New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Thinking of buying a new lathe

Posts

Thinking of buying a new lathe

#1

Thinking of buying a new lathe

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Greetings all

I am posting this in three places, since while some of you read all three, there are others who only read one, and I am looking for responses. First of all, no, the Poolewood is not being replaced, and I am still as happy with it as the day I got it home. But the student line is getting longer and longer, and one giant lathe and one mini are straining a bit. The Mini Max copy lathe just went down the road (no more factory style production for me!), which frees me (and some money) up to start thinking about adding a mid sized machine to the stable to facilitate class time with a maximum of three students.

Right now there are two lathes in the forefront of my thinking, the Jet 1642 and the Nova DVR. I have done some turning on both of these machines, and each has its strong and weak points. The price for either is pretty much the same at our local Woodcraft store, although I will be investigating some other options. Mail order is probably not going to be one of them though. I do not mind paying more for local support.

The Nova has the advantage of direct drive and a very compact footprint. That is a big plus in my shop right now and into the foreseeable future. Most of what people want to do is bowls, followed by an even mix of short spindle work and hollow forms. However, I think the Jet is going to have the edge in stability and power, and if I need it, it already has the longer bed. That longer bed will need to find a place to live though, and it may not be as easy to shoehorn it into the shop. I think it is also worthwhile to have a lathe in the size/price range of these machines, not just for my own budget, but so that people can see that one does not need the most expensive machine out there to do good work.

So here is what I am looking for. I would like to hear comments either public or private from people who own one of these machines. What do you like, what do you not like, and what would you change if you could? Also, if anyone has a suggestion as to some other machine I should be looking at, I would be glad to hear it.

Thanks.

Bill

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#2

I just got a VB36...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>and you're welcome to try it out anytime you're over this way.

Best, Ted

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#3

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

DD

>Bill,

I purchased a Nova DVR last October and have been extremely pleased with it. I went with the DVR primarily because of its small footprint, versatility and expandibility. I have a small shop so the standard long bed lathes would simply not fit. For the stand, I used the plans that come with the owner's manual and it has been fine. I added some casters to the base and some adjustable feet (from Lee Valley) that permit me to move the lathe out of the way if required with relative ease.

The Teknatool website is ok, but is short on details and for some reason takes for ever to be updated. The manual I received with the lathe was dated Jun 04 but the manual on the web site is dated 17 Nov 03 for some reason.

The only thing that bugs me on the DVR is the tool rest and its post. When I loosen the post to adjust the height of the tool rest, it simply slides down and jams into the banjo. It's not difficult to loosen, but it's just a pain to wrestle with, particularly if the lathe is running.

Speed control is fine on the lathe. The increment and decrment buttons for the speed adjustment are fine, although some people seem to think this is bothersome.

I posted a similar question to yours and received some excellent feedback from Lyn Mangeimeli on the DVR. It was his recommendations that swayed me towards the DVR, primarily for the reasons stated in the first para. If you search the archives here, you will find lots of comments on the lathe when it first came out. Some were not complementary, but over the first year of introduction, there was a noticable change in the comments from skepticism (because of the motor technology I guess) to support and endorsement.

I think you'll love it, as will your students.

DD

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#4

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

Steve Mushinski

>While you are thinking Bill. There is that saying "Go big or stay Home".

Steve pushes Bill to think of some of them there Canadian Made fine machines. EH!

Best to go into this with an open mind!!

All the best Steve.

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#5

JL

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

JL

>I got a 1642 EVS after advice from others (and Dominic's glowing reviews). It does need a ballast box if you aren't going to bolt it to the floor. I built a ballast box/tool drawer set and I've got about 150 lbs + of gravel in it (in bags). Turns reasonably well. It doesn't have the weight to handle "big" off balanced bowls, but I got it to turn between centers primarily and bowls secondarily.

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#6

I hope all comments are posted publicly

Carole in VA

>For the benefit of others looking to purchase a new machine! I would also like to hear your comments, positive and negative, on the 1642 and the Nova, Bill, as these are two of the lathes on my list of possibilites.

