaps invite the board of directors from AAW to join in?

Jennifer

Re: a response from the carving forum

#33

Fred, who is against "artsy"?

tdaniel

>No one has posted anything against "artsy". The post was whether or not a piece that was not turned on a lathe can be called a turning. If AAW does not represent "turners" then they should change their name. I admired Phil Wall's work. He started with a beautiful turning and then carved it but when the final form was finished you could tell it came off a lathe. All anyone is asking is that some standards be set for items to be included as turnings. Simply put, if it wasn't turned, it isn't a turning. No one is suggesting that no enhancements be allowed to turnings.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#34

Yep, no rest for the weary...:)

tdaniel

>

Re: a response from the carving forum

#35

Re: No confusion at all

Ed in No.VA

>"as long as the ARTIST is a woodturner, anything goes". OK. Last month in one art auction I sold three wood turnings.two block print turnings and one charcoal drawing turning,

Ed

Re: a response from the carving forum

#36

Steven Antonucci

Why I'm not a member of AAW or a turning club...

steve antonucci

>It seems to me that this topic comes up in various forms from time to time, and I always notice the same behavior and attitudes. People tend to polarize around "wrong and right", black and white. There is no right answer to your question, only opinions.

I went to one local "woodturning" club meeting, and I found the same behavior there. While I will decline to mention the club, it was very clear that there was a pecking order and that certain people's OPINIONS mattered more than others. After being told I was doing something wrong one too many times, I decide the club wasn't for me. We both lose.

What I can't understand is why people get upset over this topic? My personal OPINION is that if the object wasn't 51% lathe-made, calling it a turned object is suspect, but who cares? Mike's worm thingy is very cool, whether is spun or not. I enjoy looking at all of the Symposium pictures to see what people are doing, not how they did it.

steve

Re: a response from the carving forum

#37

Re: a response from the carving forum

john Lucas

>Jennifer Well said. I'm sorry but I don't understand what all the fuss is about. I didn't get to go to the symposium but looked at a lot of work that has been posted. Only rarely did it not looked like it had been on the lathe. The vast majority of work appeared to be bowls and vessels. granted there is alot of carving and other surface decoration but that's part of the fun and in my case has helped my sales.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#38

Re: why does AAW have to ...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Fred

We have a discussion going on with most of the contributors being people who have posted here and other places in the past, and we are exchanging thoughts and perspectives without any whining. To reinforce what TD wrote, we are arguing for DEFINITON of terms that are accurate. No one is slamming the production of art here.

So what is your point exactly?

Bill

Re: a response from the carving forum

#39

Clarification

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hello again Fred

I can't go back and edit, so I need to clarify. Most of the people participating in this discussion have posted PICTURES of their work on many occasions, here and in other forums. The rest of my post is pretty much just what I intended to say.

Bill

Re: a response from the carving forum

#40

Re: a response from the carving forum

Don Henthorn

>Mike, I greatly admire your creativity and skill and my remarks were not meant as any kind of put down. It is simply my personal value system that wants people as well as groups to be honest about who they are. I see absolutely no problem with any person expanding his skills and the depth of his creations. However when a fairly new turner joins the American Association of Woodturners I think he should find an organization whose emphasis is upon the craft that he is developing skill in. For those whose skills have moved on to other venues, they should form organizations to fit the new needs which they have and not expect the old organization to change as they change. True the old organization would become boring to them, but they should have company from other more experienced craftsmen who would join them in the new endeavor. I guess I shouldn't have opened my "mouth" because my old head doesn't work well enough to engage in such deep thinking any more.(-:

Re: a response from the carving forum

#41

HUMBUG

woodspinner/ Bill Hale

>I have read most of these and to a fault.

Quite possibly he put it on the forum to show his FRIENDS what he did. I would be proud of it too.

Turning or sculpture I think he was proud and just wanted to show it.

ENOUGH

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#42

Re: Why I'm not a member of AAW or a turning club.

Nelson

>49% lathe turned, 51% carved on the lathe, whatca got! This more fun than watching tv.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#43

Re: Why I'm not a member of AAW or a turning club.

Bill Crommett

>That is why I dropped out of that "turning" club in Phily run by the guy with the french -like moniker. It got too artsy and not enough about the lathe.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#44

Wither The Lathe?

David Propst

>I do not know where the "line" of turning to non-turning is, and I doubt it will ever be decided. Carving and other embellishments are wonderful and I applaud them on turnings. However for me, the gross final form should be produced on a lathe to be called a turning.

The AAW needs to decide whether thay want to promote lathe based creations or be a group geared towards creators and collectors of wood sculpture, a much more broad category. I was not at KC, however Mike's statement that "the AAW has decided that it wants to expand turning beyond the must be lathe turned only form" really concerns me. Turning requires skills and tools very different from traditional flatwork. If the AAW is moving away from the lathe, it is no longer promoting woodturning.

Utimately economics will decide the issue. Sculpure brings a higher price than "brown bowls". From what I have read here and in the journal, it appears to me that collectors of wood art are becoming an increasingly important driver to the direction of the AAW. Thus I suspect the AAW will continue to evolve more into a "wood art" organization than a specific "wood turning" organization.

