Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

a response from the carving forum

Posts

a response from the carving forum

#1

a response from the carving forum

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Someone on the carving forum rightly asked me why I posted my "sea creature" on the turning forum and why the AAW allows so much "non turning" in its galleries. Here's my answer. What do you think?

It is folks like me who wonder why many turners desire to restrict their craft to things that are only done on a lathe. Furniture makers will employ lathes, bandsaws, tablesaws, routers, etc.. but not exclude their product if it had a handtool included in its make.

I could have easily put this thing on the lathe to start it out. It would have been easy to turn it on 3 axes to get the basic shape, and then carved it from there. But it would lose all resemblance of a turning before I was done. Would you accept it as a turning? I'd say you had to. Isn't turning nothing more than carving with the workpiece spinning? There are a lot of folks who do this, by the way - put it on the lathe ONLY so they can say it was turned. I've done it, too, to be honest.

I posted it on the turning forum because those folks know me best and have actually asked me to continue to post my work there.

Most lathe turned work has had other tools taken to it - chainsaws, bandsaws, power sanders, buffing wheels...why does that not make you question whether something is a turning or not? How about segemented turning?

Now, if you were in KC you undoubtedly saw the OZ exhibit - lots of work there that never saw a lathe. My piece did, but only about an hour's worth out of probably 100 hours. All or most all had extensive off the lathe work, including assembly, color, carving, etc.. the AAW has decided that it wants to expand turning beyond the "MUST BE LATHE TURNED ONLY" form. I applaud that! Others in the AAW membership want it to remain a more pure sport, but how do you categorize it? Isn't sanding and finishing cheating?

But I still like to turn bowls, too.

One more thing - perhaps I should have posted this only in the main messages forum, which is also the power tools forum, because I used mostly power tools to create it.

BTW, almost all of the sanding was done on lathe mounted/driven sanding drums and discs.

To me, the lathe is only another tool like my bandsaw. It is no more special in the process. The human is the special part. The rest are tools he uses to achieve his end result.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#2

Re: a response from the carving forum Well said

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>

Re: a response from the carving forum

#3

Re: a response from the carving forum

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Mike,

I might start posting some of my furniture work on the turning forum too, components such as legs and drawer pulls all came off the lathe...hmmm

:-)

take care,

Jim

Re: a response from the carving forum

#4

AAW = American Association of WoodTurners

tdaniel

>Mike, carving is a legitimate enhancement to a turning. Your creations that do not involve a lathe are legitimate wood art or legitimate wood carvings and there are appropriate shows for those items.....but they are not woodturnings. By definition a wood turning is known to be a "carving done while the wood is spinning". If the wood is not spinning it is a carving, not a turning. Employing carving on a piece that has been turned does not eliminate the fact that it is a turning, thus enhancements are acceptable. I show my 55 Ford pick-up at Ford shows or open shows but I would not take it to a Chevy show even though it has a motor and 4 wheels just like the Chevvies. Asking the AAW to accept a piece that has not been on a lathe for the shaping process while spinning is not appropriate. Again, not meant to, in any way, take away from your art creations; but to expect the AAW to provide space on the tables for pieces not turned opens the shows to carved walking sticks that were not turned, sculptures, etc and would basically eliminate the AAW as a forum of/for woodturners. A line has to be drawn somewhere. As the old saying goes, "you can't be all things to all people".TD

Re: a response from the carving forum

#5

Re: AAW = American Association of WoodTurners

Dinyar Chavda

>I was not going to get into this, Mike, as it has been discussed previously at nauseum. But since you raised the issue yourself, I'll give my opinion in this specific instance.

I agree with TD---it is the Am. Assoc of Woodturners, not Woodworkers. If a piece has had nothing to do with a lathe, I, for one, cannot see how it can be called a turned object, or included at the Am. Assoc of Woodturners, or posted at either the World of Woodturners or at a Turning board at Woodcentral. (As you might be able to tell, one of my favorite rants is about the continuing laxity in the English language).

