Re: Your thoughts - Warning-Long
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>I've watched this thread with great interest, and see many familiar concepts being raised. In almost every case, nobody seems to question the basic premise that there is, indeed, some difference between "art" and "craft." I would suggest that, with so many people, from trained designers, like Fred, to pure hobbyists, to teachers like Keith having trouble reaching a viable consensus (you ain't the first with that problem, guys) perhaps it's a trick question because there is (or should be) no difference.
I see folks here refer to "fine art" and impute "messages" or higher meaning to "works of art" than to things merely "crafted" with high skill. I so often see people almost uniformly demand that "art works" have titles and carry deeper meanings or insight. What is this compulsion to graft literature onto non-verbal, purely visual creations? Does somebody think they will understand the piece if the maker gives them a tag line to which they can graft a bunch of literary references? Is it that they're afraid that they won't or can't reach some understanding of what they are looking at without that word-crutch?
How many of the people here put names on their pieces? Why? Do you feel that some person down the road won't get your "message" without the literary tag? Do you think that the attached words will make your piece better or more worthy? Is that a critisism of your piece or a comment on that future person's sensibilities or, perhaps, both? If you really want to communicate thoughts and concepts through language, write a book, but let your piece communicate about itself, for itself, by itself. The people who get it, will; those who don't, won't.
I had a professor in African Art when I was in graduate school who went to great lengths about how the art of African cultures was still a vibrant part of every person's life in the villages and tribes he visited and researched. His examples were the many masks that are a central art form in the cultures, and how every person with whom he spoke, from children to village elders, seemed to have a clear understanding about an item, not only its meaning and function, but also an informed opinion on the quality of the design and fabrication of the mask itself. He then contrasted that with some man-on-the-street interviews in New York where he would pull out reproductions of, say, a Jackson Pollack painting (drips & splashes), a small Henry Moore (sculpture), or an Andy Warhol pop image, and he would literally stop people and ask them about the Art Object. He related that more than 90% of the time he got, "Well, I don't know anything about art, but I know what I like." He then asked if the person liked the object. About 90% said "Don't know" with the rest split about evenly between yes and no. When he asked the yes/no group "why?" only a very few were willing or able to give him an answer. The point of the story is that there seems to be a disconnect between modern American society and what we perceive (or have been sold) is "Art". I'll venture to say, however, that there is no such disconnect between everyday people and the products of "craft" that are everywhere and in use every day.
Where and how, then, did "art" get separated in our culture from everyday life, stuffed into museums and galleries or fountains, made a symbol of "class-struggle" between those of wealth, power, breeding, and status, and the rest of us who pound our way through rush hour, and sweat whether we'll have enough saved to see us through our old age so we don't become a burden on our kids? Are "artists" somehow better than other people, entitled to more in this life than the rest of humanity, with their "opinion" on same-sex marriage more valid than mine? Hogwash! Such attitudes only perpetuate elitism, foster anger and resentment, and serve only to feed those few who thrive on the dark side of human nature.
I'll submit that, like it or not, every person who makes something by themself, be it a wood bowl, stretched cloth with multi-colored mud smeared on it, or a rock with a hole drilled through it, is an artist, and what they make is, in some way, art. Granted, some bowls are more pleasant to look at or are better suited to a particular use, and some rocks have cleaner, better-drilled holes, so we can make some value judgments on how well the items are made, crafted if you will. But because one person imagines some celestial significance to a rock with a hole in it that they also think is missing from the beautiful bowl, doesn't make it so, and it certainly doesn't make the guy with the drill more worthy than the woman with the bowl gouge.
Personally, I think we need to drop the pretense that there is some metaphysical difference between objects called art and anything else made by people.
All Art is Craft, and All Craft is Art in a neverending continuum. The rest is literary.
[Keith, you asked for it]