Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

Posts

I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#1

I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have two very large holly blanks that should yield bowls between 16"-17" in diameter. My experience with holly remaining stable during drying has been mixed. Some of the smaller bowls I have turned have been fairly stable, some have not. My usual method of handling rough turned bowls is to leave the standard 1" wall thickness per 10" diameter with a little less in the bottom. I coat the end grain with Anchor Seal put in a paper bag and put it aside for about 1 year in my shop which is neither heated nor cooled. This method has for the most part been successful with very few cracked or severely warped bowls.

Holly this size is an almost once in a lifetime opportunity (second for me).

Based on your experiences, should I rough turn both blanks and bag as usual, turn green to finished thickness bag and dry slowly or one of each? Or do you have another idea? I would boil the blanks for safety but I don't think I have a pot big enough.

Any suggestions?

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#2

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

RonZ

>I would let it dry rough turned like you do. I usually wait six months but one year won't hurt. Also anchor seal the whole roughed out bowl not just the end grain.

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#3

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Barb,

This may be just the time to try the alcohol protocol. That process has proven successful on other woods that are difficult to dry w/o cracking, like Apple and other fruit woods.

As far as a container goes, I would just use a heavy duty trash bag.

Mark

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#4

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I had thought of the alcohol but had not gone back to re-read the information to see if it helps with cracking and distortion. I have 10 gal. back ordered but if it does not come in I may have to buy it by the gal.

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#5

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Why would you Anchor Seal the whole bowl; to slow down drying?

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#6

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

Roger

>Barbara,

Let me suggest that you check out Fred Williamson's web site... www.fredwilliamson.com. He turns bowls big and thin, and I'm sure he has turned holly. You may have caught his demo. at the symposium in Waynesboro in Nov. He's a neat fellow and and makes a living turning. Good luck.

Roger

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#7

Dick Hines

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

Dick Hines

>Barbara, I have had good luck with alcohol. I will say that if you are going to soak the holly I would make sure I have not soaked anything else in it. I have soaked different kinds of wood and my aocohol is not clear anymore. Does not seem to be a proublem with darker woods.

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#8

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

Mac

>Hi Barbara, I think the biggest problem is going to be keeping it white. Be careful to check it often if you bag it.I have also found that if it does discolor, sanding sealer will make it look like a real nice light colored walnut.That would not be as likely to discolor in my new shop up here in Maine.

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#9

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

James L. Seigal

>Barbara, I had some Holly logs that were cut about a year ago, ends sealed, cut into 8"+/- bowl blanks. I rough turned to about 1/2"-3/4" and then soaked in ethanol for 24hrs, wrapped in brown paper bags with the center exposed for about 3 wks. They all warped and cracked, some worse than others, and they all turned a sick gray color. I cut the blanks in half on my band saw and the color went all the way through. I was informed by Dave Smith that he had the best luck with Holly if he turned it as soon as it was cut and then used the alcohol method. I cut some pen blanks and air dried them and they were almost pure white. Good luck with your project. Jim

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#10

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

RonZ

>Exactly, the slower the drying process, the less chance of cracks.

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#11

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Thanks, I checked out the site- very interesting.

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#12

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>LOL Mac. I hate to think what shipping would be. The blanks must weigh about 70# each.

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#13

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>These blanks have been cut out but not turned. I have been lucky with holly staying white in the past. I hope the trend continues.

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

#14

Re: I Need Some Advice From Turners of Large Bowls

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Right but I am a little afraid of drying it too slowly because of staining.