>I recently found the need to visit an orthopedic surgeon for an old knee problem (old injury AND old knees). While we were talking, I admired a burl pen he had. He indicated how much he enjoyed it, but pointed out that he was very disatisfied with the way the clip was wearing...the gold plating was all but gone, and the metal was starting to pit.
I told him about the differences between the gold, titanium, platinum, chrome, etc. platings and how they wear differently. One thing led to another, and I ended up with an order for a titanium or platinum (my choice) rollerball before I left.
This encounter, the disappointment with a hand-made pen that was wearing too quickly, made me start thinking once again of the dilemma I face when making what I think are pretty darn good pens for sale at craft shows. Knowing my crowd pretty well (80% blue collar, 15% "professional" with lots of money or credit, 5% who don't blink an eye at ANY price), I pretty much find a price point beyond which sales almost disappear - $20 for a slimline, $30 for a larger pen. In order to sell at or below this price point, I have been making mostly the "upgrade gold" kits, knowing they would wear eventually. My preference, though, is to make titanium or platinum kits that will survive without wear for much, much longer. The problem is that, to the customer's eye, they look they same, so it is hard to justify the extra $5-$10 per pen for titanium. Most people just will not pay for the titanium because they don't see the difference. On the other hand, I am not going to sell titanium for the cost of gold plated.
So, do I offer gold plated pens, which will wear more quickly, but cost less (the price point) or do I offer titanium which wear much better, but cost more to produce? I figure I need the same amount of profit to make and sell each pen. Only the materials and final cost are different.
I am curious what the rest of you do about this.
Re: Gold vs. Titanium Pen Kits - Sales Philosophy?
Re: Gold vs. Titanium Pen Kits - Sales Philosophy?
Dave MacLuskie
>Having absolutely no experience selling pens (or anything else for that matter), could you sell both? Mark the titanium with a higher price, and mention the benefits. It seems lot of product lines do that... have a high end model, and a low end model (car trim lines come to mind -- the cloth seats cost less, but the leather seats last longer).
Re: Gold vs. Titanium Pen Kits - Sales Philosophy?
Re: Gold vs. Titanium Pen Kits - Sales Philosophy?
Russ
>You are describing THE dilemma of making and selling pens.
The problem is that, you cannot charge more for something that looks the same as something cheaper. There is no amount of telling that will convince anyone that the higher priced pen is better because it costs more.
My solution is to tie the difference in the price of the plating to the wood, giving the customer something that is obviously better than the lower quality.
A plain Slim-Line in a plain wood gets the plain gold plate and a $20 price. A nicely figured piece of wood gets the Ti-Gold plating and $5 more on the price. All modified SlimLine, and all other pen styles get the premium plating, and their higher price is adjusted to absorb the difference in my cost.
This seems to work because most people will lose the simple SlimLine before the plating wears off. A higher priced pen is given better care and used longer, and the higher quality plating will insure a satisfied customer.
Keeping the two types of plating for the same pen is another problem that has to be solved.
Re: Gold vs. Titanium Pen Kits - Sales Philosophy?