Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Posts

Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#1

Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Mark Kauder. Phenix City, AL

>Well, once again tonight, I had a segemented bowl seperate from the waste block. NO, I did not have a catch!! But it has been cool in the shop.

I use Thick CA glue to glue my base layers to the waste block - sidegrain to sidegrain. Kiln dried wood. In both cases the seperations were clean - no torn wood - just the CA letting go.

Couple of questions for you experienced waste block users.

1) Do you think I would do better using another glue - Titebond, Hot Hide (got tons of it since I stopped using it for segmented work)??

2) Should I turn a 1/4" x 2" tenon on the waste block and drill a corresponding mortise in the base block to provide a mechanical advantage, not there with two flat surfaces.

I am tired of trying to re-attach a nearly finished bowl to the waste block, and true it up again.

Mark

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#2

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Duane C.Leach

>Mark I have never had Titebond 2 to fail after allowing it to cure for at least 2 hrs. The C A glue inside a joint will sometimes take hours or days to cure. And will become britle.

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#3

Dick Hines

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Dick Hines

>Mark, I know this has nothing to do with waste blocks. It's a finishing question. I know you use lacquer on your segmented pieces. What do you use to polish them. I have a cherry piece that had a big know and I turned a pot and it has big void places and I don't want to get it near a buffing wheel.

Sorry to hear you are having proublems with glue letting loose. Wally uses CA, check with him. The master will know.

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#4

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Wally Dickerman at Green Valley, Az.

>Mark, I've used hundreds of glue blocks using CA glue, with failures almost nil. In my experience, if there is a joint failure using CA it's almost always because not enough glue was used. Use a generous amount, apply accelerator after about 30 seconds and only apply firm hand pressure. If you'd feel more comfortable using a small tenon, by all means do so. I always do when turning an end grain piece. It's a stronger joint.

Wally

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Richard Allen

>CA glue works great. Thick CA glue need accelerator to work. I am fond of medium. The age of the CA glue is also important. 6 months is the shelf life. Of course it is hard to tell how long the glue has been sitting on the shelf of the store. Store unopened CA in the freezer.

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#6

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Mark Kauder. Phenix City, AL

>Dick,

Sand to 1500-2000 grit, and then buff by hand using a buffing abrasive. Micro Mesh makes one that I have used that is just fine. However, what I use mostly is 3M Finesse-It II, that costs about $25 for a quart - a quart will last you GUITE a while. You do not use even a tablespoon on a whole bowl. You can get it at any automotive paint supplier (car-quest, etc).

If you cannot find it, you can use Mcquires swirl remover that you can get a any Auto supply store in the car care section (Waxes and such).

Mark

P.S. I always forget to ask, Is this the Dick Hines in the Atlanta area??

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#7

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

JamieDonaldson

>Mark- have you considered that a good chuck would eliminate this problem???

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#8

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Mark Kauder. Phenix City, AL

>Thanks for the thoughtful response, Wally.

I am really perplexed on this one. The glue is pretty fresh, has been stored well, and the two failures were different batches of glue.

I almost wonder if I used too much glue, and there was not much wood to wood contact.

Think after this current batch of bowls, I will do the tenon thing.

Thank

Mark

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#9

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

john Lucas

>Mark

I can trace almost all of my CA glue failures to Accelorator. Accelorator makes the glue joint brittle. I use this to good affect on my hand mirrors. I can rap the glue block sharply and it will shear at the glue line leaving the wood intact on the glue block and on the mirror. This lets me use thinner wood for my mirrors because therre is little damage to the wood. If I glue the block on without accelorator it wall almost always tear one piece of wood and is much harder to seperate.

When I turn hollow vessels I don't use any accelorator if it's a large vessel. I would look at using yellow glue. You've already got a huge amount of time in the piece before you get to the final turning. It wouldn't hurt to wait 12 more hours for a glue block to set up using either yellow glue or gorilla glue. John

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#10

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Mark Kauder. Phenix City, AL

>Jamie,

I am using a SuperNova. I use the waste block because the wood that I use for segmenting is generally only 4/4. If I do not use a waste block, and turn a dovetail on it for the chuck, I can be severly hampered by the chuck on the size and shape of the base of the bowl. A 8/4 waste block give me more stand-off from the chuck.