There have been other turned pieces where the amount of lathe-work has been minimal, and one can argue as to whether or not they should be included as turned objects or not---I think that depends on one's personal viewpoint. But here we have a basic issue of taxonomy, which is giving my mind convulsions first thing in the morning, i.e., an unturned turned object. I need to drink some non-tea tea (i.e., coffee), before I can comprehend this.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#6

confusing the issue

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Gents, you are confusing my piece of work that sparked this discussion with the discussion itself. Art that is not turned cannot be called turned art, very simply put. I cannot (nor would I) put this in a woodturning display, but my other pieces, sure - they have obvious turned elements.

Still - there is an argument for art that has been on the lathe but no longer bears that resemblance. The lathe was merely a tool on the way to the end.

The original question was not about this piece itself, but about the other pieces in the instant gallery that had no obvious connection to the lathe.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#7

Re: confusing the issue

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I agree. That was my point. The rhetorical question is, "How can you tell, unless you are the artist or were present at the creation of the work of art, whether a lathe was used in it's creation?" The question can be carried further: What constitutes a lathe? Is a legacy mill, with all cuts done with a router, a lathe? How about a rotating vise on a milling machine? What if all cuts were done in the wood with the pin set in the indexing wheel? What if all of the surface of the original form were completely removed and reshaped by hand or power tools, after the piece was removed from the lathe? There is a story told about Michaelangelo. When asked by a potential customer for a sample of his work, he "simply" painted a perfect circle, freehand, while the customer was watching. Had the customer not seen him do it, the customer could have assumed he had done it the easy way, with a compass, or maybe holding the brush steady, while the canvas turned on a lathe, which is the same difference. What if I build a Queen Anne table, with cabriolet legs with pad feet? Is that "in" or "out"? The bottom of the pad is turned, but nothing else. Could that be shown at an AAW instant gallery?

Re: a response from the carving forum

#8

Re: confusing the issue

Nelson

>Intelligance will previll.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#9

People's Front of Judea

Jim K in Trappe PA

>This is a topic of biblical proportions (couldn't resist!):

Recalling a favorite scene in Monty Python's Life of Brian.

The setting: Roman-controlled Judea, circa 30 A.D. The Roman Colosseum, Jerusalem. Children's Matinee.

The players: The People's Front of Judea (PFJ) are sitting in the arena stands, discussing the importance of diversity in their fight against the oppressors. Brian is working selling snacks to the crowd. (Dog's tongues. Wren's livers. Jaguar's earlobes.Wolf nipple chips. Dromedary prezels. Tuscany fried bats.)

Brian approaches the PFJ...

Brian: Are you the Judean People's Front?

Reg: F--- off.

Brian: What?

Reg: Judean People's Front. (scoffs) We're the People's Front of Judea. Judean People's front, caw.

Francis: Wankers.

Brian: Can I join your group?

Reg: No. Piss off.

Brian: I didn't want to sell this stuff. It's only a job. I hate the Romans as much as anybody.

PFJ: [nervously] Sssh! Ssssh, sssh, sssh, ssssh.

Judith: Are you sure?

Brian: Oh. Dead sure... I hate the Romans already.

Reg: Listen. If you really wanted to join the PFJ, you'd have to really hate the Romans.

Brian: I do.

Reg: Oh yeah? How much?

Brian: A lot!

Reg: Right. You're in. Listen. The only people we hate more than the Romans are the f---ing Judean People's Front

PFJ: [together, nodding in agreement] Yeah

Judith: [disgusted] Splitters

Francis: And the Judean Popular Peoples Front.

PFJ: Oh yeah. Splitters.

Loretta: And the peoples Front of Judea.

PFJ: Splitters.

Reg: What?

Loretta: The Peoples front of Judea. Splitters.

Reg: We're the Peoples front of Judea.

Loretta: Oh. I thought we were the Popular Front.

Reg: Peoples Front! [scoffs]

Francis: Whatever happened to the Popular Front, Reg?

Reg: He's over there.

