New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

Posts

Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#1

Keith Tompkins

Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

Keith Tompkins

>A post by Jamie Donaldson brought up some interesting thoughts...Why are many turners opposed to being called an artist, and even worse, why do they avoid design elements that are considered artistic?

I got a couple of e-mails on the subject, and thought it would be a good topic. What bugs you about the whole artist topic? Do you consider those in the art fields elitist? Politically unpalatable? A craftsman doesn't need art or design? Personal experience with artist types? I'd like to hear your take on the subject.

I have thought about this topic for quite some time.....the art v. craft debate doesn't seem to be problem in other craft pursuits. I have banged my head against the wall a few times in frustration, when I don't get enough design students...there is certainly a bit of resistance.

Last, (just curious) would you consider attending a class or demo on form and design? Why or why not? I think the answer to this question may answer the first...

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#2

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I would be honored to be called either, and the distinction doesn't much matter as far as I am concerned. Every time I try to think about this subject, because I've seen it before, I come to the same conclusion - I just can't get worked up over it.

As far as taking a class on form and design, I surveyed our turning club on this same subject - they are very interested. I would be as well, but my interest level would depend on the type of work the presenter does. Is he an artist or a craftsman? Just kidding!

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#3

does an artist have to...

Terry Daniel

>wear those stupid sunglasses and leotards?

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#4

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

john Lucas

>Keith

I think your wrong about the debate or art vs craft not carrying over into other mediums. Clay artists and the crafts people who make ceramics from molds don't see eye to eye. Glass artists and Stained glass people fit the same mold as do Blacksmiths who do art and blacksmith who do horse shoes. It's a non ending debate. Oh did I mention art photography vs snap shooters. I just judged a photo contest and there is a lot of skill in design lacking.

I find it interesting because I don't have problem with someone who simply wants to make a bowl and have fun. I personally find the art side really interesting. I don't always understand it but I'm trying to learn. I work with a lot of artists and I have met only a few who are elitist and look down on the "lesser" craftsman. Most aare really down to earth people just trying to make a living at what they love.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#5

I've noticed quite the opposite...

Peter Teubel

>Many turners I know want to be called or consider themselves to be "Artists", but (IMO) they are not. Good craftsman, yes. But their product isn't artistic in the least. Of course, Art is a subjective thing to begin with, so who am I to say? I'm just a woodturner...

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#6

Re: I've noticed quite the opposite...

Ed in No.VA

>Art or craft? I do both with each piece. Last weekend I sold 3 turnings, a woodburning, two block prints, and a charcoal drawing on cedar. yes I finally am both. A design class, oh yes bring it on.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#7

Oooh, oooh, me, pick me...

Raymond Overman in SC

>Keith,

I've recently been contemplating this and right, wrong, or indifferent, I believe there is a certain amount of craft that an artist has to be aware of and practice to produce art. For some reason if it involves paint, sculpture, dancing or singing it's automatically art. Whether it's wood, glass or ceramics, or textiles it gets lumped into the craft genre. I think that where those become art is when the craftsperson steps into that grey area of trying to convey a thought or feeling with the piece.

For instance, a salad bowl shows a skilled accomplishment by the craftsman and can represent an enormous amount of work, patience, and even passion if the maker wants to expend the effort. The same salad bowl can be textured, scared, burned, dyed, leafed, patinated, carved or changed and the maker can want to create a sense of emotion when someone looks at the piece or holds the piece. That's when it becomes art.

Not to get too artsy for the bearded he-man crowd here but, Christian Burchard's madrone baskets are an excellent example. Every time I look at one I think of the wrinkles in a sheet and how warm they look even though I know they're made of wood. I look at a Bud Latven piece as an amazing work of art and get a feeling of standing on the edge of something that's getting ready to crumble. Binh Pho's pieces have the skill of woodturning and then the artistry of a painting. Mike's pieces go bump in the night and give little children nightmares. What can be more artistic than that? Molly's pieces are in constant movement. Your very own roses are figurative sculpture and that falls smack in the middle of the art crowd. Sorry if that offends. All of these required craft to make.