This is the small 7" dia bowl that came off. I got it back on pretty well centered. As you can see, the base will only be about 1.5" in diameter. I seldom reverse chuck - I part off and sand.

Thanks for your thoughts.

Mark.

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#11

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Mark Kauder. Phenix City, AL

>John,

After I posted the original post, I remembered that I had not mentioned my accelorator use. I do not generally use accelorator on waste blocks for this very reason. I like to let even CA on a waste blocks dry over night. I sometimes give a small portion of the outside where the two meet a shot, to keep them from moving around while they dry.

I think I well go to other glues for a while.

Thanks,

Mark

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#12

Sorry, Here is the PIC 

Mark Kauder. Phenix City, AL

>


img

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#13

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Mark Kauder. Phenix City, AL

>Sorry Dick, I remembered you are in VA.

I was thinking about my trip to Atlanta this weekend for the WW show, and was thinking about Dick Hayes.

Mark - early onset Alsheimers I guess.

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#14

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Bill Neddow

>Mark, I have had failures with CA glue -- I bought some roughed bowls from another turner who uses this glue with a tendon and several of them blew right off the glue block. I know he was following all the procedures mentioned above. By contrast, I have never had a failure with hot melt glue. I was afraid to use that stuff (it's only good for sticking fake flowers together I thought). Then a turner from the East coast of Canada showed me how to use it. First, get a good glue gun (1500 watts), not one of those little ones for flower arranging. Then buy the heavy duty glue. These two things are essential to success. Let the gun warm up until there is smoke coming off the tip -- four or five minutes. Put one bead of glue all around the glue block about a quarter to a half an inch from the edge. Immediately put the glue block on the bowl blank, and twist the block to spread the glue. If you are worried about this being secure, coat the whole glue block with glue before you put it on the bowl blank. You will definitely have to part it off then because I have never successfully broken this joint (though I have busted a number of glue blocks. Two other cautions. You cannot put a glue block on a frozen bowl blank. Also,, if you have a soaking wet blank, dry the spot on it where you want to put the block with a hair dryer. It just has to get dry enough for the glue to get a grip in some dry fiber before the water works its way back out.

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#15

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question *LINK*

Dennis Vallianos

>See you already have a lot of responses but I'll just confirm the Titebond II approach. I normally apply a little pressure with a drill press for about 1/2 hour & then let it cure several hours or overnight. If the shop is below 58 F, I'll bring it upstairs for the night. Usually I'll add some rings to the base before any turning so it's likely more time will pass before it sees a turning tool. No failures between the waste block & bowl so far.

Dennis


My Web site

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#16

Some CA Glue is Better Than Others

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have found that Star Bond is one of the better CA glues available.

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#17

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

john Lucas

>Mark

I glue a wasteblock on and use the chuck in compression to hold a tenon turned on the wasteblock. John

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#18

Dick Hines

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Dick Hines

>NO, wrong Dick Hines Does he work for Avaya. I get e-mail at work for a Richard Hines in Atlanta.

I am in Va. between Richmond and Williamsburg.

Thans for the info on the polishing compond.

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#19

Re: Some CA Glue is Better Than Others

Fred Le Bail

>I use the Hot Melt glue method , only I have an old electric fry pan that has a layer of glue melted in it. When I am putting wasteblocks on I heat up the pan and dip the wasteblock to cover the bottom of the block then center the bowl.You have a little time to do the positioning then let cool for a few minutes and you are off and turning. Just don't forget to unplug the pan !!

Got this idea from New Brunswick turner Ken Bullock.

Fred

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#20

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Yeah, That is what I do, too.

Mark

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: Okay - Another Waste Block Question

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Mark! You are right-on with both questions....I use titebond glue, and always turn a recess, and put a shoulder on my pieces. I think it is much stronger, and accurate too!

The shoulder really strengthens things up, and there is additional glue surface.