Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

Posts

Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#1

Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

Chuck Harris

>I'm shopping for a 36" lathe with CI bed for turning 20 - 24" chair legs. I've been looking at the Jet JWL 1236 and the Central Machinery equivalent at Harbor Freight tools and there seems to be no difference in features. On sale I can get the CM lathe for $190 vs $500 for the Jet. Does anyone have any experiences with the Jet or the Central Machinery that could shed light on the huge price difference?

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#2

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

Ruth in S.Cal

>The CM is much cheaper at HF here in S. Cal.....it is often less than $100. CM is what it is, a first lathe to see if you like turning. Head and tailsock may not line up, the ways may not be true....and from what I recall it doesn't have a 1hp motor. If you know machinery and can do all the tinkering to get it running true and in alignment, and, if you haven't really tried turning, look for it on line at HF for a better price. However, if you are already into turning you will be replacing the CM within a few months. Ebay has a whole tone of very cheap lathes that would be better than this. IMHO.

There is a mountain of info on this site about the Jet.....

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#3

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

Bill Grumbine, Kutztown PA

>Hi Chuck

The features are pretty much the same. The quality of the fit and finish are what make the difference, and it is worth it on several levels. The HF lathe has its adherents, but if it were me, and it was at one time, I would go for the Jet. Not only will you have a better quality machine to use, if you decide to upgrade, it will probably be easier to sell.

Good luck with whichever you choose.

Bill

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#4

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

Andy in Raleigh

>I concur with Ruth. I have a "Rand" that is really an HF lathe a size or two down (10x20) from the one you are looking at. I bought it on eBay for under $90 delivered. I am not sorry I bought it because I never would have ponied up $500 just to see if I like turning. Now that I know I like turning, my wife is probably sorry I bought it because I want to spend more than $500 on the next one.

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#5

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

JL work

>Don't buy cheap - unless you are into tinkering. The Jet has a slightly more powerful motor and usually has better quality. You will get better resale on the Jet, because it is a known as Bill said. Another alternative is to get a Jet mini with bed extensions. That way you can turn your spindles and have a nice small lathe for other purposes when you decide to upgrade. (But honey, the mini is small. I really need a big lathe. :))

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#6

Totally agree !!!! -

Fred in NC

>For chair legs etc. the Jet Mini with the extension will do the job. A lathe that you can keep if you go to a larger one, and the resale value is higher than most.

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#7

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

Ron in Drums PA

>I have a 1236 and have looked at Central Machinery - They look the same but are not equal. Get the Jet.

I've been thinking of upgrading my 1236 to a 1642 or 3520. Are you somewhere around NE Pennsylvania?

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#8

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

Lawrence

>Chuck,

I have the Central Machinery lathe, 12" by 36" with a 3/4 hp motor. It's my first lathe and I've been turning bowls on it for about a year. I guess I was lucky, my tailstock and head stock line up.

I did reinforce the stand and you will need to add sandbags. I agree it does not have the fit and finish of the Jet, but for me it was great way (and price) to get into turning.

Hope this helps.

Lawrence

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#9

I have one

Kent in Emmaus, PA

>Gulp! Looks like I may be the only HF supporter here.

I've had the Harbor Freight 12x36 for about a year. This is the cast bed version that goes for about $180 on sale - HF has some cheaper steel tube lathes that I wouldn't consider. It's not exactly the same as the Jet: The HF is Chinese, while the Jet is made in Taiwan, but it's a very close copy. As far as I can tell, the HF is the same machine as the Grizzly 12x36.

Now, I'm just a novice turner, so take that into account. So far, I've done some furniture parts, a walking staff, pens, and something resembling a plate. The HF lathe has done everything I've asked. It runs smooth and the variable speed works well. The tail stock will slip a bit if I crank on it hard... but, judging from the "Jet Mini Tailstock Creep" thread, that's not an exclusive HF problem.

The bottom line is, I'm learning a lot and having fun. For me, the HF lathe was a great way to get my feet wet in turning for a minimum investment. If I decide to upgrade in a few years, I could sell the lathe cheap and feel I got my money's worth out of it. As Bill mentioned, a brand name tool will be easier to sell, but even if the Jet retains 75% of it's value, and the HF only 30%, it's a wash.

I believe those who say that the Jet is better. But for more than twice the price, I think it would be tough to say that it's twice as good. If you want the best lathe under $500, the Jet is probably it, but I think the HF deserves a nod for best value.

Like I said, I'm the newbie here, and I could just be basking in ignorance. If there's anything specific I'm missing, I'd like to learn about it.

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#10

Me too

Jerry Nicholson

>I have had mine for a couple of years and it works fine for me but I haven't done any serious bowl or platter turning. I did make a couple of 10 inch diameter 1.5 inch thick wooden wheels for a toy tractor for my grandson. HF claims 3/4 hp for the motor while Griz claims 1/2 hp. I think it is the same motor, HF just tells bigger lies. It is probably actually a 1/3 hp motor and is probably as (un)reliable as any other chinese motors.

Mine is lagged to the concrete floor and I added some cross bracing to the stand. Since by owning an HF tool I have established myself as a nerd, I might as well admit to owning a Craftsman table saw (40+ years), a Craftsman drill press (35+years) and a Craftsman bandsaw (35+ years.)