I think that there are times that an artist can leave some of the craft behind and get away with it because they're an artist and they're trying to convey a feeling, not create the perfect finish. They're not always thinking about the end result of the physical piece. It's the thoughts that it conveys that counts.

I think craftspeople can grasp for that Holy Grail of perfection and never be satisfied with their work and miss some of the feelings that make their pieces stand out from the crowd. Thus, they make things out of beautiful wood with excellent finishes that don't appeal to someone when they look at it because it looks clunky or unbalanced.

And some people can have both. I don't see one being lesser than the other. Just different.

I for one am trying to soak up as much design info as possible and as much technique as possible too so I can get some of these ideas out of my head and into a piece of wood, impress a few of my friends and get my point across without having to explain it in a 500 word essay. Some pieces I turn are just salad bowls.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#8

Re: I've noticed quite the opposite...

Bill Crommett

>Keith: In all due repect to those who have attained a place in the ranks of renown designers and have achieved recognition as artists, and I realise that in order to obtain respectability amongst their ilk they must come up with something new, such as a copy of a soup label or a distorted clock face hanging over the back of a chair. Art ? In Whose book ? I personally like to create something that pleases me, and in so doing I have committed some attrocities as well as some outstandingly beautiful objects. But regardless of the outcome I am designing something that I like and I am not trying to copy something that some other "authority" has designated as correct and proper. Am I a non-conformist ? yes ! am I warped ? Maybe, but I take little pleasure in being a copycat, no matter how acceptable it may be to those who stand in judgement.

(I wish this response frame had a spell checker)

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#9

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Keith

I have very strong feelings about this, strong enough that I am sitting this one out. It always seems to degenerate into an argument.

Bill

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: does an artist have to...

Keith Tompkins

>I do, Terry, but not absolutely required...LOL!

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#11

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

JamieDonaldson

>Come on Bill, let it out or you'll explode! I seldom draw a distinction between skilled turners being Artist or Craftsperson- why bother? It only matters to that individual! Is it true that if you work in a "studio" you're an artist, and in a "shop" or "garage" you're a craftsperson or hobbiest? The work defines the worker, and I know Art when I see it!

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#12

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Keith,

Interesting. First off, I would love a class on design and form. I think that when the luster fades and wood browns with age, all you are left with is the form, so it needs to be the strongest element of the design.

Insofar as the art/craft debate. I agree with Mike S in that I feel honored and flattered when someone refers to me as either one. In my own opinion of myself, I view myself as more of a craftsman type guy who occasionally has an artistic moment in a few pieces, be they turned pieces or "flatwork" projects. I tend to want to turn bowls and vessels that people can use and that just seems more "crafty" to me than "artsy". That's not to say that you cannot get really good art in a day to day bowl. I think you can, but that again brings us back to the form of the piece. However, some people, and I sometimes find myself doing this, seem to equate "art" with high prices and basically unusable stuff while "Craft" is lower priced, a little rougher maybe (as we turners would define rough) and more suited to everyday use. I think my goal is to create art pieces that you can use everyday!!!

I'm curious to see what others think,

Mike

An artsy craftsman or a crafty artisan in Apex, NC??

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#13

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

Steve Mushinski

>Art wears the green tee shirt with the funny men on it. I know him when I see him too!

Asking Bill to let it out had me ROFLMAO. Careful what you ask for sometimes.

Art verse craft - I still believe craft must come first then the art. I personally didn't understand the art until I spent sometime at Arrowmont. I am learning. Where things get cloudy is when one gets more exposure then the other. Something that tend to happen in our area of interest. Carved, painted, and burned items seems to take the front shelf space while the nicely turned item is to the back.

I for one like them both very much. Hell I would call anything I turn "Art" if I can then sell it for 100's if not 1000's of dollars.