David

Re: a response from the carving forum

#45

lets be clear

Mike Schwing from Md.

>David, just to clarify, I said "appears to have decided" not "the AAW has decided"

I do not speak for the AAW!

Re: a response from the carving forum

#46

Sorry Mike, I cut and pasted & still messed it up!

David Propst

>

Re: a response from the carving forum

#47

Re: Sorry Mike, I cut and pasted & still messed it

JamieDonaldson

>"Much ado about very little!" I have skimmed these posts and find many to be of marginal value regarding the original subject matter. Some who trash the AAW aren't members or don't attend the Symposium, so where is their credibility? Scan the rotation subjects and the result is a lot of bowl or other round subject matter. But molds are restrictive, and often meant to be broken. I also question aspects of some subjects- was a high heel slipper in the Return to Oz show ever near a lathe- where's the turning connection? But to say that the AAW is promoting ART over turning is an example of tunnel vision. Personal agendas are a part of life, but to project those agendas as universal fact diminishes the flavor of the stew.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#48

Re: Sorry Mike, I cut and pasted & still messed it

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Well, I understand your point(s) Jamie but I have to take a little exception at the idea that one needs to be a member of AAW or attend Symposium to have a credible opinion on the matter. One needs not be a Republican or Democrat to be credible on the politics of either side. Nor does one need to be a movie star to have a credible opinion on a movie.

Does AAW need to "come to terms" (my words) with this? I think it would help, as it seems to generate a lot of consternation within the community. I do believe that if there were a clear message for both artists and those who do not wish to be called artists, membership would rise and horizons would expand. I can decipher no clear message or agenda from anything I've been exposed to from AAW, but I'm a member, because it helps me with my personal agenda - exposure of my work and adding nice folks like yourself to those I consider friends.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#49

Re: Sorry Mike, I cut and pasted & still messed it

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Jamie, I think you need to go back and do some reading again on this thread, and maybe on some others. First of all, if you want to disagree with the posts made by some, that is fine, but to say that they are of marginal value is just another way of saying that your perspective is the only one. Say you disagree or say that you think we are misinformed, but the way you put it is quite adversarial and denigrates those with whom you disagree.

No one is trashing the AAW here in this thread. Some of us are arguing for truth in advertising and nothing more. Regardless of what you think about the AAW and how you react to these threads, you have to accept that this is a perception that is gaining ground, and if there are a number of people who feel and think the same way, it needs to be examined. At the very least you need to ask why so many people are starting to think this way rather than just say that their opinions are of marginal value.

Lets review for a moment. Mike posted a very provocative note, and he got a reaction. There are those of us who think that things should be labeled more clearly. No one has said that people shouldn't be allowed to create the art they wish to create, or that artists of a certain ilk should not be allowed in the AAW. There have been a number of thoughtful posts on both sides of the issue. But look at some of the reactions to the posts critical of the things Mike has noted.

Fred, whoever he is, has labeled people as whiners and dragged out an old platitude of questionable value, with absolutely no constructive comments at all. Where is the value in this contribution? I don't see it, regardless of whose "side" he is on. He has a right to whatever opinion he wants to hold, but calling names on the playground? What good does it do beyond provoking people instead of thought?

Nelson has assured us that "Intelligance will previll." (sic) I don't even want to touch this one, but it has been hard, let me tell you.

Now you come in to tell us that our opinions are of marginal value because we have never been to a symposium. So what? I read the journal, and I read the forums. Quite frankly I do not have the time or the money to travel to a national symposium. It is going to be a stretch for me to go to Albany this year, but I am going mainly to see what it is all about. When I look at the offerings I can attend rotations labeled for beginners or go to see someone who I really do not care to see because of artistic and political sensibilities. But why does any of this prevent me from airing my opinion? Why should I be required to attend a symposium to air my opinon of my experiences? I have seen what I have seen, and why do I need to spend time and money if I am not convinced that more of the same is going to be worth my while?

But this thread is not even about this stuff, it is just about asking people to be truthful about who and what they are. I wrote it once in this thread already, but it bears repeating: to take an object that has spent a small fraction of its time on the lathe and call it turned is the same as calling a turned bowl "chainsawed" since it spent some time being sawn into a rough blank. It simply is not accurate. It would be like taking a cabinet and calling it "planed". Sure planing took place, but it was not the majority of the work.

We can argue this until the last tree is cut down and not see eye to eye, but it is discouraging to see people marginalized because one disagrees with their opinion. Attack an idea or a statement to your heart's content, but please leave the person out of it.

Bill

Re: a response from the carving forum

#50

Well put, Bill. Your comments

Frank Mutchler in Colorado Springs

>help me keep my perspective regardless of the topic.

It seems to me that any endeavor that evolves and in so doing gains non-homogenous adherents is eventually faced with defining or redefining itself. Professionals in auto racing, competitive shooting, baseball, etc. can compete in many different classes suited to their skill level, equipment, or preference.

Maybe wood turning is at one of those evolutionary points.

I'm new to the wood lathe. Perhaps a more experiences "turner" would like to start a new thread and suggest some logical divisions that could be used to describe the wood turning community??