Jerry

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#11

Re: Me too

Ruth in S.Cal

>I think we all have a tendency to 'brag' about having big brand, big dollar lathes....but I find it fun to hear what people have. My own lathe was 15 yrs old when I bought it from a garage sale. It is better than the HF Canadian equivalent I had, but still not what I want......but the lathe I want is more about this fantasy vision I have of me infront of a Union Graduate short bed, streams of shavings flying over my shoulder, smock, full face air controlled respirator and the most huge grin on my face. I don't own any of these things by the way...I even wear a jacket my cousin made me 20 years ago out of tent material...(he went through a clothes design phase). But that images always make me smile and one day I will spend more money than I can afford just to make it a reality.

So, I guess I am just saying that I think we all have a dream of how we will spend our disposable income on this obsessive hobby we have ( real income work for some of us). And I'm happy to say I have never once had a sense from any of the threads that anybody is down on those that have the cheepo lathes and tools.....after all, it's what you do with it! (I do think we sort of brushed off the guy who asked about stone turning.......but then again, he talked about 'guys' and 'fellows' and missed out the other half of us here so I didn't feel too bad :)

What do you all think about posting pictures of ourselves next to our lathes?

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#12

Re: Me too

Don Henthorn

>Sounds like a good idea, Ruth.

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#13

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

Mike-in-Michigan

>HF 1236 #VGA34760 is not a bad lathe, it's actually an amazing value. Not quite the fit & finish of the Jet but it's not 350$ worse. I had one for 2 years, turned a ton of pens, bowls, etc.. on it. At that time I didn't know anything about the tailstock & head not lining up, didn't know anything 'bout possible issues with swiveling head not always coming back true, etc.. but the wood didn't seem to know about it either so it was ok.

Lots of folks who never owned this lathe will talk it down 'cause it's from HF .. but it's all cast iron in the spots it needs to be. They ways on the ones I've seen are smooth & straight. The handles are touch chincy in pot metal, but that's easy to fix if you want.

I sold that lathe when I 'bout my Nova 3000 -- sold it w/a chuck for 150$ .. high school kid bought it .. last I know (this fall) he was still turning bowls & pens on it.. makes it going strong for 4+ years.

It's a tad underpowered - the jet motor is bigger and maybe better quality (still a low end lathe, even it says JET on it). I could do maybe 9" bowls without any problem, bigger meant a very light touch. But then for spindle turning it's not important. A lot of wood spindles have been turned (including some bowls) on a lathe with 1/2 hp motors or less.

For spindle turning like you are talking about, it's a much better value in my opinion than the Jet for 350$ more.. Though I would consider a Jet VS Mini w/bed extension, unless you need the extra 2" of throw. Odd how the HF w/a 1/2-3/4 hp motor seems underpowered, but no one says the Jet Mini w/a 1/2hp is underpowered .. they really though have the same capacity when you get to bowls, 7-9" in diameter.

Just watch the sales on the web or the local HF store and don't look back. HF does have quality variations but this one has seemed to be one of their better products based on all the folks who've had one. There is a good return policy and as I said before -- the wood doesn't know the difference.

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#14

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

Arch

>Hi Chuck, Since you live in an area with enough population to have a H.F. store, there are most likely other turners or ex-turners who want to sell a good quality older lathe in good condition that fits your present needs. Acquiring a lathe is seldom an emergency and the best way is to try turning on any lathe that you are considering before you buy. In the end, the difference in lathes is in the turning.

Asking opinions to learn from other's good or bad experience is always a good beginning, but turning something, yourself, on different lathes will help you decide if a particular machine is adequate for your present needs. If you can't do the work that you want to do on it, it's no good at any price.

H.f. may fit your present plans, needs, purse and abilities perfectly well, but it does no harm to find out. Actually, the better the turner, the easier it is for he or _she_ to use marginal machines and tools.

Just one turner's opinion, other's will vary, etc.

Turn to Safety, Arch

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#15

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

GeeSeaWhy

>I used the HF lathe for nearly two years, by which time I not only knew that I wanted to upgrade, I knew what I wanted to upgrade to. I used it mostly for bowls and boxes, not much in the way of spindle work, and it always did what I wanted. Now the HF is pressed into service as a 12" disc sander while I turn on a Nova 3000 DVR.

Graeme

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#16

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

Chuck Harris

>Thanks for your reply.

I am located in southwest Virginia - probably too far to go for a lathe.

Chuck Harris

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

#17

Re: Central Machinery 12x36 lathe

Chuck Harris

>This is to each of you who has replied to my plea for insight into the Central Machinery vs Jet lathes.

I am new to woodcentral and to the use of the web as a tool for sharing - and I am overwhelmed at the amount of help which has come to me in your responses. It seems that there is something in us which longs to share this journey. My sincere thanks to each of you.

It has taken me almost a week to get back to post a response as I have to drive 45 minutes to get on the web, (but I have e-mail in my home).

I'm now torn between picking up the Jet mini w/extension tonight at the Woodcraft store 10% off sale and waiting until HF puts their CM 12x36 on sale at $180. Am most anxious to get something in hand and start turning legs and building Windsor chairs.