To Bill! Them cherry burls you turn - must be art as they will not hold any soup.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#14

Re: Oooh, oooh, me, pick me...

DWFII

>I think you're on the right track...Art (especially with a capital "A") is almost universally regarded as a "communication." And the Artist creates almost exclusively to communicate an idea or a feeling, or share an experience which, to be effective, has to resonate, even if only dimly, with other human beings. But, in addition, the perception has to bear some resemblance to the original intent.

Where I disagree is that just because a person "feels" something when they view a "work" is no guarantee that there was ever a message intended much less that the "feeling" is what the creator had in mind. And if that's so, there is no Art, in my opinion.

I've been a craftsman (a custom bootmaker) for over thirty years. I've had people call me an artist. I am very uncomfortable with that label. For all the fancy inlays and elaborate ornamentation and my own obsession with technique and refinement, I've never once thought that there was any message in my work. For me, at least, such a conceit somehow rings hollow.

On the other hand I take great pride in being a Craftsman (with a capital "C") and in my own life's pursuit of excellence and elegance of form.

All this may be too wrapped up in self-esteem and one's hoped-for persona to ever be defined or answered definitively. But in my mind, for the artist the end result...the message...is the be-all and end-all; for the Craftsman the journey itself is paramount.

Just two cents for the kitty....

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#15

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

Ed Kelle

>Another thought provoking topic Keith.

Well, my beliefs here might not settle any argument, but it will present my experiences. I started out in photography, then went into painting, then into sculpture, into airbrushing, into grahic design and packaging, and now into woodworking and turning.

One of the biggest issues I have is just with classification in general. As a painter, I worked mostly in abstract works. I did some realistic works but I prefer abstract. I worked off gut feelings and emotions. Very often I was disturbed by people trying to describe one meduim, a purely visual one, in terms of another, verbal as in critiques. Of course it is possible to rationalize anything in a work of art after it is done, but while it is being made, I never was using words to describe what I wanted to do. My emotions, and eyes and hands led me. I would know inside myself when I piece was done. I did not try to equate the left side of the brain with the right.

As a graphic designer, I was shocked and a bit offended when people were suprised that I could draw and paint. They did not see us as artistic, just computer people. And now with advances in software, it seems like "anbody" can do graphics, so why do they need to pay you when they can do it themself. Very disturbing. I've left the industry since.

I've since been trying to find my way in wood. I've joined my local woodworking club and have since noticed that many people do not think they are artistic at all, simply because they have not been taught to develop their senses. I've given demos a few times now, and always I hear te same thing... "I'm not artistic". I believe that can be overcome no matter what anyone can say. Its just a matter of recognizing what you see already. You make choices based upon what you have already seen and have been pleased by. People somehow can know when something is the wrong size, or a curve is not pleasing. Its when they try to put this into words that problems arise.

A good exapmle is in drawing. Every child starts to draw and is very happy. But as we age, this skill is usually not encouraged any more not deveolped. thus people believe they can not draw. Entirely not true. Its just that they do not know how to see correctly. People look and classify their subject rather than see plain shapes and forms. Again, the left side vs right side of the brain conflict. the key to drawing is letting the visual side of the brain take over, and just go with the flow. It can sometimes become almost a trance. I've had many times when I was so deep in concentration, that words became hard to understand or speak. Visual is simply a different language, but is often overlooked.

The more exposure you have to works the more it develops an image bank in your head and will serve to inspire you. Or lead to a light bulb going on in your head.

Tonight I gave a demo to the club on texturing your works. While my experinece with it so far has been limited in comparison to what I have seen here, it was a world of wonder to these woodworkers. I hope that it was beneficial to them, and will open them up to new possibilities in their personal works, regardless of what form their work takes.

