New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

Posts

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#26

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>David,

Framed on my F-I-L's wall: "Any society which exhaults philosophy but denegrates plumbing will be in serious trouble in short order because neither its concepts nor its pipes will hold water."

[Yup. He's a Master Plumber]

M

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#27

Re: Art v. Craft---with a different question

Raymond Overman in SC

>I'd like to to clarify that in my post, I was not trying to hypothesize that craft + craft = art. Taken in context of the message as a whole, craft + craft + a conscious effort to communicate a message or feeling = art. Sometimes that just happens anyway whether the Craftsman wants it to or not. It takes some emotion or feelings and a conscious effort to create some of these pieces and that feeling transcends the title that the maker wants to be called.

What's good for woodturning today? That's not important to the artist. The artist wants to be able to be free to create and doesn't want to tow the party line. They want to scoff at the critics because of bad reviews and gain some noteriety by marketing that defiance at times. At other times they come in line to make a buck or two but then they deviate again for the growth. The artist will push ahead even if it hurts their reputation. They still have to listen to and respect the fundamentals of design or it's bad art. Notice in the equation, craft + craft + a conscious effort to communicate a message or feeling = art that I didn't qualify whether the art was good or bad. I also didn't say an artist is a good business person or good at marketing. That's why some artists have agents and that's why you have the term "starving artist".

What's good for woodturning today? That's important to the craftsman. The craftsman wants to be able to produce work that people want to own. He or she wants to excel in the making of the piece and wants the customer to recognize the work as being at least acceptable if not extraordinary. They too have to listen to and respect the fundamentals of design or it's bad craft and no one will buy it. On top of that, there is a marketing aspect to craft that plays an important role in their success. You never hear the term "starving craftsman" just "lazy bum that wants to play in the shop all day".

I also think that the pieces you turn are defined on how you approach explaining them. If when someone looks at a piece and says, "That's beautiful, what do you do with it?" and you explain that this is an exotic burl that's 12" in diameter and 8" tall and 1/8" thick throughout and has a finish that you can see the pearly gates in and that it's for decoration, then you've just described your craft and therefore it is craft. If you add that you chose the piece of wood for its characteristics because you wanted to express a sense of loss in a sculptural work, you've started venturing into art. I wouldn't hesitate to say that the artist would start the explanation with the emotional or communication part. It's all in the marketing at that point.

I agree that two people can be standing side by side and disagree about whether to call it art or craft. I think location and attitude has a lot to do with their answer as well. In a gallery with a glass of cabernet, it's art. In a garage standing beside the lathe with a PBR, it's craft. I'm comfortable with either but I've never had a bad PBR. I've had a bad cabernet. 8-)

You'll notice there are a lot of I thinks in this post. I don't expect or require that anyone agree. I've gotten a lot out of everyones responses to Keith's questions and respect your opinions as well. Thank you Dinyar for making me re-evaluate my earlier post and excercise my brain some more. You made some good and valid points.

Good luck everyone in honing your craft, creating your art, and marketing them both as you see fit.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#28

Re: Revealing insight .... LONG and WORDY

Terry Daniel

>I agree totally.

TD

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#29

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

John Lucas

>Bruce

I think passion is what's necessary to carry any work from craft to art. A finely crafted piece is no more than that unless there is passion involved. Passion allows you the freedom to create something truely special. Craftsmanship gives you the skills to create what you design.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#30

Re: Art v. Craft---with a different question

Dale Stansbery

>I've been to enough "Art Shows" now to finally realize that any thing can be called art, and anyone can claim to be an artist. But, it takes a true craftsman to turn a beautiful bowl.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#31

Re: Art v. Craft---with a different question

Ron in Drums PA

>Good Post Dinyar.

Personally I think an "artist" has a different temperament then most "average" people. An artist will approach a project differently each time and will look for different ways to accomplish their ideas.