[A single old man sits on a lower seat.]

PFJ: [To the old man.] SPLITTER!

Re: a response from the carving forum

#10

Re: In response to Nelson.....

Mac

>I hope so....soon.....you really think thats going to happen?

Re: a response from the carving forum

#11

No confusion at all

tdaniel

>Would I take a "pure" turned bowl to a carving show? I think this would be crashing their party. Now if the bowl had been turned and then carved I think it would be appropriate to take. On the other had if a show advertised that it was a "Wood art show" then anything of wood would be appropriate. If I were a potter could I sneak a piece in by putting a wooden handle on it? We have to draw some lines somewhere.

TD

Re: a response from the carving forum

#12

Re: No confusion at all

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Terry - this is an open topic/question. It appears that the AAW has decided the opposite to what you are describing. They seem to be saying "as long as the ARTIST is a woodturner, anything goes". How else could some of the work getting attention possibly be interpreted? AAW seems to be, in the short time I have been aware, moving rapidly towards allowing more and more freedom of expression, rather than restricting the craft/art. The intro to the OZ exhibit catalog, by Binh Pho, pretty much states that the turner has once and forever escaped the bounds of the lathe. From that - where does it go?

I'm OK with dividing items into smaller subsets - turned/sculpted/painted, segmented, etc.. It looks like I'd do things that would fit into nearly every category. And funny you should mention it, I AM looking for "wood art" shows for the non turned stuff I'm doing.

Still, no one has appeared to answer the question about an item that starts on the lathe, perhaps just to remove waste material, but no longer resembles a turning. But it IS a turning.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#13

Re: confusing the issue

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Well I suppose there's a first for everything.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#14

Re: a response from the carving forum

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Well Mike, since you asked what we think...

I think a couple of things about this. First, I think your piece is interesting. It is not my style at all, and I would not desire to own it, but I can appreciate the level of craftsmanship and skill that went into it. I have no problem with your posting it on the turning forum for as you say, this is the place where you are known.

But then my thinking leads me down other paths, one of the first being, why isn't he posting this on a carving or sculpture forum? You may not be known there, but what better opportunity to introduce yourself? That does not preclude your showing it here as well, but it begs the question, why isn't he going to the carving group as well? I do not have the answer, since I am not a carver, and currently have little interest in carving, so I do not read there. Perhaps you are already establishing your name there.

But even more importantly, it comes to your statements regarding the AAW and some of the membership. You wrote:

"There are a lot of folks who do this, by the way - put it on the lathe ONLY so they can say it was turned."

I truly do not understand this mindset. I do not have a problem with people who want to carve things by hand, paint them, burn them, put feathers and beads on them, or whatever, but why do they insist on representing themselves as turners? There is no shame in saying "I am a carver", is there? I do not know that there is any special status bestowed on those of us who use lathes, so where is the incentive to take a piece and give it a nominal spin so the creator can say, "This was turned on a lathe."?

To me it is no different than people coming into the Christian church and saying they do not believe any of the historical doctrines of the church, but since they like sitting in long rows on Sunday morning, they insist that they are Christians. Why are they here? There is some sort of fundamental disconnect in this reasoning, a non sequitur. It does not follow.

You also wrote:

"...the AAW has decided that it wants to expand turning beyond the "MUST BE LATHE TURNED ONLY" form."

Is this the "They" with a capital T for which I have been lampooned in several discussions because I see it too? I do not say that you have done any lampooning, but it has been there. I happen to agree that there is a strong movement in the AAW right now to take it away from traditional turning, and that many traditional turners are spurned. Of course, every time I mention that, I am made to look like a witch hunter, but that doesn't change the issue. Again, what is the draw, the incentive, to take a turning organization and turn it into something which it really is not? Is there some sort of social stigma in establishing the American Association of Woodcarvers, or the American Association of Wood Artists?

