Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Spalted Cherry Bowls

Posts

Spalted Cherry Bowls

#1

Spalted Cherry Bowls

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Friends,

Fourteen months ago my #2 daughter found a cherry tree branch poking through a wall in her new house expansion. I forget the name of the hurricane. I got some of the branch for bowl turning. The latest sections of branch were removed from their firewood pile just a couple weeks ago, and I went to work with my chain saw and made a few blanks. I got several pieces with a great deal of spalting. I never worked spalted wood before, so I have some questions and observations: Is it common for the wood to be extremely punky? The bowls I turned were on the soft side, and the surfaces had the texture of a washcloth. I tried sanding on and off the lathe, and it won't get smooth. I figured I have to firm-up the surfaces before using the fine grit paper. The wood was also pretty dry even though the logs had a diameter of about 9 inches. The logs were much lighter to lift, so I guess they lost a lot of water sitting in Lizzy's back yard. I am surprised that the color is so pale in comparison to the other bowls turned earlier this year and kept in paper bags. These spalted bowls are white, like cherry sapwood. However, they were from the interior of the branch. I don't like the color after an application of tung oil and naptha. Earlier bowls were very dramatic in character, warmth and color from the get-go, and are darkening/reddining as they get older. The spalted stuff after the tung oil has not popped and darkened dramatically, but looks more like a green suited corpse who died of nausia. I sure would appreciate your comments. Where should I go from here? I have about 6 more blanks cut and not worked.

George

Re: Spalted Cherry Bowls

#2

Re: Spalted Cherry Bowls *LINK*

Andrew Hilton

>Take a look at the website I've provided a link for describing a little about spalting.

On to your questions...

"Is it common for the wood to be extremely punky?"

Yes, if the spalting has gone too far. Not that this is necessarily a bad thing but it something you have to deal with. Spalted wood need not be punky but the ones "found in the wild" often are because you just got to it too late.

"The bowls I turned were on the soft side, and the surfaces had the texture of a washcloth. I tried sanding on and off the lathe, and it won't get smooth."

Different woods respond differently to spalting. Some are well-behaved even with high spalting. Some get so chippy and soft that they are very very difficult to work with. Power sanding, lightly, can work wonders with spalted, punky wood. But there's only so much that can be done.

"I figured I have to firm-up the surfaces before using the fine grit paper."

Yes, absolutely! I'll often tell buyers of my spalted wood to rough turn it and soak it in a wood preservative or stabilizer. This can be a commercial product or one of your own making. It's a lot like the "stabilized" pen and small project blanks in that your putting resins, plastics and other stuff in there to fill the spaces and harden. You can then do your final cutting and sanding after that and usually get a nice finish. Otherwise, as you've seen, it's tough to get a good surface on the really spalted, punky woods.

"The wood was also pretty dry even though the logs had a diameter of about 9 inches. The logs were much lighter to lift, so I guess they lost a lot of water sitting in Lizzy's back yard."

Spalted wood dries much quicker and the more it's spalted/decayed, the faster it goes. There's just simply less material in the wood to hold that moisture in there.

"I am surprised that the color is so pale in comparison to the other bowls turned earlier this year and kept in paper bags. These spalted bowls are white, like cherry sapwood. However, they were from the interior of the branch."

Spalting is caused, mainly, by what we call the White Rot Fungus group. You've seen why it called that. This type of rot, as opposed to the Brown Rot Fungus group, leaves a lighter, whiter coloration to the wood. It can be pronounced!

"I don't like the color after an application of tung oil and naptha."

This is a condition of the wood, spalting and the Tung Oil. Normally, the Tung Oil will really "pop" the spalting .. making the dark zone lines darker and increasing the contrast and variations of the coloration. Some woods just don't respond the same. Tung Oil is also going to darken everything such as making a nicely spalted piece of white Hard Maple turn a sickly yellow / brownish color sometimes. Certainly not with all woods and not all of the time but it does happen as you've seen.

"Where should I go from here? I have about 6 more blanks cut and not worked."

My recommendation is to rough turn, stabilize/harden the wood, finish turn and sand. Don't be afraid to sand more. Vanity says to do as much cutting as possible but even the sharpest of edges and best of technique doesn't always work and you do need to use the paper more here.

If you think you really need to use an oil type of finish, then I'd suggest just a light wipe of boiled linseed oil (BLO) and then another finish on top of that. The BLO will yellow/darken a bit over time but it tends not to do as much as quckly as Tung Oil with Spalted woods. Some kind of chemical reaction with the organic coloration due to the spalting? Probably. The top coat could be just a buff with wax if your turning item calls for that kind top coating. You could, however, just skip the oil and go straight to a lacquer. It won't "pop" the spalting zone lines as much but it also won't give you as much of the ugly green coloration either.

Let us know how the other pieces turn out!


Spalting, A Fungus Amongus

Re: Spalted Cherry Bowls

#3

Re: Spalted Cherry Bowls

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Thanks Andrew,

I read your article with interest. Thank you for your response.

George