I have one
Kent in Emmaus, PA
>Gulp! Looks like I may be the only HF supporter here.
I've had the Harbor Freight 12x36 for about a year. This is the cast bed version that goes for about $180 on sale - HF has some cheaper steel tube lathes that I wouldn't consider. It's not exactly the same as the Jet: The HF is Chinese, while the Jet is made in Taiwan, but it's a very close copy. As far as I can tell, the HF is the same machine as the Grizzly 12x36.
Now, I'm just a novice turner, so take that into account. So far, I've done some furniture parts, a walking staff, pens, and something resembling a plate. The HF lathe has done everything I've asked. It runs smooth and the variable speed works well. The tail stock will slip a bit if I crank on it hard... but, judging from the "Jet Mini Tailstock Creep" thread, that's not an exclusive HF problem.
The bottom line is, I'm learning a lot and having fun. For me, the HF lathe was a great way to get my feet wet in turning for a minimum investment. If I decide to upgrade in a few years, I could sell the lathe cheap and feel I got my money's worth out of it. As Bill mentioned, a brand name tool will be easier to sell, but even if the Jet retains 75% of it's value, and the HF only 30%, it's a wash.
I believe those who say that the Jet is better. But for more than twice the price, I think it would be tough to say that it's twice as good. If you want the best lathe under $500, the Jet is probably it, but I think the HF deserves a nod for best value.
Like I said, I'm the newbie here, and I could just be basking in ignorance. If there's anything specific I'm missing, I'd like to learn about it.