Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Seized Drive Center (1236)

Posts

Seized Drive Center (1236)

#1

Seized Drive Center (1236)

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ran a search in the archives for 2+ years and found zip, but I know I've seen this before. Sold my 1236 to a friend with the proviso that he and his sons get some free lessons.

Lesson 1 in spindles tonight and all went well except when it came time to knock out the spur drive. Sucker is stuck like glue. Yes, I was careful to clean both tapers before insertion. The spindle did get a bit warm and I applied ice to the spur, but no go.

Since I had the lathe for 2 years and that never happened, I'm short on experience.

Will it free up whan the spindle cools off?

I have a piece of 3/8" rod that I could use as a monster KO rod, but I'm leary.

Any Suggestions?

Mark

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#2

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

Mark Kauder. Phenix City, AL

>Mark,

Apply a propane/butane torch to the spindle to raise it's temp quickly - then use the knockout bar.

Mark

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#3

Re: Seized Drive

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Thanks, MK, will try that.

MM

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#4

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

George Van in WI

>Mark, it was mentioned also to apply vinegar. I have no record of the source.

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#5

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

George Van in WI

>Mark, it was Fog Tanner.

"You might do a search in this group. There was a similar thread in the last sevral weeks, with a number of replies. An don't feel lonesome, all of us have done it. You learn real quick to wipe off the drive spur and clean out the morse taper. If you get particles in the MT, you will get a bind, if you twist on the spur, you can gall the MT and/or spur depending on the material. One guy in our club had the same problem and ppunded on the spur for a couple of hours. Another club member came over and told him to pour vinegar down the shaft, he did and the drive fell out - might be work a try.. "

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#6

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

Fred in NC

>It will probably work. Vinager rusts steel.

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#7

Re: Sour Spur?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>George,

Ran a message search back 2 years, got zip "on point."

I always clean both taper parts before insertion. Have and use a TaperMate cleaner, so the problem is not a gaul. Mystified as to what caused this as never had the problem before and I checked both tapers to make sure there has no damage since it left my shop.

Will try the vinegar. That get poured in from the the other end of the spindle?

Thanks

M

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#8

Re: Sour Spur?

John Lucas

>Mark

I haven't tried the Vinegar but be sure and flush it with water and lube well after using that stuff. It will rust quite easily. Some spindles have holes in them. I don't know why but you want to check.

Be sure your not running vinegar down the rest of the machine.

I know everyone says not to twist the center but I've helped remove 2 that way. We put a pipe wrench on the drive center and one person applied a fair amount of twist while the other used the knock out bar. Both popped out fairly easily. There didn't seem to be any damage done.

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#9

Been there, done that, didn't like it!

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi Mark,

Place your 3/8" knock out rod against the offending drive spur and rap it smartly with a small sledge hammer. I have a 4# baby that works very well. Another tip is to put a box on the ways to catch the spur drive missile when it launches. I doubt you will see any tale tell marks on the spindle tapper. My take on the problem is over aggressive tightening with the tail stock.

Dave Smith

Bigger hammer usually works in Longview, WA.

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#10

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

Pete in Holland

>Bought an old lathe with a stuck drive center this past summer. No amount of heavy pounding broke it loose. Used a propane torch to heat the spindle, but trickled cold water on the spur to keep it from getting too hot (allowing both to get hot only expands them at the same rate). A couple heavy raps with a hammer and out it came. Do not put too much heat into the spindle so as to change its color to tan or blue. Might be disturbing any heat treating that was done, let alone seals & grease in your bearings.

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#11

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

Jay Dunham

>If you have a nut that matches the spindle, cut in half (I used a Dremel), then use vise grips to put on spindle and crank it out--that's what I did, based on a tip from one of these sites. Heating would have been easier, if it worked, and if I had known to try! But now I've got the nut and I continue to use that whenever I've got this problem.

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#12

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

Barry Irby

>There was previous post on this topic. Someone posted a message about some kind of spray you could use to chill or freeze the spur while heating the shaft. Freeze Out or something.

I would be concerned about heating the shaft with a torch. Might ruin the temper or the bearing if you get heavy handed. Might try a hairdryer or heat gun and chill the spur with the spray can if I could find it. You can buy stuff to freeze warts at the pharmacy. It might work.

Run your query on the other side. There was definately some conversation about this.

Barry Irby

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#13

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

John Lucas

>2 tips. Put a towel over the drive center. This is a better way to catch it when it comes flying out.

If your drive center is bigger than the treads on the lathe just take nut that fits the thread and cut it in half. Place it over the spindle and put a wrench on it and crank the drive center out.

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#14

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

Russ Fairfield

>Six (6) steps to removing a stuck center.

1. Use the steel "Knock Out Bar" and a steel hammer heavy enough to give it a good blow.

2. Lock the spindle, grab the center with a large pair of pliers or a pipe wrench, and try twisting it out. If it won't come straight out, a twist will usually do it.

3. Get help and do both 1 and 2 at the same time.

4. When none of these work, go to more drastic measures, heat, cold, acid etching in addition to No. 3 above.

5. As a last resort, remove the spindle and take it to a machine shop and let them do it.

6. Replace the spindle bearings because you have probably put flat spots on them with all of the pounding.

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#15

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

Wood Spinner

>I believe you are talking about ethyl chloride.

It may be easier to find dry ice.

Pack the center with ice and give a couple of minutes. Use the drive center with gusto. I made my own rod and it has the top of a trailer ball on the rod.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#16

Re: Sour Spur?

George Van in WI

>Mark, hope the spur drive is out. I got the quote from Tag by searching the archives for the word �vinegar�.

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#17

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

Barry Irby

>Mike,

They make a pair of tuning fork shaped wedges for removing morse tapered chuck form drill presses. Would they work for removing your drive center?

Slip one in from either side between the center and the end of the sahft and tap them together. Seems like that would not put the strain on the bearing and head stock and wouldn't risk the heat damage.

Barry Irby

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#18

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Thanks Barry,

Will be going with a split nut and slotted washer combo before I go the vinegar and BTPOOI option.

Mark

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

#19

Re: Seized Drive Center (1236)

Barry Irby

>I like the idea fo the split nut also. Apply the mechanical advantage between the two things that are stuck. If the spur is smaller than the outer diameter of the shaft, you could have have a heavey duty washer welded onto the nut and then split it.

I did not like the vinegar Idea. The thought of Intentionall rusting the morse taper bothered me. If it were the only option I guess I would try it, but it would not be my first choice.

I once left a green blank for a vessel in a chuck over night with a plastic bag over it to keep it from splitting and warping. The dampness went through the chuck and into the shaft and rusted the inside of the shaft. Not a good thing.

Let us know if you have success.

Barry Irby.