Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

jet mini or HF34706

Posts

jet mini or HF34706

#1

jet mini or HF34706

joe smith

>I have beeen reding youforum for a while trying to take it all in. I have seen this addressed some what but maybe not these two together. My question is which one of these would be best for me. Im new to turning this will be a christmas present for me and as such will be from a limited budget. I do believe you get what you pay for. I will be starting out doing small things but the HF gives me a little more before size before I would need to upgrade. The jet comes with great reviews and a good company behind it. I know I will need additional tolls and other items thats why i'm limiting the amount to be spent on the lathe itself. Thanks for all your help, joe

Re: jet mini or HF34706

#2

Re: Don't be a slow learner like I am.

Al Crandall

>I have several HF tools in my shop. They include a large floor drill press, a 4 speed tube bed lathe, 6x48 belt sander, 12" disc sander, 14" metal cutting chop saw, 4 1/2" angle grinder, 20" hedge clippers, 10" pedestal grinder, and possibly another one or two I can't think of at the moment. With the exception of the drill press, which has been just a great tool and was my only press for several years, I wouldn't allow another corded tool from HF into my shop if you paid me. Most failed prematurely and the rest performed so poorly as to be essentially useless. My experience tells me that there is a high probability you will be unhappy with the HF lathe. Harbor Freight has some great buys but corded tools aren't among them. Buy the Jet.

Re: jet mini or HF34706

#3

Re: jet mini or HF34706

Mike-in-Michigan(Richland that is)

>The HF Lathe is a decent lathe, it's basically a Jet 1236 painted green. If you have a local HF store, watch the adds. Before Xmas I bet it will go on sale for 169$ or so.. great deal. I turned a lot of items on that same lathe and I sold it to a HS kid a couple years ago and he's turning things on it. I've never broken a tool rest, but others have. It's a known problem with the Jet 1236's too. I turned bowls up to 10" or so, outboard turned a couple of 11-12" platter's as well a end-grain hollow turnings. It's bit down on power but no more than any lathe that size.

I now have a Jet VS mini and I have to say over all I like as more than the HF but I don't turn any items much over 6-8" anymore. I turn mostly pens, spindle stuff, small lidded boxes, candle holders, wine stoppers, etc... and it excels at that.

Basically it depends on what you want to turn. If you are going to do a lot of small stuff then even though I like the HF, I would go with the Jet. It's portable too!! Then when you are ready for the big stuff -- buy a bigger lathe and keep the jet for small stuff, though you can always turn small stuff on a big lathe, just not the other way around. But if you upgrade to a bigger lathe, the HF might take up to much floor space. Lastly if you buy the belt speed changing Jet, it's only a 20-30$ difference, but the VS speed jet is about 100-120$ more.. that might make the difference. You will be able to turn with any of them.

Re: jet mini or HF34706

#4

Re: jet mini or HF34706

Rick Haverstock

>I'll second Mike's comments on HF lathe. I had originally decided on the Jet 1236 and went down the road to the local HF. Mike's right; the HF 34706 is a green 1236 in every way I could see. I just got into this turning thing so my very limited experience with lathes is probably working in Harbor Freight's favor. It's a little rough in spots, but nothing that couldn't be fixed with a file and Dremel grinder. So far the only problem was with the adjustment on the tool rest banjo, but I did manage to fiddle around and nail that too. Also look at the HF $39.95 HSS tool set. They take a nice edge and for that little money you can experiment with different grinds and not feel bad about it. Do a Google Groups search with the model number and see what others have to say. I think they agree with me for the most part.

Rick

Re: jet mini or HF34706

#5

Re: jet mini or HF34706

Nathan Pettigrew

>Ditto what Mike and Rick said.

Don't get the other "tube" bed lathes though. I've been learning and my HF lathe for awhile and it's been able to keep up with anything I can do. I also picked up the HSS turning set and it works fine too.

Nathan