Re: Art v. Craft---with a different question
Dinyar Chavda
>I have to agree with Peter Teubel's comment where he says that "Many turners I know want to be called or consider themselves to be "Artists", but (IMO) they are not". In fact, the only turner I know that I consider to be an artist, but who has steam come out of his ears if you call him that, is Bill Grumbine! And people in the PA tuning community still talk in hushed tones about the guy who still has nightmares about flames shooting out of Bill's magnificent nostrils when he called Bill an "artiste! Whether he wants to be called an artist or not, some of the work that Bill has produced certainly transcends craft, at least, and, IMOWISNU, is art.
What I find interesting in several comments made in this and other threads on this issue is that some people seem to think that if you just make a bowl, you are practicing a craft, but that it you burn it, or carve it, or stain or paint it, etc., you are somehow creating art. In other words, one craft + one craft somehow = art! I think not.
Having said that, I guess I need to try to explain what I consider art vs craft. To me, it is tied up in the issue of creativity. When I look at the work of a great craftsperson, my reaction is "How the heck did he ever do that?", or "How did she ever make that part of the piece so well?". If I look at the work of a great artist, my reaction is "I never dreamt of seeing things that way. How did he/she ever imagine something that way?" Note that this definition makes Einstein as much of an artist (a creator) as Picasso, as they both saw the world in a completely different way from the way it had been seen, and forced us mere mortals to see their vision! Looked at from that viewpoint, it is apparent why I think that very few craftsmen are artists--if I have offended you, keep reading as I haven't posed my question yet.
It also means that what one man considers art, another may consider craft, and a third may consider junk---perfectly all right. To some extent, to be considered an artist, in most cases, a certain amount of time has to pass before one can be sure that the work really is art, and not just craft (or junk). (Dying, particularly violently, seems to aid in such recognition!)
Keith, you asked: why do they avoid design elements that are considered artistic? I'm not sure what you mean by "design elements that are artistic", so I cannot answer that question.
The "different question" referred to in the subject title that I am interested in, and is an issue that I have been thinking about for a while now (actually, ever since a dinner where Art Liestman, David Ellsworth, and some collectors and unbranded turners were present), is the following:
What is of more use to woodturning today---art or craft?
Think about this for a while, and come up with your own opinion before proceeding, and do that several times over the rest of this commentary.
The reason I ask this question is because I make primarily non-functional hollow objects, and people look at my stuff, and, invariably the response is "That's very nice. What do you do with it?" (The last sentence usually comes out as one word, as in "whatdoyoudowithit?") Note that I do not claim that what I do is art, but my objects certainly can't hold water! And this is not an uncommon question. As Raymond Overman observed: "For some reason if it involves paint, sculpture, dancing or singing it's automatically art. Whether it's wood, glass or ceramics, or textiles it gets lumped into the craft genre." Very true. Talk to a gallery owner or a gift shop owner, and they will tell you that wood is hard to sell. There is a perception that if it is a turned object, it must be a salad bowl. Even if it is something that is too pretty to be used as a salad bowl, it can be displayed on a shelf, and the buyer will not have to be faced with the question from their friends, "whatdoyoudowithit?"
I used to get annoyed at this question, but, actually, it is a reasonable question. Note that I am not talking about the Del Mano buyers, or attendees at the CWA--which is a small group of people that most of us do not have access to. I am talking about the buyer at a small gallery or gift shop, or a craft show, etc.. He/she has a limited amount of money, and has to decide between an artsy wooden object that they don't know what to do with, or a functional item like a bowl or a box (whose possible purpose is clear, whether or not it is ever used for that), and everything else in the store/craft show, that includes other kinds of artsy things in other more acceptable media, as well as wearable jewelry, or pretty clothing, etc., i.e., items that are pretty and also useful. This describes the majority of our customers--perhaps not in $ amount, but certainly in terms of size of population. And so, the question is, which turner serves these people better? And thereby does more of a service to turning?
To provide a concrete example, I'll pick Trent Bosch (partly because he does both functional and non-function art-like pieces, and partly because he doesn't seem to frequent WC, so he won't beat me up if I offend him!) Trent makes functional bowls, with a little decoration to them (in fact he has a video on it), plus he makes his Vessels of Illusion (that look like a hollow form within a hollow form), as well as sculptural looking work. Let's ignore the debate about whether the last two items are art, and assume that they are at least more art than the first type of objects (functional bowls). The question I have is: when does he serve woodturning better in today'smarket? Is he helping turning more when he makes the decorated functional bowls, and thereby attracts buyers who never imagined that a salad bowl could be an object of beauty, or when he gets "oohs" and "aahs" from a more sophisticated audience over his Vessels of Illusion or his sculptural turning?
Again, stop and think about what your response would be to this question, before going on to my opinion.
As someone who has worked in marketing all my life, and in how to develop markets, the obvious strategy is for Trent to work in both areas, as the segments are totally different. However, looking at it from the point of view of woodturning as a whole, it is my opinion that he is doing more for the practice when he takes this larger mass of the public that thinks of turning just in terms of salad bowls that they can get at their local Wal-Mart for a very low price, and persuades them to buy one of his decorated functional bowls. In my mind, he is providing more of a service when he does that, than when he is selling to people who are already sophisticated about wood-turned objects.
So, here's another aspect of the art vs craft issue---not whether what someone produces can be considered art or craft, not whether the person wants to be called an artist or a craftsman, but who is more valuable to the craft at this time, when most of our buying audience has a hard time grasping the concept of wooden objects as being anything more than utilitarian.
After all that, you may ask what I turn---I turn non-functional, decorative objects, because I am selfish, and that is what I enjoy doing. I have to admit that unless I can figure out a way to sell more of them, I'm going to have to build a storeroom for these objects, as it is difficult to sell them. :-)