The whole, arts vs crafts... I don't believe I need classifications for that. I enjoy works with good form, not a simple thing to do at all, and I also enjoy artistic works. Personally, I have no need to classify myself as anything other than Creator. Its the entire process of creating something myself that holds value to me. As we all have probably noticed this is becoming increasingly rare in the days of mass production. People are amazed at what we do as turners in general, while I can sit here and be self critical of myself in comparison to all the fantastic works I have viewed and learned from here. What matters the most to me is that I continue to learn and explore with the help of this and other forums. One of the most important thing i have learned from all my varying experiences is that the biggest gains come only by taking the biggest risks. Pushing the boundrys is both exciting and scary at the same time. I've had success and failures. But in the end, it is the journey that I treasure.

I'll just leave the arts vs crafts argument to others while I create and try to teach others to create.

I hope you continue to do your design class to bring inspiration and understanding to others.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#16

does an artist have to...

Terry Daniel

>wear those stupid sunglasses and leotards?

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#17

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

Arch

>I don't know what art is as in "art versus craft" in woodturning. I don't even know what it isn't. I spent four years in a college of arts and sciences and was never sure which classes were which, although I never took an art class according to the catalog.

It's said that when you can measure something in terms of the five senses, you know something about it. Craftsmanship is about degrees of expertness or skill, and can be learned and measured, at least by comparison. Usually when there are several satisfactory answers to a question or reasonable solutions to a problem there is not a true best one. Witness art vs craft.

If you consider 'art' as a way to communicate without the use of language then it is perceived more in the mind than by the senses and need not be pleasing to them. I think we should learn about pleasing forms and good designs and efficient function in order to be good craftsmen. IMO art probably has more to do with talent, craftsmanship more to do with Greek rectangles, ratios and means.

Regarding our attitudes toward artists and elitists,

I think it's often easier to disparage or laugh at things that we know nothing about than to make the effort to learn and appreciate them. Ignorance seeks out ignorance to deny inferiority and bolster ego, at least a lot of us 'good ole boys' in my hometown did. We made fun of classical music, poetry, fine art, ballet, and the like until later with just a modicum of understanding, we learned to enjoy some of them, usually in secret.

If any of you have bothered to read this far, you know I told the truth in my first sentence and the rest is bull excrement. But Keith did ask and I didn't have the good sense not to answer. :)

Arch

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#18

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

Bruce Wiseman

>I agree with John. My wife is a weaver and they have exactly this same discussion. Someone who weaves but uses existing patterns or color schemes, are they a craft person or an artist?

Why do we have to label it at all? IMO both words are tied up in emotional meanings. People have some baggage with both words and some personal idea of there meaning.

This is my hobby, I do it for fun, so maybe I'm not qualified to speak about art v.s. craft and I am not too concerned about it. I just love the feel of the tool as it meets the wood, the smell of the wood and the long ribbons of wood that seem to float in the air for a moment before they drop. I don't know if what I do is art or craft or both, I just know it is a passion.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#19

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

echo8287

>I recently returned from a visit to New York city and went through "The Metropolitan Museum of Art". Lots of painting ,sculptures,exihibits etc. My daughter is an art major and she was guiding my tour.She was pleasantly surprised at seeing all the paintings she had studied and was giving me the background info on the artists in question. Some were said to be incredibly smart people and some were deranged. Some painting intricate,some relativitly simple, all were deemed art.There were all types of people,all races,all nationalities going thru the museum. Some seemed to like one kind of painting and others something different. Art might be a vision in each persons mind oweing to ones self.It could be made by an artist or a craftsman. I see an exquistic wooden chair that is surely art, but made by a true craftsman. I see a Cambell's soup can painting(Warhol) that might be art, but I think I might be able to paint it(semi-craftsman).Maybe not come up with the idea ,but the actual painting. Musicians are called artists,plumbers are called craftsmen. As a building tradesman, I've always thought I was a plumbing/electrician artist.I just work in a piping /lighting medium. I sign my work in the panel and on the sewer line as it leaves the building. David

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#20

Revealing insight .... LONG and WORDY

Fred in NC

>Can be found in the dictionary by looking up the word ART !!