Let's call a spade a spade and describe things accurately. As Dinyar has ably pointed out, it is a taxonomic point. Your comparison of using a plethora of tools to arrive at a turned object does not work, nor does the furniture comparison. The tools used, regardless of the order or the utility, combine to produce a thing that is recognizable for the classification which is used to describe it. Regardless of what tools I use to build a table, it is readily recognizable as a piece of furniture. Regardless of what tools I use to produce one of my turnings, it is readily recognizable as a turning. Even if it is disassembled and reassembled into a different form, if it can be recognized by the taxonomic description given it, then I do not see an issue. But when someone takes a piece of wood and sticks it on the lathe for an hour, and then spends 40 more hours burning, painting, carving, sandblasting, or whatever, what is the basis for calling it a turning, especially when it is no longer recognizable as such? To follow your line of reasoning, it would be just as legitimate to call one of my bowls a chainsawing, since I did spend some time chainsawing the blank.

It is this issue that keeps a number of us from wanting to associate with the AAW. What is the point? It isn't really about turning anymore, although there is lip service paid to the origins of the organization. And whenever this discussion crops up, there are those who rise to the defense of the artists in the group, to quickly dismiss any charges of deviation from the intent of the organization. Perhaps they are right, but if the organization is intent on promoting wood art, then it really isn't about woodturning anymore, and those who are in that "They" group should not be surprised when us turned stick in the mud traditionalists have no desire to be a part of it.

Bill

Re: a response from the carving forum

#15

Re: a response from the carving forum

Kevin Gerstenecker

>Bill, I couldn't have expressed my feelings on this subject any better, and I thank and applaud you for your insight on this issue. There are many things I do not understand, and the issue(s) you addressed are among them. This is one reason why I am not a member of the AAW, and have no desire to join. This may rub a few the wrong way, but I feel strongly about turning and agree with you regarding the subjects you so eloquently addressed.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#16

but I do!

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Thanks for the thoughts Bill - you expressed them as you have consistently on this subject, well thought out and with clarity.

If you go through the carving forum you will see that I have been posting there since it was first created. I still consider myself to be, foremost, a woodturner.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#17

Re: a response from the carving forum

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Well here's my opinion....if anybody cares....

I think if we all turn "brown bowls" forever we're going no where. I think it's human nature to push the envelope with anything. Including the lathe. Some of the things I saw at the symposium in Kansas were mind boggling. I would never attempt to make some of the things I saw there, but I have incredible respect for the talents and brain power it took to create them. Malcolm Tibbett is one who's work just fascinates me. When I saw one of his pieces for the first time on WOW I could not believe that it was created on a lathe. His work in person is breath taking. I see some of Andi Wolf's recent pieces and they appear to be solely carved. The thought of the lathe doesn't even enter your head really. Betty Scarpino's work is sometimes far from the lathe, but it certainly starts there. These are just three examples of hundreds who are pushing the envelope of the lathe and or woodturned art. On the other hand I think there is nothing more beautiful than a wonderfuly shaped bowl that shows off the real nature of the material. One that is round and fits comfortable in my hands and feels like a substantial piece work. I love trying and discovering new ways to play around with woodturning. Carving, coloring, texturing, and these people I've just mentioned, including Mike Schwing are encouraging me to do so. I think if AAW didn't "allow", encourage, accept and expose some of the work that woodturners/woodworkers are creating, they would be shooting themselves and the entire association in the foot. Yes, I think that there are some limits that need to be decided upon. I don't think it's proper to have a Queen Anne table at the next instant gallery just because the legs were turned (sorry Shaver :), nor do I think it is appropriate for a walking stick that was solely whittled and carved to be there either. I don't spend time wondering if this is where it's going either. I seriously doubt it. I think if Mike's piece was started on the lathe to only remove excess material then it was certainly turned and should be considered a turning. Andi's extensively carved leaf bowls could fall into the same category really. She essentially uses the lathe to remove excess material so she can then begin the process of carving what will eventually be a beautifully carved display of leaves ....shaped like a bowl.

