Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Roughing gouge questions

Posts

Roughing gouge questions

#1

Roughing gouge questions

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>Folks -

My current roughing gouge was getting bounced around pretty badly today as I tried to round a chunk of birch trunk about 7" in diameter (but oval in cross section), so I was thinking I could use a larger one. My questions: First, how are these tools sized? I have no recollection what size mine is supposed to be, and don't know how the sizes listed in the catalogs compare. Mine is made by Crown, the flute is 3/4 inch diameter at it's widest, and the outside diameter is a bit over 1" (1 3/64th to be exact).

Second, what do folks like in tool handle size for a larger gouge such as this? I felt part of my difficulty today was that the handle is only about 8" long. Perhaps it's my technique or lack thereof, but I find the 16" handles on my bigger tools very helpful when the going gets, well, rough.

Lastly, any recommendations? I'm only an occasional turner with a Jet 1236 so I'm wondering if I'd really benefit much from one of the newer alloys that are supposed to hold an edge better. Still, it sure seemed like I was making a lot of trips to the grinder today, so perhaps it would be dollars well spent. Thoughts?

Ken

Re: Roughing gouge questions

#2

Long handles

TDaniel

>ken, I like the very long handles on my gouges. I am more comfortable using them (with less "tennis elbow") and I can make curves much easier and fluid with the long handles. I don't use a spindle or roughing gouge much; just my 1/2" bowl gouge.

TD

Re: Roughing gouge questions

#3

Re: Roughing gouge questions *LINK*

Darrell Feltmate

>Ken

For wood like that I like to use a 1/2" square HSS tool bit held in a 31" length of 3/4" galvanized pipe. The tool bit is sharpened to 45* and slightly rounded. Cheap and effective. It is essentially a 1/2" Oland tool.


http://aroundthewoods.com/oland.shtml

Re: Roughing gouge questions

#4

Why a roughing gouge?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I'm totally repeating myself from a similar question last week, but as a bowl, platter, and hollow form turner I can't see a need for a roughing gouge. I rough whole logs anywhere from 10-20" in diameter regularly and have no problems at all with the Ellsworth gouge, basically a 5/8" superflute gouge with a swept back grind. It'll hog off as much material as the lathe will allow. It doesn't suffer from bouncing and misbehaving as its presentation, when roughing, is to keep the tool horizontal so downward pressure goes right on the cutting edge, keeping the tool where it belongs. Plus, you can move right from roughing to shaping and finishing with the same gouge.

I find it to be a great tool with the standard handle, but a marvelous, stupendous, and fantastic tool with a larger, heavier handle. I use the large Kelton handle and buy my gouges unhandled or make my own. The large, heavy handle resists dramatic tool movement and is massive enough to create graceful curves as Terry has noted.

I have two roughing gouges that have never been used, don't think they ever will be used.

Tool bounce can also come from a flimsy toolrest.

Re: Roughing gouge questions

#5

Steven Antonucci

I'm with Schwing!

Steve Antonucci

>I also rough turn with a bowl gouge with a swept back grind. I typically mount between centers, and then "rough" from the headstock to 1/2 way and then from the tail stock the other 1/2 way, so that I'm always cutting with the grain.

The only time I use a roughing gouge is when ... actually, I'm with Schwing. I don't use it anymore.

Steve

Re: Roughing gouge questions

#6

Paul Porter

Re: Roughing gouge questions *LINK*

Paul Porter

>It sounds like you are using a roughing gouge that is made for spindle work. They work great on small diameter pieces. I use a 1/2" bowl gouge for roughing bowls and hollow work. A bowl gouge won't "beat-you-to-death" on larger work like a u-shaped roughing gouge.


My Website

Re: Roughing gouge questions

#7

Re: Roughing gouge questions

Andrew Hilton

>Agreed, Paul. A roughing gouge is indispensible for spindle work but for large diameter hollowforms, bowls and open forms, a larger bowl gouge works best.

I use a roughing gouge and a skew 95% of the time in my architectural turnings. A roughing gouge can act, depending on how you use it and have it ground, as a large bowl gouge (deep fluted gouge) for most coves, cones, and tapers (NOT for actual bowls, etc.), a skew, scraper, parting/sizing tool, and as a quick way to remove massive amounts of material quickly while roughing. The roughing gouge is one of the most versatile tools there is. Just behind the skew, of course.

"Use the right tool for the job instead of making the job right for the tool"

Re: Roughing gouge questions

#8

Richard Allen

Re: Roughing gouge questions

Richard Allen

>Hi Ken

I use a 1 3/4" roughing gouge all the time on logs between centers. It works fast for me and there is a large sharpened cutting edge to work with. This means that the tool can be rotated to present another sharp part of the gouge while roughing.

If the tool is dulling faster than you like there are two likely reasons. The wood could have some sand or stone in the bark which will dull a tool fast. Or you could be presenting the cutting edge to low so the bevel isn't being used.

I am not sure how a roughing gouge is measured. I would guess that you have a 3/4" roughing gouge as I am unaware of a 1" roughing gouge in the Crown line of tools.

For oval logs, aren't most logs somewhat oval, I like to have a fairly good speed so the tool doesn't have much of a chance to fall into the air. I also like to take fairly light cuts, no more than 1/32" thick at that stage. As the log gets round 1/8" thick shavings is the norm with occasional 3/16" thick shavings.

Thanks

Richard

Re: Roughing gouge questions

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Roughing gouge questions

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ken, two things, hopefully you were turning the wood in spindle orientation, not as you would turn a bowl. Second, if the wood was yellow birch, that would explain it. the stuff is as hard as a rock!

Try a bowl gouge, it works better than a roughing gouge on large diameter turnings. Also, with the roughing gouge, try this. Instead of going back and forth the length of the piece, bring just a small section at a time to finished diameter; say a 1/4 inch at a time. This prevents all that bouncing!

Re: Roughing gouge questions

#10

Thanks and....

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>I appreciate all the responses. My apologies if I was unclear about orientation; I was indeed turning in spindle orientation. I've seen it written too many times that you don't use a roughing gouge on a bowl to even consider trying it.

I'll try using my bowl gouge next time, and then see. Packard has a 1 3/4" roughing gouge for $50, which seems reasonable. I'll pass on the $80-$100 versions for now.

Also, thanks for the suggestion about possibly having the toolrest too low. I was fiddling around with heights a fair bit trying to get less bouncing, so that's possible.

Ken