IMNSHO - A craftsperson will gain a certain amount of expertise, and will repeat the same project over and over again in order to make a sale. Nothing wrong with this, so please do not take offense

I think the following quote describes an artist an artist the best.

"I am always doing that which I can not do, in order that I may learn how to do it. " -Piccaso -

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#32

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft *LINK*

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I guess I'm more of a technique-oriented turner, and haven't had a strong inspiration to go beyond that into new horizons. The desire is there, but I'm not sure where to begin.

I'm quite sure that a few members of our AAW chapter would be eager to see a Keith Tompkins demo on form and design. If you can make it up to SW Wisconsin sometime during 2006, please contact our program director at the link below:


Coulee Region Woodturners staff

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#33

Re: Your thoughts - Warning-Long

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I've watched this thread with great interest, and see many familiar concepts being raised. In almost every case, nobody seems to question the basic premise that there is, indeed, some difference between "art" and "craft." I would suggest that, with so many people, from trained designers, like Fred, to pure hobbyists, to teachers like Keith having trouble reaching a viable consensus (you ain't the first with that problem, guys) perhaps it's a trick question because there is (or should be) no difference.

I see folks here refer to "fine art" and impute "messages" or higher meaning to "works of art" than to things merely "crafted" with high skill. I so often see people almost uniformly demand that "art works" have titles and carry deeper meanings or insight. What is this compulsion to graft literature onto non-verbal, purely visual creations? Does somebody think they will understand the piece if the maker gives them a tag line to which they can graft a bunch of literary references? Is it that they're afraid that they won't or can't reach some understanding of what they are looking at without that word-crutch?

How many of the people here put names on their pieces? Why? Do you feel that some person down the road won't get your "message" without the literary tag? Do you think that the attached words will make your piece better or more worthy? Is that a critisism of your piece or a comment on that future person's sensibilities or, perhaps, both? If you really want to communicate thoughts and concepts through language, write a book, but let your piece communicate about itself, for itself, by itself. The people who get it, will; those who don't, won't.

I had a professor in African Art when I was in graduate school who went to great lengths about how the art of African cultures was still a vibrant part of every person's life in the villages and tribes he visited and researched. His examples were the many masks that are a central art form in the cultures, and how every person with whom he spoke, from children to village elders, seemed to have a clear understanding about an item, not only its meaning and function, but also an informed opinion on the quality of the design and fabrication of the mask itself. He then contrasted that with some man-on-the-street interviews in New York where he would pull out reproductions of, say, a Jackson Pollack painting (drips & splashes), a small Henry Moore (sculpture), or an Andy Warhol pop image, and he would literally stop people and ask them about the Art Object. He related that more than 90% of the time he got, "Well, I don't know anything about art, but I know what I like." He then asked if the person liked the object. About 90% said "Don't know" with the rest split about evenly between yes and no. When he asked the yes/no group "why?" only a very few were willing or able to give him an answer. The point of the story is that there seems to be a disconnect between modern American society and what we perceive (or have been sold) is "Art". I'll venture to say, however, that there is no such disconnect between everyday people and the products of "craft" that are everywhere and in use every day.

Where and how, then, did "art" get separated in our culture from everyday life, stuffed into museums and galleries or fountains, made a symbol of "class-struggle" between those of wealth, power, breeding, and status, and the rest of us who pound our way through rush hour, and sweat whether we'll have enough saved to see us through our old age so we don't become a burden on our kids? Are "artists" somehow better than other people, entitled to more in this life than the rest of humanity, with their "opinion" on same-sex marriage more valid than mine? Hogwash! Such attitudes only perpetuate elitism, foster anger and resentment, and serve only to feed those few who thrive on the dark side of human nature.

