Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

dust collectors *LINK*

Posts

dust collectors *LINK*

#1

dust collectors *LINK*

mainebowlman

>Ready to move from a shop vac to a dust collector for my lathe and bandsaw. I found some research at the link below. It recommends a Penn State 1hp unit for best filtration (1 micron) for the price.

I can't find any info on the decibel rating for the unit. Anyone have one? Opinion?

Any recommendations for best priced, quietest, and ...especially...best filtration unit to use primarily for the lathe? Any sites to direct me to?

Thanks in advance...and maybe again later.

Jack


Dust Collectors review

Re: dust collectors *LINK*

#2

Re: dust collectors

Earl

>Interesting article. I hadn't seen it and I recently installed a system in my small shop. I went with the 1 1/2hp because everything I read was that the 1hp just didn't move enough air for catching the dust thrown off a lathe. So you might consider a little more power.

I noticed the article did mention the leakage around plastic bags and I certainly do have that. I may try their fix with the bike innertube. Anybody else had this problem? How did your fix it?

I got the Delta 50-850 because it had the plastic bag on the bottom and 5 micron on top. Figured that was low enough to catch the small stuff. But the bag is convient.

http://billpentz.com/woodworking/cyclone/Ducting.cfm#Ducting%20Introduction Check this site out. It has everything you ever wanted to know and then some. Maybe a little too much!

Earl

Re: dust collectors *LINK*

#3

Re: dust collectors

Fog Tanner

>I went with the Onedia 2hp cyclone unit. It has enough for my lathe, bandsaw, table saw, jointer, drill press and anything else that makes dust. It works really great on my lathe. The dust comes off my tool and goes straight back into my dust hood. I run it anytime I am turning and sanding. It will filter down to .3 micron. I have a bag unit and would never use one where the bag is in the same room. They just move the dust from one place and blow it out in another.

Before you invest your money and confidence in a dust system, do plenty of research on the unit you are interested in. The flow advertised by Jet and Delta are noload conditions. Put some pipe on them and the flow rate drops. Use hose and it drops even more. Keep your use of flex hose to a minimum and you will have better results. I ran snaplock pipe to every thing with only a few feet of hose to connect to the machines. Also avoid the sharp radius bends that you will find in PVC pipe. All the 90s in my system are large radius metal. Same with the Wyes.

Even if I were going to run just a bandsaw and lathe I would still go with the 2hp Onedia unit. The lathe is the hardest machine to try and collect dust on/from/around, so you need all the airflow you can get. I am presently in the process of making a "muffler" for my unit, as the outlet is eight feet away, and up in the air about nine feet. It is not uncomfortable, I just crank up the rock n'roll a little louder. But, with my Jet bag unit, I can't even hear the radio - much less the lathe. And there is no way to quieten it down.

Good luck on your quest, your lungs will thank you.

Re: dust collectors *LINK*

#4

Re: dust collectors

Kent in Emmaus, PA

>"I noticed the article did mention the leakage around plastic bags and I certainly do have that. I may try their fix with the bike innertube. Anybody else had this problem? How did your fix it?"

Foam weatherstrip around the bag rim works as well.

Re: dust collectors *LINK*

#5

Re: dust collectors

DWFII

>Jack,

I have the Penn State unit. I like it. But I have a very small set up and run about six foot of flex hose to the lathe and nothing else.

I think it's a pretty quiet machine but "quiet" is relative. You won't be able to hear the radio when you are within six feet of the dust collector. But you probalby wouldn't be able to hear the radio standing at your lathe, either. I have and extra set of two and a half inch hose and accessories to vacuum up the floor using he DC. when I'm doing that...out at about 10 to 15 feet from the unit, it doesn't sound much louder to me than some old vacuum cleaners I remember from my youth.

It sure pulls the dust from the lathe though. Once I dropped a piece of brass tubing that I had wrapped sandpaper around. It sucked the sand paper and the tubing through the flex tube so fast and so hard I could hear the brass tube hit the inside of the filter bag.

If I had to do it all over again, however, I think I would get the version of the same machine that has the canister on top. I may yet upgrade my DC in that way.

Good luck...but don't expect to get rid of all dust. The DC may suck it away from the work area so that you don't breathe it, but some still gets through the filter bag...and settles or is airborne again. I can't, but if you can put your CD outside, that's the best solution of all.

DWFII

In the high desert of Central Oregon

Re: dust collectors *LINK*

#6

Re: Size Matters

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Earl,

5 micron is not nearly enough! (.)5 mics is where you want to be.

Since you have Bill's site, you should really consider the filer cartridge conversion that he has plans posted there. It'll give you much more airflow and and proper filtering.

M

Re: dust collectors *LINK*

#7

Re: dust collectors

David Galloway

>I would check out Bill Pentz web site as someone above suggested. It's the small stuff that kills and we hobbyists are most at risk.

www.billpentz.com

Re: dust collectors *LINK*

#8

Thank you - made a choice. *LINK*

mainebowlman

>And thanks again.

Your responses were all very helpful. After looking at the TON of information on Bill Pentz's site, reading your experience and insights, and looking at my wallet (and lungs), I think I'll go with Penn State's DC1BXL with the cannister top. Its 1hp under load CFM rating is the best in its class and not too far off the 1 1/2 hp. It gets me .5 micron filtration under $300.

http://www.pennstateind.com/Merchant2/merchant.mv?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=PSI&Product_Code=DC1BXL-CF&Category_Code=DC1

I'll also supplement it with my simple fan unit: a washable Web furnace filter ($20 at Home Depot) sealed in front of a $6 three-speed twenty-inch box fan. This will continually refresh the shop air to catch particles from .3 to 10 microns.

So thanks to all who responded.

Guess with this Nor'easter continuing here on the coast of Maine, I'll just have to turn until I can snowblow later and watch the Partiots. Looks like about 18" and still a comin'.

Ain't gonna git no Sunday papah delivahd today! Ayuh.

Jack


Dynamite washable filter