What can we do better?
Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Help Please

Posts

Help Please

#1

Help Please

Richard Gillespie

>I've been asked to turn two replacement spindles for an antique bed. The bed has, sometime in the past, been stained a dark brown and finished with varnish. It is therefore difficult to tell what species of wood was used for the spindles. I have one broken end on one exposed and there isn't enough to tell. The bed is in part made out of pine. The rest may be a hardwood but it's on the light side in weight and color.

The spindles are 12" long and are beaded. The large diameter is just under 1" and the small dia. is 9/16". There are 13 beads in a 10" span. The spindle is light enough that it might be pine, the exposed wood is the right color but doesn't look quite right to be pine. It is a closed pore species definitely not oak or ash.

My question is, will pine turn well enough to duplicate these two spindles or should I use another species? If so, what would be the best one to use to minimize blow out on the bead edges. As you probably know by now, my turning experience is limited.

Thanks in advance

Rick

Re: Help Please

#2

Re: Help Please

Sean Troy

>Alder would work. Best of luck.

Re: Help Please

#3

Re: Help Please

Ezekiel Holliday

>In my experience pine turns fine. However, you must use very sharp tools and take light final cuts. And of course nots in pine can be a problem. If you could post a picture, someone may be able to help identify the wood.

Re: Help Please

#4

Richard Allen

Re: Help Please

Richard Allen

>Hi Rick

I would use Basswoood. It holds a good bit of detail, sands easly, is light weight. Expect to turn at least one more spindle than needed. Perhaps 2 or 3 extra spindles and then select the ones that look the best. Also don't sand past 220 or the stain will have a hard time.

Good Luck

Richard

Re: Help Please

#5

Re: Help Please

Bert Workman

>Alder and Bass are both excellent suggestions. I think you would be happy with either of those. If you have trouble finding any Poplar would also work very well.

Good luck,

Bert

Re: Help Please

#6

Re: Help Please

john Lucas

>I think pine turns fine. Be selective so you don't have any knots. Poplar also turns well for this purpose. Be prepared to use a wood conditioner. The stain won't go on the same on the side grain as the end grain. The idea of not sanding beyond 22o is really good.

The last thing I had to match would never stain evenly on pine. I had to airbrush the side grain to get it even. Poplar stains more evenly that pine, at least that's been my experience.

I also had to buy 5 different stains to be able to match the original. I bought 3 colors of oak stain, some ebony stain, a redish stain whose name escapes me. I was able to mix these a teaspoon at a time until the color matched the original. Be sure to do a test piece, finish and all if you want a really good match.