What's a detail gouge for?
Dan Lanicek in TX
>Newbie question: I'm was looking at a 3/8" spindle gouge at Woodcraft today and saw a 3/8" detail gouge right next to it. What is a detail gouge for and why do I feel the need to have one?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What's a detail gouge for?
Dan Lanicek in TX
>Newbie question: I'm was looking at a 3/8" spindle gouge at Woodcraft today and saw a 3/8" detail gouge right next to it. What is a detail gouge for and why do I feel the need to have one?
Re: What's a detail gouge for?
Bill Howatt
>Made for spindle work. It has much shallower flute thus making it stronger relative to the same size bowl gouge. Tend to be ground with a fingernail grind thus can get into tighter spots on a spindle than the traditional spindle gouge straight grind.
If you are a newbie, I wouldn't recommend you rush out and buy one right away. Get up to speed with the conventional tools before you get into the more specialized ones.
Bill
Re: What's a detail gouge for?
john Lucas
>Dan
A detail gouge simply has a slightly different shape or grind than a spindle gouge. It is designed to get into tighter areas for a different detail. There are a lot of different spindle gouge shapes and I don't think they have names. I have a continental gouge which is also a spindle gouge with a slightly different shape.
Bowl gouges come in different flute shapes as well. Usually the flute is deeper than spindle gouges. Some flutes are V shaped and some U shaped. These all change the shape of the grind and how the chips come out of the flute.
All of these tools also have different grinds on the tip. All of them work. They are ground differently to work better with either different shapes or different styles of turnings.
Re: What's a detail gouge for? Waiting..
TomW in SouthJersey
>That is good advice. I could have waited for my skills to improve to buy the Sorby Spindle Master. I got the Sorby DVD and saw how easily that tool worked in the video. I'm still practicing with it but don't let it get near any pieces I'm trying turn without ruining. I continue to get severe catches with it.
But they sure made it look easy in the hands of the turner in the DVD. I'm sure its a great tool that I'll appreciate someday.
Tom
Re: What's a detail gouge for? Waiting..
Russ Fairfield
>My opinion of the "Spindlemaster" is that it won't do anything that you can't do with a spindle gouge, and it is lot more difficult to use. Hang it up and get a good spindle gouge. The same goes for the "Skewchigouge".
These are the same tools that we used to grind in the dark-ages before we could buy spindle gouges. Their only advantage over a skew chisel was that it was easier to cut a cove with one of them. I discovered that by grinding a flute of sorts into the top of the tool with a round faced grinding wheel, they became an easier tool to use. At that point, they started looking like a spindle gouge.
Re: What's a detail gouge for? Waiting..
pete langevin
>the way it was explained to me about the spindle master is that its just a gouge with no flute..
its a gimick type tool like the skewchigouge.
your better off buying a separate tool for each function rather than buying one thats not adequate for any of the jobs it claims.. i have a spindlemaster and there is nothing really special about it, sorby did a good job of making it look easy in their video. thats how i got roped in too. i'd sell it to you if you were close..
your better off with a radius skew and the appropriate gouges.. detail, spindle and roughing..
detail gouge is one of those tools thats great for small finials and bottle stopper sized turnings.. if your doing that.. then you probably should keep one on your bench..
Re: What's a detail gouge for?
Bill Grumbine, Kutztown PA
>Hi Dan
I have a 1/2" Oneway detail gouge I bought way back in 1996 when I was looking for a replacement for my Sorby 1/2" spindle gouge, which had been used so heavily it had been ground down to the end of the flute. I use it frequently on spindle work, especially for the tap handles I turn, whch are 2 1/2" square. Because of the shallow flute, it can be used like a gouge, and because of the heavy cross section, it does well as a scraper. Mine is ground to a very pointy fingernail, and is useful for lots of things.
My opinion is that a lot of the "new" and "innovative" tools that are on the market are older tools dressed up to look new so that it is easier to sell them. However, I will say that I really like my detail gouge and would buy it again. For the record I also have a traditional(?) round stock 3/8" spindle gouge made by Crown. It does not get quite as much use, but it does see some.
Bill
Re: What's a detail gouge for?
RonZ
>I use the 3/8" and 1/2" detail gouge from Hamlet. This is a regular spindle gouge with a long grind. This is one of my main tools for spindle work. It works just as well as a spindle gouge but the swept-back grind is exelent for hollowoing out boxes, tight detail work and I use the edges for skew-like cuts.
Re: What's a detail gouge for?
Keith Tompkins
>HI Dan, the detail gouge is one of my favorites, I use it primarily with the bevel at 90 degrees to the work.(tool on its side)
Also an excellent tool for hollowing goblets with a bit of practice. For me, an indispensible tool.