Interestingly, none of the definitions include uniqueness, but creativity and beauty seem to be important elements. I guess most art gallery people will disagree with the dictionary definition !

Having spent over two decades in the graphic arts field, dealing with advertising agency art directors, some of my views on DESIGN will probably be quite different from others in this forum.

My point is that to become a graphic artist, one must learn the time honored rules of design. To make a living as a graphic artist, one must become proficient as a designer. Yet, one who simply applies all these rules all the time will never attain recognition as a top-notch artist !!

The usual progression in any craft is to first learn how to use the tools of the trade (worker), then become proficient (craftsman). Some will go beyond this level, and attain the level of master craftsman or artist, or whatever fancy title is customary in the respective discipline.

The point is that one must learn the rules before once can successfully break them and produce art. Look at the early work of Pablo Picaso and Salvador Dali. Then look at their later work, and you will find some cleverly applied design principles that are not obvious but to a few.

The subject of "what is art" comes up frequently in woodturning forums, and to me is valid. Yet this is still a woodturning forum, not one JUST for woodturning artists. Let's remember that not everyone here thinks the same or has the same level of proficiency. Not everyone has the same ambitions either. Remember the day you first touched a turning tool, and try to remember the day you first became an art critic.

Artists have been know that starved during their lifetime. Their work was not valued until it was too late for them. I give a lot of credit to an artist who is smart enough to produce sellable items and make a living while also working on the more artsy stuff.

Myself? I have just chosen to be critical of critics....

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#21

Wormy and spalted subject . . .

Fred in NC

>

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#22

Tarheel opinion ....

Fred in NC

>IF you can define art ...

. THEN your definition is wrong ...

ELSE you can't define art ...

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#23

Re: Art v. Craft---with a different question

Dinyar Chavda

>I have to agree with Peter Teubel's comment where he says that "Many turners I know want to be called or consider themselves to be "Artists", but (IMO) they are not". In fact, the only turner I know that I consider to be an artist, but who has steam come out of his ears if you call him that, is Bill Grumbine! And people in the PA tuning community still talk in hushed tones about the guy who still has nightmares about flames shooting out of Bill's magnificent nostrils when he called Bill an "artiste! Whether he wants to be called an artist or not, some of the work that Bill has produced certainly transcends craft, at least, and, IMOWISNU, is art.

What I find interesting in several comments made in this and other threads on this issue is that some people seem to think that if you just make a bowl, you are practicing a craft, but that it you burn it, or carve it, or stain or paint it, etc., you are somehow creating art. In other words, one craft + one craft somehow = art! I think not.

Having said that, I guess I need to try to explain what I consider art vs craft. To me, it is tied up in the issue of creativity. When I look at the work of a great craftsperson, my reaction is "How the heck did he ever do that?", or "How did she ever make that part of the piece so well?". If I look at the work of a great artist, my reaction is "I never dreamt of seeing things that way. How did he/she ever imagine something that way?" Note that this definition makes Einstein as much of an artist (a creator) as Picasso, as they both saw the world in a completely different way from the way it had been seen, and forced us mere mortals to see their vision! Looked at from that viewpoint, it is apparent why I think that very few craftsmen are artists--if I have offended you, keep reading as I haven't posed my question yet.

It also means that what one man considers art, another may consider craft, and a third may consider junk---perfectly all right. To some extent, to be considered an artist, in most cases, a certain amount of time has to pass before one can be sure that the work really is art, and not just craft (or junk). (Dying, particularly violently, seems to aid in such recognition!)

Keith, you asked: why do they avoid design elements that are considered artistic? I'm not sure what you mean by "design elements that are artistic", so I cannot answer that question.

The "different question" referred to in the subject title that I am interested in, and is an issue that I have been thinking about for a while now (actually, ever since a dinner where Art Liestman, David Ellsworth, and some collectors and unbranded turners were present), is the following:

What is of more use to woodturning today---art or craft?

