Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Segmented collar bowl

Posts

Segmented collar bowl

#1

Segmented collar bowl

Capt Skip

>Well I asked the question here and with that advise decided to try. I had a walnut blank which is nothing special but had some figured maple which I thought the color and figure would be a good accent to the walnut. I am anxious to get your reactions as well as see how the solid lumber movement affects the joint. I have some other thoughts about the jointing process so more experiments are most likely to follow.


img

Re: Segmented collar bowl

#2

Re: Segmented collar bowl

Don Henthorn

>The combination always looks good. I don't think you will see any expansion problems with that glue up. The reverse looks just as good, i.e., a walnut rim on a light wood base.

Re: Segmented collar bowl

#3

Re: Segmented collar bowl

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Man you learn fast Skip! That looks gorgeous bud. I'm afraid that it'll blow apart in a few seasons, but hopefully that theory will be proven wrong.

Re: Segmented collar bowl

#4

Re: Segmented collar bowl

Doug Trembath

>It's hard to say, Mike, it depends on how wet the different woods are. My guess is that the Walnut will be wetter, and the Maple is kiln dried. Well, I did say guess...

If the moisture gradient isn't too far off, it may well not show any deterioration at all, since the two woods are relatively stable, and highly compatible. If it does come apart, the beauty of this craft is that you can always make another one, to replace it. May even be able to reuse the segments!

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: Segmented collar bowl

#5

Re: Segmented collar bowl

Doug

>What do yopu mean blow apart? Do you think the rings will seperate from the bowl?

BTW I think it looks awesome.

Re: Segmented collar bowl

#6

Re: Segmented collar bowl

Capt Skip

>I think Mike is refering to the fact the walnut bowl is a whole peice wereas the coller is short long grain peices. There could be some wood movement expected but I am hoping it is minimum. I don't recall seeing any other bowl done like this and there could be a reason. This was practice for me for my form design. This bowl will be used for our church as a collection plate for Sunday School. So if it falls apart maybe the donations will go up to replace this one. :)

Re: Segmented collar bowl

#7

Re: Segmented collar bowl

Capt Skip

>Mike thanks for the encouragement. This forum inspires many and provides tremendous information to all.

Re: Segmented collar bowl

#8

Nice job!

Dominic Greco at home in Richboro, PA

>Capt Skip,

This looks great! Having used a similar combo before, I always been fond of putting together contrasting woods. I started calling mine "hybrid bowls" since they're a combination of solid, and segmented bowls.

The one piece of advice I can pass on is to have both the wood for the segmented ring and the solid wood bowl as dry as possible. This will minimize (not eliminate) the movement.

From the looks of things, you've already gotten down the glue line trick. Again, fantastic job!

See ya around,

Dominic