What can we do better?
Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

screw centers, etc.

Posts

screw centers, etc.

#1

screw centers, etc.

Georg Waldhof

>What are the relative advantages of screw centers and cup centers? I'm a bit new to these devices and am wondering if they are worth the investment.

I have an old ('72) Oliver 2159. I know that cup centers can be had in a pretty standard #2 morse taper, but the screw centers I've come across the seller wants about $35 - again, not being terribly familiar with these things, I'm wondering if its worth it or if there are alternatives - or even if a screw center has any real advatage over a faceplate or jaw chuck.

thanks

Georg

Re: screw centers, etc.

#2

Re: screw centers, etc.

Roly (So Cal)

>About 1/2 of my turnings start out on a screw center. It is the only way that I can fix a rough blank to the headstock easily. Simply drilling a small hole into the bark of a tree limb, allows me to turn a tenon on the other end so I can turn a bowl. Then the hole for the screw center is cut away when I hollow out the bowl. You would be wise to purchase one, they will enlarge your turning applications..........Roly ~~

Re: screw centers, etc.

#3

Re: screw centers, etc.

TheHeretic

>I just had a similiar discussion regarding screw centers on another forum. I also at the same time branched out and started to use a faceplate. I would say that whenever possible go with the faceplate. I know it improved the quality of work and lessened the chatter. I will prolly still use a screw center for smaller pieces but for bowls and the like I am sold on the faceplate.

Dean

Columbus, OH

Re: screw centers, etc.

#4

Re: screw centers, etc.

Arch

>Georg, Just one of the many opinions you'll get re these fittings, all are valid for somebody:

A dead cup center is useful but not essential as a drive that will slip and prevent damage if there's a catch or an excessive cut. A revolving cup center is useful in the tailstock to prevent splitting the stock. Both are useful and worthwhile, and the cheaper ones are ok.

Opinions differ more about screwchucks than cup centers, same with pinchucks and cup chucks. You should either make a proper single screw chuck from a lag bolt, etc. (there are many sites for info) or buy a quality screw chuck (good steel with sharp, deep threads) which will cost more than $35. A single screw or multiple screw chuck (faceplate) fixes or limits adjusting the orientation of grain, knots, etc. and requires drilling holes. A quality screw chuck does allow freedom from tail support and perhaps easier making of a tenon or dovetail, but both can be made with a tail center in place.

For the initial preparation of a rough bowl blank, I like the security of a tail center and the alignment options of a spur drive. A large spur drive can be bought or made using sharpened short bolts thru a faceplate. Some find a two spur center is best for accomodating a bark or rough surface. Like a dead cup center, it's a useful adjunct but not a necessity.

If the piece is to be turned to completion without reversing to a scroll chuck a quality screw chuck is useful, but no more than a faceplate or much more than a pin chuck.

Finally, a grain of salt is a very useful tool before taking this advice for spending your money.

Turn to Safety, Arch

Re: screw centers, etc.

#5

Re: screw centers, etc.

Georg Waldhof

>Thanks for all of these responses, they have been very helpful. I'm thinking that I may as well pick up this screw center and use it to its max.

Thanks again.

George

Re: screw centers, etc.

#6

Re: screw centers, etc.

Wally Dickerman at Green Valley, Az.

>I use and recommend using a screw center. Most of my turning is done using a screw center and a glue block. Woodcraft, Craft Supplies and others sell a good screw chuck for about $50. IMO the best available is the Glaser Screw chuck. The threads are thinner and deeper than any I've seen. It's a bit pricey at around $100. Many years ago, before good screw chucks were availble I made my own, using a lag bolt, a wood block and a faceplate. Using a rat-tail file, I deepened and sharpened the threads. It worked quite well but didn't compare to those available now.

Wally

Wally