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#7

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

Bill MacLachlan

>Bill;

I also have the DVR and am greatly impressed. I also like the small footprint as room was at a premium. The digital speed controller has not been any problems. I also sometimes swear at my tool rest, but sometimes that could because of the operator!! Recommend highly. Bill

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#8

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

Gerry in Maryland

>Howdy Bill,

The Jet’s cast iron legs give it a +. But I know you and I have seen the stand that you had constructed for the Poolewood. If you made something like that for a Nova I think you’d have a winner. I don’t think you could go wrong with either lathe. By the way, I just got a 10% off card from Woodcraft for Thursday, July 21st that you could use at the Delaware store. (No Sales Tax) They have a Jet sitting on the floor. They’ve may even have a Nova sitting there…

Good Luck!

Gerry

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#9

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

Tom Mullane

>Bill, you might want to talk to Larry Barnes about the 1642.. he apparently loves his... he had it set up when you were shooting the video....

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#10

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>side bar to DD: suggest you put a clamp ring on your tool post positioned such that the bowl gouge you most often used will cut on center. Since you (I) move the tool rest many times during the turning of a bowl, maintining height will be one less thing to worry about. Just loosen the clamp, spin the rest to where you want it and tighten back up.

On the rare occasions where I am doing something that requires the rest to be higher, just move it up there. If required to be lower, you will have to loosen and re-set the collar/clamp ring.

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#11

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

John Lucas

>Bill

I have to second the 1642. I owned the Nova 3000 which granted isn't the DVR but the things I like about the 1642 are the mass of the bed and the legs as well as the tailstock. That overall mass just makes a lot of difference. As far as space what they have done at the Craft center is hang a 4x4' piece of particle board on a chain between the lathes. This lets you put the lathes a little closer together and still be safe from flying objects. It works great.

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#12

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

Russ Fairfield

>This is not an easy decision to make.

Something that we often don't think about when selecting the 2nd lathe are the similarities and differences between the lathes and how easilly we can move from one to the other without having to get our brain into another thinking mode.

Think about the things that you have a problem with when you use someone else's lathe for a demonstration. Are you ready for that same aggravation every time you use the 2nd lathe in your shop? Such little things as locks and knobs that rotate in opposite directions, things that are in a different location, things that are missing, or a different profile on a tool rest, can drive us nuts when we have to change from one lathe to another.

Don't forget the costs that are created by having different spindle threads. This can add several hundred dollars to the cost of the 2nd lathe. If you are going to solve the problem with a spindle adapter, make sure that the bearings of the new lathe are up to carrying the additional overhung load.

Then there are the attachments that you may or may not be able to use. Some lathes have a tool rest height that will not allow you to use a McNaughton tool for coring, and a different tool post diameter can be a problem.

If you use the swivel head on your Poolewood a lot, that could be the deciding factor.

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#13

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

John Lucas

>Bill

One lathe I forgot about is the Vega 24 bowl lathe. I got a close look at Marks and it's a really nice lathe. Much sturdier than it looks on the website. Doesn't take up much floor space and has a removeable tailstock if you like to start bowls between centers.

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: 24 or 2400 ?

Brad Vietje

>John and Mark,

Just in the name of clarification...

There is a Vega 24 bowl lathe, (now discontinued) that is a small, relatively light, table-top 24" short bed bowl lathe -- no tailstock available from Vega. They also made a MUGH larger 2400 bowl lathe that is a freestanding 24" lathe with a tailstock, and I suspect, the one you refer to. The 24 has a 1" - 8 spindle, while the 2400 uses a 1-2/4" - 8. The 2400 has now been replaced with the 2600.

I know 2 turners who use and love the 2400; no details at all on the newer 2600.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#15

Brad Vietje

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

Brad Vietje

>Bill,

I read all the responses offered so far, and want to offer another 3 thoughts.

1. The DVR is also available with optional cast iron legs that equalize the size and mass debate.

2. Both can be used as short-bed bowl lathes. DVR has short bed that can be made even shorter by removing one bed segment (or longer, v-v); while the 1642 headstock can be moved down the bed to make the bed any desired length. The 1642 would still need more floorspace, especially if the turner intends to stand off the end of the bed in "bowl lathe" fashion.