I would hate to see limitations put on the members of the AAW in order to remain just a "pure" woodturned format. I think the instant gallery would be far less entertaining, that's for sure! Perhaps categories is the way to go. Partially turned, Mostly carved, Segmented, etc? I think wood turning is a such a free form part of woodworking, and probably most of us started out as flatboarders I would suspect. Why put limits on the freedom the lathe brings? I say let it all hang out!

If I have any complaint at all....it would be that not all of the items in the juried "Back to the Land of OZ" gallery had anything to do with the Wizard of Oz at all? That really bummed me out. I think that if there is a theme to that part of the show...it needs to be adhered to. Most of the pieces did, but not all of them. If I had of known that the pieces didn't have to have anything to do with the theme I might have entered something!

Okay....that's my squabble for the day :)

Jen

Re: a response from the carving forum

#18

Thanks Bill!

tdaniel

>I agree with every word of what you said. The AAW is supposed to be an organization for turners. Some enhancements are good but if everything we see at the symposiums is over the edge of what most of us want to accomplish then how can it continue to be "our" organization. Those we elect to represent us should listen to us. If AAW wants to add a table for items that are less than 50% turned or whatever I could accept that but if our leadership tries to take things into the unknown then the result will be a large loss of membership. Every organization should have an agenda; every club should have an agenda. Our club's agenda is: to promote safe turning habits and increase the skill level of turners within our area and to help develope a market for our turnings. I think that should also be the goal of the AAW. Too many goals will cause none of them to be reached. We should keep it simple. We are not an organization to promote carving although as an enhancement I see no problem with it. I think we should strive to keep our "craft" recognizeable. This whole issue reminds me of our politicians who promise us one thing and then go to Washington and do something else.

TD

Re: a response from the carving forum

#19

AND Just When.....

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>I was almost done finding a way to chuck my latest end table on the lathe to turn some details....Man!! SO close...so close, thanks Jen!!

Guess I'll have to turn some round things for the AAW 2006 instant galley...hmmm, maybe a large bottle of Tums for this topic!! Yeah, different exotic woods for the different Tums flavours ...Now that sound like a plan!

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: a response from the carving forum

#20

Re: AND Just When.....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>...it's so cranial isn't it, Jim. Perhaps a bottle of Tylenol while you're at it? You'd only need some Holly and red dye for the lable then. Maybe a high speed carver?

Hee-hee :)

Re: a response from the carving forum

#21

Re: a response from the carving forum

Russ Fairfield

>Jennifer,

The problem is not that the AAW is promoting the "art". The problem is that the AAW is too often all about the "art", and nothing about that group of woodturning that you call the "brown bowls".

Re: a response from the carving forum

#22

Re: AAW = American Association of WoodTurners

Bill Crommett

>Right On, TD ! Which again brings up the comment my good wife made at the Tacoma AAW "Does AAW stand for American Association OF Whatever ?" I think Mikes renderings are innovative and beautiful, and I appreciate his sharing, but TD is right when he says that turning and lathes are a distinct process that should be recognizable in the finished piece. But please don't stop sharing your work with us, Mike.

Re: a response from the carving forum

#23

Re: Thanks Bill!

Dinyar Chavda

>TD, (I seem to be responding to you a lot), you said:

This whole issue reminds me of our politicians who promise us one thing and then go to Washington and do something else.

Really! They do that! Naah. They wouldn't.........would they?

Re: a response from the carving forum

#24

LOL!!

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>

Re: a response from the carving forum

#25

Re: a response from the carving forum

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I'm very delighted to see the breadth and depth of discussion on this topic. Thank you all for your responses. I fall towards both ends of the spectrum. I have a strong desire to create beautiful bowls (and hopefully one day the talent to do so) like those of Bill Neddow, as well as the desire to do things in the realm of Marylin Campbell and Jim Christensen. All along, I will be a woodturner. I'd be happy to participate in category separation, but we all know it can't and won't happen.

I have no idea where my art will go next, but in between I'll be putting out bowls and hollow vessels, too.

If AAW want to promote wood art, perhaps the name should be changed. I'll go along with that.