I'll submit that, like it or not, every person who makes something by themself, be it a wood bowl, stretched cloth with multi-colored mud smeared on it, or a rock with a hole drilled through it, is an artist, and what they make is, in some way, art. Granted, some bowls are more pleasant to look at or are better suited to a particular use, and some rocks have cleaner, better-drilled holes, so we can make some value judgments on how well the items are made, crafted if you will. But because one person imagines some celestial significance to a rock with a hole in it that they also think is missing from the beautiful bowl, doesn't make it so, and it certainly doesn't make the guy with the drill more worthy than the woman with the bowl gouge.

Personally, I think we need to drop the pretense that there is some metaphysical difference between objects called art and anything else made by people.

All Art is Craft, and All Craft is Art in a neverending continuum. The rest is literary.

[Keith, you asked for it]

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#34

Mark, could you please.....

Terry Daniel

>repeat that? :)

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#35

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft Whew!

Ruth Niles

>Well, there were a lot of excellent responses to this question of no possible answers. First I'd like to say I agree with Mike Schwing, Raymond's both posts, Dinyar and what D.W. said about being uncomfortable being called an artist; me, too. I think too many people identify someone as an "artist" because they feel that person is doing something they themselves can not do. Not true. Anyone can do anything, IF they are interested enough to learn.

In my mind, an artist takes the same white canvas or gray stone and creates something that is totally from their imagination. If the painter takes a canvas and makes an oragami, he then becomes a craftsman. The woodturners who use the wood as a canvas and their imaginings create a second dimension, that's an artist. The woodturner who excells at turning a perfect form, is a master craftsman. You wouldn't consider an artist and "artist" if he perfected one picture and repeated it on every canvas he bought! He'd be a production painter.

MOST of the really beautiful bowls, forms, etc. depend on the wood grain for the oohs and aahs. What if all turnings were painted black? I think there might be some that have been called "works of art" that would prove not to be so.

Keith, I definitely would attend a seminar, demonstration or presentation on design and form, in fact, I'd attend it twice. I want to turn a beautiful form, paint it black and know it's still going to be a beautiful form. Example: I posted a picture of a black walnut platter I turned and got a lot of praise. Was it a good form? No. Was the grain awesome? Yes. Did I create the grain with purpose? I wish!

Ruth

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#36

Keith Tompkins

Re: Your thoughts - Warning-Long

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks for all the responses....I think we have solved the art/craft debate! LOL.

To me, art is a piece , or even a concept, so well done that it almost takes your breath away. It could be a bowl, a painting, vessel, whatever. To my way of thinking, art is something that should reflect what good there is in the human race. God knows there is enough bad all ready.

I despise politically motivated "Art". Want to make a political statement? Write a book. I recently attended a concert, supposedly folk music....it was actually a thinly disguised political rally. I came to enjoy a bit of music, and ended up hearing someone telling me how to think. I left.

I'll take all the design info I can find.....I'll figure out the rest, without the esoteric nonsense.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#37

Keith Tompkins

Re: I've noticed quite the opposite...

Keith Tompkins

>Peter, a question.....If a turning such as bowl is well done technically, but with a poor form....is the maker truly a craftsman? I look at the highest achievements (IMHO) in woodworking..the windsor chair, and the cabriole (Queen Anne) leg, with the ball and claw foot. The best examples of these are the epitome of craftsmanship and display a great understanding of proportion, balance, etc. Just like art.

To me a bowl with a clumsy foot and a poor sense of balance would not be considered good craftsmanship since an understanding of form has not yet been achieved. Pieces like the one I described can be seen everywhere.....my opinions of course...

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#38

Keith, please don't ask what a "Hero" means..

Gerry in Maryland

>

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#39

Re: Your thoughts - Warning-Long

JamieDonaldson

>Mark- you are very close to another dilemma- there is a symbiosis of art from the masses,some would say "illiterate," and the modern"educated" man(oops,or person), and its labeled FOLK ART!

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#40

Re: Short Thought

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Not my dilemma, Jamie. That's the labelers' problem. |;-}}}

[And Grandma Moses (work) hangs in MOMA, along with a Movado watch, and a bicycle seat]

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#41

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

Eaglesc

>I thought anything that wouldn't hold soup was considered art.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#42

Yes...

