Re: a response from the carving forum
Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)
>Well Mike, since you asked what we think...
I think a couple of things about this. First, I think your piece is interesting. It is not my style at all, and I would not desire to own it, but I can appreciate the level of craftsmanship and skill that went into it. I have no problem with your posting it on the turning forum for as you say, this is the place where you are known.
But then my thinking leads me down other paths, one of the first being, why isn't he posting this on a carving or sculpture forum? You may not be known there, but what better opportunity to introduce yourself? That does not preclude your showing it here as well, but it begs the question, why isn't he going to the carving group as well? I do not have the answer, since I am not a carver, and currently have little interest in carving, so I do not read there. Perhaps you are already establishing your name there.
But even more importantly, it comes to your statements regarding the AAW and some of the membership. You wrote:
"There are a lot of folks who do this, by the way - put it on the lathe ONLY so they can say it was turned."
I truly do not understand this mindset. I do not have a problem with people who want to carve things by hand, paint them, burn them, put feathers and beads on them, or whatever, but why do they insist on representing themselves as turners? There is no shame in saying "I am a carver", is there? I do not know that there is any special status bestowed on those of us who use lathes, so where is the incentive to take a piece and give it a nominal spin so the creator can say, "This was turned on a lathe."?
To me it is no different than people coming into the Christian church and saying they do not believe any of the historical doctrines of the church, but since they like sitting in long rows on Sunday morning, they insist that they are Christians. Why are they here? There is some sort of fundamental disconnect in this reasoning, a non sequitur. It does not follow.
You also wrote:
"...the AAW has decided that it wants to expand turning beyond the "MUST BE LATHE TURNED ONLY" form."
Is this the "They" with a capital T for which I have been lampooned in several discussions because I see it too? I do not say that you have done any lampooning, but it has been there. I happen to agree that there is a strong movement in the AAW right now to take it away from traditional turning, and that many traditional turners are spurned. Of course, every time I mention that, I am made to look like a witch hunter, but that doesn't change the issue. Again, what is the draw, the incentive, to take a turning organization and turn it into something which it really is not? Is there some sort of social stigma in establishing the American Association of Woodcarvers, or the American Association of Wood Artists?
Let's call a spade a spade and describe things accurately. As Dinyar has ably pointed out, it is a taxonomic point. Your comparison of using a plethora of tools to arrive at a turned object does not work, nor does the furniture comparison. The tools used, regardless of the order or the utility, combine to produce a thing that is recognizable for the classification which is used to describe it. Regardless of what tools I use to build a table, it is readily recognizable as a piece of furniture. Regardless of what tools I use to produce one of my turnings, it is readily recognizable as a turning. Even if it is disassembled and reassembled into a different form, if it can be recognized by the taxonomic description given it, then I do not see an issue. But when someone takes a piece of wood and sticks it on the lathe for an hour, and then spends 40 more hours burning, painting, carving, sandblasting, or whatever, what is the basis for calling it a turning, especially when it is no longer recognizable as such? To follow your line of reasoning, it would be just as legitimate to call one of my bowls a chainsawing, since I did spend some time chainsawing the blank.
It is this issue that keeps a number of us from wanting to associate with the AAW. What is the point? It isn't really about turning anymore, although there is lip service paid to the origins of the organization. And whenever this discussion crops up, there are those who rise to the defense of the artists in the group, to quickly dismiss any charges of deviation from the intent of the organization. Perhaps they are right, but if the organization is intent on promoting wood art, then it really isn't about woodturning anymore, and those who are in that "They" group should not be surprised when us turned stick in the mud traditionalists have no desire to be a part of it.
Bill