Think about this for a while, and come up with your own opinion before proceeding, and do that several times over the rest of this commentary.

The reason I ask this question is because I make primarily non-functional hollow objects, and people look at my stuff, and, invariably the response is "That's very nice. What do you do with it?" (The last sentence usually comes out as one word, as in "whatdoyoudowithit?") Note that I do not claim that what I do is art, but my objects certainly can't hold water! And this is not an uncommon question. As Raymond Overman observed: "For some reason if it involves paint, sculpture, dancing or singing it's automatically art. Whether it's wood, glass or ceramics, or textiles it gets lumped into the craft genre." Very true. Talk to a gallery owner or a gift shop owner, and they will tell you that wood is hard to sell. There is a perception that if it is a turned object, it must be a salad bowl. Even if it is something that is too pretty to be used as a salad bowl, it can be displayed on a shelf, and the buyer will not have to be faced with the question from their friends, "whatdoyoudowithit?"

I used to get annoyed at this question, but, actually, it is a reasonable question. Note that I am not talking about the Del Mano buyers, or attendees at the CWA--which is a small group of people that most of us do not have access to. I am talking about the buyer at a small gallery or gift shop, or a craft show, etc.. He/she has a limited amount of money, and has to decide between an artsy wooden object that they don't know what to do with, or a functional item like a bowl or a box (whose possible purpose is clear, whether or not it is ever used for that), and everything else in the store/craft show, that includes other kinds of artsy things in other more acceptable media, as well as wearable jewelry, or pretty clothing, etc., i.e., items that are pretty and also useful. This describes the majority of our customers--perhaps not in $ amount, but certainly in terms of size of population. And so, the question is, which turner serves these people better? And thereby does more of a service to turning?

To provide a concrete example, I'll pick Trent Bosch (partly because he does both functional and non-function art-like pieces, and partly because he doesn't seem to frequent WC, so he won't beat me up if I offend him!) Trent makes functional bowls, with a little decoration to them (in fact he has a video on it), plus he makes his Vessels of Illusion (that look like a hollow form within a hollow form), as well as sculptural looking work. Let's ignore the debate about whether the last two items are art, and assume that they are at least more art than the first type of objects (functional bowls). The question I have is: when does he serve woodturning better in today'smarket? Is he helping turning more when he makes the decorated functional bowls, and thereby attracts buyers who never imagined that a salad bowl could be an object of beauty, or when he gets "oohs" and "aahs" from a more sophisticated audience over his Vessels of Illusion or his sculptural turning?

Again, stop and think about what your response would be to this question, before going on to my opinion.

As someone who has worked in marketing all my life, and in how to develop markets, the obvious strategy is for Trent to work in both areas, as the segments are totally different. However, looking at it from the point of view of woodturning as a whole, it is my opinion that he is doing more for the practice when he takes this larger mass of the public that thinks of turning just in terms of salad bowls that they can get at their local Wal-Mart for a very low price, and persuades them to buy one of his decorated functional bowls. In my mind, he is providing more of a service when he does that, than when he is selling to people who are already sophisticated about wood-turned objects.

So, here's another aspect of the art vs craft issue---not whether what someone produces can be considered art or craft, not whether the person wants to be called an artist or a craftsman, but who is more valuable to the craft at this time, when most of our buying audience has a hard time grasping the concept of wooden objects as being anything more than utilitarian.

After all that, you may ask what I turn---I turn non-functional, decorative objects, because I am selfish, and that is what I enjoy doing. I have to admit that unless I can figure out a way to sell more of them, I'm going to have to build a storeroom for these objects, as it is difficult to sell them. :-)

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#24

Re: Art v. Craft---clarification

Dinyar Chavda

>I should point out that the above represents my opinion, and not that of the people mentioned in the posting, who are obviously welcome to comment (and disagree) if they like.

Re: Your thoughts...Art v. Craft

#25

Re: does an artist have to...

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Keith,

This post is no good without a picture!

Tom