Peter Teubel

>I would agree. But (IMO) I wouldn't consider a perfectly proportioned and flawlessly finished salad bowl as "Art". Artistic perhaps, but not "Art". Again, I believe art is an extremely subjective thing that not everyone (including myself) truly understand. There are some aspects of it that can be grasped with some effort (proportion, balance, etc.) but then things start to get fuzzy, grey, and (let's face it ) opinionated.

Personally, I will never become an "Artist". I'm too left-brained for that. But that's perfectly OK with me. I enjoy making both decorative and function objects from raw wood and while some may even have some artistic tendencies and/or elements, the joy of creation is what keep me going.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#43

grain as an artistic element

Shawn L

>it's true that the grain of the wood is a big part of the oohs and ahhs- but isn't part of the turner's skill set a control of the grain? At the beginning, it's just luck, later you get better at judging where the grain will go within your intended piece.

And sometimes, when you've had enough experience, the grain becomes something that lifts a bowl out of the ordinary...

and turns it into art.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#44

my favorite quote on the subject *LINK*

Shawn L

>"A man who works with his hands is a laborer.

A man who works with his hands and his brain is a craftsman.

But a man who works with his hands and his brain and his heart is an artist. "

Supposedly said by Charles Dickens, but it really sounds more like William Morris!

As far as I have been able to formulate, "Craft" is part of "Art" and vice-versa. "craft" is the skills in the medium of choice- wood turning, in this case- and "Art" is the message which the work carries. I don't think many woodturners expect to carry a message within a bowl or spindle, but I know some that do, and my own work- dumb little spindles though they are- seem to resonate with people... maybe its all the guff I spout as a sales pitch! :)


my sales site..

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#45

the criteria are a little different

Shawn L

>at least, at this moment in time. Art has become separate from craft. It's function is communication, not technical perfection... the young'uns in school seem to think that a high level of skill is suspect in an artist! I disagree, and I think most people would also. For one thing, there's the issue of the visual message- if your skills as a craftsman are too poor, you won't be able to produce the vehicle for said message!

A poorly crafted bowl, with bad form and lumpy sides and ripped up surface could be used in a work of art, although I wouldn't be too impressed with it

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#46

Re: does an artist have to...

woodspinner/ Bill Hale

>The ability to create form and quality is the crafstman.

The ability to use the life in the wood and to make the grain become alive and beautiful is the artist.

The artist is one who can see something special in the dirty, ugly old log and the craftsman makes it happen.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#47

art vs craft, endless discussion

John K Jordan

>I didn't have time to read all of this thread, but I suspect the discussion was going strong when Michelangelo was building scaffolds for painting ceilings. I laughed when I found this last night while reading the Letters in an old FWW from a 1/4 century ago:

"There are several of us in this area who subscribe to Fine Woodworking. We all agree that you are emphasizing too much of what we call "art" and not woodworking. We strongly believe that this modernistic and impressionistic furniture has no lasting appeal and we feel it should be shown in an art magazine and not one published for a craft...

"As much as I enjoy your other articles I will not renew my subscription if you continue to pursue these articles. I believe you have the finest magazine going for the craft of woodworking and you are striving to destroy this image by opting to please the artists and not the craftsmen--there is a fine difference. Please show more and write more on any period furniture, but please stay away from the gaudiness." --Mel R. Bird, Huron, Ohio, FWW, May/June 1979

My take: as long as there are two people, there will be two opinions.

JKJ in East TN

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#48

Re: art vs craft, endless discussion

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>he he

Since I haven't noticed any change in FWW, I have to wonder if Mr. Bird has cancelled his subscription.

How terrible it must be to be born 250 years late. I wonder, if some 18th century artist hadn't invented/designed those "period" pieces so near and dear to his sense of craftsmanship, where would that fellow be now? Making Louie XIV stuff, perhaps?

M