3. The DVR has an outstanding feature for a teaching lathe: the circuitry will instantly cut power to the headstock in the event of a big catch. This can be invaluable with students to bowl turning, or someone just getting used to out-of-balance, odd-shaped, or natural-edge bowls. The one shortcoming I was able to find about the DVR when researching this lathe a few months ago for a club purchase, was this very feature, which could be a bother when coring odd-shaped or difficult blanks, where the jerky nature of the initial coring passes could trip the circuit. Since you will probably continue coring these big odd-shaped blobs on the Poolewood, I would argue that the added safety of this feature will make it a clear winner for any teaching situation. I am very seriously considering the DVR as soon as I can afford one !

One last thought -- the outrigger for the 3000/DVR is surprisingly rugged, and exceeded my expectations.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#16

Brad Vietje

Re: OOPS -- That's 1-1/4 x 8 spindle (TYPO)

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#17

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

Carole in VA

>Brad, I read somewhere that the cast iron legs had been discontinued until they find a new supplier. Don't know if it is true, or if it is, whether or not they have yet found a new supplier.

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#18

Steven Antonucci

Cast Iron legs-

steve antonucci

>I have these legs on my 3K, and I love them! They are something like 7 million pounds each, and really make a difference with clean up when you can get a broom in and out. I have added a ballast box/shelf to my legs, since the casting have cutouts for 2x6 framing.

If weight was your concern for the Nova DVR, I believe it will be 350# with the legs. Mine is currently upwards of 700#, with the ballast, and I could easily add 200# if I wanted to. I have roughed out a 110#, 22" white oak bowl with the head swung out to 90 degrees.

For a "second" lathe, I think the Nova 3K would be great. If you buy the DVR, it may replace the Poolewood.

Steve

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#19

Wanna Buy A Used 1236?

Ron in Drums PA

>Just kidding!

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#20

Re: Wanna Buy A Used 1236?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Just can't bear to part with it, eh, Ron?

|;-}}

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#21

Re: 24 or 2400 ?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>The 2600 is a slightly updated 2400. The 2400 could turn 24" over the banjo, and 26" over the bed. The new 2600 is the same, the name just reflects the true turning capacity. The 2600 also incorporates a different capacity tailstock.

Both lathes are now, or soon will have indexing and a bed extension as options. The bed extension extends the bed, but will not allow you to install the tailstock on the extension.

Mark

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#22

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)

>I love my Nova 3000 but I think I would have preferred the Jet with its sliding head making the lathe into a shortbed bowl lathe. The rotating head of the Nova required the add-on tool rest or an independent toolrest stand. I have both and like neither. Of course, I need a lather that can do bowls, delicate finials and long (3') spindle turnings. However, if you do not anticipate needing a long bed (as suggested in your original post) then the shortbed version of the Nova is my choice in your situation (i.e., limited space the need of a beginner-friendly lathe). But, on the other hand, for the same price you can get a lather (the Jet) that will do it all (short bed for bowls and log bed for ballasters).

John

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#23

Woodfast *LINK*

Ben Aragon

>Bill,

The Woodfast lathe is made in China and sold by Harbor Freight now. I do not have one but if the quality has not slipped too much, it is a very good lathe. I have seen this sell for $1,500 on EBay by Harbor freight sales. The old Woodfast lathe sold for $3,695. If anyone has this lathe, I would like to hear what you think. It is a 20” lathe with 36” between centers. I have had the opportunity to use the old Woodfast lathe and it a very good lathe. If I got this lathe, I would up grade to PWM drive for the motor.

Good luck,

Ben


Woodfast

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#24

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

DD

>Thanks for that feedback. I also have a Shopsmith that I used initially for my introduction to woodturning. It has this feature as well (different size post unfortunately). Have tried to find such a collar locally with no success (although not very hard, mind you).

Also got a personal e-mail recommending that a couple of O-rings be put on the tool rest shaft to prevent it from jamming in the banjo. Sounds like a good idea as well.

DD

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

#25

Re: Thinking of buying a new lathe

Bill Crommett

>I made my collars out of specific lengths of PVC pipe. Real cheap !