Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

Posts

Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#1

Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Well sometimes you just get a flat out dud...at least in your own mind. These two bowls fell into that category for me. The first is a piece of spalted Hackberry that laid around forever in my shop. I love turning Hackberry so I thought this would end up being a nice big beautiful bowl. It's about 13" diameter and about 6" deep. The wood was just flat and ugly with no character at all. So bad that I decided to take a stiff wire brush in my electric drill and just scrub the heck out of it on the outside. I sanded and finished the inside. To put the ugly icing on the cake...when I signed it, I said it was Maple. Duh.


This next one was a really pretty piece of curly maple. I thought I'd make it even prettier with some black aniline dye. Ugh. I wiped the dye on, and it's just got blotchier and blotchier. Are you suppose to apply something first before the dye? I'm not very happy about this one. At least I wrote the correct specie of wood on the bottom.


All comments welcome....I think :)

Jennifer

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#2

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Jennifer,

I like the second one a lot. I think it looks great! I've used water based aniline dyes a bit and have noticed the blotchiness. Only way I've found around it is to really flood the surface with the dye, then the blotchy parts pretty much even out. I have also found that the dyes really highlight any sanding marks or other errors in the finish.

Good luck,

Mike

Flat projects ruling for now, in Apex, NC...

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#3

Ugly?

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>I think the second one is very nice!

Turning is just like cooking, if you don't say anything, people just eat it hapily...:o)

Thanks for showing

Jorge

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#4

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

Barry Irby

>I like both of them. Nice work.

Can you tell me about Hackberry? I am cutting some trees off the family farm and there is a lot of hackberry. The grain looks course. Is it heavy. Looks like you might have stopped the spalting early. Wonder if it would have been more pronounced later? I have been avoiding the hacberry, but is the wood useful?

Barry Irby

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#5

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

Jim R

>I have turned stuff just like your first one, thinking it was going to be great. Oh, what a surprise when you get inside.

The second one is very nice. The curlies do well with dye. I have never tried black but I think it is very attractive. Mike is right. I have done some dyed pen experiments and I got a nice even coat when I really flood the wood with dye. It may be a bit trickier with a large piece than a pen though. I also found out the hard way that ALL sanding marks will show up like neon lights on dyed wood. I am curious about your india ink on the previous bowl. Do you use some kind of felt tip pen or just how do you apply it? Also, the gel poly, how long between coats?

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#6

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Jennifer, spraying dye, rather than wiping or brushing, has always produced much more appealing results for me. I discovered this back in my "flat" days. I prefer alcohol based dyes, and attempt to set the spray so the dye is drying just as it lands on the surface. Might be a good excuse for you to buy some spray equipment. Applying it wet in the manner you describe has always left me wanting a better look. Spraying gives it.

I've been playing with airbrushes for a few weeks now and think it will become my preferred method for applying color, but with acrylics instead of dyes. On small scale work like turnings, compared to furniture, the airbrush will probably work great.

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#7

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

John Lucas

>Barry

I've turned a lot of Hackberry. I love it. most of the time when it spalts the black lines develope in the grain areas so it's really beautiful. Sometimes it just turns colors like Jennifers bowl. I think it's fun to turn either fresh or spalted. I usually coat one end with endgrain sealer and set the other end on the ground. It spalts quite nicely in about 2 months.

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#8

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

Ruth in So. Cal

>Jennifer, the first one is what it is...and still fully functional. The 2nd one I like a lot! Guess it's all in the eye and mind of the beholder.

ruth

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#9

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

TheHeretic

>LIke you said, one persons ugly is anothers treasure. I really like the first one. The outer finsh is definately different. The second one while definately unique does not grab me like the first one. I can only hope that in time my "uglies" are of this caliber.

Dean

Columbus OH

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#10

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Jim,

The India ink comes in a tube and I thin it just a tad with water in a Dixie cup. I apply it with a small artists paintbursh. I used painters tape to mask off where I didn't want the ink to go....and then when it was dry I used a tiny scraper to remove any place where it had seeped under the tape.

You're not kidding about the flaws showing up after the dye! ugh. I had some surprises pop up that I was not aware of prior to the dye.

I've really become fond of the Rockler wipe on gel poly. It dries very fast and you can re-apply in less than two hours.

Jen

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#11

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Thank you Barry,

I agree with John. It's really nice wood to turn. This piece was just a dud. From the ends it looked like it might have some realy nice spalting going on. Sadly those areas ended up on the floor. I had this one sitting on top of a concrete downspout splash pad and a dark garbage bag over it for one summer....I was told this was the magic formula. Hmm....

Jennifer

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#12

Re: Ugly?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Jorge...thank you :)

Why doesn't that work at dinner time at my house?

Jen

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#13

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

John Lucas

>Jennifer

I'm not sure about this, I need to run more tests. I put a lot of wood in plastic bags because It seems to store better but it doesn't spalt as good. Maybe if I put some leaves and grass in with it. There's a fine line between spalt and rot and I don't always get there. Maple and hackberry have been my most successful.

Rub some shoe polish in the pores and see what happens. Sometimes it simulates the spalting you get with hackberry. It won't do much for the blue and gray areas though.

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#14

shoe polish?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Okay John...are you pulling my leg? If I have to add one more thing to the bag of tricks I'm not going to be able to carry it!

; )

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#15

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

Barry Turner

>I think it may be the color that you find so unappealling. Maple, huh? For shame!

As for bowl number two, why black stain? I would think some color in the amber range might have been more attractive.

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#16

I like the second one

Dougj Crawfordsville, IN

>You could always let me have it. I'm just down the road from ya.

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#17

Re: try this idea

Wayne Allen - Carson City. Nevada

>Jennifer -- Russ Fairfield posted this idea regarding black dye some time ago. I believe that it is in his "Russes Corner" tips regarding the use of analine dye. -- Before putting a coat of black dye on wood, put a coat of blue dye on first. I was skeptical of this at first, especially after seeing the bright blue on the vase I made, but when the black coat was applied over the blue coat, this really does enhance the black coloring. It gives it depth and tone rather than the sort of washed out coloring that you experienced. Try this , I think that you will be surprised at the difference. --Wayne

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#18

Re: try this idea

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Thank you Wayne, I will try that. I would never have thought that would work. I do have a bottle of a Denim Blue color...perhaps next time I will try that?.....I'll try a test piece first like I should have done in the first place.

Thanks again Wayne.

Jennifer

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#19

Re: I like the second one

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Doug,

Thank you :)

Hey have you ever thought about joining the local turners club? They meet in Zionsville.

Jennifer

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#20

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi Barry,

Yes, the color of the hackberry just had no life to it. Just pretty blah...the black one was dye not stain..and I suppose it was more of an experiment than anything. I've seen some figured turnings that are dyed black that really looked fantastic.

Jennifer

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#21

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Dean...you're too kind :)

Jennifer

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#22

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Attached is a spalted and wormy hackberry weedpot I did last year. I find that hackberry turns easily and turns a beautiful gray color. This weedpot is finished with several coats of Minwax Tung Oil Finish, then buffed on the Beall system.

Re: Two Ugly Bowls w/pic

#23

heres the pic 

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>


img