Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

home made scrapers - worth it?

Posts

home made scrapers - worth it?

#1

home made scrapers - worth it?

Tim conlon

>Hi,

In the catalog, heavy 3/8" scrapers cost $75 each. I need a straight one and a curved one at least.

I thought I could make my own using 3/8 x 1" carbon steel bar stock. Heat treat to harden and of course sharpen more often than HSS. Is this viable? Or shoud I just bit the bullet and shell out the money for the factory made scrapers. Any success stories out there with home made scrapers?

Thanks.

Tim

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

#2

How about $45@... *LINK*

Peter Teubel

>Go for the BIG scrapers (1/2" thick). They are on sale at Woodcraft (see link).


1/2" thick Crown Scrapers

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

#3

JL

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

JL

>Then again, why go with carbon steel? You can get HSS blanks. They aren't cheap, but they would last a whole lot longer.

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

#4

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

john Lucas

>Tim

I did finally buy a couple. I was there, the price was right and the drool factor was high enough to make me part with the cash. I've made several of them. Scrapers are so easy to sharpen It doesn't matter to me if the burr doesn't last long.

That being said I have taken HSS pieces that I cut off from a planer blade and mounted it in 5/8" steel bar. It makes a good scraper with a long lasting edge.

I have several thinner ones made from tool steel that were heat treated by me with a MAPP gass torch. They work fine but don't cut as cleanly as the really thick one. I think vibration must have something to do with it because they are sharpened the same way.

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

#5

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

Barry Irby

>I have a straight one I made from a half inch square by about four inch HSS "bit" I bought at a local used industrial tool dealer for a $1. I drove it into the end of a piece of pipe and then put a handle on that. Not pretty, but it works great.

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

#6

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

tim conlon

>Those 1/2" scrapers look good with grinding the straight one could be modified to the shape I need. Thanks.

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

#7

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

Eduardo Sarmiento Hall-Lima Peru

>wELL i MAKE MINE FROM PLANER BLADES AND IT WORKS JUST FINE

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

#8

Re: home made scrapers - worth it? *LINK*

Don Henthorn

>I made these from 3/8" X 1 1/4 bar and I love them.







http://users2.ev1,net/~henthorn

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

#9

Re: home made scrapers - worth it?

Tim conlon

>Whooo Don! Those are beautiful! very nice work. Can you tell us more details about how you did it. What kind of steel is it. Where did the steel come from. If its carbon steel, is it hardened. Or, are they HSS scraper blanks put in custom handles? Thanks.